So let me first say that this pizza is not what you would call NY Pizza....close but no cigar....cardboard crust that needs to be revamped!

I read an article about this place where the author said they import water from NY to make the most authentic NY style pizza in the area. Unfortunately that bit about the water is not true, but thankfully the rest of that statement is accurate. This is without a doubt the closest thing to NY style pizza I've had in Ohio. The crust is perfectly charred, crunchy and just firm enough to support the rest of the slice. The sauce is fresh, a tad sweet, but not over powering. The cheese is exactly what you would expect from this style. Not overpowering, not goopy, just right. I liked the overall vibe of the place. There were plenty of places to sit including a solo style counter at the front. They had a nice selection of drinks that I'm not used to seeing at pizza places around here. The only downside to this place is the location. Why is it so far north of the city!?!? I guess that may be a good thing; if it were closer I would come here every week. read more

See all

This was a quick easy lunch! And what better way to try a pizza place than when they have it by "the slice ". It was sooo good. The garlic knots for the win! Service was great , and it was in and out. Plenty of parking , and nestled in evendale. For sure lived up to the hype. No drivers were harmed on this lunch break! read more

See all

Amazing pizza! We got the classic pepperoni, added hot honey and classic white pizza. Both had the crunch and flavor that we love. Our pick up order was hot and ready when I got there. Overall, easy experience. Will 100% be going back. read more

Trophy Pizza - Evendale - Classic 20" White Pie - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Amazing pie every time & the staff is awesome We usually do take out but dining in the pizza is even better.

Got delivery when staying in town overnight. Really good NY style fold it in half pizza. We were very satisfied with our roll of the dice choice. read more

Went with my buddy for lunch and got the 2 slice lunch special. Nice, crisp, foldable New York slice. Sauce was a little salty for my taste. The white pizza with the ricotta was good but the "hot" honey, just tasted like honey. Barely any heat. Friendly service/ambience. Boylan's grape soda in the glass bottle was awesome. read more

Trophy Pizza - Evendale - Pepperoni Slice (Was too hungry to wait for the picture) - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Outstanding pizza!!! Top 5 of our lives and we have lived all over from Cincy to Chicago to San Fran. Went to school in NYC. Crust has a great char, tomato sauce was flavorful and topping choices/combos ranged from traditional to creative. Ordered slices to try a few different pies. So good we ended up taking a full pizza home for later. Staff and owner were really friendly and super engaging. Run, don't walk, to try out Trophy Pizza. Hoping they will bring one to Liberty Twp soon!!! read more

Spectacular pizza! Stop buying other pizza and come here! Incredible!! Owner chatted up a bit which was awesome! Love supporting small businesses but with how good the pizza is I doubt it's small for long! 11 out of 10!! read more

Good pizza, awesome service, and cafeteria style atmosphere. Would eat here again when in the area. The New York style was great but the grandma style we were hoping for a little thinner crust like we had in New York. None the less a great spot and a must try if in the area. The staff were super friendly and helpful. Also don't rule out the calzone when stopping by it was! read more

See all

My partner is a true New Yorker, born and raised in da Bronx. So he knows New York pizza. Service was definitely 5 stars. Great service. The atmosphere was nice, just music was a bit loud. The restaurant seems clean and has a nice design. We ordered a pie of sausage pizza. All our favorite pizzeria in NYC serve with sliced sausage, but it wasn't here, which was a big turned down for us. Crusts were actually good, and sauce was decent. But not enough cheese on it. It didn't satisfy my NY tongue. It was not bad but did not fulfill our New York pizza cravings. read more

Trophy Pizza - Evendale - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

This pizza is legit. I am a pizza snob and have tried pizza all over the country. This pizza is delicious. Made with obvious love for the art of pizza making and a passion for making customers perfectly satisfied with their food. Perfect amount of crisp and chew to the crust. Sauce that's simple and doesn't overpower. Just the right amount of toppings. Top 2 in all of Cinci for sure! read more

My husband loves New York style pizza, and wanted to check out Trophy Pizza's version. We ordered a double mushroom, and on picking it up, had some more sauce added (dollops on top) as it looked a little dry. I have to say I really enjoyed it, as did my family. The pizza is tasty both the first day and heated up, with a nice, chewy crust. The sauce was a bit one-note, but on reheating the next day, it actually tasted more flavorful. The restaurant is mostly carry-out, with a few tables inside. You have to call-in your carry-out order, but can find their menu online. They also offer individual slices, a few specialty pizzas, salads, calzones, and cheesecake. They have both gluten free pizzas and vegan cheese. read more

Trophy Pizza - Evendale - New York style pizza with double mushrooms and more sauce added on top. - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Best New York style pizza in town. Save your time - you don't need to try anywhere else. And the staff are as friendly as if you were family. Great customer service and great pizza. read more

Finally visited Trophy Pizza for their rumored amazing New York slice. They delivered, ten fold!! As a native New Yorker, I can tell you this is spot on for New York style pizza. We got two pepperoni slices and a slice of their Yes Way to share. HOT & FRESH! Service was great, people behind the counter were very friendly. Location is a bit out of the way but certainly more accessible than flying to NY. Highly recommend! read more

Trophy Pizza - Evendale - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

This was an incredible discovery. Well, someone else discovered it, wrote about it, and I am absolutely thrilled. This might be the best pizza slice I've had in a long time! The super thin crust is perfectly crisped in their super hot oven before they serve it. It is so perfect that I ordered 2 extra slices to take home to my family. From the cute little red "classic" pizza cups for water to the very friendly service, I seriously can't wait to get back. Don't expect any frills, it IS New York Style 'za after all. The simple decor and friendly attitude of the fellow diners is all you need to know that this place is a true gem. I can't wait to get back! read more

Trophy Pizza - Evendale - Hot, crisp, and incredibly delicious. This slice of pepperoni and sausage took me back to NYC in an instant. - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Definitely coming back. Pizza and salad were perfect! Ordered slices and the fresh and cool salad. Fairly clean restaurant AND bathroom. So glad we stopped in. read more

See all

Very good New York style pizza for the area. Best value food in the gatherfall, probably our favorite restaurant there. Quick service, lots of pre-sliced options. They also have some good mix and match slices and salad deals. The gatherall is always bustling, but we've never had an issue finding seating, there's even heated seating outdoors. read more

Trophy Pizza - Evendale - White pizza, trophy, and sausage/pepp - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Awesome, authentic New York style pizza! My office recently moved to Evendale and we decided to order pizza for the whole office after hearing rave reviews about this place. We were pleasantly surprised when we arrived to pick up our order. The owner was working with the rest of the team and was super welcoming. We had a cheese and pepperoni pizza as well as the BLTE salad and everything was delicious! I would highly recommend to anyone with a craving for NY Style pizza. They offer pizza by the slice as well if you're stopping in for a quick lunch. read more

Trophy Pizza - Evendale - Dining area - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

We ordered pizza from here via uber eats pick up today and it was really good! Still hot, crispy crust, and fresh after a drive home. We ordered the loophole pizza. It was quite tasty!y husband felt it could use a bit more ranch while I would have preferred a few more jalapeños. Other than that, flavor was delicious! We will definitely order from here again! read more

New York pizza has finally come to Cincinnati in style. The food here is sublime and that is not an exaggeration. Their pizza is 20in of greatness with a healthy selection of toppings to pick from. They also serve by the slice which adds to that New York feel. Service was good they were friendly despite being busy. The location itself is small and cozy but perfect for carryout or small dining groups. Tips to make your visit a success: 1) Call ahead. This place stays busy and ordering ahead is very much so your friend. Ordering ahead will cut your wait time down significantly. 2) More than just pizza. Calzones, salads, and even dessert. They offer more than your typical place. We tried the Bensonhurst salad and found it to be delightful and the perfect accompaniment to the loaded pizza we ordered. Order from Trophy Pizza today and enjoy your own taste of New York pizza without the plane ticket. read more

See all

Located in a small storefront in a tiny Evendale corner mall on Reading Rd, Trophy Pizza pumps out the best true New York slices in town. There's a register and menu board as you walk in the front door with friendly servers and a chatty baker ready to take, prepare and serve your order. Besides pizza, they also offer calzones, salads, meatballs, cookies, cheesecake and soda but unfortunately no beer. The tidy bright dining area consists of a half dozen tables and a counter by the front window. I was especially impressed by the extremely clean restrooms even towards the end of the night. We got a 20-in cheese pizza during Cincy Pizza Week for 10 bucks which was less than half of the regular $22 price. It took over an hour, since everyone and their mother were getting in on the deal. Though most of their business seemed to be take-out, since there weren't many people actually eating there. No worries. We just went next door to Walmart to kill the time with some shopping. It was so worth the wait. The crust was super thin, crispy and tasty. It stood up perfectly to the fold test. Not even a hint of flop whatsoever. The perfect vehicle for whatever toppings you desire. I ate 5 slices in a half hour! Can't wait for their new location at Factory 52 in Norwood..... read more

Trophy Pizza - Evendale - Passes the fold test with flying colors - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Great place. Slice shop for real NY style and grandma. Been back many times. Consistently cooked right. read more

See all

I would put the slices or pies from Trophy up against any in the city. Huge fan been many times. NEVER disappointed. read more

This place is the bees knees. Quick service, great staff and most of all... the pizza is the best in Cincinnati (PERIOD). The G-Ma slice could save lives. The white slice is perfect on a sunny day. And if you want your socks knocked off by an OG slice of cheese, have at it. Need I say more? read more

Best Pizza in Cincinnati hands-down. Perfectly cooked crust and cheese there Crisp is unmatched. read more

Trophy Pizza - Evendale - Their Pepperoni pizza is delicious. Best in the city. The crispy crust is so good. - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

I was actually at the Factory 52 location but, it wouldn't let me tag. Either way.. FANTASTIC. I stopped in impromptu. I got a slice of cheese, and a slice of their signature " loophole" minus the ranch drizzle. The chicken, bacon, jalapeño, and caramelized onions combination is amazing . If it had sauce, it wasn't tomato based. Amazing crust ( is it sourdough based?) the perfect crisp, just all around great will be back again and again. read more

See all

Incredible Brooklyn style pies. Rico provided superlative hospitality. It was a delight. And the cheesecake...Don't miss out on the cheesecake! read more

Trophy Pizza - Evendale - Not so great picture of an awesome pizza. White pizza with ricotta and herbs A+ cheese, pizza, and pepperoni with hot honey. - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

The Lady Behind the counter was nice, the restaurant was very Hot I don't know how the people eating in could stand it, our pizza was overcooked and hardly had any cheese could see the dough! Unacceptable don't think I will order again and I guess if I ever get it will drive out to the Norwood location, because the restaurant on Reading road was not good at all! read more

Trophy Pizza - Evendale - Pepperoni, sausage and green pepper pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Loved it from the first time I went in..the smell of pizza coming out of the oven hot and steamy ..tried a few different selections and still want to try more...would love to order one of there monster sized pies to take home.. The service is awesome always ready to answer questions about what they have for the day. The setting is a great place to take a break when running errands or just stopping by for a quick bite.. read more

It is with great pleasure to leave a review for this restaurant. My Wife is from New Jersey and whenever we would visit relatives from there we made it a point to eat pizza, there's nothing like an east coast pizza until now in Cincinnati, Trophy Pizza is the real thing! We read a review in Cincinnati Magazine about the authenticity to New York pizza and we had to try it. All I can say is WOW, it is now our go to place for pizza in Cincy and hope this great review doesn't make them so busy we can't get in or we have to wait hours to get it. Oh well It'll still be worth it....... Hey Jim remember me saying "Thank you for knowing what pizza should taste like?" I really meant that. read more

Worth the trip. I grew up in NJ and am always looking for a slice like home. You walk in and the NY style pizza smell hits you in the face. The case was filled with a variety of slices. We chose to sit and order a pie in house. Worth the wait. Crust was thin, crunchy and the pizza is very lightly sauced. Tastes authentic, and just the nicest most accommodating staff. The gentleman working the oven was engaging every single customer. We can't wait to come back! read more

Trophy Pizza - Evendale - Half and half white pizza and a sausage pepperoni pepper onion - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Read about Trophy Pizza in the Cincinnati Enquirer and decided to give it a try. We had a large sausage and pepperoni. It is NY style, the slices are large and can be folded over if that is your preference. Thought the pizza was very good. A bit of a drive from our house, but would give this place another try if I am in the neighborhood. read more

Popped in for lunch after a hike in Sharon Woods. Ordered slices of pepperoni, the Loophole and the thicker Grandma variety along with some garlic knots that were on special this day. Everything was FANTASTIC. Crust had perfect crispness, sauce had deep and bright flavor and all the toppings were top notch. This might very well be my new favorite pizza in Cincinnati. It is THAT GOOD. Extra bonuses: Friendly staff and great music being played on the sound system. read more

Trophy Pizza - Evendale - Pepperoni, 2 Loopholes (chicken, cheese, bacon, jalapeño, caramelized onions and homemade ranch), 2 Grandma slices and garlic knots. - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

We come here every day we have off because we enjoy the pizzas and Max's friendliness and hospitality. You must try! read more

Trophy Pizza - Evendale - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Tried out Trophy's Pizza. Delicious. I recommend going in person and ordering individual slices. Ordering an entire pizza would have taken an hour! We chose several different slices from the case. Pepperoni was great, as was the sausage and ricotta. Really liked their meat. The kids enjoyed, and I'll have my slices I brought home for a late night snack or breakfast! read more

My friends and me wanted to try this place previously but they had gotten swamped and ran out of dough. I then decided I was ready to try again. Upon entering, it is a very quaint establishment. The associates were very hard at work filling orders I was very pleasantly greeted and asked what I would like to order. They sell slices of pizza that looked delicious but there wasn't anything that looked like what I wanted. Unfortunately they only sell 20" pizza which saddened me as a single person wanting pizza. I also think from a personal perspective that only being able to make that size slows them down. But nonetheless I chose to get a deluxe calzone with sausage, green peppers, mushrooms and caramelize onions. I waited for the calzone to complete and was on my way as a to go order. The calzone was full of ricotta and mozzarella along with the ingredients along with dipping pizza sauce on the side. It was very delicious and I definitely want to return with a group to order pizza. I very much wish they would add smaller sizes but for now, I will maybe have to return for a slice. The calzone was also extremely large and that too could be halved in size. I definitely do not think you will be disappointed and the food is absolutely delicious. Expect a wait and expect a lot of food. Give them a try!! read more

Trophy Pizza - Evendale - Working hard satisfying customers! - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Legit NY style pizza and my wife said the gluten free pizza was also great. Can't wait to go back. read more

Trophy Pizza - Evendale - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Great slices of pizza. Cool vibe when you eat in. The essentials are done well. Crust, sauce and cheese

This Jersey girl is so very happy to announce that after more than 35 years of "pizza exile" in Cincinnati there truly is a pizza worthy of comparison to those amazing slices from my childhood in NJ and 11 years in NYC. Because our children and grandchildren all currently live in North Jersey, spouse and I simply had stopped bothering ordering pizza out here, preferring to have the real deal when we visit our family. Tonight we ordered the plain pie with caramelized onions and mushrooms.The woman who answered our phone call was both pleasant and professional. Still hot when it came home with my spouse, it simply was delicious: thin crust, the perfect mount of sauce and cheese, fresh yummy toppings, and NOT at all greasy, as evidenced by the state of the doily placed under it, a touch I really appreciate. Bonus for us: only a five-minute drive from our home. Give it a try! read more