Let me say first that I love the atmosphere at Timothy's and the quality of the service is outstanding. For the most part the food was tasty, but not a great value for the money. My bacon wrapped meatloaf ($28) was less than half the size of Stoney River's Steakhouse for $27 and Annie Gunn's lunch portion for $20. The burger was not served medium as requested and the French fries were cold. read more

I never eat fries please please please try there garlic fries my full meal and nice staff ...

Stopped in again on another trip to Creve Coeur and had a Caesar's salad and a Timothy's burger. Both were well presented and good portions. I enjoyed the meal and within my travel budget... which is becoming a challenge these days. The dining room is white paper tables and a little cramped but comfortable enough. They gave me a table as a single so I can't complain. Service is professional and courteous and turned around my order with the proper timing. I recommend if your in the area. read more

See all

When we were taken to our table I noticed how nicely the table looked with the white tablecloth, the glassware and silverware. We started with the Berries and Goat Cheese Salad. The salad was served with a spring mix, red onion, strawberry, blueberry, sliced almonds, goat cheese, and a honey mustard vinaigrette. The salad was a 5 out of 5. Excellent flavors with fresh ingredients and the perfect dressing. We ordered the Miso Poached Grouper and the Filet of Beef. We shared the entrees so we could enjoy tasting both. The grouper was a 4 out of 5 and the Filet was 3.5 out of 5. The grouper had Hen of the woods mushroom, sugar snap peas, napa cabbage, miso broth, and micro cilantro. The grouper was perfectly cooked and seasoned well. The mushroom, snap peas, and cabbage was overcooked and limpy. The Filet of Beef had Broccolini, whipped potatoes, and red wine. The filet was not tender. This was very disappointing. The sauce with the filet was a big plus. For dessert we shared Death by Chocolate. It consisted of flourless chocolate cake, dark chocolate mousse, espresso, and crème anglaise. The dessert was a 5 out of 5. We received excellent service. This is a cute little restaurant and we enjoyed the experience. read more

See all

Strong food presentation and taste, with good service. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The place was empty on a Sunday evening, so I'd like to assess the service when a larger crowd was present.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Tuesday August 8,2023 5:00PM 6 for cocktail enjoyment. Parking - private (Excellent) Staff - 100% perfect Ambiance - No room for improvement Special cocktail offered every night. Bartender is extraordinary!! Appetizers: Grilled cauliflower - so delicious BBQ Chicken wings - Perfect Deviled Eggs - Unique & tasty Heavenly French fries - gourmet Each one was perfect, unique, and delicious. Timothy's burger - Large and super delicious. Caesar salad - Excellent Excellent wine menu. Beer selection too. The entire evening was perfect. Separate Dinning room- exquisite. Quiet evening NO Loud Guests. Timothy's is a gem. You will love it. read more

Overpriced and new twists on standard menu items that can surprise you. Excellent dessert choices.

This is a lovely, upscale American restaurant whose chef is inspired by Southern and New Orleans cuisine. The interior decor is lovely. As are the serving staff. The wine list is extensive as is the whiskey and cordial's list. Price wise, this is an upscale restaurant so we're looking at $$$. The gumbo what's delicious, but they are a bit stingy on the crab meat and the sausage... We had to ask for more. Definitely recommend the shrimp and grits. The tater tots with pimento cheese is a must get. read more

See all

Food and service were top tier which is unusual during Happy hours across the city. A must visit

I took some friends for a late lunch. The food was fantastic, the service was impeccable and a nice atmosphere. I had the Timothy's burger and fries (I'm hoping my cardiologist doesn't read this) and it was excellent!! I only ate half of it. My friends had a BLT and the Beef and noodles. They looked great. I had the lemon sorbet and it was perfectly tart! Definitely going back! read more

Great food and staff Sat at the bar for brunch, staff was very personable and food was delicious read more

There's a nice, cozy atmosphere here - even on Valentines Day. Service was refined yet comfortable, what typically seems to go with a more expensive restaurant. Meal felt very relaxed and our server took care to tell us they were never in a hurry for us to move on, leave, etc. The restaurant had a few special items (some extra small plates, entrees, desserts) for Valentines, but the entire menu was available and needed for a full meal. I liked this because there were some menu items I wanted to try that likely would have been left off a prix fixe menu. They offer a nice selection of nonalcoholic beverages, including more than just a couple of mocktails. The wife took a bubbly rose option, and I went with a sangria. Both tasted good were quite similar to the real stuff. And prices were reasonable too. For food, the wife's Caesar salad was well spiced, not with heat but with seasoning. My she crab soup was also flavorful and contained a nice amount of crab. Her scallop gratin (V-day special) was very rich, which I liked in that she had to give me some of it. Generous with the butter and cheese on some quality scallops. My cacio e pepe pasta (V-day special) was also put together very well. Simple ingredients, but assembled and cooked just right. Dessert was a fantastic white chocolate bread pudding (another special), with a scoop of their butter pecan ice cream on the side. And my only ding is for the ice cream. Perhaps it suffered in being next to the bread pudding, but I thought the buttery taste was lacking and its texture was move like ice milk (for those of you old enough to remember that term). I definitely plan to be back to sample for of their regular menu. read more

See all

I am not impressed at all. Salad was so salty. Steak tips dish is aka beef stroganoff. I ordered it and two glasses of wine. I left spending $82. I did not experience that price point for dining. unbelievable in my mind Atmosphere is fine and our service great. However, I will not go back read more

Group of 4 had a lovely dinner and dining experience. Food was very good and everyone was very satisfied with their selection. Service was excellent. The server knew we were old friends and wanted to catch up. She gave us plenty of time to visit without abandoning us. Tables are spaced so that the atmosphere is a bit more private and less noisy than most other restaurants. read more

Husband and I went on a Valentines date. The food was delicious. Would definitely be back! Service was good too. read more

See all

Food was good! Service was amazing and it has a nice dim lighting for a nice date night. read more

Timothy's - Nashville, hot chicken - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - St Louis, Missouri

Excellent food and service!! If you want delicious and unique food in a special setting, this is the place. I didn't indulge, but they had an amazing wine and cocktail list. I'll be back to try that. The service was extraordinary! This is a special place and worth it. Brunch was remarkable and everyone cleaned their plates!! read more

had a chance to stop by @timothysstl for lunch! it's such a cute place! We ordered: Timothy's Burger - Angus beef, pimento cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, fried onion ring, mustard aioli served with fries, Pimento Deviled eggs, Smoked wings and some cocktails. Everything tasted great! However, we had to send the fries back because they were super under cooked, had to ask for more fixings to moisten and burger and bread up and the wings were probably some of the hardest wings I've had BUT the flavor was good!! Those issues were minor and I know to ask for things to be cooked to my liking going forward. Our server was top notch and made sure we were happy! For that, I'll definitely circle around for dinner! OH! The desserts were awesome! Apple Pie Bread Pudding- Crumble topping, caramel sauce, crispy brown butter, butter pecan ice cream Key Lime Crème Brûlée- Vanilla whipped cream, graham crumble. I HATE bread pudding but our server said it was his favorite. I trusted him and ordered it and it was not super mushy like traditional bread puddings which I was happy about. The apples and crumbles knocked it up some notches! The Brulé was good and creamy and it wasn't too limey or crunchy! LOVED IT! The cocktails were on point! strong enough, but not too strong! When you visit, be sure to tell them @followchi4food sent you!! . read more

The food was so salty to where it was almost inedible. Had steak. It says served medium rare. I prefer medium. They said they could only do medium rare, medium well, or well. I ordered medium well. It was beyond well. My husband ordered medium rare. It too was beyond well. The Demi glaze was so coagulated you couldn't pour it from the little dish they give you the glaze in. It too was so salty. Garlic Pan roasted potatoes was actually a potato cut in half lengthwise and broiled. So dry. No taste of garlic, but again plenty of salt. My cocktail was so watered down it tasted like lime water. My husband had wine. It did have a nice selection of wine. The wait staff was on top of things and pleasant. The restroom had feces smeared on one of the stall floors. Dried so not like someone just did it. The advertising for this place says romantic atmosphere. Ummm no! Nothing romantic in the slightest. And all of this for $300. Overpriced. Over salted. Overly dry food. read more

Great food. Wonderful service. And the ambiance is wonderful. The food was well Prepared and seasoned just right. Love it and nice it is so close to home. read more

If you have not experienced Timothy's, run, don't walk. From a late afternoon, happy hour where you can get delicious and varied options at really nice prices, to sit down dinners that are casual and classy, you get highly attentive service + dishes that are made and served with pride as you will experience. A variety of interesting menu choices as you will find, and everything has been delicious every time I've eaten here. Please go here and enjoy - you will be glad you did, and you will come back! read more

One of the very best in any town in whichI have eaten . The chef has southern roots so the food is comforting yet interesting read more

Excellent Meal for all! Took my husband's parents here for dinner while they visited STL and had not only an excellent meal but outstanding service. In particular, their take on a beef whelington was excellent we chose rare and it was perfectly presented. I chose the deep fried lions Maine mushrooms that were not only GF but had a meaty texture and rich flavor. read more

Excellent food, service and ambience. Took less time to get my food than any other similar restaurant.

We went here just because we liked the name. the staff were friendly and warm. I loved the ambiance of the place. Food wise it was very delicious with some unique flavor pairings. I think the best at our table was the pork belly. My only critique was my salmon could have been cooked less and the 3 deviled eggs are not worth the $10. Overall a good experience. read more

Timothy's - Salmon - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - St Louis, Missouri

Great happy hour. Fantastic service. Delicious tableside bananas foster! Yum. Menus changes with the seasons.

We just had dinner there with our family. Our server Amanda was super accommodating and helpful. I even had something that was a bit too spicy for me and she went and exchanged it for something I could eat. I would def come here if I wanted a quality meal or to celebrate a Special occasion. read more

My pick for best happy hour - also best and funniest server who was also knowledgeable, helpful and available while not being intrusive- quite a feat! I tried the Buffalo cauliflower, deviled eggs and pimento tater tots for happy hour. Often I find menus eloquently portray a dish that entices you, but the reality isn't as described. Here, the menu descriptions understate how truly special the food is. The cauliflower and tots both far surpassed expectations. The setting is casually elegant with a very comfortable noise level. Prices are in line with the quality. read more

Timothy's - Pork belly - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - St Louis, Missouri

Jordan, Wayne, James, and Tierra were fantastic bartenders, servers, chefs, and hosts! Great experience! Up class all the way. Fantastic food, drinks, and more! Atmosphere is a modern sleek feel and a great date night location! A must try! Upgrading this area! read more

See all

Second visit! Did not disappoint! My favorite thing about going out for date night is consistency, if I pick a location, I want to know everything is going to be AS good as it was the time before. We brought couple friends with us last night and they loved their entree choices also. We started with the lobster pot pie, our friends loved it so much they encouraged us to try it. The bread came off easily on top, which I loved (lower carb) its not what I had expected for a pot pie. The lobster bisque underneath was so creamy and has so much flavor I was immediately jealous that we had not ordered it. On the menu was a "charred" Caesar salad with optional anchovies, I will tell you I stayed far away from those! The four of us split 2 Caesar salads and it was a perfect amount to to not fill us up before our entrées came out. I had no idea how you can char lettuce, but it was so good! Just a little more crispy and the pieces behaved better than normal lettuce, no chasing them around on the plate. Our first visit was probably in March, at that time they had a Brussel sprouts salad, I was sad to see that is not on the new menu but I'm POSITIVE when we go back we are splitting this caesar again. I ordered the steak frites and very much enjoyed the savory gravy on top. The broccoli was slightly charred also, trying to stay low carb, I asked what other vegetables were available and accidentally ended up with a vegetable hash that was mostly potatoes. Not a win, but realistically a minor inconvenience. My date ordered the pork ribeye, saying that he's never seen that on a menu before and said it was so good, he would definitely order it again. On both visits we enjoyed very much enjoyed the wine list, since we usually get a bottle for dinner, we also enjoy very competitive bottle pricing. Timothy's is definitely going into the normal rotation! Service was amazing on both visits and ambiance. Lastly I love seeing the two owners there, chipping in and making sure their clients are happy. read more

This is a very intimate and personal setting. It does not look like much on the outside and even with GPS a little tricky to find. Once inside you find a great place for date night. Table top lighting and a general cool ambiance. I imagine this place has a very loyal following. The service is very warm, inviting and attentive. The specials they ran that night included monk fish and were enticing. The menu is dynamic and the prices are very fair. I would normally not order a hamburger at a place so nice but I was in the mood and not disappointed. Flame broiled and cooked with a sere it came out perfect. Hand cut fries were mountain sized serving. I left it alone as described on the menu and pimento cheese was a good call. If I travel through again I would choose this restaurant and try all kinds of things. If I lived in the area I would be there all the time. It was a surprising joy and I encourage anyone to check it out. Hail To The Victors! Go Blue! read more

We have been anxiously waiting to stop in since we first noticed the build. Finally made it out for a birthday dinner date night that did not disappoint. One of about five groups in our section you would imagine it would be noisy but it was nothing if not just a quiet calm atmosphere with staff that mirrored that aesthetic as well. Brandon was actual perfection. Chef delivered our main courses. We look forward to making it back in often read more

See all

I don't think I could have picked a better place for our Christmas dinner this year. Ambiance = check. Delicious food = check. Superb service = check. The trifecta of a perfect dining experience. Timothy's is nestled within a shopping/dining area on Olive and we weren't even quite sure we turned the right way were it not for trusting the small sign. There is a bigger sign on the restaurant itself and once we figured out where the entrance was, we were greeted and seated at our table. Our waitress came over immediately just to introduce herself and told us she will return momentarily so we could peruse the drink menu. They have half bottles of wine (equates to about 12 ounces or 2, 6-oz glasses of wine) and the options were actually plentiful! I decided to get a Decoy half bottle and we both ordered a salad to start our dinner with. I ordered the roasted beet salad and my husband had the Caesar and added some anchovies. He has been looking for the perfect Caesar with anchovies just like what we had when we were in Minnesota. Unfortunately, he still needs to keep the search going. He did enjoy the salad but did not deem it the perfect Caesar. Mine on the other hand, was fantastic. The goat cheese, arugula, and roasted beets were such a flavorful treat to start the meal off with! They had lobsters on special last night which I briefly debated over getting. They got me with the 8oz filet mignon special though served with broccoli, fingerling potatoes and red wine demi glace. So good! The steak was so flavorful, prepared as I had requested (medium-rare), and melted in my mouth. My husband had the pork tenderloin and he enjoyed every bite. To end the evening with, we shared the key lime brulee. The custard was perfect with surprisingly refreshing flavors in every bite. I can't believe I've never heard of this place before. I was honestly just searching for places we have never been to yet! I'm glad I made us reservations here. The staff were very friendly and accommodating and our dinner was absolutely fantastic! read more

See all

Went for Happy Hour around 5pm, the place was packed. Happy Hour M-F here is 2:30pm - 6pm and they have some really good deals. My wife enjoyed the Mango Pisco Sour drink that was the "cocktail" special for Happy Hour. I enjoyed the house Chardonnay. We ordered the chicken wings, humus plate and an order of fries for apps. The fries were piping hot and I thought could use a bit more salt. The Humus plate was OK, my wife had had it previously and said it was better when the pita was warm and soft, this version the pita was cold and crisp. I thought the wings were cooked well, but I did not care for the barbecue sauce, next time I would order them sans sauce. There are a couple of other items I'd like to try on the HH menu (deviled eggs and flatbreads) and will on a future visit. I'm also very interested in several of the Dinner entrees and will try those as well. Service here was excellent and the ambiance in the place was good as well. I'm looking forward to future visits. read more

See all

Terrific menu for breakfast, lunch and dinner. The ambiance is wonderful, don't judge from the outside

I would classify Timothy's as a hidden gem. It is also a first for me, as this was my initial experience making a reservation on yelp, confirming it, and ultimately using the platform to share a review. Talk about a one-stop shop! The newly opened Timothy's restaurant brings timeless fine dining to Creve Coeur. Before going to the restaurant, perusing the menu online, I was impressed by the classic, yet approachable offerings and inventive preparations, not to mention the creative cocktail menu and solid wines (by the bottle and glass) offerings. The interior includes both a dining room and bar area. We were seated in the dining room. The ambiance is soothing and elegant. The black tablecloths and spotless waterglasses, dishware, and utensils amplified the quintessential fine-dining feel. The service here is some of the best that I have encountered in a long time. Our water glasses were topped up throughout the evening and the female server went above and beyond, providing warmth and wit as she guided us through the menu offerings. The signature menu item, the lobster pot pie, was exquisite and a must-try as a starter. The dish is a high-end interpretation of comfort food featuring shallots, peas, and a touch of cream, sherry and, of course, chunks of lobster claw meat within a puff pastry shell. The grilled Caesar salad was incredible. I would never think to grill hearts of romaine but could easily get addicted to this memorable presentation. The cocktails, too, are simple yet elegant. I ordered the Aviation. Served in a coupe, it featured gin and creme de violette. Its stunning appearance made me feel like a roaring '20s character. Dessert here is also a must. The key lime pie was out of this world, not overly sweet and perfectly portioned. Keep up the outstanding work, Timothy's! read more

We randomly popped in here after a morning soccer game for their Sunday brunch and each one of us got something very different. Cheeseburger and fries for one kid, French toast made from bread pudding for another kid, husband had the breakfast plate and I had the crab cake eggs Benedict special. Each one was delicious and our waiter was wonderful! I definitely recommend Timothy's! read more

I love this restaurant and I frequent it. All the food has been very good. A couple of minor disappointments: the fried tofu is way too salty and allow for a baked or mashed potato substitution for the frities in the steak frites dish. read more

I dont leave reviews very often, though I consider myself a foodie. I went here for a special anniversary with my family. We were so disappointed! We couldn't understand how such oversalted (lamb), overcooked (pasta), over-mayonnaised (eggs), frozen (flatbread) food could get such strong ratings. Will not be back and hopefully you don't make the same mistake. read more

Food was perfect for lunch- great ambiance. Service was fantastic and very attentive.