This place has some of the best pizza in Cape May county. Thin crust and the tomato sauce is perfect. I hesitate to write this review out of fear that I won't get in again. Buffalo shrimp were tasty. Love this place. read more

See all

Order a bloody Mary and you get a limp olive with no pimento. Don't get me wrong I've been here before and everything's been fine but today it just got on my nerves. I went midday. The bartender catered to the locals and had her little chitchat going. Do you restaurant owners not realize that there are people coming in and out of town at all times and on various days and we may work in service industries and maybe even the restaurants/hospitality industry I ordered whatever the burger is with the Gorgonzola cheese and it wasn't bad but it wasn't great. Between the burger the bun the tomato and the onion was hard to get your mouth around but it wasn't really worth it to stretch your mouth that far. You had a choice of fries or salad and I chose the fries. In all honesty I've been in Cape May for a week now and have eaten out nearly every day and had some outstanding fries and I would swear these were yesterday's fries if not yesterday's fries from somebody else's plate. I asked the bartender if these were the normal presentation of the fries she said "oh yes they're hand cut fries" my question would be hand cut when and fried when? They were overdone and mushy. . And after exchange the bartender adopted a pissy attitude. Here's my thing to the managers/owners of this establishment: I have worked in various forms in hospitality and customer service. I'm also an older person, consumer, frequent visitor of restaurants and bars. Take this however you will. It's a Tuesday afternoon... The servers and the service and the food should be exactly the fucking same as it is on Friday and Saturday night. Feel free to contact me if I said anything out of line. PS I'm an interim innkeeper in Cape May and I will definitely be steering people away from your restaurant even though I've had decent experiences in the past. There's too much competition out there for too few dollars. Smarten up read more

Returned for Thursday night happy hour. Drink specials and Pizza was good but service was horrible. Best part of 5 West is happy hour but service (new waitress???) has taken a dive. Still like the place but it's lost its varnish. read more

See all

We stopped here for lunch. Great place to hang out. They have sitting outside, comfy couch is available when you wait if it gets busy. Excellent service and delicious food!! Try the Mac and cheese, by far, best I've ever had!! I got the salmon with the ginger honey sauce, it was a bit bitter for me but still tasty. I liked the atmosphere and the music was pleasant and not too loud. Highly recommended. read more

See all

Lovely lunch.... Great burgers. Good service! Kitchen is a little loud but that's because it's open to the seating area.

Enjoying burgers, pie, cocktails & the amazing desserts Highly recommend the key lime pie, parma pizza and banana martini read more

5 West Pub - Parma pie - Pubs Near Me - North Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Great vibe in North Cape May. I ordered the bar pizza (the Popeye) and it was EXCELLENT. Service was swift and friendly and the Flyers lost. A great night! read more

5 West Pub - Popeye Pizza (spinach, garlic, ricotta, and extra virgin olive oil) - Pubs Near Me - North Cape May, New Jersey

I was very disappointed with my experience at 5 West Pub. We ordered three cheesesteaks, and the menu clearly describes them as shaved ribeye with your choice of Copper Sharp or Cheese Whiz. Instead, we received three chicken cheesesteaks loaded with mushrooms and onions. We never ordered chicken, mushrooms, or onions. To make matters worse, the sandwiches were $17 each, so I expected much better quality and accuracy. The fries that came with them were also extremely greasy and tasted like they had been cooked in old oil. Getting an order completely wrong is frustrating, especially at that price point. Unfortunately, this experience was very disappointing, and I won't be returning. Response from business: Hi! I'm sorry to hear about your experience with us! If this was brought to our attention we would have promptly corrected this error for you! Again I'm sorry for the order mess up on a Saturday night in July, and I hope you'd give us another try some other time. Response to business: Thank you for your response. I appreciate the apology. I understand mistakes can happen, especially during a busy Saturday night. Unfortunately, we didn't realize the order was incorrect until we had already started eating the sandwiches. Since we had three meals that were all made incorrectly, we decided not to send them back and wait for replacements. We were just disappointed because the menu described a cheesesteak as shaved ribeye, and we received chicken cheesesteaks with mushrooms and onions instead. I appreciate you taking the time to respond, and I hope this feedback helps prevent similar issues in the future. read more

Great local place. Very lively and clean.Host at entry very personable. We went early so we were sat right away while there the place got quite busy around us. Our sever Alison was so helpful and pleasant. Specials drink orders gave my wife a couple mins to figure out her drink order. Ordered the buf shrimp app which we love I always want her to get her own because I want it all what can I say got a big appetite. Plus so yummy sauce isn't too hot but spicy. Great presentation comes w blue cheese and celery. Onto dinner I got the steak frites which is a favorite of mine I've also loved the hot pork sand they have some great pizza too. I loved mine fries are home cut and delish comes with green beans. Wife got crab cake sandwich said she liked it very much mentioned how meaty I'm not a crab cake person but I think she meant not a lot of filler. She had the fries too. Desert we split the key lime pie my wife used to own a cafe and was the baker. Both of us thoroughly enjoyed the key lime tart but not crazy the whip cream home made not from a can my wife said I wouldn't have noticed I love em both. Nice crust on bottom. Hit the spot after a lovely meal we will be back and we keep going back highly recommend in the area.great service,really nice folks nice place and food was a cherry on to of a great visit read more

This is a fantastic hidden gem! The ambience is amazing, the service is fantastic and everything we've tried was yummy! I highly recommend the crab bisque with lump crab, shrimp lettuce wraps as well as the crab cake tacos (messy but generous and flavorful) but oddly enough the green beans take the tasty-cake! They seem to be roasted and they are delicious! Can't wait to come back for dinner! read more

5 West Pub - Ambiance - Pubs Near Me - North Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Great service, food, with a decent bar. Have some classic cocktails featured. Second visit as we were very favorable impressed the first time. This time we brought guests and they put this place on their list when they are in town. read more

We ended up here as part of a wine tour package. Salads and waters were already on the table waiting for us when we walked in. We were offered 5 different entrees and it was a pretty well rounded offering, it seemed like there could be something for everyone even though the chicken tenders and cheeseburgers ended up to be most popular with our group. The staff was wonderful and very kind and patient with us since we were kind of indecisive and possibly a little loud post wine tour. Thankfully there were only a few locals hanging at the bar on this Saturday afternoon so there weren't too many people to disturb. read more

5 West Pub - Chicken fritters - Pubs Near Me - North Cape May, New Jersey

I've been here several times and I loved it each time. We've ordered some soups, appetizers, pizzas, burgers, and sandwiches. Each time we have walked away completely satisfied. Their pizzas in particular are my favorite. I love whatever cheese they use because it has the perfect amount of saltiness that brings the flavor over the top. My favorite pizzas are the buffalo shrimp and the clams and macaroni pies, so good. There is one minor kink they need to work out with the pizza pies though: they can be a tad too soggy at times. If they can work that out, it would be perfection, because the flavor is already there. The rest of the menu is pretty good too I'll add. The menu is priced very fairly and service is always good. They are also open later than quite a few other establishments in the area which is a godsend in Cape May County. I would highly recommend checking this place out. read more

We stopped here for dinner after seeing the good reviews. We were surprised that there wasn't any parking in the parking lot and followed others that were parked in the grass. We thought it must be really good with how busy it was. We put our name in with the hostess and she told us that it would be a 40 minute wait. The restaurant itself was nice and had a pretty big bar area. We were surprised to see that the roof was leaking in several areas. The people who were sitting at the bar kept getting water drips on their heads while trying to enjoy their drinks. There were a few other areas that had yellow caution cones in the walkway from the leaky roof. Once seated our waiter came to take our order. He offered us water and we took him up on it. We noticed that there was something floating in our bottle of water which seamed to be a straw wrapper, but we weren't given any straws so it definitely wasn't from us. We alerted our waiter and he gave us new water and glasses to use. I ordered the meatballs for my entree and was not disappointed. They were delicious and cooked to perfection. I'd come back just for those! read more

5 West Pub - Meatballs - Pubs Near Me - North Cape May, New Jersey

The pickle pizza was a table favorite!! Fresh - tasty - cooked perfectly!! Burger was fresh and cooked to order. The fries were overcooked and cold ... the waiter was friendly but could have been more attentive.... We came on St. Patrick's Day weekend and Irish music filled the place - it was a little loud and we couldn't really hear each other. However - overall a very positive experience and we will be back! read more

5 West Pub - Bourbon Burger - Pubs Near Me - North Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Loved the arugula pizza and special roast beef sandwich. Pam our server was exceptional. Will return read more

5 West Pub - Arugula prosciutto pizza - Pubs Near Me - North Cape May, New Jersey

Great food, service and bar tenders. Great ambiance. Great pizza and appetizers with a full menu

I must say I have never had an issue at 5 West except for service at times. Tonight I placed a to go order for a bowl of soup for $14. Ok, but the size of the container was at the most a cup size. Strike number 1. Also ordered the cheese steak egg roles for $14, which was 2 burnt roles cut in half. Are you kidding me. To also add the size of the egg rolls was not very big. I know times are hard but come on! REALLY!!!! Very disappointing read more

Solid meal at 5 west. The wings were crispy and well sauced with a nice kick. Soup was flavorful . Server was relatively quick to get drinks and clear plates read more

5 West Pub - Cup of bisque - Pubs Near Me - North Cape May, New Jersey

See all

We love it here, food is delicious, staff and the is great too!! Great to watch a game here too.

We were looking for a quick light bite after driving to the shore. It was close to 9 pm. We were greeted and seated immediately. Tables are still socially distanced. The dining room was clean but a little dark. Our waitress came over as soon as we were seated. We ordered pretty quickly and were served quickly. I had the crab bisque which was delicious! Lots of crab chunks with a thick creamy broth. It was seasoned nicely. The French fries were served hot and crispy. The salad was a nice size for a side salad. The greens were fresh. My husband wasn't happy with the cheeseburger. It tasted like a frozen patty and was a little over cooked. There's a good variety of food along with beer, wine and a cocktail menu. Our server checked on us several times. Prices were reasonable for the shore area. read more

See all

Food is always so delicious. They have unique menu items and for sure a must stop location! Service is always good. Never had to wait for drinks or on the check. It's very nice inside, plenty of seating. Very large bar. read more

See all

Lunch yesterday with my friend. I had the Thai Beef Salad . Beautifully presented with the flank steak medium rare on top and sliced just right for me to see that it was indeed med rare. So sorry I didn't take a photo. Greens were dark cold and carrots julienne were crunchy. The dressing was perfect not too spicy but tangy. Your back room do over is very nice. Our server was very pleasant. Just a great lunch . My friend had the eggplant appetizer it had changed from a tower to a baked bowl. Not a problem the gravy/ sauce was very good. read more

5 West Pub - Eggplant Arribiatta ! Sooooo goood ! - Pubs Near Me - North Cape May, New Jersey

did Not start off good. No pizza ??? No explanation just not serving. Kendra was our waitress. She was horrible. No sense of urgency at all. Did not check on us at all. Waited 45 minutes for appetizer and 15 minutes more for dinner. No explanation again. Will never go back and will advise friends and family to stay away. read more

We sat in the bar and had excellent service. The waiter was very attentive and accommodating. Bartender made sure we enjoyed the drinks ( Guinness at the right temp/proper pour, cherry martini that was strong-- he added sprite and it was perfect). Crab cake sandwiches that were all meat and very tender. This is a hidden gem! Will go back next time we are in the area read more

Never disappoints It is what it is... great local spot!! Clams and macaroni on point!!!!

Excellent service from Donovan. Crab Cake sandwich was scrumptious and full of crab meat! I also got the crab bisque soup , very good! Bartender was personable and fixed my Cherry watermelon Martini! Delicious! Will be back on next visit! Hot spot! read more

Inconsistency of quality of some menu items. Took family that was visiting to 5 West this past weekend. Two people ordered cheeseburgers. Both said the meat did not have a good flavor and not ate a very small portion before calling it quits. Mac and cheese is so so, nothing to write home about. Terrible acoustics, very loud. One person commented it sounded like the staff were throwing the plates! Difficult to have a conversation given the noise level. If you go while the sun is still up, do not allow them to seat you across from the doors, you will need sunglasses. They CHARGE A SURCHARGE when using a credit card, but they don't let you know this until after they run your card through. Salmon was great and crab cake tacos good. Will go elsewhere in the future read more

Pizza is decent here Had a party at my home with about 20 people and ordered a bunch of pies The pepperoni pizza was the highlight along with the white pizza Crust was soft yet crunchy ( how I like it) Cheese tastes so good and sauce tasted fresh The pizza also had crust bubbles which I like Would definitely come back soon. read more

Always great stuff from bar food, excellent pizzas and more. Service always fast and friendly. Very loud place, but worth talking loud to be heard for the great food and service they provide. read more

Good food and bar area. The acoustics can get loud in there. Lots of parking available. Good sandwiches. Popular during game times.

Quite honestly the best crab cakes I have ever had. I was in Cape May for 4 days and ate here twice. read more

5 West Pub - Philly Cheese Steak Egg rolls and the crab cake entree with Mac and Cheese - Pubs Near Me - North Cape May, New Jersey

When you are in Cape May, every place is touristy & we wanted something more low key & local & found this place. GREAT menu with lots of good things on there. We enjoyed some drinks & pizza. Loved the pizza - very very good! Service was great & there is plenty of parking! The best thing - the bill was very reasonable! So glad we make our way to this place - would definitely go again. It's seems to be a popular place so be sure to make a reservation! read more

Wings are delicious. Drinks are amazing. Atmosphere is very nice . Plenty of parking.

Not sure about food, walked in got seated. The waitress came by, not friendly at all! Asked about draft IPA and told none available, asked about bottled ones....none. She was not helpful at all. Came to Harpoons and totally great experience! read more

Just ordered a cobb burger and a Italian roast pork sandwich.. the burger was the worst I ever had I asked for med and got a dry burger not a drop of flavor and the pork was the same way .. what a rip off Well I won't be going back there .. no thanks read more

Pizza is fantastic! Had the pepperoni and burrata! Crust was thin and chewy! Would completely order again!

Great burger. Recommended. I was craving a pub style burger and had had the Exit Zero one a couple days before. I was unimpressed with Exit Zero's bland burger. It did nothing to satisfy my craving. Because of my bad experience, I was wary of 5 West despite recommendations from locals and my friends wanting to try it. But I'm so glad we went because this totally hit the spot. Meaty grilled flavor, quality throughout, every bite consistent. Fries were good too. My son ate a ton! Will be back to try more! read more

5 West Pub - Pubs Near Me - North Cape May, New Jersey

Great atmosphere, great food and perfect dinner music! This is the perfect place to go when the Wildwoods and Cape May get crowded on the weekends. We waited about 5-10 minutes and enjoyed a drink at the bar. When seated at our table, both my husband and I ordered burgers which were very reasonably priced and even included fries! The food was done to order, hot and delicious. They had an acoustic guitar player who sang and was later accompanied by a fiddle player. The song choices and volume were perfect for this small restaurant bar as we could enjoy our meal and conversation. Will definitely be back!! read more

Wide variety of food at good prices. Everything was really fresh and I loved all of the options! They have a great space for social distancing/outdoor dining with heat lamps and a covered roof. The chicken Gorgonzola pizza was one of the best pizzas I've ever bad! Gorgonzola cheese adds a unique flavor. The Cuban sandwich was also very good. Unique combination. read more

5 West Pub - Chicken Gorgonzola pizza - Pubs Near Me - North Cape May, New Jersey

See all