We took a party of 8 and order ton of apps from both Next Door and Yiasou. It was awesome. Their Marinara is great. Order the flat breads if you go there. The service is phenomenal too. I Recommend to anyone. read more

Next Door - Flatbread, baked clams, salads. Calamari frito - Italian Near Me - Sheepshead Bay, New York

Love this place! Always good service and fresh and perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection! You can order from both restaurants.

We went to a rooftop lounge for a birthday party of our friend. In a beginning everything was ok, but with the time passing by the service became worse and worse. At the end we waited for almost an hour to order a dessert, but even after we notified a busboy, the waiter didn't show up. We decided to pay and it took us another 25 minutes for the staff to process a payment. This is not a cheap place plus they include 20% tip in the bill. For that kind of service didn't deserve even 10%. It's not that I couldn't afford this place, but I would spend my money much better in many other places. Besides that the DJ plays music which is outdated, probably 30-40 years old and he play same song multiple times which is annoying. I would love to come back but probably never will. To be fair, I was at that restaurant before on a main level and it was Ok. I do not recommend a rooftop! read more

My husband and I go here at least twice a week, food is always on point, service is always phenomenal and just a great vibe! Totally love it and recommend! read more

Always the best time at Next Door. The food is amazing and the service is top notch! The pizza is to die for and so are all the drinks. 10/10 would recommend read more

What an incredible restaurant. Attentive and personable staff, great craft cocktails, and sumptuous food. it's the #GoTo in Sheepshead Bay. Fun and diverse guests on Emmons Ave. Walk along the bay and take in the beauty of what South Brooklyn offers. George, the owner is always welcoming, is passionate about creating a great experience and remembers who his guests are.Sit at the bar for dinner with friends. Great value and by far the best secret kn the bay. read more

Honestly ... one of the best restaurants on Emmons Avenue and seriously has to be mentioned among some of the best in the Sheepshead Bay area. Yes, I REALLY MEANT THAT. For the longest time I ignored Next Door because, well, no one thinks of Emmons Avenue as an Italian food haven. Typically, if you wanted good pizza, you could just go to Del Mar, V&S or the hundred other pizzerias in Brooklyn. If you wanted a good sit-down Italian meal you would visit restaurants like Anthony's Place, Joe's of Avenue U and Michael's of Brooklyn, which are further inland. And if you wanted good seafood, Randazzo's was right there. Next Door just seemed to be lost amongst a new wave of restaurants that opened in the area post-Sandy, but DO NOT overlook it like I did. My wife and I visited on Christmas Eve for our annual "just the two of us" Christmas dinner. It was pretty quiet at the restaurant, but there was a large party and a few other 2 person tables occupied. First thing's first, we loved how modern the restaurant was for the area. It was definitely different from the old school establishments that had been there for many years. Everything was very neat and clean, yet it also very casual inside. The Christmas decorations were simple and perfect. We knew the restaurant was known for their pizza, so that was a given that we were going to order it. In fact, a large portion of their menu was dedicated to just pizza. In addition to the pizza, the restaurant served some appetizers, salads, small/first course entrees, as well as some larger and more expensive second course entrees. To be honest, I didn't have much expectations when we came here, but we were shocked at how good just about everything was. GRILLED OCTOPUS - The octopus was served as small bite-size pieces and was excellent. We loved how light it was, yet very flavorful. We've been to quite a few seafood restaurants and, I can't believe I'm going to say this, but it was one of the best grilled octopus dishes I ever had. Like mos things that are good, we wanted more! RISOTTO PORCINI - Risotto with porcini mushrooms - I had my doubts after ordering this, but it was quite delicious. Risotto is really a hit or miss dish at a lot of restaurants and it's so dependent on the texture. Some restaurants make it too creamy and some restaurants make it too watery, but props to Next Door because they got it just about right. My wife thought it could have used a bit more flavor, but I felt it was almost perfect. It was one of the better risotto dishes I have had in a while. FUNGHI e TARTUFO PIZZA - Shiitake mushroom, caciocarvallo, fontina and truffle oil - This was the ABSOLUTE highlight of our meal and now that I had a few days to let it sink in, it is still one of the best pizzas I ever had. I know it's a bold statement, but we've been to some of the best pizzerias in America (Roberta's, DiFara, Paulie Gee's, Frank Pepe) and this was shockingly right up there with what we consider to be the best. If this pizza was served at a famous pizzeria, it would be getting so much attention because it was everything you'd want in a pizza - very thin crust, just the right amount of oil, plenty of shiitake mushrooms and, the ingredient that molds it all together, that ever-so addictive truffle oil. The truffle oil scent was so sharp and pungent it got us at hello. It was as perfect of a mushroom pizza that our taste buds ever enjoyed. NUTELLA PIZZA - Lastly, for dessert, we decided to indulge a little .. or a lot in the Nutella pizza, with strawberries and bananas on top. The pizza was solid, but we did have a few gripes. First, the pizza, wasn't really a pizza, but more of a doughy flatbread. We assumed they couldn't use pizza dough to hold it all together, but we would have preferred it as a base. To call it a pizza because it was shaped like one was an absolute sin. Second, where was the banana and strawberries? Yes, they added slices of bananas and strawberries, but they were cut so thin and small and were far and few in between. Bottom line, we would have preferred that they didn't skimp on the toppings. Our waiter throughout the evening was friendly, but he did forget to bring us a water refill. The restaurant was also pretty quiet, even though there was a large party celebrating. I'll be the first to tell you that I underestimated how good Next Door was and their food taught me a lesson. In fact, the Funghi e Tartufo is dare I say, pilgramage worthy! Everything we ordered was good, but the Funghi e Tartufo was literally to die for. read more

See all

Excellent food and atmosphere! I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of pizza, a great selection of seafood and wines, awesome service and beautiful views! read more

See all

The experience was very disappointing. The ambiance and interior of this Italian restaurant in Sheepshead Bay were very nice. They had a lot of lights and a Christmas tree, along with candles for every table. But everything else was sorely disappointing. The wait staff ignored my table very often, even when we tried to get their attention. They rarely ever refilled our waters, which left my table and I very parched and thirsty by the end of the night. The margherita pizza was decent, and the filet fish had A LOT of bones in it. I had to spit out my fish every 2 seconds because there were a lot of bones. I know fish has bones, but I am not sure that this specific dish was supposed to come with any. Since all the wait staff cared about was talking amongst each other, it took us a VERY long time to get the bill. Overall, I would definitely not come back. read more

Next Door - margherita pizza - Italian Near Me - Sheepshead Bay, New York

See all

Amazing restaurant in sheepshead bay the best Italian food in Brooklyn! Owners are super friendly and amazing especially George! and staff very professional and helpful! Oysters, truffle Pizza, octopus, fish, dips and all the pastas, wine... oh dear! Strongly recommend!! read more

Next door is one of those restaurants I wanted to try on Emmons. Next door has excellent food and service. Me and my wife tried the margarita pizza and mushroom and onion pizza, with fried calamari. I felt the calamari could of been better cooked. The pizza is why you should come to this place . Fresh brick oven pizza at a reasonable price. The drinks are pricey but not too strong. I recommend this place if you want to taste great brick oven pizza. I will come back to taste More Italian cuisine. read more

See all

I really love the Hawaiian pizza here, especially the thin crust. I got linguine and clams, it was pretty good. Pasta was al dente, flavor was good. However my friend ordered chicken Parm, and when it came with a side of mashed potatoes. Obviously we were both confused, Who serves chicken Parm with potatoes? I had seen a picture on Yelp in the past with pasta. So We questioned the waitress and she said they had changed it from pasta to potatoes a few months ago. How would we have known that? Perhaps you could've mentioned that when we place the order. Needless to say my friend was not satisfied with her meal, so I asked the waitress to replace the potatoes with pasta. Thankfully she said that she would check with the manager, and then came back with pasta. read more

See all

Fake Italian food with High prices. Always walked by and it was empty. We walked by Friday night and it was crowded. So we decided to go in. We ordered Chicken Parmasean and Salmon. Chicken was good with huge portion. It came with awful mashed potatoes. So that's a minus. My lady friend ordered Salmon which was very salty. The place is small and doesn't hold noise well. Due to two private parties. The small restaurant's noise level was unbearable. It was so bad were going to walk out. But the parties eventually left Prices are very high. Our bill was $100 with two glasses of wine. We won't be coming back here. Our best recommendations are for you to stay away. read more

This spot is great , Definitely will be stop again great service and meals are delicious. Thank you guys

Ridiculously expensive... Total rip off $80 for a rib eye, $13 for brussel sprouts, $11 for french fries.. SERIOUSLY?? I COULD GO TO MANHATTAN AND PAY LESS.. Sad how this neighborhood is being ruined. read more

I live in Manhattan, I always go all way down to this amazing restaurant just because of the fresh food and service. Next Door and Yiasou (same owners, next to each other) are the best Mediterranean restaurant in South Brooklyn. Amazing food and service. I highly recommend any seafood, you can't go wrong. Always fresh and delicious. It's always busy so try get reservation in advance. read more

Next Door - Branzino, Oysters, Octopus & Seafood Pasta - Italian Near Me - Sheepshead Bay, New York

So... I have been going to Yiasou (next door to Next Door... ;) ) for the past 13 years. I finally made it to Next Door... got the truffle pizza, beef carpaccio and tuna tartar - Emmons Avenue is BACK!!!! great food, check ... good scene, check ... was delicious and had a great time! P.S. the specialty pastas are a must P.P.S. the Nutella pizza for dessert read more

Next Door - Italian Near Me - Sheepshead Bay, New York

See all

Absolutely amazing! Food is delicious! You have to try the truffle pizza, beets, cheese, calamari and octopus. read more

Next Door - Italian Near Me - Sheepshead Bay, New York

Used to love this place but the food is not the same. They had a special for black truffle pasta $30, i was expecting to taste and smell truffle and see the shavings on top but no, that was not the case. I got mediocre noodles with a few pieces of shitake on top and watery olive oil on the base of the plate. Prices went up and the food quality went down.. read more

So the food was amazing! Not a big eater and I got the Greek salad , and regular pizza for kids. Which was also very yummy. The service was horrible, I'm not saying all waiters are; but I got one angry WAITER!!! He gave me the dirty look, then he wouldn't come up to my table for more then 35 minutes after I was done eating. By the way I came there with two small kids. After 35 minutes of sitting with finished food and dirty plates I was waiting to order something else, but he didn't come up he disappeared somewhere so I came up to the bar and I think it was the manager, I said my waiter hasn't come up to me in a long time I wanted to order some more things, he apologized and said he'll talk to him. After 5 minutes he said he talked to him and that he is having a bad day, and he was thankful for bringing it up to his attention. I felt uncomfortable and wanted to leave kinda fast because of being treated like that. So other waiters were more normal I saw there were other guys there. But I guess I got the angry one that night read more

Dined here a week ago and still thinking about all the delicious food me and my friends enjoyed. We tried so many dishes from the versatile menu and each one was packed with flavour. My personal favourites were : * grilled octopus * branzino * Truffle pizza * Nutella pizza Was wonderful to dine outside and enjoy the view of the Bay. Service was great and efficient. Truly worth the drive, looking forward to be back again. read more

Next Door - Italian Near Me - Sheepshead Bay, New York

So disappointed in this place, never coming back again. Me and my friend decided to get lunch on sunday, the service was disgusting and everyone starting from the girl in the front to the valley were so rude!!! The server was ignoring us the whole time, he basically threw our plates to the table and left. I had to ask another server to get a check and waited to pay for over 20 min. Nobody came to check on us or refill our glasses with water once! So gross and unprofessional, this place literally went down to hole. read more

The ambiance is classic and the food is good, but the service leaves much to be desired. The waiter came by twice to ask if we're ready to order and we just weren't yet, but then it took at least five minutes before we could wave him down. Then, once we finished our lunch, we waited for a good 10 minutes to get our check and then had to wave another waiter down to bring our credit cards back. Mind you, all of this is happening when there are only 5 tables occupied. As if this one waiter was the only one available to service all the tabled. There was at least one other one. Also, I found it very unprofessional that the kitchen staff was bringing the orders to the table. Does the quality of the food make up for it, not a chance because the quality is far from from what they believe the price is worth for it. read more

Next Door is our Family's favorite restaurant. This is our go-to spot whether we are dining with the kids or just a quiet date night. It's perfect for a casual dinner, birthday celebration, girls night out or just a quick meal at the end of a long day. Either way- it's perfect. The Owner and staff are always welcoming, warm and friendly. We are always greeted like we are family. The atmosphere and decor is cool, modern and tasteful decorated to the nines with no expense spared. More importantly, it is perfectly clean and well maintained. But the best part is the food. Next door has the absolute best pizza on the planet. It's thin crust, fresh cheese and crunchy dough is to die for. It's a cheat I never feel guilty with. The fish is always fresh and prepared to perfection. The salads are unique, creative and delicious. And the desert!!!! That Nutella Pizza!!! It's incredible!! The desert options are perfect to suit everyone's taste. It's the only restaurant where I can never skip desert- IT'S JUST TOO GOOD TO PASS UP!! Next Door is actually right next door to Yiasou Greek Restaurant, which belongs to the owner's parents. If you don't find us at next door- it's a safe bet that we are visiting mom and dad for some delicious Spanakopita and Humus. Or sometimes we go really wild and order from both spots and smear that humus on our pizza. You just can't go wrong. Our family has been loyal patrons from day one will continue to be #1 fans for years to come. read more

See all

I love this place! The ambiance, the decor, the food & the service are all top notch! Coming here in the summer is great too because you can sit outdoors :) They allow BYOB but have a cork fee of $15.. not bad at all.. although they have a fully stocked bar & the drinks are delicious! My go to yummies are - the diablo pizza (Any of the pizzas are really good but that one is my fav!) the fried calamari, tuna tartare, the SALMON BURGER always cooked to perfection (I love to add mushrooms!!) and dessert is obvs the best part of the meal & they have the yummiest Nutella pizza!! Also, the s'mores dish is unreal but HUGE! so there's enough to share. Always recommend this place. A lot of my friends have had their birthdays, baby showers & bridal parties here because they have a private room upstairs. read more

See all

Everything here was AMAZING. We had the greek salad, beet salad, mezze plate, octopus, branzino, and Nutella pizza.... everything was cooked to perfection and so nicely done. Such a cute restaurant with great ambiance and staff. I cannot wait to come back! read more

Next Door - Nutella pizza - Italian Near Me - Sheepshead Bay, New York

Next Door, what can I say - I don't think that you'll stay in business for too long. I feel bad for you, Next Door, because your rent must be expensive and you have to compete with about a dozen of other restaurants located on just a two-block stretch of Emmons Avenue. I understand that you absolutely must keep looking for creative solutions to increase your profit margin to pay your rent, to keep your staff, and to support your owners, but me and my friends are not going to support you and here is why: 1. We felt cheated when our $25 cheese and meet board arrived and we discovered a $1.99 per pound bologna - the one you would make sure not to buy in the Russian store even if you are in a mood for unhealthy Russian kielbasa ( pic is included) 2. How could you possibly mess up Brussels sprouts, Next Door? It should not be boiled- you should either fry or bake it (preferably the later) and you don't need a Michelin chef on staff to pull it off. 3. You should do some research and invest into coffee - the beans you are currently using left a burning sensation in my friend's mouth as a last impression of her unforgettable dining experience with you. Sorry we left early and decided to skip the entry. We heard from other Yelp reviewers that your pizza is great, but we don't eat pizzas and it was too risky to experiment with your branzino. So we paid (after returning our unfinished food) before heading to another place almost next door to you as we were determined to have a good time despite everything. I still gave you a second star, Next Door, because the people who work for you are nice. adios, Next Door - we are not coming back and making sure nobody else we know does read more

Next Door - Italian Near Me - Sheepshead Bay, New York

Lovely, European style outdoor dining with a view of the Bay. After spending a day on the beach decided to stop for dinner before heading home and wow just wow. Atmosphere, service and food all five star. Fresh whole black bass, shrimp cocktail, oysters, calamari, lemon potatoes and the house cheesecake were better than any city restaurant and obviously made with love! Will be spending many summer nights dining at Next Door! read more

Next Door - Italian Near Me - Sheepshead Bay, New York

To start from the beginning I did recommend this place to my friend a while ago, so today it was the nite that we finally decided to go. After running on the rain directly to this place, we finally arrived. It was an empty restaurant with maybe two tables, we had to spend like 5 mins on the door b4 waitress finally came to get us. We set on the table, another 20 mins - no water, no bread and no server at all to ask us if we need anything. What would we want, lol, right? Might just came to stare at the walls lol. Finally after waitress came we were soooo ready for a dinner with what I asked for the glass of red wine. Meanwhile I live in this neighborhood, and I'm over 30 years old. The girl is asking me for my id, if I'm age appropriate to drink alcohol. I thought I misheard her for a moment, Bc you know I don't look under 21 at all. After asking why does she need to verify my age she was saying that it's a law that each and every customer customer has to provide Id, lmao can you just imagine if it's each and every- she has to ask even a men that are over 60, right? After me realizing that I'm not gonna get an answer WHY she needs my Id except of - it's a law, hell knows which one I asked for the manager hoping she will give some clarity and provide us certain level of hospitality. I'll repeat, I've never were asked for my ID IN THE RESTAURANT OF MY NEIGHBORHOOD on sheepshead bay. After the manager came, that was epic Bc this woman was aggressively telling me that I have to show her Id for a glass of wine. That was just way too much for a moment, I simply didn't wanna stay there no more, Bc no one cared to smoth the conflict at all, but instead was giving attitude and attacking with that law that no one knows about. It's just dumb, so dumb, I'm not surprised now why this place is empty. Walked out with such a frustration, don't think will ever go back there. read more

Just had a Valentine's dinner with them. For starters, this place is WAYYYY TOO OVERPRICED. $17 for a burrata when it's the size of a ping pong ball? Then they added some bologna to it to make it look fancy, some stupid waste of meat for that one. I ordered the salmon tartare....word of advice, if you're making a salmon tartare, don't add so much soy sauce to the point of where half of the tartare is EXTREMELY SALTY. Also ordered the Lobster Ravioli, 5 pieces of ravioli???? At least make it even and have 6 to split with. Funghi pizza was good. Service was very good. My view is this: you guys need a new chef, you need to lower your prices, or just shut down. Unfortunately this is not a place I will be coming back to, no wonder it's always empty every time I pass by it. read more

Consistently fresh and high quality, vibrant dishes. Great team and ambience for families and parties alike

Nothing to write home about. You're paying for the location, not exceptional food or service. We had a larger party and weren't checked in on or asked how our food was even once. The food was subpar -- we got the caesar salad, calamari, salmon burger, fettuccine alfredo, rib eye, whole branzino, linguine with clams, and another pasta & meat entree. Everything was either too salty or completely under seasoned. The best thing we had in my opinion was the caesar salad -- but it was just as good as the one you'd get at a nice local pizzeria. Wasn't a bad evening but don't think we'll be returning. read more

Took my lady here for dinner and was 1000% satisfied with the food,vibe and service. Had the lobster ravioli,asparagus & mash with mussels for app.but these weren't no ordinary mussels -they were the size of a toddlers foot, they give you like 12 of those woooo jesus christmas Then finished it off with a Margherita pizza topped with olive oil basil and my personal preference "Parmesan cheese" read more

Next Door - Italian Near Me - Sheepshead Bay, New York

See all

Finger-licking good! Next Door is a my favorite Brooklyn Italian Restaurant! I'm not saying it's the best but it's the best. Wild and imaginative pizzas that will have you salivating! Every time I'm here, I try something new. Ask for specials and you won't be disappointed... I have a private event scheduled at the end of August so will post pics. Okay, I'm officially hungry and heading over. read more

See all

Pizza was OK. There are definitely better wood fired pizza options in Brooklyn (Lea on Cortelyou Rd/Wheated on Church Ave, Robertas). Also had the Tuna Tartare which was excellent. The atmosphere of the place and attentiveness of the waitstaff I would rate 5 stars. Overall it was good just didn't leave there feeling 100% satisfied. 1 pizza, tuna tartare, 2 drinks came to $75 before tip. Posting a pic of the menu because there doesn't seem to be one anywhere on the internet. read more

Next Door - Menu in March 2016 - Italian Near Me - Sheepshead Bay, New York

Tonight was my second time at Next Door and both times were excellent. Perfect if you're looking for a cute trendy atmosphere without going too far from home. I highly recommend getting the mushroom & truffle pizza, lobster ravioli, & Nutella pizza for dessert. read more

Next Door - Nutella pizza YUM - Italian Near Me - Sheepshead Bay, New York

What a wonderful dining experience! Was here to celebrate my father's birthday. Loved the decor - a simple modern look - and the food was fabulous. From the yummy, soft long rolls to the flavorful chicken parmigiana and combo sausage plate to the absolutely scrumptious profiteroles drenched in chocolate sauce and cheesecake, we enjoyed a simply delectable birthday meal. Great location, too - right on the "strip" on Emmons Avenue in picturesque Sheepshead Bay. Lastly, we had the pleasure of meeting the owner, George; he simply couldn't have been nicer to us. He was so welcoming - and even joined us in singing "Happy Birthday" to my appreciative dad. So if you're looking for a fun night out with great service and excellent food, come (to) Next Door!!! read more

See all

Dined here last night part of a party of 14. The service was excellent the staff was attentive and catered to our every need. Usually service lacks in most places when trying to serve 14 people but not at Next Door. The good was excellent as well. We had all the appetizers and they were great. The burrata and beef carpaccio was excellent. I loved the truffle pizza and the Margarita. For main I had the bronzino and it was cooked to perfection the sauce it was in was light and complimented the fish well. For dessert I really enjoyed the Nutella pizza. The atmosphere was pleasant and the ambience was very trendy. Next Door is a gem in the south brooklyn area. Overall I give this place 5 stars everything I had was very tasty and I surely will return. read more

Next Door - To die for! - Italian Near Me - Sheepshead Bay, New York

One of my favorite places on the bay !! Always always always Fresh & delicious!!! Straight Hit never a miss with their Unique custom cocktails.. highly recommend if in the neighborhood, super cute for a party or even a date night read more

The best meal I ate in Brooklyn. Great fresh fish with an amazing menu and their tuna tartare and the octopus are a must. Staff are courteous and helpful and happy to give advice on their dishes. I absolutely love this place. read more

Next Door - Italian Near Me - Sheepshead Bay, New York