Cancel

Open app

Search

The Monk's Cellar

4.1 (1.2k reviews)
ModeratePubs, Breweries, American
Open • 11:30 am - 10:00 pm

About The Monk's Cellar

Loading...

Read the full summary in the app

The Monk's Cellar Photos

THE MONK'S CELLAR ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Classy
Casual
Moderate noise
Good for groups

You might also consider

More like The Monk's Cellar

Recommended Reviews - The Monk's Cellar

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Joseph R.

Through another Yelpers recommendation, I decided to drag my cousin out to this establishment for the first time. This was actually the first time I visited the entire downtown Roseville area, and I was pleasantly surprised there was a parking garage since all the parking spots in front of the establishment were occupied. We arrived around 1:30PM and observed a fair amount of patrons on a Monday. We were immediately greeted and seated. Loved the decor. After a few minutes mulling over what to get, I ended up getting the French Dip with duck fat fries. I also tried their Divinity Stout. Wow. The food - Amazing! Really enjoyed the French Dip - well sized portion and ended up having leftovers that I was able to enjoy a few hours later ha! The Stout (Divinity) - I need to go back and buy some bottles to go. So good! I'll definitely be back. The one minor gripe was I observed was there weren't any TV's at the bar (from what I can see anyway). I would have loved to head over here as I am writing this review to watch the NBA finals. All good!

Lager and French dip
Myrriah C.

This was a solid choice when stopping through. The beer was pretty good and the NA list was extensive which is always nice to see. We ordered the French dip and the Reuben. For the French dip I will say it was bursting with flavor, the bun was nice and crispy and soft on the inside and the meat tasty. My only issue was it was way over salted. The Reuben was also tender, tasty and the sauce was very good but again the fries and meat felt over salted. They were packed so our server was few and far between but she was really kind and you could tell there was just a lot going on. Overall the feeling of space was on brand for a cellar with low lighting and dark ambiance that made it feel a bit more classy.

Caesar Salad with Anchovies
Tara T.

The food is always so delicious. I've been coming here for years!! Last night when we went for dinner, I found out they added a few new items to the menu. We tried a couple new items + ordered the special. The service is always great and the ambiance is nice. Great place for large parties and family friendly. Love when they have special events too!

Pickled Veggie Jar
Dante B.

Decided on an early Friday dinner date night around 5pm here since we were in the area for an event. Located in the middle of downtown Roseville, parking is not hard to find at all as there is plenty of street parking and a nearby garage. The decor inside is stunning. You can see industrial-size equipment for the beer fermentation process, and the dark wooden walls match the cellar theme perfectly. However, we were seated at a small table with bar stools that wasn't very comfortable. It was a warm day outside, so the AC was blasting inside and I got cold very fast. Shout out to my husband for walking back to the car to grab my jacket! We started off with drinks. I got the Thirst Trap mocktail, which was sweet and tart and reminded me of Nerds candy. However, I don't think it was worth the $14 price tag. My husband got the Vernon Street Lager, which was a very tasty beer. For an appetizer, we ordered the Pickled Veggie Jar. It had a great variety of brussel sprouts, onions, radishes, and more that were deliciously pickled. Unfortunately, it took over 40 minutes for our entrees to arrive, so we ended up eating half of this just waiting for our food. Carbonnade Flamande: My husband ordered this braised short rib stew served over mashed potatoes. The beef itself was very good, but the portion of meat was very small compared to the mountain of mashed potatoes. It tasted nice, but for $26, we expected a bit more meat. Moules Frites: I got the mussels cooked in broth, served with duck fat fries and crostinis. The mussels were plentiful and the broth was very flavorful. Overall, the food was decent but the fries were the absolute best part of everything we ordered and everything is on the pricey side. The service didn't really stand out either. There was no reassurance or update on why our food was taking so long. Plus, water was never served automatically, and when I finally asked for some, our server only brought one glass even though we were a party of two. This was not worth the $100 we spent on dinner and I don't think I would find myself back here.

Chloe B.

When you want a hardy meal, a good beer or cocktail, and ambience for a good chat....this is the place to go! Indoor and outdoor seating. Seating near people or far away from people. My favorite was the pretzel! My friend and I got so full just off of appetizers. Will be going back!

Lisa X.

My friend and I came by for dinner. She previously been here for Oktoberfest. Very lively place. We opted to sit outside, have some non-alcoholic beverages, a couple of appetizers and enjoy the nice weather. We had the following: *Jake is a non-alcoholic cocktail - really good. I enjoyed the citrus flavors. We later found out this was named after our waiter and another non-alcohol drink was named after his wife. So cute! * ATLÉTICA Copper - my friend wanted another non-alcoholic brew but was accidentally given this one. She didn't like it. It wasn't to her taste. *Large Pretzel - served with spicy mustard and pub cheese. Good and really big portion. *Croquettes - Mashed potatoes with roasted jalapeño, crispy bacon & cheddar cheese. They were tasty! *Scotch Egg - Soft-boiled egg wrapped in ground sausage & breadcrumbs and fried. We both like this. Delicious! *Duck fat fries - traditional. I accidentally ordered traditional even tho we wanted the Parmesan & Cheese one. We were both a tad disappointed that we didn't taste much Duck fat. Overall, lively place, good vibes, friendly and chill servers. Located on Vernon and Washington Blvd.

While this restaurant initially impresses with its beautiful physical space, the aesthetic appeal quickly fades once I sat down. I wanted to love this venue, but the experience was entirely ruined by a combination of incredibly slow and antagonistic service, an unbearable noise level, and a total failure in the kitchen. From start to finish, the evening was a masterclass in how poor execution can derail a nice establishment. The issues began the moment I was seated. The service was excruciatingly slow, and the staff treated every basic request like a massive inconvenience. It is incredibly frustrating to pay premium prices only to be met with a grumpy attitude and palpable disdain from the waitstaff. Adding to the discomfort was the restaurant's acoustics. The space is deafeningly loud, making it an absolute nightmare for anyone trying to have an dinner. Good luck holding a normal conversation here without actively shouting across the table just to be heard over the din. However, the ultimate disappointment was the food, specifically the halibut. The kitchen completely failed in both the preparation and the flavor profile of this dish. A significant portion of the fish was severely overcooked and dry, stripping away the delicate texture you expect from a premium cut. To make matters worse, the dish was smothered in a jam that completely overpowered what little flavor the fish had left. The entire combination was a complete failure of culinary balance. Bottom line: a nice physical space means nothing when the service is poor and the food is a letdown. I will not be returning.

Sarah S.

Date night! Perfect environment & vibe! Cozy but not crazy crowded..love the staff! Very helpful & attentive Hubby made these past three reservations, & we used the free parking garage on oak st, did a little night stroll to the restaurant. Great night!

Jenny K.

Came on a Saturday night at 545, told it's a 30 minute wait but we were able to find bar seats. The inside looked very cozy with a variety of seating options. Nice place to chill but not the best food. Hamburger was okay, fries a little soggy and the fish and chips were not flavorful. Overall disappointed in the food but liked the ambiance . I ordered a cocktail and it was a bit too sweet for me . My husband tried 2 different beers.

Daniel S.

The Monk's Cellar holds a different kind of space less about routine comfort, and more about meals that feel worth sitting down for when the occasion calls for it. This visit took place on a Thursday morning, May 28, 2026. My friend and I were there to celebrate his birthday, which already set a different tone for the experience. The restaurant was quiet. Being early in the day, there was no rush or noise, just an easy stillness throughout the space. We chose to sit on the patio, which felt like the right decision given the weather. I can't fully speak to the interior atmosphere, since I joined my friend directly outside. Service was handled by a staff member whose name I unfortunately don't remember, but whose presence stood out throughout the meal. She was attentive without being intrusive, consistently present at the right moments, and delivered a level of service that felt natural and well paced. The meal began with a rabbit dish ordered by my friend. It was my first time trying rabbit, and it left a strong impression. The preparation was juicy and well seasoned, with a depth of flavor that made it memorable. Looking back, that first experience with rabbit also set a high expectation for any future rabbit dish I might order myself. My main was The Monk's Cellar burger, one of the restaurant's signature items. I ordered it with avocado. It initially arrived without it, but once requested, it was brought out promptly and it was some of the most cleanly presented avocado I've seen served alongside a burger. The burger itself delivered exactly what it was meant to. The beef had a solid, grounded flavor, and what stood out most were the pickled red onions, which added a sharp acidity that balanced the richness of the meat. The structure was simple, but effective, and everything felt intentional rather than overworked. With the avocado added, it became a more rounded and balanced bite. It's the kind of burger that doesn't try to reinvent itself it just executes well. For me, it remains a staple when I return. For dessert, we asked the server to recommend her personal favorite, which led us to a caramel cheesecake. It turned out to be one of the most memorable cheesecakes I've had. The cheesecake itself carried a rich caramel flavor, but what made it stand out was the combination . Each bite brought together cheesecake, crispy banana, a hint of chocolate or cacao, and nuts that added texture and contrast. It was sweet, but controlled complex without feeling forced. Definitely one of my favorites dessert I had ever tried. I won't go into detail about the drink, as I ordered something off menu (Salty Dog) but good. By the end of the meal, the impression remained consistent with previous visits. The Monk's Cellar is not a restaurant I go to constantly, but every time I do, it delivers. I've ended up here more than once for celebrations, including birthdays, which says something about the role it plays for me. Not every restaurant needs to reinvent itself. Some earn their place simply by being reliable when it matters. This one has consistently been that. Daniel Salguero.

West coastin ipa
Giselle T.

I've been coming to Monks Cellar for a few years now and wow!! The food is incredible, my fave appetizer is the pretzel! The bar tenders are amazing and always make anything I've ordered great. The whisky options...10/10! Recently I went for Oktoberfest and had so much fun! Definitely will be returning for the music and vibes again!

West Coast Tripel. I'd recommend it.
Jason M.

Beer here is great. Lots to choose from. Seating can be difficult though. Parking can be sparse but we've kicked everyone we came here. Food was good enough. We were even lucky enough to bring our dog!

Vernon Street Lager
Gretchen T.

Came here on a busy Saturday just a few minutes after they opened, there was already a line and I was able to get a seat at the bar. I ordered a pint of the Vernon Street Lager ($7) and the fish and chips ($22). The fish and chips had a slightly sweet flavor to them, which was unique. It came with duck fat fries, which were great, some coleslaw, a lemon wedge, and some sort of aoli and tartar sauce. I also got some ketchup and malt vinegar on the side. Everything came out tasting fresh and would try other things on the menu. It came out to $32 + tip.

Fish and Chips

See all

10 days ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 3
Love this 4
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 6
Thanks 3
Love this 3
Oh no 2

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 1

5 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 25
Thanks 6
Love this 22
Oh no 1

1 month ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 2
Love this 4
Oh no 0

7 days ago

Good food really good beer I recommend the Scottish egg if you have never tried 1 before

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Dan ..
0
13
0

1 month ago

We stopped as we were in town on business. All we had was beer so I can't vouch for the food but everything we had was great.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Service was inconsistent, the cocktails were not very good and the food was over priced. Save your time and your money.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0
Photo of Randy M.
40
105
62

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Derek E.
122
27
49

9 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

2 years ago

Helpful 4
Thanks 2
Love this 7
Oh no 1
Photo of Aly A.
971
707
15522

2 years ago

Helpful 17
Thanks 4
Love this 12
Oh no 6

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Matthew K.
72
161
1038

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Dana M.
104
18
19

9 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 1 of 30

The Monk's Cellar Reviews in Other Languages

Ask the Community - The Monk's Cellar

Do they rent out small spaces for private parties? It's for a little wedding after party and we love beer.

Yes they do

View All 2 Questions

You might also consider

Boxing Donkey Irish Pub - Fried Fish

Boxing Donkey Irish Pub

3.7(454 reviews)
0.1 mi
•$$

Over the years, it's such a treat for me to come to the Boxing Donkey for lunch. I used to come…read morehere late at night on the weekends back when I went bar hopping. After a friend introduced me to their menu, I started occasionally getting a craving for their corned beef tacos. You have to add bacon and jalapeños, though! Today, during my tattoo session, we took a lunch break and I came over to the Boxing Donkey. I've been wanting to try their version of fish & chips ever since my daughter ordered them years ago. Plus, I needed something not quite as filling as my beloved corned beef tacos. So, I ordered the fish & chips and their Donkey Pretzel Balls with homemade mustard aioli. While I waited, I went with a hazy beer that I can't remember the name of because it wasn't my usual go-to. The Donkey Pretzel Balls arrived first. I was looking forward to dipping those soft pretzel balls into their mustard aioli... but unfortunately, I wasn't a fan. There was something about the pretzels themselves that tasted a little burnt to me. Kendall, the bartender, offered to remake them. She mentioned that's just how they taste, but offered to bake them a little less to see if that would tone it down. Unfortunately, I still picked up that same flavor. The fish & chips, on the other hand, were fantastic! Crispy batter, juicy cod... and the batter was seasoned perfectly. I loved the sprinkle of sea salt and dill on top of the fish, and it came loaded with tons of their hand-cut Donkey fries. At that point, I decided to leave the pretzel balls alone and focus on my fish & chips. Over the years, I've tried a few things from their menu, and I highly recommend the fish & chips and, of course, the corned beef tacos. I personally wouldn't order the Donkey Pretzel Balls again, although that homemade mustard aioli was delicious. They just had a flavor that wasn't for me.

Wanted to love this place, but was disappointed. Bartender Joe was not trying to be fun or…read moreaccommodating, and seemed annoyed that there were customers in his bar. Multiple groups of 2 and 3 came in, and he was dismissive of them all, and their questions about the menu and beer list with a short retort of "it's on the wall behind you!" This has the bones of being a really great hang, but on my visit it felt like they don't care.

Photos
Boxing Donkey Irish Pub
Boxing Donkey Irish Pub - Patty melt with donkey fries

Patty melt with donkey fries

Boxing Donkey Irish Pub - Old town Roseville water tower

See all

Old town Roseville water tower

LBB Gastropub & Smokehouse

LBB Gastropub & Smokehouse

4.0(514 reviews)
6.9 mi
•$$

Solid dinner and drink location in Loomis along the main street. If you were looking to hit up High…read moreHand but the parking or crowds were a bit too much, this is a great location to settle in for dinner as well. The BBQ was decent, although I wish the brisket had more moist cuts and larger portions. Garlic bread was great, and the dirty grilled cheese were solid choices. We had our kids with us, and the servers and staff were so helpful and kind despite their controlled chaos. We really appreciated them for that. Prices are reasonable and manageable, even for our family of 4. Parking is available adjacent in the lots behind the restaurant. Casual/Tahoe-esque vibe with cozy, woody/cabin feel that's great for dinner and catching up with friends and family. Beers and drinks were great! Selection was on point and the cocktails were creative and delicious as well. Recommended.

This is one of my favorite places to eat, so I still rate it high, but tonight I was pretty…read moredisappointed in my choice. I usually go for the dirty grilled cheese, always comes out great (tons of meat), looking and tasting delicious. Tonight I made a different choice, thought I'd try a bit healthier option with the meat sampler chicken. Now usually when I have been to bbq spots you get like 1/2 chicken so I was VERY shocked when the smallest piece of sliced chicken breast came out on a little side plate. Was a strange presentation and immediately had me disappointed in my choice. In fairness, the chicken tasted nice, was pretty dry though and barely warm, but good flavor at least (needed sauce so wasn't so dry). It was maybe 4-5 ounces of chicken which seems a bit skimpy for the price. My side salad with blue cheese dressing was good as usual. They should really consider at least more chicken and better plating though! Got my usual, very berry refresher, maybe a new bartender tonight? Wasn't as good as usual, but everyone has an off night. Overall though, love this place, still gave a good rating and of course will be back.

Photos
LBB Gastropub & Smokehouse - Inside

Inside

LBB Gastropub & Smokehouse - Dirty Grilled Cheese pulled pork with smoked white cheddar, on artisan swiss German bread

Dirty Grilled Cheese pulled pork with smoked white cheddar, on artisan swiss German bread

LBB Gastropub & Smokehouse - Spectacular

See all

Spectacular

Goose Port - Western Chicken Salad

Goose Port

4.1(493 reviews)
0.1 mi
•$$

We've reserved this place for our team dinner during basketball tournaments in Roseville - we've…read morecome here 3 times now and we've absolutely loved it! Making a reservation by phone is super easy and staff is very friendly. The owner, Al Santos, calls back to discuss further details and confirms the order which I think is such a plus especially in a world where everything is digital. We can't say enough about Al's hospitality! And the fact that he is from Niles, we loved supporting a Bay Area native! Our reservations of usually 30 or more are ready for us when we come in - Al made sure there was a table for the team and then separate ones for the parents. They also accommodate different checks - not individual ones which is difficult but we batch together orders to make it easier on the staff. Drinks are solid and pour on the cocktails solid to generous based on what everyone received. Wait staff is friendly and attentive even when the rest of the restaurant is busy. Food is solid as well. We never felt rushed during our times there. The establishment is clean, has a nice atmosphere and offers outside seating as well. And if Al is there, he'll always come over and say hi and ask how things are going- definitely something we appreciate and it's what sets Goose Port apart! If you're looking for a place to accommodate a big party with good food and drinks choices - this place is an awesome spot!

Cool spot to duck into for a cocktail on a rainy Saturday afternoon visiting the Big Boy train…read moredisplay in old Roseville. Was able to get two seats at the bar on a overwhelmingly busy lunchtime. Hour wait otherwise. Lot's of TV's, strong Old Fashioned and some good advice from the bar tender on a shortcut Walk back to our car 1.5 miles away.

Photos
Goose Port - Watching the 49er game

Watching the 49er game

Goose Port - Mushroom Swiss

Mushroom Swiss

Goose Port - Wings!

See all

Wings!

Dog Haus Biergarten - Sooo Cali hot dog

Dog Haus Biergarten

4.3(393 reviews)
3.9 mi
•$$
Locally owned & operated
Free WiFi

We stopped in for lunch and had a great experience. The wings were absolutely delicious definitely…read morea must-order. We also tried a few cocktails, and they were well made and complemented the meal perfectly. The location in the new Blue Oaks shopping center is great, right near Nugget Market. They have an excellent selection of beers, TVs throughout the restaurant for watching sports, and a fun, laid-back atmosphere. Whether you're stopping in for lunch, happy hour, or to catch a game with friends, it's a great place to hang out. We'll definitely be back!

We tried Dog Haus Biergarten for the first time and overall had a really good experience! The…read moreowner, Joe, was very friendly and personable. We let him know it was our first time there, and he made us feel welcome. I got the cheeseburger and really enjoyed it. I especially liked the Hawaiian roll bun. I was worried it might be overwhelmingly sweet, but it wasn't at all. The sweet pickles were also a nice touch. My husband got the Swole' Chick breakfast burrito, which has a whopping 80g of protein! He enjoyed it, although it wasn't his favorite thing we ordered. The fries, though--SO good. The regular fries were crispy, stood up instead of being limp or soggy, and had the perfect amount of salt. We also tried the chili cheese fries and those were bomb! I thought the prices were very reasonable for the portions and quality. The cheeseburger was $11.99, the Swole' Chick was $14.99, regular fries were $3.99, and the chili cheese fries were $7.49. We definitely got a good amount of food for what we paid. There's plenty of seating inside and a bar at the front. My only real complaint was the fountain drinks. They don't carry Coke or Pepsi products and instead have RC Cola, which I had never tried before. I'd heard it was supposed to taste similar to Coke or Pepsi, but to me it oddly tasted more like root beer. The diet Dr Pepper was also out--it came out extremely light brown and mostly water. The ice machine also ran out of ice while we were there, but when we mentioned it to Joe, he immediately came over and refilled it, which I appreciated. Overall, we had a good first experience. The food was really good, prices were reasonable, and Joe was incredibly friendly and welcoming. The fountain drink situation could definitely use some improvement, but the food--especially those fries--would bring us back!

Photos
Dog Haus Biergarten - Inside the restaurant

Inside the restaurant

Dog Haus Biergarten - Chili cheese dog

Chili cheese dog

Dog Haus Biergarten - The Hot Chick As A Bowl (hot fried chicken salad)

See all

The Hot Chick As A Bowl (hot fried chicken salad)

Original Al's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Artichoke Hearts

Original Al's Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.1(476 reviews)
1.5 mi
•$$

Imagine that The Cheesecake Factory is a small one-off family owned restaurant. This imaginary…read morerestaurant doesn't specialize in desserts, but still has a few crave worthy astonishing ones. This family joint has great pizza, dozens of American food favorites, healthy salads, a hand made soup of the day, lunch specials, a decent 12 draught beers selection and reasonably priced good quality wines. Sound like a dream? Wake up! It's reality. It's Al's Original. My first ever visit. We ate a Cesar salad, a small pizza, a giant slice of chocolate cake. I'm not a pushover for reasonably priced restaurant food quality. I expect goodness, real flavors. Al's delivers big time! This eatery has been in this same location for 31 years because the food is way above average, is reasonably priced, has a pleasant dining room and the servers are great. Friendly, kind, helpful, cheerful. Bambie & I thoroughly enjoyed our dinner tonight. We had some left overs to bring home. Oh boy, reheated pizza for breakfast! Love you Al's. My new favorite restaurant in Roseville. Addendum: Returned 8 days later for dinner. I had the chicken, Bambie had the Fettucini shrimp with creamy sauce. Both dinners were excellent. I drank the Original Al's pale ale. It's delicious, too.

A mixed experience that overall will keep us from returning. Our first time, and we were wondering…read morewhy we hadn't heard much about it, though we live only 10 minutes away. Bottom line is, I can't recommend it. It all started out just fine. It was a beautiful day, perfect for sitting out on OAR's patio. It's certainly not much of a view, as you're quite literally part of the parking lot. But the chairs were very comfortable, and even though there's a large garbage can adjacent to the eating area, it generally seemed clean. It all began in a way that led us to think this was going to be a great experience. We were met by one of the most pleasant and helpful servers ever - Tami. She was terrific, and she explained a bit about the history of OAR, and it's recent name changeover from Pete's to Al's. We started with the included salads. Mrs. had the house salad with blue cheese dressing; I had the Caesar. Both salads were surprisingly large and excellent. Larger than we expected, with cold, crisp ingredients and top-notch dressings. Totally enjoyable. 5-star. Because we were first-timers, we over-ordered a bit so we could taste several dishes. We ordered the fried calamari. Tami correctly assured us the coating was crisp, and it was. The problem was the calamari itself. It was tough and chewy, not particularly pleasant or tasty. After our 5-star salads, the calamari was a 3. Then came the mains. Mrs. had the shrimp linguini, which she pronounced: "good." The shrimp and pasta were cooked to just the right textures. We took home the leftovers. The dish was a solid 4. I had a full slab of the St. Louis ribs, and honestly, and sadly, they were a disaster. They arrived barely above room temperature. They were so tough that even with the provided sharp steak knife, cutting off an individual rib was difficult. The BBQ sauce was mediocre, and slathered atop a cold slab of tough pork ribs, the dish simply should never have been served. I'm guessing it was prepared yesterday and kept overnight in the refrigerator, but who knows? You do not want to order the ribs. I tried two ribs and left the rest on the table to be cleared away. I'd give them 1.5 on Yelp's 5-star scale. I don't want to dwell on a negative experience. There are quite a few positive Yelp reviews that make me think there might have been an explanation for our experience. But the tab with a 20% tip was $105.66, and I'm not willing to risk returning.

Photos
Original Al's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Inside

Inside

Original Al's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Prime Rib Dip

Prime Rib Dip

Original Al's Restaurant & Pizzeria - The included salads were great.  Cold, crisp, great dressings.  This is the house salad with blue cheese, i had the Caesar.  5-star salads.

See all

The included salads were great. Cold, crisp, great dressings. This is the house salad with blue cheese, i had the Caesar. 5-star salads.

The Monk's Cellar - pubs - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...