Staff was super friendly. We sat down right away and ordered two slices. One pepperoni and one cheese. Cut them bad boys in half and swapped them, because we like to do that. Each slice was amazing. The crust crispy and no grease. The vibe was awesome as well We each had a lager and bailed. I would definitely come back to this spot. read more

Surf City - Lager - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Immaculate service, slices as big as your face and a great Brooklyn lager to add to your meal. I highly recommend eating here. The vibe inside is amazing as well. read more

Surf City - Slices and beer - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The pizza plain pizza was delicious. I felt like I was in the old coney island when it was a world attraction. Such a great atmosphere and a plus on the customer service. read more

We stopped by to get my niece some pizza , and it was really good . I feel like Surf city is under new management . Their menu changed The service was attentive , the atmosphere was friendly . The pizza had very thin crust and tasted really good . The prices are ok, because you are right by the amusement park. We will be back read more

Surf City - Half regular pizza half pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

It's across the street from Luna park on Surf Ave. It has an outside patio. They have more than pizza here which is awesome. Pizza is def good here. They also have what looks like a small bar area that can pass as a coffee bar as well. Upon entering it's a bit confusing if you get seated or you order at the counter. I'd suggest they'd put a sign up like "please wait to be seated or Seat yourself". Staff was cool and friendly. I'd def come back when in Coney. Beats the heat for sure. read more

Surf City - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This was one of the worst and most humiliating experiences I've ever had at a business. I politely asked to use the restroom and clearly said I would purchase something. I really just needed to use the bathroom and couldn't hold it. Instead of responding respectfully, the employee physically pushed me. I told her not to touch me, but she pushed me again. Then the manager came over and started yelling at me as well, which made the situation even more upsetting. I was not being aggressive or disrespectful in any way I was simply asking to use the restroom and was ready to buy something. I have never felt so disrespected and uncomfortable in a place like this. No one should be treated this way. If the restroom is not available, that can be communicated politely. There is absolutely no excuse for physical contact and shouting at a customer. This was completely unacceptable behavior from both staff and management. I would not recommend this place to anyone. read more

Surf City - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

To quote my husband "the worst calzone I've ever had." Yikes. The dough tasted sour -- not like sourdough but like someone left it out and it went bad before shaping and cooking. The cheese tasted like a sad attempt at a cheese substitute. The sausage was okay but hardly enough to make up for the terrible terrible cheese and dough. I got a coffee. It was fine. Service was fine. read more

Delicious pizza and drinks. Ofcourse I have to get the kids favorite. Pepperoni and for myself Margherita Pizza. My tequila sunrise was delicious. Service was excellent Overall I was pleased with everything. read more

Surf City is the best restaurant after a half marathon!! It has been my 3rd year eating here after Brooklyn Half and it does not disappoint! Location: It is located in Coney Island. Right in front of Cyclone. There a lot of seatings inside and outside! Service: the staff were nice, they are very attentive and give us recommendations. Food: The food is always good! 3 years I have been going here and everything was delicious. PENNE ALA VODKA with SHRIMP: it is probably my favorite! The pasta is cooked al dente and the sauce was just delicious! They topped it with grilled shrimp and it was the perfect addition to the sauce! MARGHERITA PIZZA: best type of pizza here for me! The crust is crispy and cooked properly. The sauce and mozzarella is delicious. 1 slice and I'm already full. SPAGHETTI with MEATBALLS: very authentic! The meatballs is juicy and flavorful inside. The sauce is af course tomato base and tangy. The pasta again is cooked al dente! Price rating: 6/10. To be honest the price is not bad for authentic Italian food. I will definitely come back here to try other food! read more

See all

Their food is ok I mean nothing special definitely can find better pizza in Brooklyn. Price wise 2 regular slice and a can coke $10. It's Coney Island whatever in the colder/ cooler months they are cheaper I think. I guess that's the only way they can survive in Coney Island price goes up in the warmer months and cheaper in the colder months. I am local in the neighborhood I get pizza here when I don't want to cook. Do I really sit and have pizza? No since my house is close by. However it will be LAST TIME EVER coming to this establishment. Today 5/17 Brooklyn half marathon since I have something to do on surf Ave. and I had some time to eat before I go run my errands. I decided to go get pizza and sit down since it was a warm day. No seats were available so there's a few bar tables no chairs tho. But whatever I stood there ate few bites I saw an empty table walked and sat down. I was just going to eat and get going. If I didn't have plantar fasciitis (permanent heel pain) I wouldn't mind standing and eat. The bus boy manager, I believe or whatever he is cause this is a self serve establishment, like fast food restaurant . Did a waiter served me ? "NO" did a hostess bring me to my table with a menu "NO" this SURF CITY employee came to me and said this table is reserved can you sit somewhere else? I am like where am I sitting ? He points at the bar. I got up and walked to the bar with my pizza and soda . I asked him since when pizzeria have reserved table ? He goes with his lecturing tone of voice this is a restaurant and u are one person that's a 10 people table am I going to lose 10 customers cause of one customer. I was literally in shock how he spoke to me. I am not at a fancy 5 star restaurant I don't expect no superior service. In other words I was kicked out of my seat cause I was by myself, a minority female or cause I am not the ideal privilege group in their case is their annual tourists or marathon runners, orrr this establishment need to train their worker. The next time I go to a pizzeria I will ask if the bigger tables are RESERVED for bigger groups only and there are no smaller tables available. There were no big party waiting for a big table, If party of 9 came to ask if any body was sitting on the table that I was I would have gladly let the other party sit there. Still in shock this establishment allows their employee speak to customer like this. Lost a customer I will make sure my friends and family know about this. Their food is ok there's plenty of better pizzerias in the area that have way better pizza, but for that treatment no thanx i can't even say customer service was bad cause wtf it's f*+*cking self service, a fast food joint. MANAGEMENT PLEASE don't leave a reply saying we are sorry it happened and I should give your pizzeria another try. Other customers saw what happened so did the manager/owner. One star for the manager/owner who tried to convince me not to be mad and gave me a beer I wasn't there for beer tho, I was there to eat my pizza drink my soda minding my own business and be out. Probably woulda took me 20 mins to eat the pizza drink my soda and be out. The picture of the table in the back I was sitting at, when I left still no one sitting there I guess their reserved party still didn't arrive yet read more

Surf City - The table at the end is where I was sitting, no one is sitting there when I was walking out. Reserved? - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Super cute pizza place that matches the whole Coney Island vibe! Pizza was great! Service was friendly and helpful! read more

Surf City - Bar area - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

i always have such a great experience here! Their pizza is absolutely delicious! amazing entrees and their wraps are my favorite!! The staff was friendly and welcoming, and our order came out quickly even though they were busy!! Been here plenty of times!! Highly recommend if you're craving really good pizza! read more

Great spot to grab a bite. The food was great. I had a buffalo chicken wrap and it rocked. The staff was very little but they made it work. ( off season) Also very spacious and very clean. I recommend stopping in. read more

I'm a local and I came here with my son after camp almost every day during summer, it was our escape from the heat. And now as the school year started - on Fridays. The food is great! Pizza is delicious so is the caesar salad with grilled chicken or grilled shrimp- both delicious and the dressing is tasty and fresh. The ambiance is hip without trying too hard - cool vibe, great music, cozy atmosphere. The service is always great. Sometimes I get a glass of prosecco which is always nice:) read more

They no longer have the ice cold beer. Came twice specifically for it, yesterday and about 6 months ago. Both times they indicated that they don't have it. The ice cold beer is definitely the draw, without it, it's just another NYC style pizza place. read more

See all

Not a bad spot for pizza and Italian eats in Coney Island. Located on Surf Ave across the street from the boardwalk it's an alternative to grabbing a slice at one of the many small food joints here. A little pricey but it's a full restaurant experience with a nice setting as compared to walking around with a slice on a paper plate. read more

See all

We were on the way to the aquarium, but were starving after arriving from JFK. This place was great in a pinch for grabbing some quick grub, as they had several pizzas on hand. A quick reheat and late lunch was served. About $5 a slice but the pizza was delicious. read more

Food here is just okay. It is very easy to get to as it is just off the West 8th St/New York Aquarium station on the F/Q lines. You could also walk the extra 5 minutes from Coney Island/Stillwell Ave station on the above lines, as well as the D/N lines. They sell pizza here, and the pizza is solidly okay. The slice has a nice marriage of cheese and sauce, but it could use to be cooked a little longer. It is a floppy slice and the crust is a bit too chewy for my liking. I also got a potato and egg hero. This was pretty filling! They basically use eggs and French fries and combine the two of them to form a delicious sandwich. It is a big sandwich and contains a lot of both potatoes and eggs. I was surprised at how big it is. For that nice summer evening after a day at the beach, if you want a change from Nathan's, this will work nicely. Especially if you do not like hot dogs. Just keep it in perspective, and you will end up satisfied. read more

Surf City - he front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Food came out in no time, the issue for me was the delay in getting my check.. I had to ask for it several times and then when I finally got it, it was someone else's check and my ride was already waiting. This is a convenient location for a quick meal, I'd rate the food a 7, but it was perfect coming from the aquarium, less than 5 minute walk. read more

Surf City - Fries and tenders - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Great Pizzeria located in the picturesque Coney Island area right across the street from the infamous Cyclone. It offers a vast selection of all kinds of very appetizing looking pizzas, calzone, stromboli, rolls plus many of traditional Italian dishes. Interesting ambiance, very courteous and friendly staff, young bartender was kind enough to show me all sorts of exotic beers and spirits they have in stock and advised a great one-"Fat Tire" which I never had before but enjoyed tremendously and it was a perfect compliment to the slice of the magnificent Margherita pizza I picked also following an advice of a very pleasant pizza maker plus traditional Italian chicken & cheese roll which was huge and was served with a side dish of the delectable house made marinara sauce. Pizza was delicious-flavorful, scrumptious with an amazing crunchy but soft crust and lots of yummy cheese, so was the chicken roll which was so enormous, I wasn't able to eat it all and took the 2nd half home. All in all-great dining experience, definitely recommend to everyone visiting Luna Park and Coney Island beach to drop by for a refreshing drink and a hearty meal. P. S. They have this intriguingly looking machine with an ancient fortune teller-Zaltar that reminded me of an old movie with Tom Hanks "Big" where similar machine changed young boy's life forever so I couldn't resist and paid Zaltar for the reading, hoping it will change my life too. https://youtu.be/Q6RK4479XD8 read more

See all

Before seeing a concert at Ford Amphitheater, my husband and I had grabbed dinner at Surf City Pizzeria, which was within walking distance of the venue. Meal was good. We ordered a Margherita Pizza, a Veggie Lovers Pizza, and a Greek Salad to share. I remember having a $5 beer. We were seated at a window table. A classic vibe inside and the people working there were nice. I would come back again if visiting Coney Island. read more

I didn't like their pizza. The mushroom & Margherita both have basil, which I don't like. The pizza itself wasn't flavorful enough. read more

Surf City - Mushroom & Margherita - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Garlic Knots had no flavor, very very bland. Same with regular pizza. Place looked nice on the inside.

On the opposite side of the street from the cyclone we were warmly welcomed by an employee. We ordered a pie and they accommodated my daughter with a grilled chicken request. The Pizza was perfect as was the chicken. 100% will return. Ask for Johnny B read more

Surf City - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Ordered from my favorite again and as usual I get some of a lot of yummy things. To my amazing surprise they have improved their recipes and everything was even more delicious than the last time I ordered. I'm speechless honestly. Lasagna insanely good, meatballs bomb, Stromboli freaking delicious, special ham calzone definitely different than before but I loved, margarita slice's delicious, and always get extra sauce cups. Sauce is addictive. I'm extremely satisfied so is the rest of my family we were all full and delighted. My favorite spot. If you read this also my 44th birthday is coming up on July 25th I would love a coupon to use on The slice app to enjoy dinner for my birthday. read more

What can I say Brooklyn and pizza go together. There's a good choice to get that New York slice along with that classic Coney Island aesthetic read more

excellent pizza. We sampled the white pizza and Sofia Loren; both were excellent! Even so, the spaghetti was a tiny bit more bland. The pricing are fair, and the service was excellent. The restricted selection of drinks is the sole drawback. read more

I had the vodka pasta with shrimp which was really tasty. It was very surprising for this coney island place. It is a big space and not a very long wait for a lot of food. read more

I have been here a couple of times and during each visit I was impressed with the friendly service from everyone who works here! Today I tried a slice of thin crust because it was when they opened and no Sicilian slices had been put out yet. It was generously covered with cheese and had a not too thin crunchy crust. Yesterday I had a cup of very good coffee but because the restrooms are out of order, I passed on one today! Yesterday we also tried the spumoni gelato which was pretty flavorful. Maybe I'll try to swing by tomorrow for a Sicilian slice that other Yelpers have written is well made here 9/15: tried a slice of Sicilian - as other Yelpers have remarked, excellent crust! read more

Surf City - Nice place. Good pizza. Friendly service! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Visited the aquarium and decided on pizza on our way out. Coney Island is literally a ghost town in January so we literally had the restaurant to ourselves. We ordered garlic knots, and slices. I also ordered a cappuccino to help warm up. The manager was super nice, restaurant was clean and due to inactivity in the area we had an easy time locating parking. Overall we had a pleasant experience, we enjoyed our pizza, and would definitely return. read more

See all

I ate the PERFECT SLICE OF PIZZA! Super thin crust just the way I like it. The right amount of cheese. The flavorful toppings. CRUNCH, CRUNCH, CRUNCH! I loved it so much that I wanted a second slice! It definitely hit the spot on a hot and sunny Sunday afternoon! My family and I were hungry and wanted lunch nearby. Without having any particular place in mind, we chose the nearest, local, corner spot and so glad we did! Everything was on point. I noticed the table next to ours ordered pasta pasta and it looked so good! Italian food must be their specialty. Their kitchen looked very clean and modern as well. Inside is very rustic style. I felt very comfortable sitting there enjoying the delicious food, cool AC, and hit background music. There is also TV on silent mode. I didn't really want to move after consuming the most amazing slice of pizza!!! The staff is also very friendly and nice. They took our plates away soon after we finished eating. I agree with fellow Yelper, Toni P, that this random dine-in turned out extremely well!!!!! This might be my go-to spot whenever I am around the Coney Island neighborhood hehe Too bad I didn't get to try their gelato and specialty coffee. Another reason to come back!!! *wink* read more

Surf City - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

No indication of how to seat your party or how to order. Staff ignore you as you wander the lobby looking for instruction. When I asked a staff member what the process was, he told me to pick a place to sit. We had to ask a staff memeber to take our order after passing us many times over. 25 minutes for our server to bring us our canned pepsi and straws. 1. Lady with 4 kids has to ask staff to clean table 2. Couple waiting for cheque attempts to get staff attention and just give up and go to counter to ask to pay for meal 3. Group after group of patrons come to entrance and just wait while staff ignore hungry people seeking food 4. My kid says Mc Donalds would have been a better choice Pizza arrived and tasted pretty good. I noticed our waiter was bussing tables at the same time. Food was good but I think staff level probably contributed to the level of service that could be provided. read more

See all

It has a decent selection of typical Italian fan fare but the service was really slow and confusing as they had separate take out lines and unclear front staff. Also random street people would roam around the outdoor dining area read more

The chef was so nice made our pasta so delicious the flavor was incredible so recommended

One star only because the pizza was okay! But I felt extremely discriminated against and I never do. I came in with my wife and two kids sat down, and no one came okay so my wife goes orders sits mind you we are Hispanic. Shortly after the same waitress that was just standing there and appeared to be Russian greeted the Russian customers who came in took their food order brought them their sodas and food! How dare this place do that. You are in BROOKLYN NY home of minority's yo I guys are immigrant who migrated here. I'm the 8 generation of born citizens from Brooklyn. This will not became the new norm.!!! read more

Surf City - This is the girl who just stood there ignored us and when Russians came in greeted and served them Surf City Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

the absolute best pizza in NYC. service is also outstanding . nearly 2 hour drive for us to get here from LI, but the pizza was worth it!

The best pizza in Coney Island BY FAR. The people working there are friendly & VERY ACCOMMODATING. Sicilian, round, grandma pie...we've had them all, and all delicious. I've eaten in & taken out and have been happy with both...really really good grandma pie read more

Went there with my family two days in a row. They were visiting from Oregon. First night the pizza was delicious. The second night we ordered different Italian antrees like shrimp and chicken parmesan, fetucinni Alfredo. Everything was delicious. Plan to make it my regular place for pizza and Italian food. read more

Desperate for a place to eat after traveling all day and ending up at Coney Island and this place was the only thing open as the rest of the island was closed for the season. The interior is quaint and the service is friendly. For a restaurant run by non-Italians, we were surprised by how taste their pizza and calzones were. The only downside was that the pizza and calzone were very salty, and I usually have a high salt tolerance. Otherwise, the pizza and calzone were plenty flavorful. The pizzas are thinner than what we're used to (not sure if this is NY style?). They do not skimp out on toppings either at this restaurant. Every inch of the pizza is full of toppings. The calzones were quite literally stuffed to the brim with toppings and even tho my fiance and I thought we didn't order enough, we were plenty full with our meal. Had we come during a different season, we may not have stumbled upon this place, but we don't regret doing so. read more

Very good and fresh food, nice service. Only downside is that it's a bit too pricey for a pizza place.