Herbie's is Jim Halpert. Likable, competent, easy to spend an evening with, everybody's favorite guy in the room, and the one you never end up telling stories about the next morning. Start with the service, the most Halpert thing about the place. Our server (I didn't catch his name, but he has a magnificent beard), was the best part of the night. He was professional, unhurried, and looked pleased to be helping us. The room matches him: modern, dark wood, vintage French advertising posters on the walls. The Old Fashioned was solid, though I'd take a heavier bit of orange bitters. The special burrata and tomato salad disappeared in about ninety seconds. If it's on the menu, get it. If it's off the menu, ask for it. I had the steak frites. Classic grill marks, cooked right, and the accompanying reduction earned its spot on the plate (I normally eat steak naked, and this one was better with it). The fries were fantastic, so fantastic we asked. Our server admitted it: bag, fryer, plate. You are paying for the top-priced entrée at a Clayton bistro and the best thing on the plate came off a truck. I'm still not sure how I feel about that. The housemade caramel bread pudding, served in a little skillet with a candle, was great. 3.8 out of 5 stars Herbie's delivers an excellent dinner with service to match. Missing is a dish I'm still thinking about the next day. The steak at that price should wow, not satisfy. A stronger signature entrée and a bolder cocktail and this jumps into the low to mid fours. read more

See all

I've visited Herbie's several times for business meetings and most recently a birthday lunch, and every experience has been consistently excellent. The food has been enjoyable every single time. I honestly haven't had anything there that I didn't like. From the coconut shrimp and mixed greens salad to brunch and dessert, everything has been well prepared. I'm not much of a cheesecake person (I know ), but the cheesecake from Hank's Cheesecakes was absolutely worth ordering. The atmosphere is polished without being stuffy. It's hard to find restaurants that stay consistent across multiple visits. Definitely one of my go-to spots in Clayton. read more

A celebration calls for great food, drinks and experience! Herbie's conquered all 3! Seatings: Great outdoor and indoor seating area. Extensive wine menu to choose from. The vibes of the restaurant will fit whichever mood your are in. Indoor for more dark and cozy experience. Outside by the fire pit, or around the front for a more brighter outdoor experience, or cozy up in the sofa like seating for a more comfy feel. Service- Service was great! Whenever I would turn my head, its like she had already read my mind and was right there. Good- Delicious! I had a hard time selecting because all entree sounded so good to me. I went with the pick 3 deal. Glad I did, it was worth it for an indecisive person like myself. read more

See all

What started as finding a place for dessert after eating in Clayton had turned into this being one of my go-to dessert places. Herbie's has also participated in Clayton Restaurant Week, which I love being able to try something new. Their bread pudding is amazing and what my friend's consider #1 read more

See all

We hadn't been to Herbie's for about four years - not for any particular reason - it just happened. I was looking for a place to have dinner and when I saw Herbie's, it sounded good! We had a reservation and were greeted and seated as soon as we walked in. We prefer sitting outside when we come here, but it was chilly and in addition to not wanting to be cold throughout our meal, their outdoor seating wasn't set up. The dining room is just bland and boring looking. Our server came over with water right after we were seated. We needed a minute to check out the cocktail menu. We ordered drinks, heard the specials, asked a few questions, and made our choices. My husband started with a half Caesar salad and said it was just okay. I started with the French Onion Soup and I was disappointed. I believe it's the worst I've had. It was oddly sweet and it was served with two full bay leaves in it. I thought everyone knew to remove bay leaves before serving food. When our dishes were removed from the table, I pointed it out. The person said, "sorry about that" and that was it. My husband got the halibut special and said it was good, but nothing great. I got the Pear and Goat Cheese Flatbread and it was really good! I feel like everything used to be a bit more elevated there. Service, food, and vibe were all very average and we remembered, and expected, it to be better than it was. read more

See all

I enjoyed Herbie's. My husband is from StL and our family still live there so while in town for a visit we had a family dinner here one night with some others and they were excellent with our toddler and larger group. Waitress was very friendly and efficient. We tried several things from the menu including a large dinner Cesar salad add chicken, a burger, the duck, whole chicken, salmon and the surf and turf hotdog (interesting). All enjoyed their food and everything was large portion and great taste. For dessert - delicious coffee and a decadent chocolate torte. The inside is spacious and elegant and I loved the outdoor patio with the fire pit (too cold in FEB to enjoy). I think we will be back. Parking was street but easy enough. read more

See all

Enjoyed the cozy ambiance and good food with excellent service. Oysters were great and would highly recommend the crab cakes as an appetizer! Also enjoyed the flounder with cheesecake for dessert. The roasted chicken was a bit too salty to reorder. read more

See all

Had late lunch here. Sat at bar, I think Mya was our bartender. She was absolutely awesome. Looks like it would be a nice hangout during the warmer weather as it appeared to have a large outdoor area. I had Modern brewery's Citraopolis, a very nice hazy ipa. I ordered the lobster roll, I was impressed with the amount of meat, but it seemed a little bland. Lobster is the star. I had the white chocolate raspberry cheese cake. I may be mistaken, but it seemed like it had spent too many days in the refrigerator. Taste was good, but the texture seemed a bit off. Next time I'll try the crème brûlée. I tried my wife's espresso martini and agree with her. It was the best espresso martini I have ever tasted. read more

See all

I always like Herbies! It's like an ultra dependable place to go for lunch or dinner if you don't want to be adventurous but still want good quality food and drinks! It's conveniently located and very roomy in the inside. The drink are actually really good tho (especially the Bloom No. 2...goodness). I always sit at the bar and they are so attentive. They bartenders have really good personalities and skilled enough to make off menu drinks and can do substitutions for menu drinks (I'm a bartender so this is always important to me). I had the steak frites which was a little fatty for my liking. I have had other things in the past...(like the Oklahoma onion burger ) this just wasn't the best but everything else made up for it!. I will always frequent this place! read more

Herbie's is a trusted place!!! Service was friendly and welcoming. The food is always yum. This was my first time trying their brunch menu!!! Crab Benedict with fruit and an espresso martini !! And yall!!! Tvs in the bar area for the sports fan in me!! read more

See all

Another Yelper highly recommend Herbie's. Herbies is easy to find on the corner in Clayton, featuring a large fire presentation on the elevated patio near the front entrance. Parking is available on the surrounding streets and public parking garages. When I arrived my eyes were immediately drawn to the unique lighting. The restaurant features dark wood that conveys warmth with low lights. The large windows in the bar area make it seem expansive. Seating is around the perimeter so tables are half comfortable cushioned bench and half chairs. The service was excellent! I was greeted immediately on arrival and shown to my table. My server, Bianca, quickly checked in with me and bartender was outstanding. She was personable and customized my brunch drink with lime, and personally brought it to my table. It was delish! I ordered a veggie omelet with crispy breakfast potatoes and a side order of cheesy grits. Everything was cooked to perfection and flavorful. I loved the touch of pickled red onions. The ambiance lighting was my absolute favorite thing here. It was so enjoyable to spend time here. I'm looking forward to my next visit. read more

See all

Great place in downtown Clayton. The food and service were both excellent. Wonderful patio and bar.

We had a group of 8 and had a nice enclosed room. Thankfully! Otherwise it is a loud ambience. Service was great! Very attentive. Drinks were mixed in the group. Several bourbons out of stock. Gin drink too sweet. Pinot Noir good. The issue was the food. I've never seen a filet mignon shaped like a pork chop. Didn't have filet caliber. Every person who ordered meat was overcooked including the burger. The sides were good. Pesto was super super garlicky. Fresh veggies. Due to it being a group dinner and in a time crunch, we did not send our steaks back. Overall it was meh. It's a St. Louis iconic place and good location. But you go to be seen and grab some drinks. Great for that. My out of town guests were not impressed. read more

Just in time for the season, Herbie's new autumn menu is here, and it's a treat for pescatarians. #stlouispescatarianapproved Known for its comfortable ambiance, Herbie's continues to charm with one of the most enjoyable patios in St. Louis. Starting with the shrimp and tuna Niçoise salad--absolutely delicious. The shrimp was spicy and juicy and the tuna Niçoise balanced fresh flavors with just the right amount of fall heartiness. The crab cakes were divine as well, crispy on the outside, tender on the inside. The real surprise was the garden lasagna. Packed with fall vegetables, it was layered with rich flavors that were satisfying without feeling too heavy, and the seasonal ingredients made me have the autumn feels! Stop in and Give Herbie's some Autumn Love! read more

See all

I'm a little late to the party for this review, as I visited Herbie's earlier this year but when we stopped at Herbie's for dinner, I was excited because I had never been. Our family friends were in town and picked Herbie's because they had heard good things about it. Overall, it was a pretty average experience. The service was good, and the ambience was what one would expect from a more upscale restaurant. The food, however, is what I was mostly disappointed by. The entrees were all very unevenly seasoned, with most of the vegetables lacking any salt, and the steaks did not have a great sear either. The risotto for the scallops was undercooked as well. The one upside is that we had some very excellent appetizers-- both the Brussels sprouts and the crab cakes were very good and something I would get again. The desserts were also decent but I'm not sure I would order again. Overall, the service was great, and I would go back for the appetizers which were amazing but I don't think I'd head back again for their entrees. read more

See all

I have begun following Herbies on Instagram and when they began to showcase their Fall Menu I felt compelled and inspired to visit. Mostly, I kept seeing the scallops and the light sprinkling of parm that whispered with a taunting finger to stop what I was doing and take a trip to Herbies. Herbies is located in Clayton. The weather was nice but still chilled enough I opted to sit inside. There is a welcoming vibe upon entering. One is greeted with a dark elegant space that felt quiet and intimate. I cannot remember my server's name but he was cheerful and friendly. First, I ordered the Rum and Crumble. I was initially going with Autumn Fires, but was convinced to try the Rum & Crumble. The drink was great but quite strong! I had to balance it out with a little something else otherwise having not eaten anything prior to arriving I was going to end up tanking! For appetizer, I chose the flash-fried Brussel sprouts. I am not a fan of Brussels, but I am always willing to give a chance. These were flash fried, giving the leafy greens a nice crispy texture and mixed with pickled carrots and sambal. Honestly, while it was very delicious, I am still not a fan of Brussels. My own take away is perhaps chopping up the Brussels more than leaving them whole, it made them a little less enjoyable, and adding more of the sambal. The main event for me was ordering the scallops with the dauphinoise potatoes. The scallops were seared nicely and slicing through them was like butter. They tasted heavenly, little ivory clouds of silk that when dredged through the scalloped potatoes provided a rich, decadent bite. The dish also came out very hot which forced me to slow down but I felt so impatient! The whole experience is terrific and I look forward to becoming a recurring visit to Herbies! Thank you for dinner! read more

See all

Herbie's is one of the best restaurants in Clayton! It's perfect for any occasion - date night, work meal, happy hour. The menu is filled with delicious staples, like Truffle Fries and Brussels Sprouts, and seasonal items, like Coq Au Vin! Be sure to save room for their bread pudding!! read more

See all

The ambiance and decor are nice and original. The service was pleasant and attentive. The food was bad. I had the lobster roll and shoestring fries for brunch. The lobster roll was terrible, could not have been real lobster. Had no flavor at all and too much mayonnaise. I would compare it to Captain D's quality if that helps. Not to have CD's to catch a stray for no reason lol. The fries were rock hard and cold. My companion had the everything omelet and potatoes. The omelet was a glob of eggs with sausage tossed on top, flavor was fine. No matter the price, I would not go back to eat. I would do a happy hour for drinks only and the nice staff. read more

Did Herbie's Breakfast Flatbread just become a new brunch favorite? OH 100%! The description alone tells you everything you need to know: Artisanal flatbread topped with house-made sausage & thyme gravy, scrambled eggs, bacon, and fontina. I've included a closeup, plus pics of the rest of our meal out on the Herbie's patio this past weekend! read more

See all

Went for lunch today since weather was so beautiful we wanted to sit outside. Patio was very pretty. Our server was wonderful and very attentive. He kept coming back over to see if we needed refills on our drink or if we needed anything else with our meal. We both did the deal where we did the $25 deal. We could either get half of the soup or salad, an entrée and a dessert to go. My husband had the French onion soup and I had the half Caesar salad. My Caesar salad was not very good at all. It just had a ton of the Parmesan cheese you can get in the can at the supermarket, just dumped all over it. Much of my lettuce had turned brown, and it was not very appetizing to eat at all. Both my husband and I ordered the chicken salad on a croissant for lunch. This was a very huge portion, and large chunks of chicken in it. Although it wasn't my favorite flavoring of chicken salad, it was still very good and so big that I had a little bit left over. It also came with a huge portion of it, thin french fries, which were very addicting, excellent. Our drinks were refreshed frequently and as mentioned before the service was wonderful. When we were paying the bill, we each got a small brown bag with a dessert in it. I loved the approach because, come on, who doesn't like opening a little bag with a gift in it! I can't say for 100% sure, but when we ate it, it tasted almost like a lemon bar and had some chocolate drizzle and some blueberries on it. It was just the right size for an after lunch treat. I will definitely give it one more go because overall it was a positive experience. Aside from the salad being disappointing, the food was enjoyable for a lunch outing. read more

See all

The best patio dinner time with my friends! The server was attentive and took really good care of us! Everything we ate and drank was pretty much solid! I got their Pina Colada drink. It was not too sweet, and you can taste the alcohol, but not heavily strong. Just exactly how I like it! We ordered the Truffle Fries, Brussel Sprouts, and their corn dip for our appetizers, and they were so delicious! I am lactose intolerant, so I didn't eat the corn dip as much, but my friends loved it. For our meal, we ordered a steak dish, the salmon, and their burgers. Everything was cooked perfectly. Must get the Balaban BBQ Salmon! That was my absolute! I'm not a huge dessert person, but their bread pudding was heavenly and the best way to end our dinner! Need to come back for Happy Hour! Recommended! Parking may be inconvenient, but you will read more

See all

A set back! We arrived @1:52 and was informed the last brunch table had been seated. The brunch is over at 2 but we could look at the dinner menu that begins at a 2:30. The food came recommended but disappointed to not be served. read more

Service phenomenal, cold beer, and the cocktails cocktailing. Ben and David were the best bartenders ever! 10/10 recommend, great fries!

Food is mediocre The tables are always dirty when you come in to sit down Even after they wipe them, they still look dirty read more

Clayton hangouts never miss! Herbie's is place to add in your arsenal for all your brunch/lunch needs. - Great food - Full bar service - Patio seating - Corner lot location - Amazing for celebratory needs read more

See all

The Chef knows how to cook! The Halibut was cooked and seasoned to perfection and the mashed potatoes and garlic spinach were a perfect complement. There is talent here ! The confidence and experience of the wait staff shows with solid recommendations. Very impressive. read more

I wanted it so bad ... to be like your Wellington you had in cwe.. First of all size.. wayyyy to big and served sooo bloody.. Puff pastry was not even cooked thru..mashed pot tasted days old. Pls let's retrieve that old petite good quality beef Wellington w the deep rich merlot sauce sauce and carrots... I spent over $100 on this entree and it didn't get the love and care it deserved... It literally wasn't cooked even after sending it back twice. I know this is below the quality owners expect. More training is needed.. waiters need to greet you w a welcome and the specials rolling off their tongue.. I'm not being a Karen as I waitresses bartended thru grad school.. not do I want to destroy anyone.. I'm just super sad as this cost me a lot of money and it was beyond recognizable. read more

Herbie's Restaurant - Beef Wellington - New American Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

Food was amazing & the ambiance/vibes were even better. Loved the music. Ben provided great service. read more

See all

If you're looking for a low lighting vibe, this is your restaurant! Not one of us had complaints with our food - everything was cooked to perfection! I couldn't get enough of the garlic aioli that came with my fries, delicious! Around 9 a dj started playing, we went on a Saturday, it was cool to see the transition from dining to a fun music experience read more

Herbie's Restaurant - Steak special - New American Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

Food was very delicious - came for Sunday brunch and got the eggs Benedict and chicken and waffles. Also got the mimosa carafe, which has a decent amount of champagne, worth it if you're looking for boozy brunch! It's on the pricier side but it was good for a fancier brunch date. read more

See all

The French fries were plenty and tasty. The bar tender did not pay much attention to us but the waitress did. We sat at the bar. The onion burger was average and very expensive. read more

I prefer Herbie's for brunch. Just seemed like the pricing was more reasonable. Not sure I'd come back for dinner. But both the Happy Hour and Brunch are great! ‍ read more

See all

We will never go to Herbies again. I made a reservation for Easter brunch for 13 people over a month in advance so they knew we were coming. When we arrived we were taken to a corner in the bar where they put together a menagerie of cocktail tables some round some square and rectangle. We were crammed in a small uncomfortable space. It was insulting. The hostess said take it or leave it. They knew we were coming since we made the reservation more than a month in advance. The staff that got our drink order were also the bar tenders behind the bar. So not much service. Terrible customer experience. I planned in advance with a long reservation lead time. They cobbled something together at the last minute. No way to run a business! We have been going to Herbies since the central west end days. Never again PaulLiberatore read more

We went after the Clayton wine and food festival and sat on the charming patio to hear the festival band still playing. Our waitress Bianca was terrific. We started with street Corn Dip which was addictive, I couldn't quit snacking on this! Had a great kick to it. Also had the Cajun crab cakes, which were equally tasty and a nice amount of crab and salad. The morel pasta was naturally amazing, though out of season the morels came from Oregon. I was amazed at the volume of mushrooms We also had the lobster and crab ravioli. The pasta is so fresh and the favors were delicious. I'm so glad they've continued with some of their Balaban traditions. It was a perfect evening and wonderful meal. read more

See all

Terrible food, expensive , terrible service . I often wonder why this place always seems empty. Now I know! read more

Herbie's Restaurant - New American Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

See all

I walked in around lunchtime and immediately noticed I was the only customer. That should've been my sign to turn around, but I decided to give it a chance. I won't make that mistake again. Right after my food was brought out, a health inspector walked in. Not exactly the confidence boost you want mid-bite. Then I overheard the staff openly talking about how none of the produce was dated and some of it needed to be "put back in the fridge." That's not just sloppy, it's blatantly unsafe. What made the entire situation worse was the manager's attitude--patronizing and dismissive, as if I should be grateful they were even open. Not an ounce of professionalism or concern for what had just been made obvious: that food safety and customer experience are clearly an afterthought here. I came in expecting a quiet lunch and left questioning every bite I took. Never again read more

I went to Herbie's for brunch and made a reservation in the bar area. There was some Christmas performance going on for Toys for Tots so parking took a while but I was lucky to grab a free street parking spot! I thought it was soooo nice having a server but also another staff to help her. They were both so friendly- I wish I remembered their names! The bottomless mimosas were definitely worth the price! I am a hugeee biscuits and gravy girl and theirs were so delicious with meaty pieces of sausage and super soft biscuits read more

My company does their holiday lunch here every year and we always have a great experience! The lunch menu has a good variety of sandwiches, soups and large main dishes as well. The service is great! They always have lots of recs and are extremely patient with a larger party. The drink menu has lots of options and unique mixes which I love! I'd love to come for brunch because that menu looks so good! read more

Herbie's Restaurant - Cheesecake and espresso martinis - New American Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

Have been to Herbie's for dinner and Happy Hour, but thought I would give it a try for brunch. Enjoyed a gf option of polenta, and shrimp in a spicey Mexican tasting sauce. It was delicious and not terribly over priced. Service was amazing. Quick, attentive, gracious! A bit noisy in the back room, but enjoyed a pleasant Sunday brunch. read more

Herbie's Restaurant - Polenta , shrimp in Mexican flavored spice sauce. - New American Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

Met a few friends for brunch. First time at this establishment. Once you get over you are paying Clayton prices, the food is great and the service is excellent. I got the "If Only It Wasn't New" cocktail to sip on while waiting for my food to arrive. Bourbon, Hot Honey and Chocolate Bitters was a perfect mix. I ordered the Avocado Toast which comes with breakfast potatoes. Huge slice of crusty bread topped with avocado, radish, grape tomatoes and red onion. One of the best avocado toasts I have had. The place is comfy and not too loud. Servers are very attentive and professional. read more

Herbie's Restaurant - Brunch Avocado Toast with Breakfast Potatoes - New American Near Me - Clayton, Missouri

See all