I've been going to Sicilia's Pizzeria for over 30 years now, and it's still one of my all-time favorite spots on Federal Hill. Their Chicago-style deep dish pizza rivals Giordano's, but with a lighter, less greasy crust. My go-to order is the stuffed veggie pizza (no mushrooms, add olives). The olives add the perfect salty balance, and skipping the mushrooms keeps the filling from becoming overly watery. The garlic bread is exactly how it should be, crispy and packed with flavor. The fried zucchini sticks are also excellent, lightly breaded and not too heavy. The servers are always friendly, and they recently updated the decor. Whether you're dining in late at night or grabbing takeout, it consistently delivers comforting, high-quality Italian food that keeps you coming back for more. read more

Sicilia's Pizzeria - Chicago-style stuffed pizza - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

I first tried the pizza here during the RI Food Fights pizza month, and fell in love with the cheese slice with a tall, fluffy crust that was served here! I don't know what about that slice style was different than a regular pizza that I ordered on my next visit, but I preferred the slice. There isn't too much sauce to throw off the sauce-cheese ratio, the crust was lightly baked so it wasn't burnt looking or tasting at all (which is common at pizza places in my opinion), and it was so tall and unique that I found myself wanting to eat just the crust in broken off pieces! (I never do this and usually hate the crust on pizza, so this is BIG!) The service is friendly, although the crowd around the takeout area by the door can get a little crowded, so you'll have to slither by that if you're dining in. The dining area is pretty spacious and I appreciate their late night hours (Google says they're open to 3 am, but you'll get a side eye if you try to eat here after 2, just fyi - I wonder if their listing is incorrect then?) The pizza is a must-try to me - and I'm saying that without even having tried their famous deep dish recipes! read more

Great pizza! We ordered two stuffed pies--one cheese and one meat lovers. Both were delicious, but the meat lovers was truly out of this world with incredible flavor. They are not shy with the amount of cheese and toppings they use. The only thing I'd change is adding a bit more flavor to the crust. Whoever answered the phone when I called was very helpful in helping me decide what sizes I needed. read more

See all

We got a Pizza to go. It was delivered. It was very good. I had never gotten Pizza from here before. We got the usual cheese and pepperoni. There was plenty of cheese, toppings and sauce and no odd gamey, tasting pepperoni, like some places have. They cut the pieces in kind of in odd shape, so they're kind of like squares of pizza because they cut them diagonally. Everything was good though I would definitely recommend going there and I will probably go there again. read more

Sicilia's Pizzeria - We got take out from there. The pizza has lots of toppings and crust was perfect. - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

Family owned pizza place. Saw the stuffed pizza on TikTok. Was good. Had a little confusion with the menu and she charged me but she ended up taking it off. Original- mushroom with one or the other zucchini OR spinach. I just got zucchini and spinach. Thought u can have all, but I don't like mushrooms. (Probably was my fault because I'm in a totally different state lol). Pizza crust was great!! Tons of cheese with great stretch lol. I'd order it again but with different toppings. Also tried my friends Alfredo, it was yummy! Creamy without being greasy!! read more

See all

Another amazing visit here!! It's the highlight of our yearly Providence trip!!! The food is always amazing here and the staff and SUPER friendly!!! Some of the best stuffed pizza and chicken tender ever are from here!!!! Planning our next trip as we speak!' read more

See all

Super friendly bartender, quick service, and really good food. I've been trying to find something that gives me the same pizza vibe as Ned's Pizza in Milwaukee, and this came sooo close. Definitely hit the spot and worth a visit. read more

Sicilia's Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

Second time at Sicilia's. Third leg of Lord of the Pies. Sometimes you need to go back to a place to really understand what it's doing.. The space hits differently on a return visit. That ornate tin ceiling isn't just decoration. It's the real deal, probably older than half the buildings on Federal Hill. Navy blue booths line the walls, brass chandeliers hang overhead, exposed brick everywhere. It's comfortable without trying to be. The kind of place where you can hear the person across the table no matter how busy it is. Started with the chicken parm sandwich. Thin cutlet, hand breaded, pounded down properly. The bread is excellent. Crusty, crunchy, holds together under pressure. My only gripe is the sauce situation. There's not enough of it. I'm always going to want more sauce, but this legitimately needed it. Comes with a bag of chips. No pretense about what you're getting. Then the pizza. And this is where things get interesting. The crust at Sicilia's does something I haven't seen elsewhere. It's simultaneously flaky and crunchy. Not like pastry flaky. Not cracker crunchy. Something else entirely. Like someone figured out how to cross a deep dish crust with a traditional medium thick slice and landed on this hybrid thing that shouldn't work but does. The cheese is good quality. Not trying to be fancy, just doing its job well. The sauce has actual character. You can taste they've put work into it, maybe roasted the tomatoes, done something beyond just opening a can. Still could use more of it, but what's there brings flavor. Got pepperoni this time. Simple choice, but it lets you see what the pizza actually does. The pepperoni sits on top of all that cheese, good quality stuff that adds some extra spice. The real story is still that crust and how everything works together. The flaky crunchy texture, the cheese doing its stretchy thing, the sauce with enough acid to cut through the richness. Our server was great. Genuinely friendly, attentive, helpful. The kind of service that feels like actual hospitality rather than someone working for tips. She knew what she was doing and seemed to enjoy doing it. Sicilia's has been here since 1988. They're doing their version of pizza in a neighborhood where quality and consistency matters. It's not trying to be cutting edge or innovative. It's just solid, generous, straightforward pizza served by people who care about your satisfaction. It's a nice spot for lunch or dinner done well. read more

See all

As I told the guys around the table, Sicilia's was the go to late night delivery in PVD. I hadn't had it in years, and I had never had their most iconic item. The stuffed pizza. Today, I changed that. I had never stepped foot inside the establishment before. I had always gotten delivery. It was open and bright. It was much nicer than I expected. Plenty of room for seating. Our server was fantastic, waiting patiently and offering guidance as we hemmed and hawed about what we wanted. Finally we sorted it out and made our selections. First, we had the regular pepperoni pizza. The dough was interesting, very soft and almost fell apart when you bit it. A LOT of cheese on this pie (which is a signature move here) but overall tasted like a good pepperoni pizza should Then we had the main event: the Stuffed Pizza. There were a few of us who had limited or no experience with this dish so we went with the classic Original, stuffed with cheese, mushrooms and spinach. When this baby showed up in all its glory, well it is quite the show stopper. At Sicilia's, they always serve your first slice of a stuffed pie. Our server expertly plated our slices, showing off the cheese pull for dramatic effect before sliding the pie server neatly along the edge of the plate for a clean eating experience. I've had other kinds of deep dish pizza before, but this was an entirely new and unique experience for me. The crust was crisp but tender, like a pie crust or a shortbread cookie. The texture of the crunchy crust is exactly what's need to cut through all the soft fillings inside the pizza. The pizza itself was like an elevated version of the spinach pie, a RI staple. But I think my favorite part about the pie was the sauce. I am partial to tomato pies because of the way the sauce tastes when baked openly in an oven. In a Sicilia's stuffed pie, you get that expensive without giving up your cheese and toppings. My only critique is I wish it had more sauce, but that only means I'll be asking for extra sauce the next time I order it. I had a fabulous night out with some dear friends of mine. It was wonderful to be able to experience an old favorite in a new way and it's a good reminder why Sicilia's is the institution she is read more

See all

Great food. Great bar. Great neighborhood! Seriously, the pizza is really good. Thanks!!!

We were in the area and were looking for some pasta or pizza and came upon Sicilias. The food was priced well and was very tasty. Everyone in our party got a baby stuffed pizza and we all took a little home. I got the original stuffed pizza and it was delicious. Service was good as well read more

Sicilia's Pizzeria - Original Stuffed Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

My waitress was phenomenal: such a very friendly, polite, attentive woman, with a constant and lovely smile! The eggplant was perfectly cooked and very tasty. The tomato sauce was thick and delicious and not acidy, the fried mushrooms were plentiful and delicious. read more

My mom and I have been coming here for decades since I was a baby and we have never been disappointed. Their stuffed pizza is PHENOMENAL. We drive 1.5 hours just for the pizza. Service is great too, and they renovated and beautified the restaurant to make it look more updated in recent years. This is absolutely a mainstay for us and I don't see that changing anytime soon! read more

Food is good, service is not good, came in wanting to order a drink and they didn't want to serve me one because I look "to tired". Again great food just terrible service, this place is better just for delivery, avoid eating in this spot read more

Sicilia's combines the vibe of a cozy neighborhood pub with the look of a retro trattoria. The staff are friendly & helpful, & the food is delicious. Their specialty stuffed pizzas do take longer to cook than standard pizza, but are SO worth the wait. Great selection of sandwiches as well, & some really lovely desserts. Don't miss out! read more

I ordered a personal stuffed pizza with artichoke, eggplant, mushroom and spinach to go. They didn't skimp on filling and I really enjoyed the flavor of the sauce on top. For me it needed more sauce and maybe ricotta inside to make it creamier but overall It was a great pizza and I'd get it again. read more

Sicilia's Pizzeria - Cheese Stuffed Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

Sicilia's serves, by far, the best seafood platter I have eaten in New England. This restaurant is my go-to spots for seafood. The ingredients are so fresh and the batter is amazing. They also have a really nice selection of desserts including banana chocolate cake and Italian lemon cake. read more

Absolutely the worst pizza. The dough was not cooked it was almost raw , loaded with cheese you had to chew and chew . No tomato sauce very cheap on the sauce also asked for paper plates and hot pepper flakes and got none for $ 52.00 . Do yourself a favor and order somewhere else . read more

Prior to visiting I called to confirm that that there are no peanuts or treenuts on premises (my son is anaphylactic to them). A man confirmed there were none. We were seated promptly upon arrival and placed our order. I also informed our server that my son had a peanut/treenut allergy. She reassured me that the kitchen was free of both. To my horror she came out of the back with a jar of jif peanut butter asking other staff who it belonged to because she may make a sandwich. I asked another staff member if there was peanut butter in the kitchen and she confirmed it was just in the staff breakroom. Our server came out and apologized and stated she washed her hands but would feel better letting the other staff serve us. She later stopped by with sodas wearing gloves stating she washed her hands but wanted to be safe. The man I spoke to earlier stopped by to let us know there is no peanuts or treenuts in the kitchen. The staff was extremely understanding and kind about the situation. I would absolutely return and feel comfortable letting my son eat here. Overall really good food, extremely kind staff. I highly recommend the stuffed pizza. read more

The biggest issue I have is parking. Parking is horrible. The pizza is good and the service is good. The ambiance is also good as well. Lit real clean. The bathrooms are extremely clean and it's one person in at a time. So as you go in you can lock the door and you can have it to yourself read more

Sicilia's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

Never take the time to write reviews but genuinely....I Was targeted for being a gay man, young men at the host stand were extremely rude and continued to look over at me and laugh which made my experience completely uncomfortable. I wasn't dressed exotic, I was not speaking loud, just a simple casual night out to grab some pizza. Terrible experience, would not recommend. read more

Food was amazing and everyone was so friendly. Will definitely be back again. Restaurant was so clean and great ambiance.

Stuffed pizza is amazing. It tasted heavenly. HOWEVER, a small one (A SMALL ONE) was $47!!!! Including 20% tip and taxes. Apparently the $15 price doubles when you select a small (unless each pizza doubles in price as you order online??). I will admit I was not paying attention when I ordered online. I then noticed the price on my phone while I was sitting and waiting for the pizza and thought to myself "self, I must have ordered two pizzas by mistake". Yeah... nope. Just one small where they tack on an additional $14. Honestly when he handed me the small pizza I was dumbfounded how it could cost me $47. LOL. Anyway the pizza was amazing. I will give them that. And it had some heft and weight to it. However I am not sure if it was $47 amazing. For a small.... A SMALL!!!!! . The taste of the pizza is 5 stars. The price is a 1 star. I therefore evened it out to two stars. read more

Went here for lunch with friends on a trip. The women waiting on us was super nice and attentive. She even served a slice to each of us. . We ordered the original stuffed pizza and two salads. The salads were very good size . The pizza had lots of flavor and was good. Lots of veggies and the sauce tasted great. I would recommend trying it out . read more

See all

We got take out deep dish pizzas from here recently. We got the meatlovers pizza and a veggie pizza. The pizza was pretty good though not comparable to the actual Chicago deep dish pizza. It also took a while for the pizzas to be made which is understandable. Overall good experience. read more

5 stars on delivery service alone! The driver got stuck in the snow on a hill (I felt awful because I didn't know it was supposed to snow). They walked my order the rest of the way... not sure how far it was! Food was delicious, and didn't take too long... not many great local RI pizza places deliver- so major points for that! Good pizza, good wings, good salad, delicious desserts! THANK YOU TO THE CHAMPION DELIVERY DRIVER!!! read more

See all

I rate this a solid 3.5. Loads of food on the menu, I got the flat bread and it was very good. Perfect amount of sauce to cheese ratio. It was also very cheap for a za. Bar inside and loads of seating. Waiters were nice and hard working. Hats off to the chef sweating in the back. #MyHero read more

Sicilia's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

I ordered spaghetti and meatballs with mozzarella sticks and garlic bread with cheese and pepperoni appetizers, and it was all delicious! For the price, I thought it was well worth it. My favorite part of the night was our server, Angela. She was so lovely, she complimented my jewelry, and she handled my friends and I, who were very rowdy, indecisive, and loud. I appreciated her patience and her curtesy with us. Will be dining here again soon! read more

Excellent food! Excellent customer service! Yolla was amazing and very hospitable. She was attentive from start to finish. She made great recommendations and we couldn't be happier with everything we got. Stuffed pizza was great! Regular pizza was also delicious. We also ordered the mixed basket and calamari. We have no complaints! Thanks Yolla!! read more

I love the Chicago stuff pizza at Sicilia! Everything else at Sicili's is awesome as well!

THE OWNER IS A COMPLETE ASSHOLE AND HAS ZERO CUSTOMER SERVICE SKILLS . i'm sorry but if food has one bite taken from it and they drove a DELIVERY order back because it was disgusting they should be understanding and not blame the customer for not liking their food .... first time ordering g and definitely last time... steak and cheese is a pile of salt they're pizzas are just pounds of cheese it's honestly disgusting how the owner handled things i paid 60$ and tipped the driver and he would only agree to give me 30$ back and was rude blaming me like the way your acting there's NO WAY U HAVENT HAD ONE COMPLAINT BEFORE read more

This is an old school pizzeria that has been a staple of the Providence Community since the 80's. I ate here regularly during collage in the late 90's. I was coming to Providence for a quick trip this was a must eat at spot for me. You can order at the counter or sit at a table and a server will come over to take your order. I went with the classic. A baby (serves 1) stuffed pizza with spinach and mushrooms and a coke. Soda is by the 20 oz bottle and no refills. This was as good as I remember it being 20 years ago, The cheese oozes and is not greasy. The toppings are plentiful and spread nicely! Thank you for a great meal that brought back a lot of memories. read more

See all

from the outside it doesn't look like much, but once i got past the bar this place had me feeling some type of way even before ordering! I came here specifically because I heard they do single-serving deep dish pizzas and I was traveling solo in providence. I ended up ordering the baby stuffed pizza with mushroom, garlic, and ham and ohhh myy.......it was heaven. i can't remember my server's name, but she was incredible and extremely attentive. i am so glad i got to experience this pizza! i definitely want to come back the next time I'm in rhode island. read more

Need some simple quality control on the fish n chips station. In the past I've been very happy with the portion and fish content. This time, not so much. Long strip of fried batter around hardly any fish, and what was there was tough and chewy. A manager would have easily spotted it and not sent it out. I picked it up so too late by the time I got home. read more

I loved the deep dish stuffed pizza! Very delicious. I can't wait to come back again! read more

Sicilia's Pizzeria - Pepperoni and garlic deep-dish stuffed pizza - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

Customer service was amazing..........I had the deep dish pizza veggie and pepperoni ........delicious..............I had the sex on the beach drinks soooooo good...... I definitely recommend to family and friends:):):):) read more

Sicilia's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

Delicious stuffed pizza! Will definitely be back again! Service was awesome. Everybody was very nice and attentive to everything that we needed! The pain read more

Sicilia's Pizzeria - Delicious stuffed pizza! Service was incredible! - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

I've been here in the past. I'm a New York type of pizza kind of guy. So stuffed or deep dish, it feels wrong. Good thing my new motto is trying new things. It's a small space, railroad style bathroom in the rear. The dinning area was recently remodeled. Can't say enough of how cool it is. Plugs at each booth for charging! They only have one server to take care of 10 plus tables. Wasn't too busy, but she was able to handle 3 while having her lunch. Kudos to her! Ordered the beer battered onion rings from other reviews. Wasn't awful just not as good as described. A little over little greasy. The ranch for dipping was a little tangy and thick. The stuffed pizza ordered was meat lovers(Sausage, pepperoni, beef and bacon) with thick mozzarella stuffed in the crust. It's not a crispy type of pizza, more of a baked pie type of feel. Extremely filling, don't under estimate the number of slices. As they are extremely filling. Ordered a medium but the small would have been fine. Overall it's a nice place with decent food, attentive service and updated dining area. Parking on the other hand, is street parking where available read more

See all

The pizza is on par with Dominos at best. Crust is floppy ..paucity of sauce that was bland - no flavor . Way too much cheese.

Super good food! The crust on the pizza was a little weird, but the pizza was still great. Prices were very good vs other pizza places around. Service was also great. read more

Sicilia's Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all