Cancel

Open app

Search

Thee Pitts Again

3.7 (185 reviews)
ModerateBarbeque

Thee Pitts Again Photos

THEE PITTS AGAIN ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Moderate noise
Outdoor seating
Good for groups
Good for kids

Recommended Reviews - Thee Pitts Again

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Pulled pork, chicken, mashed potatoes, corn
Mikey R.

Food was fine. But $36 for this setup is a bit much. The meal was $20, and I suppose the beer and cream soda was the other $16. I was OK paying the posted price for the food - although I think a little more meat would've been better - but there's no way the drinks should've cost that much. Prices aren't posted for those, so it was a surprise. This is a tourist stop, and I'm assuming they're not counting on anybody coming back so they charge as much as they do. Goal achieved; I won't be back.

Beef brisket sandwich with an order of fried pickles and potato salad
Tracey S.

This is a very popular restaurant. It can get very crowded, but the service goes fast. The owner has won many awards for his bbq. You can see his awards around his restaurant. The bbq is very delicious. It is a casual restaurant with good food. I highly recommend this restaurant.

Pulled pork plate (pulled pork, fries, cornbread)
Emily H.

Great spot in Silverton--it's been featured on the Food Network so it's quite popular, be prepared to wait in line. Pulled pork was juicy and delicious and the fries were great!

Matt G.

This comes from a Texas boy. This was good BBQ. Damn good BBQ. After a 3 hour ride on the train from Durango to Silverton, the wife announced she had a surprise from me. She had apparently seen an episode of DDD where Guy visited this humble establishment. I wish I had been there when he was there. We only had about 20 minutes due to the train being late. We dashed in, ordered the brisket, pulled pork, and sausage platter. Sides? Coleslaw and mashed taters. As I said, really good BBQ. The coleslaw was a little dry. The mashers were a hit with the wife considering I got NONE. OK. just a little taste. All in all, DO THE TRAIN RIDE...then eat here. You will not be disappointed. Rock solid 4 stars.

Outside
Michelle T.

I had the pull pork sandwich with onion rings . You order at counter and deliver to table great sever needed knife to cut in half side I picked was coleslaw and also got Dr Pepper. The place had aprons hanging of the competitions they enter and plaque that they won with ceramic pigs everywhere . The pull pork was very good and so was the onion rings with ranch dressing

Pork Sundae
James Cindy B.

Don't believe the bad reviews... We just had a great experience here during a busy...busy lunch time rush. Ribs were moist, bbq sauce was great...just right. I had the Pork Sundae...unusual, but great. I ended up dumping it on my plate and attacking it! Service was awesome!! Guy at counter was positive and calm, even though it was a packed house. It was standing room only, with the line out the door. Well done, especially during a difficult time.

Pulled pork, 1/2 slab, potato salad & beans.
Sandy C.

After a full day of activity, we were starving! Stopped by this local eatery for dinner. The gentleman at the counter greeted us with a howdy. I ordered one full dinner for hubs & I to share. He said what I ordered was enough for 1. Let me tell you, it was just right for 2! Food came out quickly (very quickly.) My only complaint was that it was lukewarm. Not overly hot. But, it was enjoyable. BBQ was good. Enough of a bite, not too sweet. Overall, yummy food stop.

Light meal, Beef Brisket, mashed potatoes/gravy and corn bread. It was just ok.
Izzy G.

I see a constant theme in the reviews, "Good value". I can agree with that. It is a good value. Good BBQ? Umm....It's ok. I ordered the light meal which included beef brisket, side of mashed potatoes/gravy and piece of corn bread. Brisket already came covered in BBQ sauce. I got the light meal because I just are breakfast an hour earlier, but decided to try this place that's DDD (Guy Fietti) approved. Overall experience.....eh.

3 meat platter

The food tasted good but our bill was $51 for a very small portion ( 3 meat platter), baked potato and two soft drinks. The 3 meat platter is pictured. Everything else was fine...literally quarter cup portions.

the outside of a restaurant
Xerxes S.

I'm from Texas but I understand that other places have brisket too. I have to add my personal preferences, but the brisket and the meal was great and a a great value, more especially for the area. I've worked on my brisket smoking skills for many years. I would be happy with any cook that came out like the brisket here. The meat was standalone good and I mean it needed no sauce to be good without. The hot sauce I later tried was perfect, as it hit with some heat, then quickly retreated for a smoother finish. There was no smoke ring and I like a little hickory flavor in my brisket. The rub was indiscernible to the point I am not sure they used a rub. I only use salt and pepper like I picked up from Aaron Franklin, so I don't use anything heavy. The rub need not be the primary flavor in brisket. I don't care for sweet cornbread, but this only had a little hint of sweet and that went away. It was awesome! I like cole slaw a little creamier, but this was on point! I'd eat it any day with any BBQ. The potato salad didn't blow my hair back, but it wasn't bad. The fella that delivered our order was neither friendly nor unfriendly, but professional. The food arrived shortly after we were seated. The only negative review I saw was a gimme. "I should have known not to order vegetarian food at a bbq joint..." Right! Next time exercise better judgment. I read the first line about ordering vegetarian bbq and I knew that was a poor decision. I don't go into my garden looking for a steak, but then I listen to that little voice that keeps me from making similar mistakes. I guess my only criticism is they have vegetarian food items on the menu. Then again, that is more a business decision issue than a food item issue. Finally, with this covid-19 scare, there is limited seating. I saw a party of 2 in front of us taking up a table for 8. There were smaller tables open and there were a few couples at large tables as well. Good manners aren't common, but you should try to practice them anyway. Your egocentric behavior is abhorrent.

Mindi A.

Came in a Thursday lunch at 1130. 6 of us walked right up to the counter to order. Place is fun to look at for kids. Hundreds of pigs and pics of pigs. Food was just mediocre. If they served it hot I Might have considered 4 stars.

Ming X.

It's good to make friends on a road trip. Someone insisted that I should go to Silverton and eat at Thee Pits Again. I love BBQ. What can I say. So while I was road-tripping in Ouray, I headed to Silverton and looked for a pink structure in town. Yup, just like the dude told me. You can't miss the place. It was late in the afternoon. They sold out of the brisket. I settled for the ribs. I can't believe how much food they gave me for a little bite. And the food disappeared quickly. The ribs were falling off the bone. It's juicy and tender. Their BBQ sauce was a hit. It was so worth the trip.

Beef brisket dinner plate

See all

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

15 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

16 years ago

AMAZING! Try the pulled pork, or the beef brisket. Youll be back for more without a doubt

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Brisket was very dry, worse meal of our 5 day trip in Colorado, will definitely not recommend or ever go back

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Ribs are superb. Pulled pork sandwich very good. Even the sides are great. Bought some sauce to take home.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

15 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Laura E.
194
12
0

10 years ago

Good food, with pretty quick service. Definitely expensive. We had 2 mini meals, a drink, and 2 beers and it was over $45.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

15 years ago

Great Bar B Q, best in town since two years before the Smokehouse on Blair Street closed

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

15 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 5 of 5

Ask the Community - Thee Pitts Again

Golden Block Brewery - Outdoor Enthusiast

Golden Block Brewery

4.0(264 reviews)
0.1 mi
•$$

The service was friendly and fast! Atmosphere was interesting and well done…read more Food was fantastic...we had pesto cheese bread, spinach artichoke bruschetta and three different kinds of pizza...all was delicious!

We walked in with my legitimate medical service dog, who is trained to alert me before medical…read moreepisodes occur. Instead of being welcomed, we were immediately interrogated by the woman at the front, then questioned again by the bartender. We were seated and left sitting there for 30 minutes without a single person taking our order or offering service. Our waitress even apologized and admitted she "hates that she can't help us," making it obvious the staff had intentionally decided not to serve us. Throughout the entire time, my service dog was exactly where a service dog should be--quietly lying under the table at my feet, causing absolutely no disruption. After waiting half an hour, I finally asked if we were ever going to be served. That's when we were told the issue was my service dog. When I questioned this, the bartender's response was to tell me I "didn't need an attitude." I've written maybe five Yelp reviews in my life, but this experience deserves to be shared. The way we were treated was humiliating, discriminatory, and completely unacceptable. It felt like we were being singled out simply because I have a disability and rely on a service animal. All six of us got up and left because of how we were treated. Small businesses deserve support when they treat people with respect. This business did the opposite. I would never recommend this restaurant to anyone, and I sincerely hope no one else has to experience the kind of discrimination we did.

Photos
Golden Block Brewery - Where the pizza magic happens with the magic makers!

Where the pizza magic happens with the magic makers!

Golden Block Brewery - Caprese Platter

Caprese Platter

Golden Block Brewery

See all

Handlebars Food & Saloon - Chicken fried steak

Handlebars Food & Saloon

3.8(198 reviews)
0.1 mi
•$$

This was one of the best places in the area (Ouray included) that we ate at. When walking up, it…read morewas very busy with people waiting outside. The waitress taking down names seemed dazed, related to how to manage. Someone older and more experienced saw us, came over, answered our question about the wait, and immediately sat us. We very much appreciated it. Our waitress was very kind and attentive, checking in on us very often. We ordered the crispy chicken sandwich, the strawberry walnut salad, and the half order of chicken. The salad was fresh and tasted really good. I liked the vinaigrette that was offered. I also really liked the chicken sandwich. It tasted great with the fries after a long day of exploring and hiking. I'd definitely come back. I couldn't believe how many people were seated inside, and it seemed they had everything under control. People were enjoying themselves.

This is the highest rated restaurant in Silverton so we were excited to check it out during our…read moreDurango to Silverton Narrow Gauge railroad tour. First the good things. Although there was a group of 12 ahead of us, our wait was just 10 mins as they were pretty good about crowd management. The inside decor is super cool with taxidermy animals everywhere. We saw bobcat, mountain lion, mountain sheep, and all kinds of animals that you would expect to live in Colorado. There were super funny signs everywhere (my favorite was the oats one). The disappointment was the food portion size. I ordered a reuben sandwich for $19 which came with a very skinny portion of meat between two small pieces of toast. We barely got maybe 10 fries with it. For $19 I expected the portion size to be a little bigger. Their draft beer were on the smaller size at 12 oz instead of the standard 16oz. Come here to checkout the cool wall decorations and maybe get a drink but skip the food. If a real cowboy walked into this saloon, he would be pretty angry by the portion size and probably start a bar fight!

Photos
Handlebars Food & Saloon
Handlebars Food & Saloon - Side salad - delicious

Side salad - delicious

Handlebars Food & Saloon - The bar

See all

The bar

OAK Beer,Bourbon & BBQ - Pulled pork sandwich

OAK Beer,Bourbon & BBQ

3.3(119 reviews)
11.8 mi
•$$

When a local says you have to go to the Oak and get the smoked BBQ wings - you do it!…read more OMG these are shut your mouth good! If only pics could capture the smell and flavor you would jump through the screen and eat them yourself. Service- nice team, order at the bar and sit in or outside. We rolled in after a 6 mile hike, backpacks and all and we fit right in. We ordered 24 and taking home 10 for later and that's aok with me!!! They are very large wings and eat bite is amazing with BBQ sauce covering the bottoms of the bowl.

Clearly a locals spot and favorite for after ski hangout, Oak has a busy atmosphere as it is…read morelocated right next to the gondola. It is also attached to the Camel's Garden Hotel so a convenient location. The bartenders, cashiers and other staff seamed friendly. They were in and out delivering food and cleaning up after everyone quickly. Drinks came quickly and were nice pours. For food, we ordered the steak fries, very good. Crispy outside, tender inside. Nachos were also very tasty. Real cheese not the sauce type fake cheese. Good toppings. The pork sandwich was a little dry and needed seasoning and sauce. The burger was a little dry as well, not cooked to order and the bun was dry and fell apart. But it came with all the toppings. Inside the restaurant were several families. Packed! Kids running around everywhere. It was way too chaotic for us personally so we sat outside. The patio was busy every afternoon with people and pups alike. I was sad to see so many people leave their dogs outside on the patio unattended, barking and whining looking for their person while they are inside drinking and dining. This happened every day so it seams normal. Telluride is a very dog friendly town. Overall good for after ski atmosphere. There seamed to always be some activity happening outside to watch or participate.

Photos
OAK Beer,Bourbon & BBQ
OAK Beer,Bourbon & BBQ - Great fries!

Great fries!

OAK Beer,Bourbon & BBQ

See all

Sportsman's BBQ Station & Backyard - Impossible burger

Sportsman's BBQ Station & Backyard

4.3(11 reviews)
23.8 mi

Well this was an unexpectedly pleasant surprise. We just stopping for a restroom & this was the…read morefirst promising place we found. We really hesitated to try the bbq because we haven't had the greatest experiences lately. Their lunch menu is between 11-2 & we arrived around 2:10 so some of the menu items were all gone, for instance, ribs & sliced brisket. So my husband got chopped brisket, it wasn't swimming in sauce instead it was on the side & to tell you the truth it didn't need any sauce which is a telling sign of good bbq! We also got pulled pork & that was really good too but I think the brisket was better. On my check in I accidentally clicked that the staff is not wearing masks & they really are. I didn't go in but my husband said it's very clean & nice inside, maybe 8 tables & there's about 4 outdoor tables.

Stopped for an early dinner after hiking Redcloud Peak! We were famished. Found this cute spot in…read moremaybe a refurbished mechanic shop? The doors were wide open and there were indoor and outdoor seating. I got the cheeseburger with cheddar and my husband got the BBQ pork sandwich. I upgraded for some french fries which were OK. The sandwiches were both massive! Very solid but nothing super special, but hit the spot after burning so many calories. Had a good list of beers - really liked the $3 can options! One of the cans was craft beer too which was pretty cool. Good, local vibes spot!

Photos
Sportsman's BBQ Station & Backyard - Inside

Inside

Sportsman's BBQ Station & Backyard - Impossible burger

Impossible burger

Sportsman's BBQ Station & Backyard - Outside

See all

Outside

Serious Texas BAR-B-Q - Sausage, pulled pork, ribs, smoked turkey

Serious Texas BAR-B-Q

3.6(284 reviews)
40.7 mi
•$

A very open and casual great bar b q with seating indoors and out. Even when you're in you feel…read morelike you're outside. You order at the counter and then take the food to your table. I had the ribs which they sell by the bone The were tender and flavorful. They have a dry rub on them and then there is sauce in the table you can add I would have loved to have a side order of fries but they don't have a fryer. Other sides are pinto beans potato salad max n cheese Cole slaw cheesy potatoes. My husband has the turkey sandwich and cheesy potatoes. I'm not usually a fan of cheesy potatoes as I don't like a lot of cheese sauce but these seemed to have the dry rub flavor and cheese but not a cheese sauce they were actually very good. I look forward to our stop here every year.

We went to Serious Texas Bar-B-Q because we let a non-foodie family member pick a place while…read morepassing through Durango. That was our first mistake Lack luster BBQ. Strange sauces. The house bbq sauce on the tables was a watery mess. The "hot sauce" was better than the BBQ sauce but also very thin. The smoked turkey was the highlight. The brisket was very fatty and flavorless. No bark to speak of. The weird part, most BBQ joints are priced per pound, 1/2 or 1/4 pound. It looked that way on their menu, however they seem to just eyeball it. Ordered 1/4 pound of turkey and got 2 slices. Someone else in our party got 3 slices. Both of us paid a flat rate. Skip this place if you're truly into BBQ. Also, the flies were driving us crazy.

Photos
Serious Texas BAR-B-Q - Dining area

Dining area

Serious Texas BAR-B-Q
Serious Texas BAR-B-Q

See all

Thee Pitts Again - bbq - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...