Tonari has been high on my list for a long time. Their regular menu looks inspired and unique.
I was the last in my party of 3 to arrive and was escorted upstairs to meet them. I quickly realized that I was required to take my shoes off and regretted not wearing shoes that required socks lol.
It was Restaurant Week, so the menu was limited and Tonari decided to pay homage to the tv show, The Bear! How cute.
There was a total of 5 courses, two options in each, and a welcome drink to start us off. My friends and I ordered one of everything, except the charred radicchio from Course 2. I also ordered the Mochi Sour cocktail and my friend ordered the Tonari Chino.
WELCOME DRINK-
1. Cocktail - served in a mini red solo cup, and reminded me of college jungle juice, 6/10.
2. Mocktail - tasted like mango juice and not much else. Very sweet, 6/10.
COURSE 1
1. Oyster Rockefeller - my friends were disappointed that it wasn't in the shell and it was very watery. I wasn't able to try it. They both really liked the oyster crackers though.
2. Cannoli - I wasn't sure how the flavors would go together and I was still confused after eating it. Salmon roe overpowered everything. Mortadella mousse was yummy! Cannoli shell seemed a little soggy. Not bad, but not good, 4/10.
Waitress then came over to ask for our thoughts and we hesitated as we didn't really enjoy it. She kept pressing us for answers about what we liked, which was awkward. When she left, the 3 of us agreed that the question should be rephrased/approached differently in case patrons might have constructive feedback.
COURSE 2
Lamb Ragu - lamb was cooked well and had great flavor. Buns were soft and complemented the meat well. Dish felt very one note and we all agreed that it would work better with some kind of acidity, 7/10.
COURSE 3
1. Mushroom Adobo - was a unique dish. The mushroom adobo was flavorful and tasty. The coconut rice was very rich and mushy. Everything paired very well together, but felt heavy. My friend and I found the flavors tiring after several bites.
2. Spaghetti - my friend & I's favorite of the night. It was simple, yet executed brillantly. Pasta cooked perfectly and the sauce was sooo good. However, my other friend didn't like it and couldn't finish it. I give it an 8/10.
COURSE 4
This came out shortly after Course 3. We had more than half of it left and now our table was packed. Timing was a big issue from this point on.
Pizzas were essentially the same. They came out room temperature and soggy. I love a hot pizza, especially in the pan-pizza, Detroit-style-esque way that Tonari makes them. Comparing the Deep Dish to the Pepperoni, there wasn't any difference in look or taste besides the toppings. We thought they were okay, 6.5/10.
Our waitress came again and asked about our courses. She even commented about how quick the succession of food came out and said, "I wanted to make sure the food was coming out." Again, felt really awkward as she pressed for very specific things we liked or noticed about the courses. Also, service team kept taking away some of the dirty plates and leaving some. It was weird.
Some time before dessert our waitress came back again and kneeled in the seat next to my friend, and let out a big sigh. She looked around and then apologized because she just remembered that my friend ordered the Tonari Chino. Since there was only one course left, my friend declined going through with the order.
COURSE 5
We waited for over 15 mins for our dessert and our waitress was no where in sight.
1. Sundae - when our sundaes came out they were already half melted, and they poured the hot fudge immediately for my friends as if to cover this fact up. My friends ate what was left of their dessert but the vanilla and pistachio gelatos had melted into a soupy mess. The hot fudge was quite good, loved the dark chocolate, 5/10.
2. Donut - small and cute, cinnamon sugar donut. I would have preferred the chocolate cake they had earlier in the week, but it wasn't available. They paired the donut with an apple cider sauce which made the dry donut taste a lot better. I liked this course overall but wouldn't order it again, 6/10.
Overall, I did not enjoy this meal at Tonari. It felt overpriced and menu confused. I liked the homage to The Bear, but I don't feel like it captured the show at all besides the names. Im more intrigued by their regular menu items. I don't think this meal represented Tonari in a good way.
I hope to come back for their regular menu one day, but not anytime soon. read more