The Cookie Tin in Riverside is such a great lunch spot -- I'm so glad I stopped in. They have a wide selection of sandwiches, cookies, and coffee, and the prices are very reasonable. The staff was friendly and attentive, which always makes the experience better. Pro tip: the grilled cheese isn't on the menu, but you should definitely ask for it. So much gooey, melted cheese -- it was amazing. The only downside was that the cookies weren't labeled. The guy behind the counter had to keep explaining what each one was to customers, which could easily be fixed with simple labels. And the banana bread with cookie crumbles on top? BEST thing ever!!!! I honestly want to go back just to buy a dozen of those alone. Definitely worth the stop. read more

See all

10/10 Experience! My partner and I just ate at The Cookie Tin Café, and we were blown away by the warm hospitality. It's been a long time since we've experienced service this genuine and welcoming, it truly felt like home. The new owner personally greeted us, and along with Genevieve, made our visit unforgettable. The paninis were incredibly fresh, flavorful, and perfectly made and the cookies tasted like grandma baked them herself! soft, nostalgic, and absolutely delicious. Everything about this place radiates comfort and care. We left feeling full, happy, and already planning our next visit. If you're looking for a cozy spot with amazing food and heartfelt service, this is the place to go! read more

The Cookie Tin - Turkey bacon panini - Sandwiches Near Me - Riverside, California

I came for the cookies and tried 5 of the 6 different flavors and unfortunately I didn't love any of them. The cookies are big! That's a plus if you like their cookies. I have a huge sweet tooth but some of these were way too sugary for me. A few were under-flavored. These cookies have more of a sugar cookie texture than classic homemade cookies with heaps of butter. My theory is they've reduced the eggs and butter in their recipes. Although the service was great and it's a cute shop, the cookies are akin to chain store grocery cookies. White chocolate macadamia was pretty good, it wasn't too sweet and had the best outside texture of all 6 that I got. There weren't that many white chocolate chips and only 3 macadamia nut pieces in it though. It was also undercooked. I love a gooey center but these were just straight up undercooked. The chocolate chip was the most disappointing, it was dry and dense. I really wanted an ooey gooey chocolate chip cookie that people have posted in their reviews. Snickerdoodle was undercooked so the center was doughy. It needed a punch up to the flavor, but maybe the flavor just can't come through because it needed to be baked a bit more. The strawberry milk had a single strawberry on it and was also undercooked. There were a lot of white chocolate chips in it so it was a tad sweeter than I expected. I didn't get a strong strawberry when I took a bite. The brookie of the month was just okay to me, it was also a bit sweet. The sprinkles were dried out. It was also undercooked. read more

The Cookie Tin - Sandwiches Near Me - Riverside, California

See all

I was craving panera for lunch and holy smokes am I glad I came here instead. The Caesar salad wrap with chicken was enormous and delicious. Absolutely no skimping on the croutons, dressing or chicken whatsoever. I was stuffed after the first half and after marinating in the wrap it was even more delicious for dinner. The service was amazing. The cookies were amazing. My strawberry basil latte was unique and amazing. The jazz, sunshine and bushy pothos inside made my virtual work day a breath of fresh, delicious air. read more

The Cookie Tin - Spring Caesar Wrap - Sandwiches Near Me - Riverside, California

We decided to explore this place after seeing it on tiktok. The service was excellent and extremely welcoming as the owner talked us through all of our options and checked up on us throughout our meal. We chose a wrap and paninis came with a free cookie or chip. The cookies had the perfect amount of sweetness, and the cookie milk latte was one of the best coffees we've had in Riverside! The rocky road cookie had a nice balance between the nuttiness and sweetness of the cookie while the apple butter snickerdoodle had a nice cinnamon spice. The caesar salad with chicken inside the wrap was delicious, and we would love to order it on its own next time. There was a bit too much outer wrap and we ended up tearing out the excess. The caprese panini with prosciutto was extremely rich and buttery, but there was a lot of cheese that was slightly overwhelming the tomato and pesto. Overall, the cafe had a cute and welcoming charm. We would come here again when we have a craving for sweets, and we would recommend to others who are looking for an affordable meal nearby. read more

See all

I really enjoyed this sandwich it was a perfect balance of sweet and savory. Location is unassuming located off of spruce tucked between businesses. I ordered online to be able to pick up. Service was fast and friendly. They didn't have the brookie so I opted for the rocky road cookie and it was delicious! Not a lot of parking and it was really busy inside which was really nice to see. read more

See all

Shop is clean, service is fast and friendly staff. The cookies have been so dry since it changed owners. We have given it many try's but it's just not the same. read more

Yes, come in. I wish I wouldve taken a picture before I started inhaling this delicious sandwich. Whoever curates the menu has a passion for flavor. Its not just a simple sandwich. Its made to be enjoyed and savored with every bite. A feeling of being taken on a journey as your pallet explores every flavor, but within the crispy but soft slices of golden bread. They managed to achieve this within a sandwich, that tastes like it was made with thoughtfulness, unlike fast food joints. Always greeted by kind and cheerful staff who are willing to help you decide if youre not too sure. They also let you know that each meal comes with a cookie. My favorite is the pb&j, but its definitely worth trying any of their other unique cookies that are baked fresh and to perfection. Along with their classic cookies they also have season cookies. I recommend this location, and I hope you enjoy it as much as myself and others whom ive recommended it to. read more

Tried a bunch of things out but was super disappointed for the most part. Tried a couple paninis, a bunch of cookies, a few lattes and the lavender lemonade. The caprese panini was delicious and the only thing I'd come back for. All the cookies were almost flavorless. Very bland. The other panini wasn't good either, had a strange taste and felt like it was missing something. The lattes were very bitter, not sweet at all in any form. The pb&j latte was the worst and for whatever reason there's a bunch of peanut chunks at the bottom of the cup as well. Not impressed and wasted a lot of money only to like one item. I would absolutely order that panini again though which is what the two stars are for. I did forget to mention that the girl who helped me out was extremely friendly and informative though. So points for that for sure. She was incredibly sweet. read more

The newly opened "The Cookie Tin" by James Madison catering kept the classic cookies and brought out some new stuff to their menu! These pics/review is from back in July when I visited, but now they have their own Yelp page, so updating here! When I visited, I talked with the new owner and she was very sweet and kind and answered all my questions regarding their new business! The decor is cute and modern, it is the perfect place to stop for lunch or just to hang out in a nice cozy spot. At that time, I ordered a turkey, bacon, swiss melt panini and a white chocolate macadamia cookie. Both of which are my two favorite things to order from there and have had at least a few times already since my last visit in July! The cookie is as sweet and soft as I remember! And the panini was warm, crunchy, and flavorful. Everything about this place is amazing and definitely fills the craving! Can't wait to come back and try more things from the menu! read more

The Cookie Tin - Turkey, bacon, swiss panini melt! So good! - Sandwiches Near Me - Riverside, California

See all

I cannot say enough good things about the Cookie Tin! I have used them for both a lunch spot during the work week, catering for [corporate events, family celebrations, and parties], and in-store events! Their menu is a treasure trove of culinary delights, offering a variety of sandwiches with unique and fresh ingredients. The cookies, in particular, are a sinful indulgence, both in size and taste. With most entrees accompanied by one, be prepared to be pleasantly surprised and soon addicted. Regarding catering, Cookie Tin/James Madison Catering goes above and beyond. For a family celebration, I ordered their quiches, and they were an instant hit. The quiches, generously filled with fresh ingredients, were a testament to their commitment to quality. Jonathan's willingness to accommodate our preferences and his creative touch made the experience truly special. Last but not least, I reserved their store for a private party on a Saturday. Once again, they blew us out of the water with their smorgasbord of sandwiches and treats. The owners and staff are lovely and very customer service-oriented. Please do yourself a favor and visit this lovely establishment. You will not be disappointed! read more

The Cookie Tin - Sandwiches Near Me - Riverside, California

Really good quality sandwiches and soup. Healthy menu options. Quality of the food is good for the price.

Fire cookies would recommend to my Mom. I haven't tried their food but the cookies are a favorite read more

Oh man this is a great local, hole in the wall cafe. They serve sandwiches, salads and wraps. Even soups. The oatmeal cookie oats are amazing! I had the roast beef au jus and the pastrami and they were excellent. And the cookies are super good. Moist and tasty, each flavor is better than the next, you can't stop at just one. The owners are super nice and ensure your meal will be perfect. And they offer catering as well. Definitely gotta check them out if you are anywhere close. read more

See all

Very friendly and accommodating. Overnight cookie oats delicious. Very disappointed in new recipe for peanut butter and jam cookie. Cookie milk latte very tasty but I would suggest using a finer sieve because the small random nut pieces didn't add great mouth feel . I'd probably go three and half stars to be honest, but they're close to getting things right. read more

U unique flavors. I It was very good I did not stay to eat but I would like to go back and try a different one by the way I had the garlic and beef sandwich panini I might try the pastrami next time read more

I work close to here so I order a sandwich on Fridays sometimes. I call ahead so it's ready. The sandwiches are really fresh, fairly priced, and the cookies are delicious (key lime is my favorite). I need to get a menu so I can try something besides turkey. read more

I found The Cookie Tin by James to be the perfect lunch spot. It's such a cute, friendly, and clean place. I enjoyed their tuna melt and a cold chia drink. read more

I work relatively close to here and wanted to give it a shot bc I'm a sucker for soup and a sandwich. I loved that the had a large cookie collection and actually ordered two, chocolate chip w/peanut butter and rocky road. Unfortunately they forgot to put in one of my cookies but I called and they said I could pick it up tomorrow. The tuna melt was really great seems to be panini pressed. As for the soup I think it was also good just wished it was hot and not like warm. It came with croutons which was cool. Anyway the soup, tuna melt, and two cookies cost be 23.99. Compared to another sandwich shop in Riverside it was hefty but it definitely was because the 2 cookies were gourmet. The cookies at the other shop are standard chocolate chip 2 for 1.95. Besides that the shop was really cute I think the cookie jars are a really nice touch and I definitely would come again just to try the other cookies. read more

The Cookie Tin - Tuna melt Soup of the day - Sandwiches Near Me - Riverside, California

Thanks again so much for your guys hard work and effort last night in your restaurant's Grand Opening, i really have a good time and food's all great as always and it feels like we're in hilton so cozy and all! Keep up the good work and more power to both of you! Love uncle elmer and auntie alou read more

I just went here today and imma put y'all on! GET THE CITRUS BUTTER COOKIE, it will change your life the lady in the front is super nice too!! read more