I went here to get a small pizza pie with mushrooms for dinner the other night. The pizza was the perfect combination of cheese to sauce to crust. And I'm a New Yorker so I am a big Judge of character of pizza. This pizza was outstanding and they have a lot of great choices. The service was quick and the server was helpful and friendly. Overall I give it 5 stars. I am excited to try more of their pizzas really soon. read more

This place used to be decent until my wife recently found a spider leg in her wimpy skimpy. Idk what else to say except *gross* read more

Caserta Pizzeria - Spider leg in wimpy skimpy - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

The last few times we have gotten Caserta, I have liked it a bit more....the bottom crust has been firm and crisp and the cheese and tomato sauce have been a bit more flavorful than I used to remember from years past. It is still not my place to go (it is my husband's) but not a bad place to grab a quick bite if you are in the area or are in the mood for Caserta. read more

Caserta Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

I usually grab Casertas to go - a square pizza w/ pepperoni, mushrooms, and olives. Yum! Nice and simple. Parking is pretty accessible, right on the edge of the hill. I'm not a big fan of tomato sauce, but Caserta's is an exception. read more

Worst food I've ever eaten. Extremely rude owner. Slow service, hideous tacky decorations. Nobody there seemed happy to be there. It's a miracle to me these people are still around. Just a bunch of blowhards. read more

On my god. Been eating Caserta pizza since 1968. Have not had any since last fall. Last week met friends for a pizza lunch. What has happened? Crust OK, less cheese, less pepperoni and smaller pieces and less sauce. Ends up being boring and missing the Caserta yum. Sadly disappointing. Hope it was just a bad day for the pizza assembler. read more

My elementary class had a reunion here recently. Why? Because this was our place when we were young. Every half day, we would walk here and have pizza together. The pizza then was as good as it is now. But what shines for me is the whimy skimpies. They are spinach pies with pepperoni and cheese - truly a nostalgic legend. The interior /ambiance has always been clean and inviting. They have multiple tables various groups. The service was great, friendly staff and helpful. Overall a great place. read more

It's an old school location for the best pizza on the planet. Never disappoints and always worth the trip if I'm in Providence or anywhere close. Make sure to order the cheese. Iconic taste. As my daughters said, the pizza is read more

Caserta Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

Best pizza ever! We shared a Wimpy which was to die for! We arrived at about 4:30 before it go busy. People didn't seem to wait very long. I will definitely be going back. read more

I took the kids in so they could experience the famous Caserta Pizza and a Wimpy Skippy. The staff are very efficient and their system works seamlessly. They restaurant is kept clean and comfortable. The Wimpy Skippy was definitely good. It is always consistent whether you eat it there or take one to go. I would love to go back there and make my own because I would stuff it full and have much less crust on the outside. The pizza is always fresh and tastes the same as the first time I've ever had it. It comes out hot with a think crust and the ingredients are good. I wouldn't say it's my favorite pizza, but it is good every once in a while. The kids liked it and we devoured that pizza between the four of us. read more

Caserta Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

Placed an order online, I forgot to put the topping I wanted. Someone called me immediately and asked what I would like, thank you for that! Didn't take long at all to get the food, also appreciated the extra care with the securing the food with the tape. I also love that they have a parking lot, most places on the hill don't. Pizza is light, crispy, and flavorful. I'm a first timer on the wimpy skippy, soooo good if you like spinach and toppings. Also, perfect size for sharing. read more

Caserta Pizzeria - Small one topping pizza - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

A real Rhode Island institution. Terrific pizzas. Whimpy skimpys are really good. Take out of eat in. Beer and wine.

A must go to every time I return to Rhode Island for a visit! Got my sons hooked on it too! Located "on the hill" in Providence it's my favorite RI pizza. Simple and delish. To me something has changed. Didn't seem as thick, less sauce, smaller in size. But it still tastes great and I will continue to be a loyal customer. Also noticed the Whimpy Skippy has changed. Always a go to for me, I no longer buy this. Bring back the original please!! The only pizza I will eat cold, to me just as good as hot! Nothing fancy about this restaurant, but it just has that cozy neighborhood feeling. read more

Caserta Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

Absolutely love this pizza place. The one issue I have with it is the type of toppings are very limited I got a large pizza with mushrooms olives and pepperoni. And cheese of course. But beyond the the only other option that I didn't pick was anchovies. Pizza is always solid here and when I'm in Providence I usually try to get a pie from here or twins. Parking is in a lot. Price is reasonable given the quality of food. Definitely will be back when I'm in Providence! read more

My family has been coming to Caserta for decades. The restaurant and their recipes haven't changed at all during this time. They have a very limited menu and follow an "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" mentality when it comes to their food. The pizza is thick and the sauce is tangy but they are best known for their "Whimpy Skimpy" pie - a seasoned spinach calzone with olives, cheese, and pepperoni nestled inside the most delicious, buttery, crispy dough I have ever had. This is the item to try if you are new to this place. Pro tip: you can also order your "Whimpy Skimpy" pie assembled but uncooked so you can bake them in your own oven when you are ready to enjoy them. They have a very large parking lot (for Federal Hill) and there is also street parking available. You can call ahead to place your order or order online so that everything is ready when you arrive. This place is always busy and frequently "sells out" on the weekends so plan accordingly. read more

See all

Stopped by on the way back from visiting relatives, and the place decently lived up to its reputation. The pizza we ordered wasn't the best, but was still ever good. It was skimpy on the toppings of olives and pepperoni, which disappointed me. However, the texture of the pizza was overall good and filling. They cooked it in a reasonable amount of time, about 20 minutes when it was dinner time. The service was quick and nice. The staff were very polite and quick with their work. Never had an issue with the service here. The ambiance was nice. It's a large open pizzeria with a lot of seating. Wasn't the cleanest establishment but not unsanitary by any means. The bathroom was very small and cramped, and only fit one person. If I'm driving through Providence again, I'll make sure to stop here! A solid restaurant with decent pizza read more

Caserta Pizzeria - Cheese Pizza w/ two additional toppings (Pepperoni and Olives) - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

Nothing like enjoying a small pizza pie with a friend ar Caserta Pizzeria! I was early for a nearby special event and just my luck it was nearby, so it all worked out dreamy. Friendly Federal Hill service and classic pizzeria vibe. read more

Caserta Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

Of course I always liked it alot and was looking forward to going there when we went back to RI fora visit, However what a big disappointment. It was May 2023, the usual people were not there instead 2 other women. The pizza was soggy and although I clearly said anchovies on HALF of the pizza they put anchovies all over it. Next time in R.I. I won't bother going there. read more

The pizza here is very savory and flavorful. Different from New York, New Haven, and Detroit styles, it holds its own and super satisfies. The service was great and the place has an old-school vibe. Highly recommended. read more

Crust was golden and had a nice crunch. The sauce tasted homemade and rich. I'll be back for sure.

undercooked, dry, little sauce...this place is not what it used to be. Won't go here again

Old building lots of character. The owner is an awesome guy. His daughters work here as well. So good to see a family business. Not a typical pizza place definitely different. The salad was good and the Sicilian pizza was delicious. Crust is perfect and just the right amount of sauce and toppings. This is a Rhode Island Pizza joint not New York. Your topping choices are sauce,cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms and olives and anchovies. This is a must go to place. If you are visiting here read more

Caserta Pizzeria - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

Caserta's Pizzeria was much better this time around compared to the last time we were here. The pepperoni pizza had much more pepperoni on it, the sauce was as good as it was back in the day, and so was the crust. We were very happy to have pizza here tonight. read more

Caserta Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza, large - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

I used to come here 30+ years ago when I was a student. It's a no-frills local joint. It's been around for ages. After all this time, I brought my 22 year old son back. I've always remembered the pizza as being my favorite. The place is the same... old school and basic. I was really happy to see that it's still there. The pizza was exactly as I remembered. I personally love their sauce and the crust is thicker than regular, but not as thick as a typical Sicilian slice. Perfect The woman behind counter was so great. I really wish I could get to Providence more often for this. Love the old school, authentic vibe. Stay the same, Caserta! read more

I've been all around the world, even spent 2 weeks in Italy (and a full week in Naples) pizza slumming. Caserta is the real deal. Generations, years, they don't change a thing. You go in, it's all old school, you ask for a mod (they will do it), but they look at you like "are you sure?" because they know they got it DOWN, Don't mess with it. They know what they are doing, it works. I now go regularly (when i dont make my own pizza) and surrender the ordering process. I know I am getting real pizza. Not like so many others that just have a pseudo Sicilian that is more like pizza break and nothing special (or some cases like funny after taste due to cheap oils - i won't mention names) but not here. I see some reviews say they have gone down hill from old days, or inconsistent, not my experience at all. Had my first Caserta pie about 50 years ago. I've never had a disappoint pie from them (but hey, it can happen read more

I've been going here for pizza & wimpy skippys for 50 years. I live in Maine now and only occasionally get to go to my favorite pizza place. The pizza was awesome today as it was 50 years ago. What ever their secret is a gift from God!! I can say the same for the wimpy skippy's. read more

Tried Caserta after a break of many years. I was surprised to see they now do online ordering, which is awesome. I tried a small "all the way" which is pepperoni, mushroom, olive and anchovy. I don't mind the taste of anchovies but these ones kind of ruined the pizza, making it soooooo salty. They were so salty you could even see the salt crystals on the anchovies. Taking them off left a hint of flavor and a little more palatable but definitely not getting the anchovy again. The pepperoni pizza was good, which was to be expected. The sauce is on the sweet side and the dough is bready which is typical of Castera. Overall pretty decent pizza, a good place to try every now and again. What makes Caserta worth it is the price - only $10 for a small pizza which is reminicent of prices YEARS ago. I think the simplicity of the menu is what allows them to keep prices low especially when some other places are charging double that or more for a small pizza. Very worth the price. read more

Caserta Pizzeria - Pepperoni, Anchovy, Olive, Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

Love it all Food is excellent been going here for decades Wimpys are delicious Pizza is so good read more

Don't ask for extra olives or mushrooms. You'll pay for it and then play dumb when you call to tell them it wasn't delivered as ordered. Customer service is horrendous. read more

Caserta Pizzeria - This is extra mushroom and olive?? - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

The Sicilian style pizza is some of the best I have ever had. The sauce & dough taste fresh while the crust is cooked perfectly & is nice & crispy & the topping are what you would expect. When you are in there, you definitely can tell it's a small family owned place in a good way. The service was quick & good. read more

This iconic RI pizzeria is a MUST try. I mean MUST. It's a thick crust pizza and it is FABULOUS. Caserta is the home of the famous Wimpy Skippy which is a Spinach pie stuffed with black olives, cheese & pepperoni. It's MASSIVE and it is $5.25! WHAT? Best spinach pie you will ever have. I HIGHLY recommend Caserta Pizza. It's not far from anywhere in RI ... it's an hour from one end to the other! read more

We have been eating Caserta for 30 years and kept coming back. We were there today and ordered a large pizza, a Wimpy Skimpy and pig in a blanket. The Wimpy Skimpy was still cold and the pizza lost the specific smell of spice that distinguished Caserta's from other pizza. The Pig in a Blanket never came when we finished eating the pizza. When asked about it , the woman at the front insisted that she already gave it to us. After checking, she came back with it and said: we made it for you again! Very disappointed after 30 years. Will never come back again! read more

Consistency forever rules this place and the pizza is very tasty, especially the sauce. Not a fan of Wimpy Skimpy, seems soggy. Can't go wrong here. read more

Haven't been to Caserta pizza in a few years due to being out of state. Went Friday night with 8 of my friends who grew up in providence. We had a great time reconnecting and we all ordered our own pizza our way. Fantastic! We also had wimpy skimpy spinach pies and I forgot how delicious they are. My only suggestion would be to add extra sauce on the pizza, especially the large. A few of my guests were disappointed because the cheese was melted into the dough with very little sauce if not any sauce at all under the cheese. That's the only thing I would change. We love it and the staff was very professional and courteous to all of us. We will be back again!!! read more

See all

Love the food here! Definitely a must if you're in Federal Hill. Staff is always so friendly

Take and bake pizza or have them cook it . Order 'well done' for a mind blowing crispy crust . Don't walk in here looking for a meat lovers, Hawaiian pizza , calzones or grinders. Spinach and pepperoni are toppings don't raise your brow definitely worth the trip. read more

Good spot for Sicilian style pizza (thick crust with rectangular slices) on Fed hill. Most places serve the Neapolitan style pizza. Limited toppings and quite cheesy, although the pizza is not as good as it used to be. Their Caesar salad is pretty good. Overall decent experience. read more

We picked a large three topping pizza. But I couldn't wait to eat it until we got home to Fall River , so I dived in while my partner drove. If you have acid reflux, this is a great pizza because it does not have a ton of sauce. But if you are lactose intolerant this would not be a good pizza because it is WICKED cheesy . I have always heard of Caserta Pizza but never had it. My partner has not hard it in years. She said it was has good has she remembered. Even though I love thin crust NY style pizza , I also love this pizza. I love the contrast of the crispy crust and crispy bottom of the pizza with the soft cheesy top. The pepperoni is one of the best I have had. Also the service was really good. Can't wait to go back and get one with extra pepperoni. read more

Caserta Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

I don't know about their Skimpy Wimpy wimpy skimpy wanna b wimp.. spinach just don't go w/ pizza/calzone if in me lifetime that I ever come back I'll try an actual pizza let's say spinach goes well in spanakopita or as part of bff artichoke doing the dip read more

See all

I will preface this by saying I've been eating Casertas most of my life. Today was only my third visit in the last year. I had stopped in previously back in February and March; both times the pizza I'd become so accustomed to was unfamiliar and lackluster. Since then I've found many other deserving new pizza haunts. Came across a gift card I'd forgot I had and decided to see if anything had changed since March. Went for my usual large Cheese & Roni. As soon as it came out I felt immediately bummed out because it looked just as flat and dull as it did back at the end of the winter. Like the last occasion as well; the pepperoni was not only ridiculously sparse, but it also didn't appear to be the old cup & char 'good' pepperoni. I absolutely remember their pizzas being smothered with pepperoni. No more. I've heard this refrain from acquaintances and coworkers about this decline in their product and sadly I really feel as though, like seemingly many places since Covid, that once great places to eat have now become quite bland and mediocre. The dining room is a ghost town but I'm guessing that maybe the other restaurants on Atwells Ave are drawing away business. Like so many other parts of my past that have gone askew or dithered away, I think Caserta Pizzeria will now too go that way. read more

See all