I'm gonna update and give them 5 stars, the menu has changed they have started to offer a happy hour... which is a great thing for the area gives locals a chance even though I don't know how they would know, but it's a chance to keep the seats full on the off weeks. Which compensates for the higher prices (which is totally worth it you don't have to travel to the other steak places to get a great steak and it's in the neighborhood) I would definitely give it a try the staff is extremely friendly and the kitchen seems to Know what they are doing give it a try you shouldn't (I won't say will not because you might be having a day) be disappointed. Plus they have a great little banquet hall upstairs for special events read more

See all

The Library Restaurant building looks a little worn from the outside and is in an IND adjacent neighborhood that has seen better days. We arrived after looking up "Lunch near Airport" and this place popping with good reviews and a high TripAdvisor position. Gayle and I had a very enjoyable Lunch. The inside was bright, clean, well-appointed and spacious. Our wait person was friendly and prompt. I ordered the tomato bisque and grilled cheese special, while Gayle opted for a Patty Melt (with Fries). Both choices were delicious and just the right amount of food for me. Gayle left a fair amount of food on her plate, mostly due to a huge sandwich and lot for fries. I appreciated that this place offered beers that didn't have the word IPA in them, with my Oatmeal Stout being a great choice. Gayle went for her favorite Chardonnay preference. We both nursed our drinks and the fries as we were in no hurry to get the airport. The Library Restaurant and Pub was a solid choice, and one that we would repeat for either Lunch or Dinner. read more

Stopped in for a quick lunch to mark this off my to-try list. It is in a very unassuming area, with a slight funeral-home look from the parking lot. We had no trouble getting a table at 1pm on a Tuesday, the occupied tables looked like business lunches and regulars. Our server was kind and gave us space to look over the menu. We were there for lunch, so we had a lunch menu, but the prices were the same as at dinner. I had always assumed it would be a restaurant full of books, but I was disappointed in that. It does have beautiful artwork replicas of Napoleon, some with funny additions. My husband had the fish and chips, which was a decent serving with very good homemade tartar sauce. I had half a sandwich and their broccoli soup. All in all, it was good enough food, in a nice enough setting, but not something we would come back for. read more

Had a good meal at The Library. I got there pretty early to catch their happy hour which is well drinks and some menu items. The outside needs a little help but the inside is nice and inviting. I sat at the bar and Samantha took great care of me. I had the Caesar salad salad, and I ordered the New York strip. Both were good and the steak was cooked perfectly. Definitely a spot to check out if you're over in that part of the city. read more

See all

What a hidden gem. From the minute you walk In The decor and service are great. The ambiance is great and the overall vibe is upscale. The menu is full of great options. We started out with the wings and they were done perfectly. We both fit steaks and they were cooked well and very flavorful. Our waitress was in top of every and made sure we were well taken care of. Will be back next time I'm on this side of town for sure. read more

The Library Restaurant & Pub - NY strip steak with steak fries and green beans. - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Upon arrival, you feel the classic midwestern comfort food aura. And boy did it live up to that description. Fresh bread with a pesto olive oil tapenade that you just don't see at too many casual restaurants these days. The French onion soup was hearty and bursting with flavor. The salmon, whoa baby don't get me started. The mushroom cream sauce and spinach paired perfectly with the salmon and green beans. They're known for the prime rib, but I don't know how I can order anything other than what I just got! read more

The Library Restaurant & Pub - Salmon Florentine with green beans - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

This place has older country club vibes to it. You can tell who the regulars are as they are immediately greeted with service. We noticed our table moved much slower than everyone else's service wise. The food was good! Everything was a little spicy on the pastas but I was a fan. I think the creme brûlée was delicious and I really appreciated their options of beer on tap. They have cute cocktail names but they are standard cocktail blends! read more

More like 1 1/2 stars. 1st time we went there they were out of prime rib, which is why we went there. Really nothing on the menu that I liked. So after giving them another try, took them off the list. Verrry pricey but not worth it. Second time had salmon and it was over cooked and over seasoned. French onion soup was not bad but there again too pricey. I doubt we will give them another chance. read more

The food was really tasty and our server was very attentive to us. We love the atmosphere of the place.

Was there for lunch. Great service and ambience. Had a salad and sandwich and both tasted very good and fresh.

We ate at the Library and all we have to say is don't judge a book by its cover!!! We are visiting from out of town, saw some good reviews on this place. While running errands we drove past this place and weren't too impressed with the aesthetic of the outside. If we didn't see the reviews, we probably would've never came. But Kailey our server was great. Super attentive. We ordered the prime rib and the filet, both cooked medium and everything was great! read more

See all

Service was horrible! it took 2 hours to get our dinner. It made it seem that if you are mexican that's the service you will get.

Met promptly, seated promptly. The Cajun chicken Alfredo was fantastic! Normally my lunch haunt but my schedule hasn't allowed. Tonight, dinner and it was worth the trip. Try it, you'll like it. read more

The Library Restaurant & Pub - Cajun Grilled Chicken Alfredo - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The food was adequate. The server was polite but not very attentive. The decor was not what I expected from an establishment named "the library" - the only decorations in the room we ate in were the sporting photographs hung on the walls. The paint job they were hung over was also very poorly done which led to a shabby look overall. If this was a $20 per meal sports bar I wouldn't rate my experience worthy of a negative review, but at $40+ per person I expect better food, service and ambience. Won't be returning. read more

Came here as it was one of the few restaurants near our hotel by the airport. The area around the restaurant looks bleak. When you enter, it's pretty cute. The entrance looks like a library--that's where it ends. I felt like it would've been cooler if the rest of the place was decorated like a library too. There were a good amount of people coming to eat dinner. The wait was long, around 35 minutes for our food. Our group of 3 each got a ribeye. For my side, I got a Caesar salad and mashed potatoes. The ribeye had quite a bit of fat on it, but after a long travel day, it was quite good. Our server apologized several times for the wait. She was very friendly. Overall I think the Library can use a refresher in terms of looks but it's otherwise a solid spot for a hearty dinner. read more

The Library Restaurant & Pub - ribeye - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Not bad. Good pork chop. Slow service. Wine selection not good. Atmosphere needs work. Server was trying, but lot better places.

Decided to try this place for dinner since it looked like the only niceish restaurant within walking distance of my airport hotel. It's a cool building. The themed decoration is strongest in the foyer, but the whole restaurant has a charm to it. There are a few rooms in the house which are somewhat secluded from each other, and I was in the bar area with just a handful of tables, which made the place feel less busy to me than it actually was - I was surprised at how quiet it was on a Friday night until I was leaving and saw that there were more diners in other areas of the restaurant that weren't visible from my seat. The food was pretty good. I first ordered a draft oat stout by New Holland Brewing, which was a very nice beer poured perfectly. Complimentary bread and pesto were brought out before my entree. The bread was so good - it was very soft and fresh, brushed with a flavourful herb butter. My entree was the vegan puttanesca. The dish had a good variety of vegetables all cooked well, and the marinara sauce was tasty (lots of garlic) but so brothy that I felt like I needed a spoon to eat it, but alas no spoon was provided. The waitress did offer more bread but I didn't feel hungry enough, so I declined and just tried to get as much as I could with my fork. The cheesecake with chocolate sauce for dessert was very good too - the cheesecake was rich and a little tangy but not overly dense or sweet. I appreciated that their dessert menu has both smaller and larger desserts, so I could get something from the small bites menu for just myself. I think my entree was too expensive for what it was - chickpea pasta and vegetables in marinara sauce - but the prices made more sense for the drinks, dessert, and meat/seafood entrees. The service throughout the meal was great. My waitress was attentive and very nice. She checked in often to see if I needed anything else but was also patient with me and other parties. The hostess was also pleasant. I didn't have to wait long after ordering to get my food either. Given that its located right by a handful of airport hotels, I expected more of a traveler vibe, but it seemed like the crowd was mostly locals, which actually makes sense to me after my visit. It's a really nice, kind of old-school place with good food, and it could fit the bill whether you want a casual but quality meal, or a nice night out. read more

See all

Prime rib sweet potato fries and a salad!! Sign me up!! Delish!! Service could be a little better but food is amazing!

I've had plenty of prime rib in my day, and that is the best I've ever had. No joke! Pricey? Yep, but still worth it. REALLY damn good!

The prices really high and happy hour is from 2 to 5 pm and and mushrooms are were good

The food was amazing. The wait staff were total rockstars. The lighting was right. The vibe was good and lots of delicious food to choose from. Great date night or special occasion venue. read more

The Library Restaurant & Pub - Prime rib. Potatoes and green beans. - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Great spot! We all enjoyed everything! Service was solid and appreciated. Great job! The food was on spot tasty! We destroyed the maple bourbon chops! Great drink options too. The ambiance was clean upscale! read more

See all

Stopped at this place for a quick lunch while driving through town.Wasn't quite sure what to expect. The front entrance decorated uniquely. The sitting area was a large open room that felt a little too spacious for dining. Did not give a comfortable feel. The waitress was very personable and the food was good for what we had ordered, a salad and a wrap. read more

See all

This place sold and the menu isn't anything it used to be. Disgusting! Is it even American? Taste like someone is trying to throw some foreign twists on it. Bring back the stuffed salmon, and wedge salads and prime rib. IT's absolutely disgusting. This will not last long , it's absolutely not the same owners, can't be possible. The soup of the day today tasted like something foreign. I don't even know what it was. It simply said soup of the day on the container. The menu has been ruined and the prices for that garbage is absolutely insane. I will never go back and if I could, I'd give it zero stars. ick ick ick read more

We were there when they first opened. In fact, thirty minutes early for the reservation. We were admitted and seated quickly. The room decor is awesome. The seating does not do much. There were four of us who ordered. The table was far too small and cramped. There were many empty seats. Perhaps because of the early hours and the price and the available selection of entree items. Not really enough room at the table for food. The waitress was charming and kept up with everything. Bread and olive with pesto was good I asked for balsamic vinegar. Both are very fresh. The chicken parm was ok ., The prime rib was excellent had sauces on the side. Glad I did, I don't care for their Auju. Horseradish was good. Walleye excellent. Cauliflower was ok. French fries are crispy and hot. The person who ordered mushrooms did not like them at all. I tried some I did not care for them either. For dessert, we had Lemon bars were good as was the chocolate cake the Venus Delight, it was very good but tasted almost no Caramel sauce or rum. Somewhat disappointed. This is my second review of this place. I reviewed them several years ago. I feel they are not quite as good as before, but still good. Some selections are no longer on the menu that were very good then. Seems as though they have down-scaled somewhat. That being said will eat there again if I am in the area. read more

Trendy lunch spot. Great variety of sandwiches and salads with interesting flavor choices. I tried the breaded tenderloin and sweet potato waffle fries. Huge portion, I cut in half and had dinner with leftovers that eve. Fast service, clean and plenty of choices for everyone's palette. Less than $25 for lunch and tip. read more

The Library Restaurant & Pub - Breaded Tenderloin Sandwich - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We stopped in for an early dinner to meet with a client. The restaurant offered both a happy hour menu and an early dinner menu, which was nice to have as options. We ordered the "full" shrimp appetizer for $16 (as opposed to the $8 option), and I was surprised that it only included six pieces. That felt expensive, especially for a happy hour offering. The early dinner menu itself was relatively good, but we ended up ordering from the regular menu because it had the items we wanted. I had read that the tables were smaller for parties of four, and while I'm not completely sure I agree with that, I will say the tables are very close together. The spacing made it uncomfortable, as I didn't love having to constantly say "excuse me" or worry about bumping into guests seated behind me. There seems to be enough room in the area to space tables out a bit more and reduce the crowded feeling. I will say the service was very good. However, it felt like the bar area might have benefited from an additional server, as it appeared that many guests were seated there to keep the service area compact. Despite these minor issues, this was my fourth visit, and I will continue to come back. read more

I absolutely love this place. The ambience is so different but pleasant. The waitress was very attentive, polite and knowledgeable of the menu. She made great suggestions. We started with the stuffed shrimp which is a MUST! It is delicious. (I didn't get a pic) The hubby got the Cajun shrimp Alfredo was was very good but it did need salt. The Cajun was on point but no salt. My salmon was good. There was a lot of the cheese that they use which has a bold flavor so I didn't eat a lot of it but the flavor and cooking was spot on. Juicy salmon! The green beans were amazing although they could've used salt too. The potatoes were soooooo good. Looking for a different place to go w/ great food and service this is your spot! read more

The Library Restaurant & Pub - Cajun Shrimp Alfredo - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

The food was great here. I had the filet mignon and sat the bar with Samantha. She was incredible. I will definitely be back next time in the town. read more

My partner and I have been numerous times. In fact it's our go to spot. The wait staff is always friendly, the food is fresh and steaks are cooked to perfections. We plan to go for Valentine's Day. read more

I want to give them 5 stars because the service was amazing, the atmosphere was pleasant and 90% of our food was delicious. Instead I'm giving 4 stars because I really didn't like the prime rib. I'm not sure if I got it on a bad day... or if it's typically on the "grainy" side, but it just wasn't for me! It tasted like it had just been reheated in a microwave. However, when I told the server that I didn't need a box and 95% of it sat on my plate, she realized there might be an issue and credited our bill. Overall, it was a nice experience! read more

The Library Restaurant & Pub - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

The food and service was perfect and we had 18 people in our party. It was clean and my water and cola was always full. I had the filet mignon and it was cooked to perfection. I will definitely try this restaurant again. read more

The Library Restaurant & Pub - Filet 8 oz. Filet Mignon 8 oz. - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Service was good. Food--not so much. Too salty. Way too salty. Pretty sure this walleye will be good for a few months as a result.

Even though I've worked in the area for 10 years, I somehow have never tried to dining room here before. I have been upstairs in a conference room for a work meeting and lunch before. They have three dining spaces downstairs and spaces upstairs that you can rent out for meetings. They also had flyers out for murder mystery dinners they host. This visit I was eating lunch with my team from work. We arrived right around 11 and there was only a few other diners. By the time we left at 12, it was pretty packed. It's very pretty inside, they have chandeliers and paintings everywhere. They have a good selection of soup, salad, and sandwiches to choose from, including vegetarian options. They also have a bar as well. I had the Buffalo chicken wrap with cole slaw. Both were delicious. My colleagues had the Philly cheesesteak and sandwich/soup combo and enjoyed them too. They were great at accommodating our substitutions too. The prices are a little on the higher side but the food is worth it. Our server was friendly and kept our drinks refilled throughout. The only issue I had was that they sat all the tables close together (probably for convenience) but I felt like everyone could hear our conversations. We typically only get 30 minutes for lunch so we won't be able to go often, but they do have online ordering for pickup which might be a good option for us. We also all loved the bowls of peppermints as you exit. I'm glad to know there's a great non-fast food option in the neighborhood! read more

See all

We had lunch. Close to the airport and track. Food and service were good. Nothing to complain about. If you're looking for a life changing dining experience probably not your spot but if you're looking for a decent lunch spot give it a shot. read more

Great place to eat . Loved our server . The service was also good I liked the menu options as well

Food was very good. Service was excellent. No booths but ample seating. $$ but worth it!

This was a treat. Next to the airport and convenient to the airport. Loved the prime rib and definitely will stop in again.

Had a great experience when I ate in the restaurant last night however, tonight I ordered to go and a $28 Caesar salad was the smallest salad I think I ever had. Do Not Order Take out. read more

Terrible food, overpriced, crummy service, tacky decor, and loud. First and last time there.