Have been going to the restaurant since the early 1990's. Have always gotten the same meal. Baked clams, 1/2 order of linguini with lobster sauce, shrimp stuffed with crab meat and chocolate mousse pie for dessert. Last few times they were not able to accomodate the linguini with lobster sauce because it is now a special item on certain days. Went last Saturday for our anniversary and a few more things have changed since the last time. The long time waiters Jerry and Giancarlo are no longer there. We had an Indian waiter with a heavy accent that was hard to understand. No specials were offered and the vibe was different. I think I expect an Italian waiter at an Italian restaurant the same as I expect a Chinese waiter at a Chinese restaurant. I was told the linguini with lobster was not available but I could order a lobster and have sauce on top. I settled on the veal chop and it had no garnish or sauce on it. And the third issue was they no longer had chocolate mousse pie but they had a chocolate mousse cake. Totally different from my go to. We decided to share Italian cheese cake and it was dissapointing. Was not traditional Italian ricotta cheesecake. Was made of cream cheese and was on the dry side. Over all the food was ok, the dessert wasn't, the service was attentive but the vibe was off. End result is after 30 years of eating here a few times a year I think this will be our last time. read more

This restaurant is very good. I grew up in Brooklyn and I had never gone here before, but I will say the food is very good. The people are very nice as well. One of the owners walked by and had a conversation with us. I will definitely return for another meal when I visit New York. read more

See all

Food was good but overpriced excellent service and cocktails nice romantic decor. Parking nice almost 200 bucks for dinner no dessert. read more

We went for my birthday lunch. There were 8 of us. We each ordered an appetizer. I had the baked clams. We had fried zucchini and fried mozzarella and Caesar salads. The main courses were mostly filet of sole racanati! It was very fresh and a lighter food choice. Each came with potato croquettes and mixed vegetables. Service by our waiter Igli. Such a lovely man and helpful server. BTW: we won the game for a free lunch. My husband used my birthday age and that number showed up! Such a fun e patience. Thank you Gargiulo's. read more

See all

Pasta pasta. I enjoy eating a really delicious pasta. Rich in flavors Service was great. Hand down. It was very clean once I got incident read more

See all

This is a classic restaurant where you should plan to come hungry and leave feeling satisfied The owners are walking around and making sure all the guests are well attended At the end of the night they bring the check and some dice If you pick the right number dinner is on the house!! Fun....but we were 1 off Good for a laugh read more

See all

Place is a joke. Mob boss wannabees roll around in suits like it's the 1930s. Food sucks.

Nothing on website about no shorts- all properly dressed- one child with "gym" shorts and refused to seat after waiting for manager and after telling him we had been there a number of times going back years and have reserved for private parties-could have easily made an exception-never again and never recommend- heading for Marco Pollo- better food and "gym" shorts on 10 year old is OK read more

All I can say is had double order of linguine and white clam sauce and tiramisu absolutely delicious and as always the very best..... read more

Gargiulo's - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The food, service and ambiance has made this legendary restaurant our home away from home! I have been a loyal patron since 1982! Thank you Louis Russo and the entire Russo family! read more

Gargiulo's - We love the entire Russo Family!! Gargiulo's is our home away from home!! Thank you to the entire Russo family! - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

How the mighty have fallen. Went there this evening for a Mother's Day dinner. It couldn't have been worse. We had a reservation and was still made to wait twenty minutes to be seated despite available tables. We didn't see the first waiter for at least another twenty minutes. A price fixed, somewhat limited menu. Most of us had the pasta and chicken cutlet parmigiana. Came with a 'salad' and potato croquette. We had our pasta after a wait and then...nothing. We got to talking and remembered we were to receive a salad. We hoped it wouldn't come with our entree. It didn't. What we did get was some soft lettuce with olive oil drizzled on it. Pitiful. Our chicken cutlet was a patty and tasted like chicken fingers with a little mozzarella and tomato sauce to hide this fact. Not one of us was able to finish our meal. Not one! I wanted to take the included dessert to go but was voted against. We shouldn't have taken it at all. We ended up being one of the last tables to leave and were being stared down by the bus boys and other waiters. Not our waiter though. We never saw him. The ONLY reason we were among the last to go was because we were always left waiting. The valet was kept waiting as well. Our cars were the last in the lot. I had to retrieve my coat from the coat room as there wasn't an attendant. My son complained to the owner who introduced himself as Anthony. He stated he farms out the work for busy nights like Mother!s Day and that he didn't know what to do. Didn't know what to do? You're the owner, pride yourself for being in business for your be hundred years and you don't know what to do? I know what to do. We won't be back, we won't recommend the place ever again, I'll tell people about my experience, and write this negative review. Sorry for giving it one star. Zero stars wasn't an option. read more

I really enjoyed my meal at this restaurant and hope to return for my next trip to NY as I live in Las Vegas. Our waiters name was Emilio. He was very attentive and kind and took several pictures for us then I didn't catch his name one of the owners spoke to us and was also very nice and I told him we were celebrating my daughter's graduation and that I don't live here and where I live and he gave us a limoncello to celebrate which was really nice and the food was excellent. A few minutes later another one of the I believe he was an Owner also walked by and greeted us as well. I posted some photos below and I will definitely return on my next trip to New York and highly recommend this restaurant. The red sauce is really good. The eggplant rolletini was delicious and I enjoyed my pasta Fagioli soup and next time I want to try the Escarole and beans one. Also, the restaurant was decorated beautifully for the holidays. read more

See all

Love their seafood salad and the family atmosphere. This is a Brooklyn staple that has been around.

No one who knows good Italian food would eat here anymore. Twenty years ago, yes. Now, no. Food is disgusting, overpriced and of a poor quality. The setting is still lovely. The food sucks. read more

My food adventure spirit was rewarded at this spot. Employees deliver highly attentive service with personal touches. Each bite makes you want another. This place has a central position. I'm anticipating another meal here. read more

Came here to celebrate my birthday a couple of weeks ago. Service was a little odd. The waiter kind of stood over us while we looked at the menus. I asked to see the cocktail list and he asked if I wanted him to recite it for me which I guess is nice? Idk I need to read things. The food was ok. I got the pasta with artichokes and pancetta but I didn't notice any pancetta. I don't know that I'd be back honestly. It wasn't bad but there's better Italian out there read more

Gargiulo's - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Located at the bottom of Coney Island. Great food n great service. Lucky to get a reservation last minute on a summer Sunday. This place has been here a long time I remember coming here a while ago. Same Classy old fashion decor. The waiter Willie gave us a tour of the banquet hall in the back! I wish I had s as b occasion to throw a party! Chicken Scarpariello portion is huge! read more

See all

Food was disgusting!!!! Came here for an award ceremony dinner for my son's football league. The salad on the table was subpar, it looked like the olives and string beans were served out of a can. The chicken parm had absolutely no seasoning on it, it tasted like they transferred the chicken breast straight out of the freezer, to the plain unseasoned breadcrumbs and into the oven. The mozzarella cheese tasted so bad!! I wouldn't feed my dog the food that they serve, I actually reach out to one of the coaches and asked that the venue be held elsewhere! read more

A perfect meeting place when you are coming from Central Jersey and your friends are in Long Island and Brooklyn. Not much has changed here over the years, except no octopus hanging from the ceiling, and I say that in a positive way. Excellent service and the food is still all of the old school favorites. My Fish Salad (generally called elsewhere as a Seafood Salad) and my Pork Chop were excellent. Everyone else seemed to enjoy their meals too. Onsite valet parking. read more

Absolutely best service. I love this place. They gave me the wrong entry and within 3 minutes they corrected the situation and delivered. This is the most iconic restaurant in coney. read more

Food always enjoyable service wonderfully pleasant and helpful comfortable environment. Have been a frequent guest without regrets. I especially enjoy their accommodating off the menu capabilities that often include )when requested) items such as tripe and scungilli - we have never been disappointed especially with their daily specials. read more

Came here for restaurant week summer 2022. Great choice for $45 lunch (and dinner). However all 6 of us decided to go with their regular menu Beautiful room. I grew up in coney and used to eat there a lot before it was renovated Patient nice waiter (he had to deal with 6 indecisive women). Rigatoni bolognese was delicious. Great sauce Caesar salad was good I had shrimp parm. Not the biggest portion but it was sufficient. Baked clams were small but good (a bit too salty) A beautiful side (for the table) of veggies and potato croquettes. Stop to look at the black and white pics on your way to the restrooms. Free parking lot right next door to restaurant. Forget about parking on the street. There's major construction going on all around the area. read more

See all

Classic New York Italian institution. Traditional waiters who know their craft. Quick, efficient, but attentive service. Kitchen consistently turns out classic pasta dishes cooked just right and the sauce is addictive. Seafood dishes are cooked just right-not overcooked and not undercooked. Everything comes out fresh. read more

See all

I went here with my boyfriend for Valentine's Day. We had a great time and the food was great. Live music and great drinks. I got the chicken parm. read more

Great service and tasty authentic Italian food. I was there for a family celebration and they setup a nice large long rectangular table for us. A great experience, would definitely go back. read more

I made an early reservation before a baseball game trying to support a restaurant we have long gone to as a family. Upon walking in, we were ignored and then a waiter looked at my teenage kids in disgust because he said they were wearing gym shorts. I get it, these are your rules, but the way I was spoken to and waved off by a waiter was absolutely disgusting. There is a way to handle things like a gentleman. This will be the last time anyone from my family sets foot in this dying establishment. I will also make it a point to have every one of my family members and friends in Brooklyn to never spend an additional dollar in this place. read more

Good Food, service and atmosphere is excellent!!!!! Every meal I have eaten at this restaurant is outstanding ! read more

Gargiulo's - Italian cheesecake - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Came yesterday for a party, hadn't been here in a few years . Place is consistently good . Clean beautiful place with great service . Food was delicious from their signature appetizers to the linguini with white clam sauce and then a yummy chicken artichoke sundried tomato entree . Followed by coffee and dessert. read more

See all

Gargiulo's is a shell of its formal self with the clientele mostly seniors and tourist. The service was great but that's about it. Food was tasteless and lacked any flavor. The broiled salmon didn't have any seasoning as well as the Veal Marsala. If you want an old school vibe this is it but don't expect a good meal read more

Went there for a wedding old school classic what's not too like. Wish it was easier to get around CI would go there for dinner more often

Went to Gargiulo's for the first time ever last night before heading down to the boardwalk for the fireworks. A sharp-dressed fellow was manning the door and opened it with a flourish. My friend was already at the bar and had asked George (the bartender) to make me a slightly dirty martini with "fancy gin." He made me the most glorious martini with Empress (it's purple!). A woman at the next table ordered one after she saw mine! And it was only $12! The same martini in the City would easily be $18-$20. We were a party of 3 and shared a Caesar, plus each got a separate pasta half-order. Plenty of food! I got the spaghettini with garlic and oil. Huge slabs of yummy garlic and the perfect portion. Friends got the rigatoni with meat sauce and the linguini with clams. Classics, all of them. The interior is elegant and it felt like we had time-traveled with the tuxedoed waiters and the terrazzo floor. And everyone who works here is so kind and witty. read more

See all

Lower your standards, not your dress code here. Overpriced menu items for a mediocre food experience, all the while the staff is all wearing tuxedos. The confusing menu items also have no explanation of what you are about to be served. Even though the portions are generous, the taste and value of the food weakens after the first few bites. They do have a gimmick where if they pick your number out of a container then your meal is free. I was here with my mother and we did not get the free meal. Unfortunately, I can not explain how this once Coney Island institution went from having excellent food to just fair food. read more

A South BK classic. Have been here for countless events. Stopped in after a walk on the boardwalk. Fried calamari to start. Got filet of sole for entree absolutely amazing. All entrees come with mixed veg for the table family style grilled perfectly. Wait staff if friendly, there was even a game at the end if you guess a number out of a jar and pick it FREE DINNER. Consistent as always. read more

Fantastic experience for the price. We called 30 mins before on a Sunday night and they found us a spot. They have a dress code - no swimwear or too lax of a clothing. Was immediately seated. Menu is amazing. Can't go wrong with any pastas or seafood plates. We started with some shared calamari and independent entrees. Vegetarian friendly plates available. For the amount of food, we'll worth the trip. Highly recommend read more

Gargiulo's - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We were looking for a small function room for a birthday party in Brooklyn, and came upon Gargiulo's, a throwback to a different era, decorated in dark woods and staffed by tuxedo clad waiters. According to their website, Gargiulo's Restaurant was established in 1907 by the Gargiulo family, and was an entertainment venue throughout the heyday of Coney Island. In April 1965, the Russo brothers acquired the restaurant, kept the name and implemented their Neopolitan hospitality and cuisine. We chose the Board Room, a small event room which holds up to 25 people. We thought the room looked great, the service was excellent, and most of the food quite good. A gourmet restaurant? Not so much. An iconic spot for a good meal, certainly. We sampled: Prosciutto, Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers $14.50 Shrimp Cocktail $14.00 Fried Zucchini $10.00 Tre Colore Salad (Arugula, Endive & Radicchio) $10.50 Caesar Salad $11.00 And many entrees. Most of what we sampled was quite good, the Zucchini was tasty but a little soggy. And the Shrimp Cocktail was good, though the shrimp were a little on the shrimpy size! Our party of 15 had a great time, and would be happy to return. Note that they do offer valet parking. read more

See all

Old school is the game here. I was waiting on line to go to a Cyclones game with my cousin and we both said how we never at here despite it being legendary, so about half way through the game (Seinfeld night) we gave in to hunger (Cyclones park has pretty bad food) and headed over to Gariulos. It was a saturday night around 8 and we had no reservsations but were seated after a very short wait. Being an adult I wear long pants when going to eat in a nice restaurant so there was no issues with dress code which personally i think more restaurants should have. Put a damn pair of pants on people. The service was great and we were quickly given a basket of bread and bread sticks and our water glasses were frequently filled. the decor is really nice. The place is huge. For starters we split an order of baked clams and a seafood salad. The clams were quite good, lots of flavor in the bread crumbs and the clams were plump and tasty without all that excess oil that some places put it in. The seafood salad was bright and lemony and perfect for a muggy August night. For my main I had Chicken Scarpariello. Now my only qualm with the whole dinner was this dish is Chicken (usually on the bone but i went boneless) with sausage,potatoes and hot peppers in a vinegar based sauce. So the waiter asked if i wanted the sausage,potatoes and peppers i was a bit confused and just figured that maybe most of the diners were not Italian and didnt know this. Well when the bill came i saw i was upcharged for all of those things bringing my 24 dollar dish up to about 35. My cousin who had Braciola was asked if he wanted the pasta and also got upcharged. I likely wouldve added all the things anyway but to upcharge for ingredients already supposed to be in the dish in the dish I felt was a bit uncool. The dish however was delicious, spicy and vinegary and garlicky. Another cool touch is the waiter comes at the end and tells you to pick a number between 1-99 and shakes a big shaker full of numbered tiles and picks one out. If you guess right the meal is free (I did not lol) but I liked that. Overall the food was good and thats the main thing even if I wasnt crazy about the upcharges. That was only thing keeping them from the 5th star. read more

See all

Gargiulo's Pizza Garden. Delicious food, excellent service, (Vanessa) beautiful atmosphere and surroundings. Open only Thursday and Friday evenings through the Summer. read more

See all

I don't know why this restaurant is rated as high as it is because to me the food was a disservice to Italian food. Having been to Italy and experienced an "authentic" experience, the pasta, sauce, and bread service were mid. I ordered the Fettuccine Gargiulo and regretted it upon first bite. Bland, no salt, hospital chicken, ugly, and a complete disgrace to pasta. It was not homemade pasta which is what I would expect in an authentic experience. The ambiance was pleasant with complimentary drinks upon arrival in the waiting area. It got pretty busy throughout my dine. read more

This beautiful, historic restaurant feels like a step back in time but in the best way possible. The service is attentive, the decor elegant, and the food is everything you'd expect from an old school Italian restaurant in New York. I had the veal special, and it was very flavorful. We also ordered an eggplant appetizer which was good but lacking a bit on seasoning. The Caesar salads were very basic, but passable. Dessert was really nice and the presentation on the sorbets are worth the price. Cannoli was delicious! We went in for a very late lunch or early dinner and our casual attire was fine, but if we had gone later at night, I would have been more dressed up. read more

See all

We love this restaurant! We went for dinner. We ordered eggplant parm, seafood pasta & escarole with garlic & olive oil. For the seafood pasta, it was supposed to be "Risotto Pescatore", but I asked the server to make it with angel hair and it was so amazing!!! The eggplant parm was served lasagna style and my fiancé loved it! The atmosphere is great, service was amazing, food absolutely killed it! When we asked for the check, the server asked us to pick a and, after shaking a box of numbers, if it matched, we would only have to pay for drinks, the meal is on them. Unfortunately, we didn't make win. Overall, great place for a date night! We would love to go back! read more

See all