Cancel

Open app

Search

Tomato Pie Cafe

3.9 (85 reviews)
ModerateItalian, Pizza
Closed • 4:00 pm - 8:00 PM

Tomato Pie Cafe Photos

Business Info

TOMATO PIE CAFE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Moderate noise
Casual
Good for groups
Outdoor seating

You might also consider

More like Tomato Pie Cafe

Recommended Reviews - Tomato Pie Cafe

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Penne Pink Leek swimming in sauce with hardly any noodles
Liz G.

I grew up going to Tomato Pie Cafe in North Park and anxiously await for it to open every year since (seasonal). In all of the years going, I've always had pleasant service and the food is typically a 4/5! It's a BYOB spot and only open a few days a week for a few hours so you have to get there right when it opens to snag a spot, or hope you're lucky. They do not take reservations. Recently, I called to place a to-go order at around 5:30pm on a Friday night. I was told the wait would be 1 hour & 45 minutes - While I do think that is quite a long time for a pizza & a pasta dish, I understood it was a busy Friday night and was willing to wait. When I arrived at the restaurant, I was 15 minutes earlier that the anticipated 1hr. & 45 min. wait time but wanted to go in to pay. When I was greeted by the hostess, I said "I am here early for my take out order but wanted to come in and pay." When the hostess went back to the kitchen, all I could hear was the staff in the back complaining about me - "Liz is early, why did she come early, we told her 7:15pm and it's only 7pm, she's not getting her food early" etc. I was appalled that they were speaking that loudly/poorly about a customer, especially when I didn't ask for my food early or anything of that matter. I ignored the comments because the hostess was friendly. I paid and she told me it would be 15 more minutes - totally fine, as I KNEW what the expected order time was. So I went back in after that time to get my food. When the hostess went back to the kitchen this time, I could hear the staff again - "Is she really here for her food 1 minute after the scheduled pick up time?" etc. At this point, I'm like...."what am I doing wrong??" I came in to pay early and then picked up my food at the time YOU told me to? Again, I never said anything about the time/wait/anything!! Finally, I get my food and take it home to eat. The food was truly not good which is the first time I've experienced less than good food at TPC. My usual favorite dish, Penne Pink Leek, was like sludge in the container. The sauce had barely any flavor and was so thin. The ratio of sauce/pasta was not good, there was so much sauce that the pasta was swimming in it. I'm so confused because there was hardly any pasta in the container. I had never ordered the flat bread before but wanted to try it - it is literally just baked dough with a side of marinara sauce to dip. The only "saving grace" of this order was the Tomato Pie Pizza. It was pretty good. I am truly saddened by this experience. I have no idea what I did that was causing the staff to be so angry but I can honestly say, I won't be returning any time soon because of that treatment.

Pepperoni pizza
Carolyn K.

The star of the show here (in my opinion) is the outdoor patio in North Park, the BYOB option, and of course the pizza. We got the pepperoni and was pleasantly surprised. They were severely understaffed on the day we were there, but our waitress did the best she could (which was great) to accommodate a full table. **IMPORTANT NOTE: CASH ONLY!!!!!***

Beans and greens
Ashley P.

I've been here a few times now. While the hours are few and the menu is a bit sparse, everything there is quality. It's a small family owned business that has been around for many years and you can see why when you go. Since they're only open for a few hours, the restaurant is usually pretty full. The food is fresh and there are healthy options, like a beet salad and their healthy version of beans and greens with kale and chickpeas. The pizza, pasta, and salads are all good. I haven't gotten anything I didn't like yet. As I said, the food is very good, but don't expect extras. Like parmesan cheese on your pasta? Nope, not gonna get it. They don't accept credit cards, but have an ATM inside. They don't have alcohol, but allow you to bring your own and don't charge a corking fee. If you're drinking wine, you may want to bring your own wine glasses, too, unless you don't mind possibly drinking out of a regular glass.

Restaurant

I have been coming here since 2012 and it has always had the same freshness and quality of food through the years. Rico is the most incredible restaurant owner I've ever met. A great man through and through. Combine the excellent food with the excellent culture he's created and you have Tomato Pie Cafe. Everything that a restaurant should be.

Large cheese and basil half pepperoni

Pizza was absolutely amazing, best around Pittsburgh. A bit expensive, but can be a nice treat once in a while. Heads up it's cash only, but they have an ATM inside

Hot Sausage and Peppers

See all

Reviews are generally positive. People praise the fresh, flavorful food, especially the outstanding pizza. The cozy outdoor patio and friendly, attentive service are also highlights.

Read the full review summary in the app

Photo of T W.
0
2
0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Al S.
0
40
0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 3 of 3

Ask the Community - Tomato Pie Cafe

You might also consider

DiAnoia's Eatery

DiAnoia's Eatery

4.4(1.3k reviews)
9.7 mi•Strip District
•$$

My mom and I spent the night in Pittsburgh on our way up to Toronto and got lucky enough to get a…read morespot at DiaNoia's for dinner. We got on the list and waited about 35 minutes for a spot at the bar. The restaurant itself has a casual Italian American vibe, with a small bar in the front and a dining area on the side. So happy we got a spot there because our bartender/server Nami was one of the best service experiences I've ever had. She asked us if we had been there before, gave us the rundown on the handmade pasta, what they're known for, and more. She mentioned the gnocchi being their top seller, but I'm not the biggest fan. However, the girl next to me got the gnocchi and meatballs, so snuck a pic of that just for sharing. They are HUGE and puffy and might make me change my mind about gnocchi. Anyway, Nami was so fun and attentive without being overbearing, and the place was busy as hell. She even made sure we had some cookies to take home when we declined dessert, telling us she didn't want us to have any regrets. Spoiler, the cookies totally hit the spot later in our hotel when we needed a little sweet before bed. Ok, onto the food. Nami brought us the fluffiest, most beautiful foccacia bread with olive oil and balsamic vinegar for dipping to start. We ordered the stuffed mushrooms, which were cooked to perfection, filled with this decadent mushroom mousse and then surrounded by a bright and flavor tomato onion jam that we kept scooping up with everything we could find. For our entree we shared the Salsiccia e Cavolo - which is fusilli, sweet sausage, braise cabbage, onions, cream, nutmeg and parmesan. What a perfect, cozy, delicious pasta for a fall night. It was creamy, flavorful, pasta was perfectly cooked. We took the leftovers back with us and it also reheated beautifully with a bit of water over the stove, so we got to enjoy it twice. Highly recommend a dinner here if you can get a table/spot at the bar, did not disappoint. If I'm ever back in Pittsburgh, I'll be back to give the gnocchi and meatballs a try.

Located on a corner lot, DiAnoia's signage stands prominently on top of a beautiful brick…read morebuilding. There is even a little balcony overlooking the main ordering area on the inside. I have no idea if it's a functioning balcony or not, but it was a neat touch. They had cool light-catching chandeliers made of blue and green glass bottles. We ordered near the back of that main room and sat ourselves. We came at the tail end of the lunch service; there was ample seating. There was a little baked goods case by the ordering counter. It was incredibly responsible and thoughtful that they had ingredients listed for their goodies. Everything looked delicious. We chose the family style wood slab high-top table. I ordered the meatball sub- it was delicious. Three massive meatballs on warm crispy bread and three cheeses. It was absolutely delicious. I ate my meatball sandwich with a knife and fork, because it knew I'd make a mess if I'd attempted otherwise; I was very pleased with the portions. It was still delicious when I ate the other half the next day warmed up! It holds up well.

Photos
DiAnoia's Eatery - Seating area

Seating area

DiAnoia's Eatery - Margherita Calabrese

Margherita Calabrese

DiAnoia's Eatery - House Salad with Mixed Greens, Olives, Chickpeas, Cherry Tomatoes, Roasted Red Peppers, Cucumbers, and Oregano Vinaigrette

See all

House Salad with Mixed Greens, Olives, Chickpeas, Cherry Tomatoes, Roasted Red Peppers, Cucumbers, and Oregano Vinaigrette

Girasole Restaurant

Girasole Restaurant

3.9(762 reviews)
10.6 mi•Shadyside
•$$

So this location was only about a 10 minute walk from our hotel and we are so glad that we checked…read moreit out. It is a very cozy Italian restaurant that's serving homemade Italian food like your Nonna would make for you. We showed up on a Tuesday night and it was packed. It was around six or 6:30 in the evening and when we first got there, we were told it would be about a 20 minute wait before a two top was available. But the host came back and asked if we didn't mind sitting by the kitchen they could see us right away. We chose to sit by the kitchen, which honestly was probably the best option because it was actually a little bit quieter because there was a very large party that was celebrating a birthday and they had live music going on so it was hard to hear when you were in the main dining space but back by the kitchen it's a little bit quieter and we could actually hear ourselves talk. My husband got the penne with meatballs and the penny was nicely cooked with a beautiful tomato Bass sauce and the meatballs or some of the best Italian meatball he's ever had. His only complaint was that there were only two in the order and he wished there would've been three. I got the spinach and ricotta, stuffed ravioli, and by far one of the best raviolis I've ever had. The ravioli are large so there's only about five in a dish but they're packed fully and the flavoring and seasoning is absolutely spectacular. It's got a beautiful sauce like accompanies it and the chew you can definitely tell it is handmade pasta/ravioli. Our server, Emma was absolutely spectacular and was so kind. We truly enjoyed our experience here and would highly recommend anybody to check it out if you're in the area. But we also do recommend make your reservations ahead of time. This place gets packed quickly.

Very, very good Italian spot near Walnut Street, very close by all the top shops. The ambiance is…read morevery nice, both inside and outside. Pretty tight space though. The waitresses are friendly and have great recommendations. I got to try their linguine rustica (essentially the clam pasta dish), a cappuccino, some cherry soda, and soup of the day, as well as complimentary bread. They got that bread out very quickly! Very soft, and served with quite high quality olive oil. The bottle has both olive oil and balsamic! The soup of the day was quite good as well. It was some sort of beef broth, I think may a beef and bean soup. Chickpeas in there as well. Next time, I might try the salad. The salad they have as a side is so good, an amazing portion and seems so fresh and tasty. The mains were excellent. Very good pasta with clam sauce. Lots of clam meat and a flavorful oil based sauce. My friend had some red penne with chicken and enjoyed that as well. Great portions, pretty fair prices. Finally, great drinks as well. Very memorable cherry cola that I believe the company is owned by the owner's son. Real cane sugar, very good. The cappuccino was great as well. Definitely come here!

Photos
Girasole Restaurant - Penne with sausage

Penne with sausage

Girasole Restaurant - Beef Tenderloin over Risotto & Spinach

Beef Tenderloin over Risotto & Spinach

Girasole Restaurant - (Mediocre) spinach and ricotta

See all

(Mediocre) spinach and ricotta

Saint Ravioli

Saint Ravioli

5.0(6 reviews)
9.6 mi•Bloomfield

Every year my girlfriend and I find a cooking or baking class that is local in Pittsburgh to do…read moretogether. This year we decided to down our robes and become disciples of Saint Ravioli. Getting a spot in a class is very hard since they are limited to 6-8 people, but if you get the chance I absolutely recommend it. The classes are 2 hours long each and are extremely intimate. Bryan and Justin will meet you at the door and will introduce you to their workshop. There is a spread of antipasto to snack on which was curated very well. Each person gets to make 4 (four!!) dozen raviolis each. The class is extremely informative and fun. I personally haven't ordered any of their ravioli drops before, but from eating the batch I personally made, I know I will in the future. Highly recommend ordering their raviolis online or taking the class if it's available.

Although it takes some planning to order ahead, then pickup your order, the Ravioli is amazing…read more When you pick up your order, it's frozen. To prepare it, simply drop into boiling water, then after it floats to the top, wait a few minutes. I also ordered the Marinara sauce which was delicious. The owner friendly and helpful. He noticed that this was my first order, so he took some time to explain a few things and answer questions. Parking is on the street, and I had no problems finding a spot. It's a fun experience and I will definitely do it again.

Photos
Saint Ravioli
Saint Ravioli - Wedding soup ravioli

Wedding soup ravioli

Saint Ravioli

See all

Lucca Ristorante

Lucca Ristorante

3.1(314 reviews)
10.7 mi•Oakland
•$$

Had a wonderful work holiday meal at Lucca! I didn't even know this place existed. Everyone's food…read morelooked great and everyone enjoyed their cocktails as well. The service was good - she was very busy and could have used a hand when there were several parties and we were a bigger party. I had the sausage and mushroom risotto which was delightful! I really enjoyed the sundrjed tomatoes on top and felt like it could have been throughout for a little brightness, just because it was so rich. Also thought it was a little light on the sausage. I enjoyed the hazelnut crunch cake but wasn't wowed by it. I might be back if someone else is paying! A little steep to be a regular!

The food here is really good! I have just two of the dishes shown here. The frutti di mare was…read moreabsolutely amazing. I love the different seafoods mixed in with the vodka sauce...just so good! The restaurant is a bit small, at least in the area we got sat. I did ask to move because of how narrow the walkway was between our table and another party plus the chair behind me was directly up against my head so if somebody sat right behind us it would have been awkward. The only other thing I've noticed was that they were very slow to greet us and get our order...took around 15 minutes for that. No other complaints besides that! I'm only given it 4 stars just because of the slow service and the seating arrangement being very awkward but they were nice to accommodate and move us somewhere else!

Photos
Lucca Ristorante - Shrimp, scallop, tartare and beef

Shrimp, scallop, tartare and beef

Lucca Ristorante
Lucca Ristorante

See all

Piccolo Forno - Three Cheese Mezzaluna with Wild Mushroom Marsala Cream Sauce

Piccolo Forno

4.1(685 reviews)
9.0 mi•Lawrenceville
•$$

The pizza at Piccolo Forno is consistently excellent, with thin, perfectly cooked crusts and…read morecreative topping combinations. The Fichi & Formaggi, Mortadella & Pistachio, and Calabrese are among my favorites. On my most recent visit, I also tried the burrata appetizer for takeout. The peppery arugula and sweet peaches worked beautifully with the creamy burrata and made for a great combination. Pickup was a breeze. A friendly staff member greeted me and quickly pointed out my order among the others on the takeout table. The restaurant itself was packed, and for good reason. I've been coming to Piccolo Forno for years, and everything I've ordered has delivered. It remains one of my go-to spots for excellent pizza in Pittsburgh.

I liked this place! Not all of the dishes and not the attitude of the server at times. I just…read moredidn't like that the server kept reminding us of a time placed on each table before it needed to turnover. I thought that was very rude and off putting. Parking is difficult in this area, so keep that in mind when reserving. However, I had a great time fellowshipping with friends. The place was lovely with laughter and what I ordered, I liked. For appetizers we ordered the peach bruschetta (special), the pistachio and pesto pizza without the pork, and the insalata salad. My favorite was the brussel sprouts and carrotts app. We also ordered the lasagna which was different. It had cinnamon and nutmeg. I was expecting classic lasagna. The seafood spaghetti also was not what I expected. The spice was nice, but I didn't like the texture of the pasta and the seafood was very fishy. The pesto pasta was good but needed salt. For dessert the boomba was the best! Tiramisu was mid. Again, cinnamon and a fresh flavor that didn't provide the traditional flavors I anticipated. The wine from the package store near by can be ordered and brought to your table. Paid for separately and via an app.

Photos
Piccolo Forno - Inside

Inside

Piccolo Forno - Seasonal Peach Bruschetta

Seasonal Peach Bruschetta

Piccolo Forno

See all

Alla Famiglia - Vodka pasta

Alla Famiglia

4.3(556 reviews)
11.8 mi•Allentown
•$$$$

This deserves a bonus star (or I need to quit giving so many other 5 star ratings). A true diamond…read morein Pittsburgh's Allentown neighborhood on the South Side. First tip: come hungry. They will give you more than you can eat (starts with bread, then a salad, then pasta, and then the entree). There is lot parking nearby that you can pay at a kiosk (if you can find parking) or pay a valet. The meal is structured with bread served along side "holy oil" (olive oil dipping sauce infused with herbs and peppers) and fagioli spread for the bread. Incredible so far and gets better. We skipped appetizers and went to the salad. You get a lot of salad. I got the Tuscan kale salad - delicious, with the heavy bitter taste of the kale balanced with apples, candied walnut, and lemon vinaigrette dressing. The star of the evening was the cacio e pepe pasta which they mix in front of you at your table. The taste of the rich Romano cheese, salty with pepper and silky smooth (yet binding) is almost transcendental. You have to just taste this. I can't do it justice in a written review. The main course was the pollo forno. Chicken with a sauce that was almost like chimmichurri, fingerling potatoes. I was still bedazzled from the pasta, but the main course was still scrumptious. Service is top-notch. The servers know the menu and are ready to help with recommendations. This is worth the splurge. Go already if you haven't.

This is our second time visiting this restaurant and we loved it just as much…read more We started our meal with the smoked provolone. It was very over the top and indulgent. I went with the casa salad, it had so many toppings including a lot of blue cheese. I feel it would have been enough for my meal. For my pasta, we did the cacio e Pepe, which what they are famous for. They don't do it table side for GF pasta since it would be cross contaminated. For our main my husband and I shared the margarita veal medallions and the sea bass. Both were very good and large servings. For dessert, they gave us a complimentary champagne glasses and a little dessert. We also got the crème brûlée. It had cherries on top and a chocolate ganache at the bottom. Once again, very indulgent. I had a lemon drop martini that was very good during my meal and a glass of wine. They have a very good wine list but not very affordable. Overall, it's a great place for special occasions. They have very good waitstaff and it makes the experience even better.

Photos
Alla Famiglia - Upstairs Bar and Dining Area

Upstairs Bar and Dining Area

Alla Famiglia - Chicken alla limon

Chicken alla limon

Alla Famiglia - Exterior of restaurant

See all

Exterior of restaurant

Big Jim's Restaurant & Bar - Chicken Parm Sub

Big Jim's Restaurant & Bar

4.2(371 reviews)
11.9 mi•Greenfield
•$$

Big Jim's is a Pittsburgh institution. It's been 20 years or so since my last visit to Big Jim's…read more My family was headed towards town around dinner time and decided to take advantage of the opportunity and stop by. We arrived around 4:30 on a Friday. We were able to get a parking spot around the back. We were quickly seated and beat the dinner rush by a few minutes. First off, our waitress couldn't have been sweeter. Super friendly and attentive. Very kind, especially to my youngest son. My wife had a small fish sandwich, my oldest son had the baked ziti, my youngest son had chicken parm, and I had gnocchi with meat sauce. Portions were large and tasty. Three of us had cups of wedding soup. Everyone was stuffed and enjoyed their meal. I would highly recommend and will not have a 20 year gap in visits to Big Jim's (in the run).

A friend told us how good Big Jim's was and we are so glad we decided to go try it…read more We were warmly greeted when we entered. The waitress was also very nice and accommodating the entire time. A man was also very helpful and brought us things we may need. I really enjoyed the super meaty and delicious meatballs on my meatball hoagie. The Marinara was really good. My husband's Italian and absolutely loved the veal cutlet sandwich. It was huge, crunchy and tasty. It made him nostalgic for the veal cutlets his grandmother used to make. The Fresh-cut Fries were good but weren't seasoned well enough. I also wish they were crunchier. We saw a man order the Stromboli and it was ginormous but looked delicious. He was a big guy and only ate about 25% of it. Got my mom a corned beef sandwich and she said it one of the best she had ever had. We're Irish and she loves them. There are lots of great things on the menu and will be back to try other things.

Photos
Big Jim's Restaurant & Bar
Big Jim's Restaurant & Bar - Giant reubens

Giant reubens

Big Jim's Restaurant & Bar - Bar area

See all

Bar area

Tomato Pie Cafe - italian - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...