The setting is the driving force of why this business does well. It has water view with boats and the picturesque moments. Inside there is plenty of seating with cooler temp on hot days. Modern style indoors. Staff are friendly but not quite on top of it. Our drinks needed to be refilled, not the end of the world though. The margarita pizza was ok. Tons of watery sauce on a fluffy dough on a few heaps of cheese. It was just ok. I think I'd only be back for the view. read more

Stone Harbor Pizza Pub - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Stone Harbor, New Jersey

Note: this review is about the food only. The ambiance and service were a 8/10. I Went with my family and we Ordered a cheese steak, a chicken cheese steak, Caesar salad and a capris chicken salad. I had the cheese steak. It cost $17 and had about 4 ounces of terribly cooked beef with a single slice of flavorless American cheese and chunks of sauted onion. Ive been disappointed with sub par cheese steaks in the past but this one insulted my taste buds and I now have a mental scar. I grew up eating pizza and cheese steak at this place and was unaware the Reeds purchased it. This explained a lot. The Reeds food is some of the worst overpriced food I have eaten in Stone Harbor. The capris salad looked great but had no flavor and the chicken was dry, old and arrived in 2x2x2 chunks. The chicken cheese steak was a 5/10 but did not insult my palate. The chicken Caesar salad was meh. I'll be back for a beer and the view but will eat elsewhere. read more

I don't know if this is a Pizza shop or a meat market. My 15 year old daughter was on vacation in stone harbor with her friends family. The girls decided to walk down to the pizza place around the corner(stone harbor pizza pub) to get a pizza. The workers would not stop looking and her and asking for her instagram. After their order was ready, a few of the workers followed them and kept asking for her number or instagram. One in particular was the foreign man that had a curls. It made her extremely uncomfortable and to be honest they were extremely creepy she had said. The fact that there were men hitting on a minor is disgusting. If you decide to eat here and have you d daughters, hold them close. The workers are extremely creepy and they do not take no for an answer. Management, I know out of town help is cheaper, but do better. read more

Service was bad. Waited 20 minutes for a server to come to us and we had to get them. Ordered our food and never got our appetizers and tried to blame the cooks. Do not recommend. read more

My husband called in and ordered a Mediterranean salad for me to pick up. I got there and the manager was clueless. He said no one ordered that. It was not busy and I was the only one in this place. Meanwhile it was sitting on the shelf right behind him. He then couldn't ring up the order and had to get a nice young server to do it. The cherry on the top was that the tomatoes were past their prime and there was t even 1/2 of a chicken breast on the salad about 4 olives and 5 little pieces of feta and it cost $22.00. . I would not recommend eating here. read more

Horrible food. Got two sides of fries and they BOTH came raw and uncooked-- straight potatoe. Had to ask for them to be cooked again. Service bad, didn't even ask us if we wanted drinks or apps just came over after a while and said "do you want food?" Yes I obviously want food. Got a chicken parm sandwich, chicken cold and dry with a bunch of tomato sauce slapped on it. Heard neighboring table also complaining about service -- don't recommend ever coming back here. read more

Just passing by while shopping and needed a holdover slice before dinner. Margarita slice was pretty good. It's off season now but only by a week. Restaurant was pretty quiet for 5p. read more

Stone Harbor Pizza Pub - Margarita - Pizza Near Me - Stone Harbor, New Jersey

Had a wonderful experience at the event space in Stone Harbor Pizza Pub! The staff here is awesome and were hustling hard to make the event a huge success - from passed appetizers to a delicious buffet and wonderful selection behind the bar. It looks like the downstairs space was well appointed as well. A great option in a bustling part of town for drinks and eats! read more

Stone Harbor Pizza Pub - Upstairs event space - Pizza Near Me - Stone Harbor, New Jersey

See all

Walked in for a couple of slices - no line, friendly counter service. Pretty cool bar with nice seating area where you can look at on the bay. Unfortunately, even on the very hot and humid July night we were there they didn't have the air conditioner on so we decided to get a couple of slices to go. We grabbed two slices of the margarita pizza. My wife thought it was OK. I thought it was terrible. The marinara was not very good and tasted like Ragu. The mozzarella was not the buffalo I was expecting. The crust was thin, but the flavor of the crust was not very good. I might go back for the atmosphere and have a couple of drinks but not for the pizza. read more

Re-reviewing this year -Apps came out quick -got the bruschetta appetizer again, always great, would have liked more bread, still, great presentation -pub fries, a thumbs up -Really enjoyed their namesake pizza, great chew on the dough/crust -The waitress Reagan was a doll as well -Overall, you'll have to stop in while in Stone Harbor ! read more

Stone Harbor Pizza Pub - "Stone harbor pizza" - Pizza Near Me - Stone Harbor, New Jersey

I enjoy going to restaurants that get unfair beef from disgruntled ex workers (you don't know the situation, as the situation should always remain confidential) or entitled folks (never satisfied or just bitter) and have people like that being proven wrong time every time. Yes, especially at a time when many small businesses are struggling, this is still happening but they just don't care. My inner Dean Martin would say it only needs more gravy, and my own chutzpah/ego even made a polite suggestion about it. But on our next nostalgia trek, I'd eat these meatballs again in Stone Harbor among the great listing of options we had. Service was very kind, personable and efficient too. And the waterfront view was beautiful. So good! Another wonderful memory together. read more

Stone Harbor Pizza Pub - Meatballs, fresh ricotta and toasted garlic bread (I don't usually eat pasta in this country, but you can get it with pasta too) - Pizza Near Me - Stone Harbor, New Jersey

Excellent experience. Great IPA and The pizza was hot and perfect. Great service as well. I don't know what the stars over all are so low. We were quite impressed! read more

Very good we got the bbq chicken and it was very good the service was great and the view was amazing would recommend again read more

Stone Harbor Pizza Pub - Pizza Near Me - Stone Harbor, New Jersey

I am not sure why the ratings are so low for this business but we had a good experience for lunch in early October. We were able to sit with our little group on the deck in the back and we shared a bunch of different items- pizza, chicken fingers, fried mac and cheese, brushetta... it was all good! My niece especially loved watching the birds fly over the boats in the bay while we wait. But be careful- I saw a seagull try to steal some food from another table! read more

server took 20 minutes just to take are order and didn't k ow what was on there menu and not and took a while just to serve us and i found hair in my food the service was terrible don't waste your time coming to this dirty pace read more

Stopped in to feed 5 hungry kids and myself. I was in a hurry to rush home since I was drained from spending an hour on the Blob. I wanted to order our food to go and maybe sit on the stools the lookout to the street. After we ordered and paid my gang decided they wanted to sit on their awesome back patio that overlooks the bay. The staff was happy to accommodate us. The "Stone Harbor" pizza was so delicious. We will definitely be returning. read more

Stone Harbor Pizza Pub - "The Crew" - Pizza Near Me - Stone Harbor, New Jersey

My aunt and uncle picked this place and we went along for the ride. Overall it was very good. The place was not busy and the staff, especially the guy behind the bar, was super accommodating and nice to us. They have a good tap list and the beer was fresh and cold. We got a couple of pizzas and they were both very good... crispy, gooey, fresh ingredients good flavor. We also got the meatball appetizer (good) and a side of french fries, which were actually awesome french fries. Prices were reasonable and the restaurant itself was nice, clean and relaxing. I could see really spending some time here in the summer when the deck is open and you can sit outside. But even sitting inside, it was a fine experience and good food. A really nice little gem for a relaxed meal. read more

See all

Not sure what's going on with these low reviews, this place offers good food, drinks and an amazing view. I live not far from here, so I frequent the pub often, and the pizza and beer selection are great. They offer an upscale dining area and plenty of choices for everyone on the menu! read more

The bad and the good... BAD: The Reeds bought Stone Harbor Pizza, the. Holding and the business. Our lovely waitress said the the owners were very eager to sell. GOOD: While the crust is not quite as good as the original Stone Harbor pizza, the Rushetta E Proscuitto pizza was absolutely outstanding! We also had the Brushetta pizza, but that was mediocre.$22 for 16" with 8 large slices was not a bad price. They also have a liquor license. They are currently renovating the outside dock area, but we had a lovely seat under the awning. We will be back. .,.. Summer 2019 update: great crust. Quick take out. Also lovely outdoor dining. Not sure why others rate this place so poorly. read more

Stone Harbor Pizza Pub - Pizza Near Me - Stone Harbor, New Jersey

Had a great experience at the bar We enjoyed a couple of beer flights Dan the bartender explained all the beers on tap He gave us awesome service We had a meatball appetizer and 2 slices cheese pizza Everything was really good Will definitely be back read more

See all

Yes please! Great pizza with fresh toppings, good for takeout plus the back deck overlooks the bay. read more

Stone Harbor Pizza Pub - Supreme pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Stone Harbor, New Jersey

We were here last year and had the 'new' spicy chicken sandwich. It was amazing! We've told multiple people about it. Went back tonight to have it again. It is not the same. Okay, but not amazing. They changed it. And with the subpar service, they need to bring it back. read more

We docked our boat and had beautiful service docking. Sadly- Mediterranean salad was simply field greens with a cheap processed feta along with 3 grapes tomatoes halved with a sprinkle of red onions and two cucumber slices. Not a value for $15. Sadly, my daughter was eating her Caesar salad until she came across a tiny bug...which happens sometimes in an outdoor restaurant. However- when my son found bug in his spaghetti...it wasn't a coincidence. Also, the pizza has a cheese that is of the lowest quality grade and tastes 100% processed. Frozen pizza tasted better. Plates were dirty and had to ask for clean plates. The ambience is lovely overlooking the water but the cleanliness of the kitchen needs to be re-examined. And the bathrooms are pretty gross and filthy. read more

I've been coming here for years and the service has always been consistent, quality of the food has been acceptable and never had a bad experience. We had the meatball pizza and loaded fries and everything was great tonight. Great casual dinning with a nice bay view. read more

When SHP opened the pizza was really good, not quite artisanal, but tasty with a crispy crust. I was just back there over the weekend and I could not believe how far quality the has fallen. We waited about twenty minutes in a not very crowded restaurant for a very disappointing pie. read more

This joint was the only place serving late food after my late arrival. The za was tasty. Tangy sauce. Morsel delish crust.

Best pizza on the island. Everything came out tasty and our service was great. It's super quiet in the off-season! Brianna was a wonderful server and we loved her upbeat, positive attitude. The pizza was hot, fresh and clearly made with high-quality ingredients like San Marzano tomatoes and sliced buffalo mozzarella cheese. 2 large pizzas was perfect for 4 people and we had plenty of leftovers! Highly recommend getting your pizza fix here. Pro Tips: - If you have an allergy, try the GF personal pizza and add your own toppings - Ask for a table outside by the water - Try the crispy white pizza - Definitely can get a table outside in the off-season read more

See all

Bad service, room temperature beer, mediocre pizza. Go to Mack's. This place stinks. Fries decent.

Really 3.5 stars. Great location and view, okay food and good service. Pizza and salads mainly, casual atmosphere.

Don't waste your time here. Especially if you have been coming here for 6 years and got used to good pizza, fast service and no bullshit. Pro: the view Cons: the food, frantic service, no lighting on patio, the wait, and the $30 CORKING FEE! read more

Stone Harbor Pizza Pub - Pathetic Caesar salad. Asked for no cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Stone Harbor, New Jersey

See all

The location is great. The drinks are great. The salad is great. But the pizza is bad. It's been ruined, and I don't know why. The dough is very different, it feels like it might even be freezer pie crusts. It's super bland and boring, and that ruins perfectly good toppings. The dough tastes like cardboard and doesn't have any of the flavor that it used to have last year. We were disappointed eating the pizza, and probably won't be back unless they start making fresh dough again. read more

The Caesar salad was good, but basic, and had good dressing. The slices of the large pie, do not even compare to the size of the slices for the take-out slices. We thought that was very odd. Drinks and service were good. I always say, would I go back? Yes, I would go back here. read more

Normally I think the pizza is pretty good here but got a simple cheese pizza from here and it was terrible. Looked and tasted like a 7-11 pizza. Ended up throwing it away. The Mac and cheese bite we are hit with the kids. read more

Updating my review. During our recent meals the staff demonstrated a much higher level of service than we experienced in previous years. The pizza and salads are excellent. Beer selection still solid. I was happy to return and enjoy the outdoor dining on the water. read more

Another restaurant destroyed by the GREEDS hotel people. This location actually had decent food at one time. Slow as molasses service and pizza served raw and uncooked. I am not talking about pizza that is cooked a little "light", this was gooey and raw. Our salads - the chicken tasted like the fake stuff they serve in airport convenience stores. Rubbery and chewy. They call themselves a Pizza Pub. However, if they wish to compete with someplace like the Watering Hull (who have a stellar beer selection) someone needs to pay attention to what selections are on tap. The day I was there, they had THREE separate white ales on tap. How about some variety? It's really sad - I have been going to SH since 1995 and the amount of mediocrity and outright crap that has come to this town in recent years - is downright depressing. Go to Macks if you want awesome pizza. read more

Long time stone harbor residents. First time visiting the new pizza pub. Pizza was outstanding. Thin crust pizza the way it should be. Crusty and perfectly seasoned. Reminds me of good New York and Italian pizza. Not doughy at all. Great selection of craft brews on tap ad well. A great way to take a break from the beach. read more

Stone Harbor Pizza Pub - Pizza Near Me - Stone Harbor, New Jersey

Very tasty pizza. Good appetizers and an awesome atmosphere. Friendly staff and quick and good Service even with COVID. We have tried many pizzas from here and all of them are delicious. The outdoor seating provides awesome views of the sunset on the bay. read more

Sad that this place has turned into such a disappointment. And yes, I've been there several times since it was bought. Since that time, the service has been okay. But we usually sit at the bar, and they have decent specials at the bar for happy hour. This past week we walked in, saw two staffers and asked if we could sit inside. They said sure, pick any seat. We did. And we waited. And waited. And waited. The manager type woman was milling around the bar, so one of our party went up to her and asked if we had a server. She replied yes, she'll be right with you. We were within eyesight and earshot of the two servers, who were filling up waters are the bar. They were decided who got the next table. We were hopeful. Maybe those waters were for us! They were not. Neither was the server, who 'called' our table. She walked by us twice more to drop off a check and replenish drinks. Once again, one of us went up and asked, this time to the waitress herself, if we could get some waters and menus. She said she'd be right with us. And yet... you guessed it. Nothing. She picked up the check from the other table, and walked by our table. At this point, it was 18 minutes. I know because I have a three-year-old and he loves to ask the time. We sat down at 12:28. We ended up leaving at 12:49. That's crazy. And the waitress, who had yet to address or acknowledge us aside from when we asked her for service, had the nerve to ask as we are leaving: "you guys headed out?". Yup. And she didn't say anything, no apology from her, or any manager type. I counted. There were 5 other tables seated. Two servers. I know 'in the weeds'. That aint it. At least drop waters and menus. And speaking of...if you are the manager and you've been asked by customers about getting service, wouldn't you get the waters and menus yourself? Nope. She just stood there too. I am sure she felt it wasn't in her job description. So we sat. We waited. And we left. The pizza is slightly above average, not exceptional and not deserving of the high price. Terrible and I do mean TERRIBLE service. I can't remember the last time I walked out of a restaurant without ordering, being acknowledged or without an apology. YIKES. read more

Wow! Kiran great bartender Mac and Cheese botes are to die for, can't wait to bring the kids. Music was a little weird, spaghetti kid picture made me laugh read more

So to start off the waiter was amazing very attentive and kind but the food was sub par the pizza isn't the best on the island.. the view is beautiful for sure and is the only reason Iv gone.. I ordered a cheese stake and that was pretty good but for the price of things it's not worth it.. they don't have specials also not many drink options when it comes to alcohol.. the lavender drink is ok but tastes more like syrup... better places for food on the island but the view during sun set is amazing read more