While we knew this restaurant would be a little on the pricey side, it was the best meal we had in Idaho, not just Stanley. There were lots of options and the first thing we started with was a loaf of the sourdough bread. When we asked how large it would be the waiter responded "the size of a small baby" lol. He wasn't entirely wrong either, it was a pretty good size. It was so good paired with the whipped feta and pimento cheese. I am not normally a huge pimento fan, but this was really good. Next we had one of the salads, but it wasn't the star of the show, still tasty though. The pierogis were quite good and had a good consistency. We did make friends with the table next to us who ordered almost 1 of everything on the menu and raved about even the stuff we did not try so it seemed like you couldn't go wrong no matter what you order. read more

We enjoyed a wonderful dinner here at the Stanley Supper Club. The lamb terrine was flavorful but it wasn't too over the top lamb-tasting for folks who may not have tried lamb, or it's not their fave protein. Hubby liked the smoked whitefish and said he would have it again. The house-made and baked sourdough was delish and we took a half loaf home to enjoy tomorrow. The sausage charcuterie board was great. The highlight for us was the house-made bacon which had a great spiciness. The bratwurst was really good paired with the house mustard, and the kielbasa was good as well, although not our fave. We just preferred the brat and bacon. We shared the fried chicken for two and it didn't disappoint. The coating was crunchy and well-seasoned. It did fall off, but if you held tightly, you could get a great bite of both the breading and the moist chicken beneath. They served three sauces with it which were all complimentary and offered a choice for everyone. The mashed potatoes were reminiscent of those we've had at a few fine dining establishments such as Joel Robuchon, (although these fell short of that, they were quite tasty and deserved of their own accolades). The shaved broccoli salad was the hit of the meal. It delivered on all taste elements. The ambiance reminded us of a cozy Bavarian restaurant. There was lots of wood, cozy tables and chalet-style decor. All that was missing may be a cheese fondue. I wouldn't be surprised if they offered that in the winter season. The prices were very reasonable and could fit almost any dining budget depending upon the menu selection. A rare find anywhere, but especially in such a small town. Don't miss this special place if you're in Stanley or the surrounding area. It's worth a visit just to grab a loaf of bread for your trail sandwiches. read more

See all

Amazing food. Best fried chicken I've ever had. This is our second time coming to this restaurant and even though the food is truly incredible the service is so so bad. They will make you feel like they are annoyed and upset that you stopped by to eat (Even with reservations) The food is worth the terrible service though lol read more

Stanley Supper Club - Comfort Food Near Me - Stanley, Idaho

BOOM! Best in town! Staff are SAVAGE and the food is off the rails with very interesting and diverse selections!

What a fun date night this restaurant provided for my husband and me during our stay in Redfish! We discovered it on Yelp and were excited to try it. Despite not having a reservation, we walked in, and the hostess was incredibly kind to accommodate us. I didn't think we'd get a table! The restaurant is run by a husband and wife team: he's the chef, and she's the pastry chef, creating fresh, unique desserts daily. Our dessert was phenomenal. It's comfort/rustic cuisine, delicious with every dish beautifully presented and bursting with flavor. read more

Delicious food, cozy atmosphere and no more expensive than the other restaurants open during the winter for dinner. Make sure to purchase a loaf of sourdough to take home. It makes the best toast! read more

My fiancé booked Valentines Day dinner for us while we were staying in Stanley. The reviews had been great, so we were expecting a culinary experience, however, it definitely did not live up to those expectations. I am a vegetarian, due to health reasons, and we were told that they could accommodate dietary needs. I have been to many places that substitute items and create unique and tasty dishes, but the Supper Club was definitely not one of them. Our first dish was less than stellar. The Semolina & Sesame Bread was tasty, however, there were areas that were burnt. Along with the bread we were given a turnip mash, and instead of Brandade, a cold, limp, green vinegary vegetable dish, which I am not sure what it consisted of. It was so unpalatable that my fiancé and I could barely eat two mouthfuls each. The second course consisted of Twice Baked Sweet Potatoes and they were burnt. When I mentioned it to the server, she only stated, "Oh, yes, they were cooked twice" without even addressing the black areas clearly visible around the entire edges. We could not eat it. The third and fourth courses were so unpalatable, that we asked for boxes to take with us, figuring that we could possibly add something at home to make them taste better. The Spicy Carrots were not spicy and were cold. The Oyster Mushrooms were nothing more than a clump of mushrooms with no additional sauce or dressing. My fiancé ended up with a plain Pork Rib Cap, which he stated was "Okay" and definitely nothing special, while I ended up with a thick cut pastry "sandwich" with dried up beets inside. One bite and it went in the box, to perhaps repurpose as a sandwich or something else (It did not as we ended up throwing all of the food out.) The measure of a restaurant is the ability to time the cooking and serving of dishes so that the entree or appetizer is appropriately cooked and heated. Not one of the items was served to us warm as it possibly was intended to be, so we are not sure if it was supposed to a warm dinner or an entire cold selection like we were served. The only item on the entire menu that was good was the Pavlova. We received one to share between us. I am not inclined to return to this restaurant. The hype of the reviews over the "Best Fried Chicken" is what had us sold, but the actual dinner that was served to us was below underwhelming. Our check was $75 each, a total of $185 with a drink each, and most of the food was left on our plate or taken home and later thrown out. I would definitely not recommend a fixed course meal at this restaurant. read more

We need to make mental note to make reservations in advance - especially on a holiday weekend. Despite such, Stanley, supper club was accommodating and was able to take us on a walk in basis. I know others weren't as lucky. Lucky because the food was amazing. The staff were kind in the establishment felt so curated and intentional, beautiful ambience. We came in here, hungry, and left very satisfied. Between my boyfriend and myself, we ordered the fried chicken for two of which comes with a quarter of sourdough slices and a salad in addition to the chicken and sides. We had the blackberry salad and it was absolutely delicious. The fruit was so fresh, which I really appreciated after a surprisingly hot day. The sourdough certainly better than my own loaf. I say this humbly because I thought me and my starter were the best. We also split a daily pasta. I really appreciate the different sizing options that allows to try more while not breaking the bank. What I think was a stand out was the house made Earl Grey tea and blackberry iced tea. I miss it so much. It was absolutely delicious and I really wanted to take it to go cup. Would recommend everyone sample it. For the fried chicken, I appreciated the diversification of dipping sauces. Each one was so unique and felt like a completely different experience. Although I would say we progressively got messier and messier as we eat the rest of the chicken mostly because the establishment was so nice we didn't want to get too messy. Since we sat at the bar, they had cakes on display for dessert and it was so tempting not to just eat it right there. However, we were inspired to grab a slice of each so we can enjoy it and watch sunset over the sawtooth. We initially came to Stanley in January when everything was closed and I'm so glad we made the return trip back so we could try places like the Stanley supper club. read more

Stanley Supper Club - Fried chicken for two Daily pasta special (ravioli with oyster mushrooms) - Comfort Food Near Me - Stanley, Idaho

Finally we made to the Supper Club and it didn't disappoint. It was excellent and I they recommend dinner here. The wine list is a worldly flavor which I loved. We started with their homemade sourdough bread, so so good, and the sausage plate. Full of flavor. For dinner we ordered the pasta special and it was perfect. Seating is inside and outside with a local flavor and fresh ingredients. Go and enjoy! read more

See all

The Stanley Supper Club is a hidden gem in the Sawtooth Mountain Wilderness area. We had the most amazing meal there. Fresh ingredients, creative but not fussy food, flavor-filled. The fried chicken and pasta of the day were standouts. And don't get me started on the homemade ice cream sandwich. To die for. Not overly priced either. Would def recommend. read more

Best fried chicken I've ever had in my entire life. Service fantastic. Ambiance was cozy. read more

See all

This place is amazing. My boyfriend and I went here two nights in a row when we were in Stanley. In the summer make sure to make a reservation, we got there 30 minutes before the restaurant even opened both times in order to secure a walk-in spot. There are people lined up waiting at the door to get in before they open. The fried chicken is a must, both salads they had on the menu were great, and the bread is amazing as well! It wasn't cheap, but actually not expensive for the quality and portions of the food. Totally worth it! read more

A wonderful dining experience on our first night in Stanley. Reservations recommended but not required. Friendly staff and a casual, but upscale atmosphere. Sit at the bar, at tables inside, or outdoors. We split the fried chicken for two, which came with turnips and mashed potatoes, and a plum salad. It was all very good. The sausage plate had two different types of sausages with pickles and mustard. The bread was delicious with salted butter. Great date night spot. read more

Stanley Supper Club - Comfort Food Near Me - Stanley, Idaho

Best imaginative and good food I've had in years! Large portions, friendly service, beautiful restaurant ....wow. Fantastic experience. We all recommend going to the Rod and Gun club for a drink before dinner read more

Good food, good price, rotating menus. What more could you ask for!?! I have not had anything on the menu I didn't like. Obviously, the desserts are best. Doughnuts, yes please. Cheesecake, hit me! The staff is friendly and welcoming and the decor is cozy and screams Bavaria. Only reason it's a four instead of a five. The good is the bad, rotating menu equals some of your favorites may not be there next week. Also, finance-bro influencer hipster-f* bags that have polluted this area with their highly inflated sense of economics will eventually make this place too expensive just like SV. I'll continue coming here as long as I can afford to though. read more

My girlfriend & I drove in from Boise here to celebrate our anniversary and we couldn't have picked a better place to have dinner. Best dining experience I've had here in Idaho. The menu, layout, even the table-wear is thoughtfully curated down to every detail and it really shows. Incredibly creative usage of ingredients... hazelnuts, acorn squash, pickled fennel, etc. Food was amazing, service timing was perfect, wine list was good, and the overall layout & lighting made this dinner feel special. Glass of wine, appetizer, dinner, coffee & dessert. Awesome experience! read more

Stanley Supper Club - Comfort Food Near Me - Stanley, Idaho

See all

Quite the gem! Amazing restaurant and quite a surprise for a town with less than 200 people. Fantastic vibe, great service and wonderful food. read more

Incredible experience at Stanley Supper Club. The ambiance and feel of this intimate & unassuming little restaurant was so charming. We ordered the Fried Chicken for Two with all the fixings & the pasta and were absolutely blown away by the fresh, homemade taste and such a symphony of flavors. This is a meal I won't forget in a small town that's stolen our hearts. read more

It's been 9 months since I ate at the Stanley Supper Club- and my mouth still waters thinking about the meal I had there! I am not exaggerating when I say this may have been the best meal in my almost 55 years of life! I cannot wait to eat there again this summer. If you are in Stanley this is a MUST! But please don't get too busy that I can't get in;) also best of luck with the James Beard award! So so well deserved! Totally rooting for you! read more

WOW, WOW, WOW. What a delight! Had a STUPENDOUS meal for our anniversary dinner that rivals anyplace in the US! Seriously, the folks at Stanley Supper Club are providing a top notch dining experience in a relaxed setting in the Sawtooths. We made a reservation easily online via their website for our 44th anniversary dinner. Rayme and Hallie and took wonderful care of us as we kicked things off with a glass of wine and some of that delicious sourdough bread. Followed up with the strawberry fig salad which is one of the freshest and tastiest salads we have ever had in our 67 plus years! Entrees included the special carrot ravioli and the leg of lamb both of which were EXQUISITE in their own rights and full of wonderful flavors!!!!! And all of this provided for in Stanley Idaho. Yes, you should and could drive from Ketchum, Boise, Twin Falls or anywhere else within a 2 hour or more drive and not be disappointed. This restaurant ranks up there with the best and is another terrific dining option in little old Stanley Idaho. I might have taken some pics but I was too consumed with the wonderful dining experience to care! Just saying. ENJOY and THANK YOU STANLEY SUPPER CLUB! read more

One of the best meals I've ever had. A family we met while hiking in the Sawtooth Wilderness told us that we shouldn't miss coming here. Spot on. Fried chicken was out of this world. Amazing spicy broccoli salad, sourdough bread was the best we've ever had. A mint (REAL mint) ice cream sandwich was like no other. Service was excellent and the owners are super humble and cool. We went out of our way just to eat dinner there and are so glad we did. Anyone that didn't give 5 stars might need some therapy. It's not a big place so they might not be able to serve all walk ins. Reservations or being there right when they open would be best. Can't wait to return. read more

See all

A delightful evening with friendly service, a cozy atmosphere with Polish inspired gourmet food. This restaurant is tucked in the small mountain town of Stanley, Idaho. This is a definite stop with your visit. We enjoyed their winter menu and highly recommend this establishment. read more

See all

If you find yourself in Stanley this place is a must! We had the fried chicken meal for two and it was cooked perfectly. The vegetables were the star of the meal, for me, as they were uniquely prepared and delicious! What an unexpected find in this small town the chef is outstanding! Best meal we have had anywhere in years!!! Only negative is the hostess and waitress ignored us when we arrived for quite some time despite a near empty restaurant. Very odd and unusual the unfriendliness of the staff‍ read more

The food was outstanding. We loved the fried chicken dinner for two so much that we went back again a few nights later. Everything was so flavorful, fresh and homemade with love. The servers were wonderful and gave excellent suggestions. The atmosphere is warm and reminiscent of Northern Europe. Love everything about this place. I wish we didn't live 14 hours away! We look forward to returning in the future. read more

If you're visiting Stanley or plan to do so, you must dine at the Stanley Supper Club!! They're open Friday- Tuesday, hours 4pm-9pm. Catch them while you can and load up all sorts of delectable grub. We had the fried chicken dinner for two, with some tasty shaved broccoli salad, corn cakes, pimento cheese, and half a sourdough to get us started. Portions were huge, if you ask me and everything was super filling! We were blown away by the size and portions of the fried chicken dinner and to be honest I thought the breading was so well seasoned that the sauces accompanying the chicken weren't even needed! I felt like I was coming home to grandmas house and left feeling well-nourished and cared for, just like grandmas do. The interior feels cozy, warm, and inviting. It has a rustic appeal and down home cooking smells filling the air. The building itself appears new and certainly feels well cared for too. You can't go wrong having a meal or two here! read more

See all

It's cliche but this is one of the best meals I've ever had. My friends and I were seated right away. The restaurant's vibe is eclectic and enjoyable. We ordered: Homemade ice tea with Earl Grey (yum!), homemade sourdough and wedge of cheese (good and crusty yet soft), cream of corn soup (yum!), turnip cake (good and spicy), shaved broccoli salad (yum!), pierogis with dandelion greens (good), grilled zucchini (good), chocolate cake with coffee frosting (so moist and creamy), mint ice cream and graham cracker sandwich (yum! It was real mint). If anywhere near Stanley, you must go! read more

Wow, this place was truly a gem. They must update their menu bc the one on yelp isn't accurate, and we almost didn't go. They have a few entree options (with one vegetarian and one vegan option). They also have salads, a picnic basket variety, and a few desserts. I got the pierogi, which were filling and delicious. Everything we ordered was generous and tasty, and my only regret is that I didn't save room for dessert. Definitely check them out! read more

We left before we ordered due to the horrible service. Life is too short to spend your money where people treat you as bad as that!

Best restaurant in America. Hands down. No if ands or buts. We live in Boise and come to Stanley in the winter just so we can eat here. If you come in the winter you HAVE to get the pot roast dinner for two and the spicy pork doughnut. Good lord. The beet salad, the sourdough bread, the seasonal vegetable, the mashed potatoes, the pot roast. You'll have to be rolled out of the establishment with a wheelbarrow you'll be so full but you'll have a damn big smile on your face. The fried chicken dinner for two that we've had in the summer is super good too. Their dessert is stellar as well. We've been to many many restaurants and nothing compares. We'll be back countless times in the future If we lived in Stanley we'd be broke because we'd eat here every single day read more

See all

Get the sourdough! You won't regret it! Spicy pickles and gnocchi were also on point.

Don't waste your money on bad attitude and bad service. Sat us down at our table and took FOREVER for the waitress to come over to our table, she greeted us with horrible attitude and acted like she didn't want us to be there. Won't ever be coming back. read more

I was super excited to eat at this restaurant because I had heard so many rave reviews about the food. When we walked in we were seated and weren't even approached by the wait staff for about 10 minutes. Finally the waitress came up to us and asked us what we wanted to order and I asked her what the specials were and what the pasta was and she said it didn't matter because they already sold out. We were just curious so we asked what it was and she acted very put out telling us what the special was. Then she said she'd give us some time to check the menu which we already had plenty of time and we asked if we could start with a couple of orders of sourdough bread she said she would take our order all at once and walked away. We were so distraught by the lack of service and professionalism that we literally picked up and walked out of the restaurant. I hope she's just having a bad night but it was very off putting. I've heard the food is amazing and I'd love to try it again but the service was just really really tough. I've never walked out of a restaurant but this was a first. read more

Quality 5/5 Service 5/5 Value 6/5 Wow... What an amazing find! Top notch quality at an unbelievable value. We tired the fall salad, house made sausage and a side of unbelievable mashed potatoes and gravy. You won't find crazy fusion dishes or wild off the wall creations, but you will find woefully understated and highly executed comfort food that is fresh made from scratch and beyond your expectations. Our house-made huge sausage came on a crunchy homemade bun with homemade Kimchee, marinated onions and mustard. The fall salad was super fresh and the homemade walnuts crumble and goat cheese with just epic. The mashed potatoes, oh man, were expertly prepared, sieved, well seasoned and oh so good. You think mashed potatoes would be be an after thought, but it here, they were literally unbelievable for $4. This is one of those places that you will remember for years to come. read more

See all

First time at this Restaurant. Had heard how fabulous the food is. Husband and wife owned business. It is truly worthy of its 5 stars and I would give them more if I could. 3 of us had the Pork Steak and OMG, have never had anything so delicious. We also had an order of the Pasta special. Fabulous!! Hardly had room for dessert, but everything we had was baked by the owners and delicious. Also had ice cream that they had made. We were rolling out of this place with very satisfied smiles on our faces. Don't miss this place when you are in Stanley. read more

Call way ahead and don't expect a call back. The only way to make a reservation is via phone vs the web like modern establishments. They DO NOT answer the phone and DO NOT check their voice mail. I arrived hoping to get a seat and was told they did not get my reservation. That sucked, but what really sucked was the way they made me feel. Like I was lying about leaving a message. They said the rechecked the messages while I was five feet in front of them. They never once checked a phone. Pompous and arrogant. I hope the food is good, because the business, experience, and process was horrible. They likely won't care now, but when they realize how hard it is to have a restaurant here maybe they will make it about customers and not boutique boujoi. read more

I know it sounds crazy, but this might be the best meal I've ever had. We got the fried chicken meal for 2 with extra sourdough bread and cake. And I'm dead serious, every single thing we had was like the best I've had of that item anywhere. My girlfriend (who is very much a "foodie") was beside herself after one bite of the broccoli salad (she noted it was the perfect combination of sweet, salty and vinegary, and honestly she's right) and it only got better. I never in a million years expected this, but I gotta shout this off a mountain top, this was all just perfect. Absolutely coming back to try everything else! read more

Absolutely amazing food. Wow. We came in for our anniversary dinner and we're so impressed. The chicken dinner for two was perfect and a ton of food! read more

Stanley Supper Club - Sourdough bread and broccoli salad - Comfort Food Near Me - Stanley, Idaho

See all

Well we decided to return to support this fine establishment this summer on our annual Stanley vacation (52 years). We anticipated and planned to visit in person for some great food on their patio days in advance. Though we were disappointed the pot roast was not available, but were very satisfied with the creative and fresh items on the menu. We ordered corn pancake, fried chicken, and salads. All were fantastic. Our host quickly greeted us and kindly accommodated 3 of us and our dog on the edge of the patio and asked we keep our dog on beyond the fence of the patio, which we were happy to do. Our host without asking was kind enough to bring water for our dog as well. We loved the food and the overall experience. From the kind and welcoming waitress/host, to the creative food, the eclectic vintage dining plates and of course the beauty of the Stanley Basin. Try this place. You wont be disappointed. read more

I had one of the best meals of my entire life at this restaurant. It was over two months ago and I can still remember everything about the food. Seriously, just go there if you haven't tried it already. High quality ingredients and rich flavors without overwhelming or compromising the taste of the vegetables, meats, and grains. Lovingly served and presented. My sincere compliments to the chefs! read more

We stopped by on a Saturday night around 6 pm hoping to get in for dinner. The pictures on yelp and the reviews all looked great. Unfortunately, we never had a chance to try the food since the hostess wouldn't make eye contact with us or even acknowledge that we had been patiently standing by the host stand. I can completely understand if they had a full night with reservations or were just short staffed, but at the very least you should acknowledge customers and politely tell them the situation. She never spoke a word to us or made eye contact and we ended up walking away and finding some yummy pizza just down the road. read more