Order Jeff's Pizza Takeout or Delivery
Jeff's Pizza Photos
Business Info
Jeff's Pizza Popular Dishes
JEFF'S PIZZA ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Jeff's Pizza
Recommended Reviews - Jeff's Pizza
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
We easily found street parking at lunch time. You walk in, the counter has menus, the staff are friendly. You pay and seat yourself while they get to work. The pizza was delicious! We opted to share a 1/2 figgin bacon / 1/2 BBQ Grayson and we're so happy with the choice! We even enjoyed glass bottle ginger ale with the pizza. This place is great, the decor is unique, the bathroom clean, I even played the drop claw machine and actually won! We had 3 slices leftover to take home. Will definitely return to try other pizza combos and other menu items.
They forgot our wings. They didn't address it but they did. A 22 minute order turned into 35. And then let's talk about this wings. They throw them in a to go pizza big and just dumped the Buffalo sauce on them. No toss. Just dumped. I had a wing with absolutely no sauce on it. The pizza... 1/2 pepperoni, 1/2 buff-a-que. The pepperoni is thick but I did like this pizza. The buff had way too much going on. My mouth couldn't identify what flavors were being thrown at me and my mouth went on a journey. The place looks like a shop in NJ. I just think their 6 person tables were a bad idea for such a small space. Overall not a great showing. Pro tip: we took the food across the street to the Myrtle
** I felt compelled to change my rating from 5 stars to 4 stars. We ordered the same items as last time, the pizza was just as good, but the fries were inconsistent. Unfortunately, they were oily and burnt this time.** Jeff's Pizza is dangerously close to our place and we just tried it, which honestly feels like a mistake because we shouldn't have waited this long. I've been searching for the closest thing to New Haven style pizza and I don't think you can get any closer than this. We ordered half pepperoni and half meatball. I loved that the meatball was crumbled instead of chunky and the pepperoni was just crisp enough. The sourdough crust was the real standout, cooked just about perfectly. We also got a side of fries and our immediate reaction was, "These are almost identical to McDonald's fries." So good. Next time we will have to dine in, instead of pick up. The fresh pizza coming out to the tables looked even better.
Ordered Jeff's after a little hiatus and the picture says it all. I get that pizza can have dough bubbles (pockets? balloons? puffiness?), but my pizza had the MOAB (Mother of all Bubbles) which basically ruined the pepperoni side except for one slice. If you ever want to see visually that sadness looks like, look at my pie. :(
My favorite New Haven style pizza! The dough is a sourdough made to perfection each time with a little bit of char. It comes out of the wood fired oven super hot! I ordered a pizza with pepperoni, mushroom, and cherry peppers...my favorite combination for my pizza. The crust was fantastic! It is a thin crust pizza that takes most of the credit for this superb pizza! It will crunch a little when you fold it, but won't sag on the end. There is a light layer of sauce topped with bubbling cheese, cupped pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, and jarred cherry peppers. The inside is very clean and comfortable with a few arcade games to play while waiting. The staff are really nice and go above and beyond to make sure everything is just right. In a perfect world, they would move closer to my house so I don't have to cross the bridge during traffic hour. The only change that I could possibly suggest besides moving their business is to cut the stems off of the cherry peppers. I don't know any establishment that cuts the stems off, but I wish they all did it. Overall, this is my favorite pizza and I will be back stems or no stems.
The 1st time we went to Jeff's we were not impressed, I thought the sauce was tasteless. The 2nd time was much better. Last night we ordered a take out pepperoni pizza delivered by Grubhub. We requested well done. The pizza stayed hot and was crisp even though it was in a box. I would order again.
They have their own parking lot! Great slice for dinner. $6 cheese. I also got a draft beer. Over $15 after tax. Kind of pricey! Delicious pizza though. I'll be back.
Hate to give this rating. I wanted this place to be great. I heard so many good things. Start with the good: cool physical space, lots of hockey decor, old school video games, and pinball. The crust on the pizza was great and the ranch dressing was solid. The young lady taking the order over the phone was helpful. The not so good: sauce and cheese were essentially flavorless. We got a half pepperoni and half buff-a-q. The pepperoni lacked flavor throughout, just boring and not worth the hype. The buff-a-q was confusing and over engineered. Way too much going on and nothing tied it together. We ordered wings, when we got there the pizza was done, wings were not. Honestly seems like they forgot, but the didn't want to say it. Just tell us, mistakes happen. I could have had a beer while waiting. Waited another 15 minutes and got our cold pizza and wings. The wings although fried nicely were not very good. The buffalo sauce was pretty bad and the wings were pushed out in a hurry so only half had the bad sauce on them (a blessing in disguise). I may try again if in the area, pretty tough visit for a highly regarded place.
We recently got take out from here for the first time. They told us it would be ready in 15 - 20 min, and they were. The restaurant has a decent size parking lot, so pick up was easy. The pizza itself was very good. They only have one size of pie, which was probably close to 16". The crust was thin and crispy without being crunchy. The sauce and cheese ratio was also good, and the pepperoni topping was generous. I think we're likely to go again!
1 month ago
14 days ago
5 months ago
W.O.W. I travel extensively throughout the US and Canada. I love some great Za! This is great Pizza! Do yourself a favor and get here/order early. Jeff bakes pies until he is out of dough. The crust was perfect, great chew and crisp bottom. As much as I did not need it, I went for the Cannoli Pie at the end. Heaven. Great Job Jeff! read more
We easily found street parking at lunch time. You walk in, the counter has menus, the staff are friendly. You pay and seat yourself while they get to work. The pizza was delicious! We opted to share a 1/2 figgin bacon / 1/2 BBQ Grayson and we're so happy with the choice! We even enjoyed glass bottle ginger ale with the pizza. This place is great, the decor is unique, the bathroom clean, I even played the drop claw machine and actually won! We had 3 slices leftover to take home. Will definitely return to try other pizza combos and other menu items. read more
2 months ago
They forgot our wings. They didn't address it but they did. A 22 minute order turned into 35. And then let's talk about this wings. They throw them in a to go pizza big and just dumped the Buffalo sauce on them. No toss. Just dumped. I had a wing with absolutely no sauce on it. The pizza... 1/2 pepperoni, 1/2 buff-a-que. The pepperoni is thick but I did like this pizza. The buff had way too much going on. My mouth couldn't identify what flavors were being thrown at me and my mouth went on a journey. The place looks like a shop in NJ. I just think their 6 person tables were a bad idea for such a small space. Overall not a great showing. Pro tip: we took the food across the street to the Myrtle read more
9 months ago
** I felt compelled to change my rating from 5 stars to 4 stars. We ordered the same items as last time, the pizza was just as good, but the fries were inconsistent. Unfortunately, they were oily and burnt this time.** Jeff's Pizza is dangerously close to our place and we just tried it, which honestly feels like a mistake because we shouldn't have waited this long. I've been searching for the closest thing to New Haven style pizza and I don't think you can get any closer than this. We ordered half pepperoni and half meatball. I loved that the meatball was crumbled instead of chunky and the pepperoni was just crisp enough. The sourdough crust was the real standout, cooked just about perfectly. We also got a side of fries and our immediate reaction was, "These are almost identical to McDonald's fries." So good. Next time we will have to dine in, instead of pick up. The fresh pizza coming out to the tables looked even better. read more
Ordered Jeff's after a little hiatus and the picture says it all. I get that pizza can have dough bubbles (pockets? balloons? puffiness?), but my pizza had the MOAB (Mother of all Bubbles) which basically ruined the pepperoni side except for one slice. If you ever want to see visually that sadness looks like, look at my pie. :( read more
My favorite New Haven style pizza! The dough is a sourdough made to perfection each time with a little bit of char. It comes out of the wood fired oven super hot! I ordered a pizza with pepperoni, mushroom, and cherry peppers...my favorite combination for my pizza. The crust was fantastic! It is a thin crust pizza that takes most of the credit for this superb pizza! It will crunch a little when you fold it, but won't sag on the end. There is a light layer of sauce topped with bubbling cheese, cupped pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, and jarred cherry peppers. The inside is very clean and comfortable with a few arcade games to play while waiting. The staff are really nice and go above and beyond to make sure everything is just right. In a perfect world, they would move closer to my house so I don't have to cross the bridge during traffic hour. The only change that I could possibly suggest besides moving their business is to cut the stems off of the cherry peppers. I don't know any establishment that cuts the stems off, but I wish they all did it. Overall, this is my favorite pizza and I will be back stems or no stems. read more
3 months ago
6 months ago
The 1st time we went to Jeff's we were not impressed, I thought the sauce was tasteless. The 2nd time was much better. Last night we ordered a take out pepperoni pizza delivered by Grubhub. We requested well done. The pizza stayed hot and was crisp even though it was in a box. I would order again. read more
2 years ago
They have their own parking lot! Great slice for dinner. $6 cheese. I also got a draft beer. Over $15 after tax. Kind of pricey! Delicious pizza though. I'll be back. read more
3 months ago
4 months ago
4 months ago
Was so excited to try this place because I have heard great things but was extremely disappointed. Overall the pizza wasn't great and I ordered half figgin bacon with no onions and they left off all of the toppings besides the bacon. Not great pizza and kinda upset I wasted a meal here. read more
Hate to give this rating. I wanted this place to be great. I heard so many good things. Start with the good: cool physical space, lots of hockey decor, old school video games, and pinball. The crust on the pizza was great and the ranch dressing was solid. The young lady taking the order over the phone was helpful. The not so good: sauce and cheese were essentially flavorless. We got a half pepperoni and half buff-a-q. The pepperoni lacked flavor throughout, just boring and not worth the hype. The buff-a-q was confusing and over engineered. Way too much going on and nothing tied it together. We ordered wings, when we got there the pizza was done, wings were not. Honestly seems like they forgot, but the didn't want to say it. Just tell us, mistakes happen. I could have had a beer while waiting. Waited another 15 minutes and got our cold pizza and wings. The wings although fried nicely were not very good. The buffalo sauce was pretty bad and the wings were pushed out in a hurry so only half had the bad sauce on them (a blessing in disguise). I may try again if in the area, pretty tough visit for a highly regarded place. read more
We recently got take out from here for the first time. They told us it would be ready in 15 - 20 min, and they were. The restaurant has a decent size parking lot, so pick up was easy. The pizza itself was very good. They only have one size of pie, which was probably close to 16". The crust was thin and crispy without being crunchy. The sauce and cheese ratio was also good, and the pepperoni topping was generous. I think we're likely to go again! read more
4 months ago
Been interested in going here since Dave Portnoy came here a couple of years back! Very Friendly front line staff, cute but small interior space. As for the Pizza I would give it an 8.3, The Crispy Crust is the Highlight of the show as I'm sure other people have said. Lets put it this way, I WILL GO BACK! I liked it and I think it's worth a try! read more
9 months ago
7 months ago
2 years ago
The pizza was good. They don't answer the phone and I was going there for my uncle that is elderly and handicap so he is unable to order on the internet. So how can the community support the local businesses if they are not available for the high elderly community ? If they answered the phone it would be less people hanging around waiting for their food. Too packed to be comfortable. read more
2 months ago
1 year ago
Review of 08/10/25. Fun atmosphere and possibly a great place to watch sports. We ordered a large pepperoni. Pizza had a good taste and one of the better crusts we've had(slightly charred but delightful).Bottled sodas. We would return if in the area. Self service payment & tip /pos ordering system then find your seat. Rating is 4.5 on the pizza. read more
2 years ago
My self and the whole family went over to East Providence to Jeff's pizza over hype only reason we went here was be cause of Dave's review .... My score 5.7 .... Staff was nice service was good but there is so many good places to go to in Rhode Island the bar is set very high here in little rhody . The cool part is the old fashion bubble hockey game from the 80s read more
1 year ago
The pizza here is so delicious! It's very small but you can take it home or to the bar across the street. Bring quarters for the old school games while you wait. Helpful service as well. We Jeff's! read more
2 years ago
Got two pizzas for takeout. The fig pizza was great! Very figgy- not sure how I feel about the sausage on it as the meat, as that is a pie meant for prosciutto, but I appreciate their creativity. I didn't love the cheese pizza, but I believe that that may be a part of their pizza style- thin crust, heavy on the cheese and light on the sauce. Crust is very crusty, but not too hard. read more
1 year ago
Love, dear sourdough pizza. The service is amazing very friendly stuff and the place is cool, couple of old school arcade machines. read more
2 years ago
I had to try Jeff's pizza a few months ago because I heard that they special in a sourdough base and they got a solid Barstool pizza rating. We went around 6pm and figured we could place an order at the counter and it wouldn't take too long. They were quick when taking our pizza order and said that the kitchen was backed up, so it would take about 45 minutes for the 2 pizzas. In reality, it took a little over an hour. For me, that's what brings this down to a 3-star rather than a 4-star review. Being so ravenous it was hard to take pictures before tearing into our pies, but I had to pause for the good people of Yelp! I would score the pizza at a 3.5. The sourdough base was fantastic, and that's something that really sets their pizza apart from others in the area. The balsamic special was the perfect combo of sweet and savory and if I went back I would just order that it was so good. The Margherita pie is always my baseline pizza and that one didn't really stand out to me. If I ordered again, I'd study the menu, call in advance and then drive over rather than waiting as long as we did. Though if you're bored and have quarters the pinball machine makes for a fun distraction! read more
4 months ago
9 months ago
9 months ago
8 months ago
8 months ago
Portnoy got it right this time! I really, really love great pizza. Jeff's has created a unique style of pie that is supreme. It is wood fired so you get that char, but it's made with amazing, fresh ingredients so the integrity of the pizza as a whole is unbeatable. Super chill vibe in the establishment itself. Some high tables, some low, games and overall inviting. The staff are busy, but present. I'd rate this one of the best pizza places pound for pound in all of RI. Highest recommendation! Bon appetite read more
1 year ago
2 years ago
Kinda stumbled out of Myrtle's and was heading over to Red Bridge when I spotted the glow up sign in Jeff's window and just immediately got hangry. And just like Foo stumbles out of Myrtle's, Foo stumbles in to Jeff's. "Hey Foo, what up? Long time!" "Yeah, I'm jonesing for some pizza pie!" "Well, you know Foo, we have some good pies!" "Plus it's homey in here, nice calm place and warm from the ovens!" Foo just kinda then stares blankly and starts to sway a bit. "How can I help you Foo?" "Foo needs some amore and some Hawaiian amore sounds like my rizz right now." "Crispy like you like?" "After Myrtle's all I got is crispy, Foo like crispy critter! Crispy like Peking Duck!" read more
5 months ago
Page 1 of 6
More info about Jeff's Pizza
127 Waterman Ave
East Providence, RI 02914
Directions
(401) 537-7500
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
https://jeffspizzari.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
More Info
Health Score
Ask the Community - Jeff's Pizza
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
9 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
7 years ago
1 year ago
6 years ago
1 year ago
6 years ago
4 years ago
6 years ago
5 years ago
