I visited Rider on October 31, 2026, for a 5:30 p.m. dinner reservation and came away with mixed…read morefeelings.
ATMOSPHERE AND SEATING
The atmosphere made a favorable first impression. The music was interesting and enjoyable, and the subdued lighting generally created a sense of privacy without making it difficult to see my food or surroundings.
Unfortunately, my original bench seating was extremely uncomfortable. At 6'0" and 245 pounds, I found the bench positioned so close to the table that I felt as though I was being cut in half. To Rider's credit, I was offered the opportunity to move to another table with individual chairs, which was a considerable improvement.
The second table, however, highlighted an odd lighting problem. A light was positioned directly above one seat at the four-person table. If all four seats were occupied, one diner would essentially be sitting in a spotlight while the other three remained in shadow.
I also noticed that menus remained on the tables throughout the meal. Initially, I assumed mine had simply been overlooked, but I saw the same thing at other tables. This struck me as unprofessional.
APPETIZER
I began with the $20 golden calamari. It looked appealing when it arrived, with a nice presentation and accompaniments, but unfortunately the eating experience didn't match its appearance. The breading lacked the crispness I expect from fried calamari, while the calamari itself was chewy and rubbery. At that price, it was a disappointing start.
MAIN COURSE
Fortunately, the $34 salmon completely changed the direction of the meal. It was excellent: perfectly cooked, moist and tender, with outstanding seasoning and flavor. The presentation was beautiful, and the accompanying side salad was dressed very well.
The fingerling potatoes were good, too. They were properly cooked, pleasantly textured, and nicely seasoned.
I also ordered $13 truffle fries, and they were excellent. They had exactly the contrast I look for: a crispy exterior with a soft, fluffy interior. The seasoning was excellent, the portion was generous, and the truffle ranch dipping sauce was a welcome alternative to ordinary ketchup.
One word of caution about portions: they are substantial. Between the salmon and sides, the amount of food was almost too much.
DESSERT
I finished with two scoops of plain vanilla gelato ($10). A simple dessert can still be satisfying when the quality feels special, but this one did not stand out. After such a strong entrée, dessert was underwhelming. It reminded me of ordinary store-bought ice cream, only at restaurant prices.
The wait made matters worse. More than 10 minutes after placing the order, I still had no dessert. My waitress eventually came by, confirmed that it had not arrived, and went to check on it. It arrived afterward.
SERVICE AND MANAGEMENT
My waitress approached the table promptly at the beginning, so there was no initial wait to be greeted. During the meal, however, soda refills were not particularly attentive. I also noticed, as a separate observation, that she spent a considerable amount of time on her cell phone.
On the positive side, she was genuinely pleasant to speak with. We ended up having a long conversation about everything and nothing in particular, and that was a surprisingly enjoyable part of the evening.
Management left a different impression. The manager stopped to speak with guests at the tables around me, then walked away without speaking to or acknowledging me.
WEBSITE AND MENU ACCURACY
Rider's website advertised a "Local's 3-Course Dinner" for $55, but that option was unavailable during my visit. Although it did not influence my decision to dine here, advertised offerings should accurately reflect what guests can order.
I also noticed conflicting information about service charges. Rider's dinner menu states that a 20% service charge will be added to each bill, while another section of the website specifies parties of six or more. As a solo diner, I was not charged an automatic service fee. I have included a screenshot of the website's wording. Clearer information would help guests understand what to expect.
BILL AND OVERALL IMPRESSION
My bill totaled $83 before tax and $91.76 after tax. I voluntarily added a 20% tip of $16.60, bringing my final total to $108.36.
There is plenty to like about Rider: outstanding salmon, excellent fries, good fingerling potatoes, enjoyable music, and a genuinely pleasant conversation with my waitress. However, the disappointing calamari and dessert, uncomfortable initial seating, uneven lighting, inconsistent service, and lack of acknowledgment from management detracted from the experience.
Rider's kitchen demonstrated that it can deliver an excellent main course. I would like to see that same attention to detail carried throughout the entire dining experience.