Cancel

Open app

Search

Fair & Square Pizzeria

4.3 (21 reviews)
Closed • 12:00 pm - 8:00 PM
Updated 3 weeks ago

Order Fair & Square Pizzeria Takeout or Delivery

Fair & Square Pizzeria Photos

Business Info

FAIR & SQUARE PIZZERIA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Fair & Square Pizzeria

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Meatlovers
Jason M.

I was skeptical at first driving 25 mins to Bristol for some pizza. But this was probably the best meatlovers Detroit style pizza I've had. The sauce on top had a sweet savory taste to it and they weren't cheap with the meat on the pizza. Overall I was content with what I got and would make the trip again for other pizzas from this place

Lauren A.

I was in town visiting family and I already knew what I was doing for dinner, hours before they opened for the day. Fair and Square Pizzeria is on Gooding Ave in Bristol, on the edge of town so you can get your pizza while still avoiding the craze of the downtown festivities. I have been a long time fan of Riccotti's Sandwich Shop and had been watching Ben's journey with Detroit pizza unfold over the last year or so, when it started as Friday pop-ups at the sandwich shop. I have eagerly awaited the opening of the new shop for months. My moment had finally arrived. Inside the shop the ac was pumping (bless) and the staff was cooking up a storm. I got there early to check out the space. Blue and white checkered, with touches of Rhode Island here and there. You can see the steel pans stacked up as you wait for your pizza and you get to enjoy the delicious smells as you wait. My online order quoted my pizza being ready for 6:03 and on the DOT they called my name. I scurried around the corner and got dinner plated for everyone. We got a custom pizza with marinara and pancetta, plus the Pig Newton. The pancetta pizza was perfect. Light airy dough - the flavor of the sourdough coming through wonderfully, the crunchy cooked cheese edges, perfect sauce - savory, slightly acidic and herbaceous. The pancetta is top quality, the taste and crisp exactly how it should be. The Pig Newton had fig spread, arugula, prosciutto di parma and parmesan reggiano drizzled with balsamic glaze. This one two combo of sweet and savory knocked it out of the park. The brick cheese in contrast to the fig added a funky depth of flavor I really enjoyed. While I give Fair & Square two thumbs up, if you know me, you know it's my grandmother's opinion that matters most. Her verdict? "You can get this pizza anytime for me " so Ben if you could please be open Mondays, we would appreciate it because that's my usual day with her. For my pizza loving friends, don't let a silly thing like the bridge stop you from experiencing this high quality pizza firsthand. It's more than worth the trek to the East Bay! Come and see for yourself, you'll be quite pleased

Margarita pizza
Stef S.

I love their pizza when they were selling it out of Ricotti's and was so excited when they opened up! They definitely didn't disappoint. We got the margarita and it was fantastic! The quality of what they're putting on the pizza makes it one of the best around and the dough is phenomenal. I ordered our pizza online and it was ready ahead of time. Reasonably price, quick service and great tasting Pizza. So happy they opened and I can't wait to see their continued success!

The DELICIOUS Usual pepperoni pizza my favorite
Michael B.

I am now officially addicted to their "Usual" pizza haha..I have been at least 4 times in the last month and the consistency is true perfection and does not disappoint. The folks are super nice with great service and they even have a rewards program for frequent flyers like myself lol. Can't wait to go back!!

Meg M.

Wow! We got four pizzas for our pool party today and they were hot and ready in under 20 minutes. The pizzas are so flags and unique and everyone loved them! They were perfect for sharing, and it was nice to get a bunch to try. The new pizza shop is stunning and service was great. For a new shop, they certainly have everything down to a science already! Yum!!

Randall M.

I stopped in to Fair and Square Pizzeria before going to the East Bay Bicycle path. I ordered a Margherita slice, and a classic Pepperoni slice. My Pizza was served to me at room temperature. The Goober who runs the place got bent out of shape when I asked him to warm it up. The slices when warm were just average. No bathroom after driving five hours didn't improve my experience. Thank U next!

Cheese bread

See all

6 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

13 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ben H.

Ben H.

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 3
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ben H.

Ben H.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ben H.

Ben H.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

2 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ben H.

Ben H.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ben H.

Ben H.

Helpful 3
Thanks 2
Love this 3
Oh no 0
Photo of Randall M.
30
804
860

2 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ben H.

Ben H.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ben H.

Ben H.

Helpful 4
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ben H.

Ben H.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

27 days ago

The pizza size was very small for the price if $22. The pizza was extremely greasy. Will think twice before going back!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ben H.

Ben H.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

24 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ben H.

Ben H.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 months ago

This is definitely the best pizza Bristol has to offer. And they will text you when the pizza is ready.

Business owner information

Photo of Ben H.

Ben H.

Glad to hear you think so too, Anthony! Thanks for the great review!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ben H.

Ben H.

Helpful 2
Thanks 2
Love this 4
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Fair & Square Pizzeria

You might also consider

Pomodoro Pizzeria - Arancini

Pomodoro Pizzeria

4.1(247 reviews)
1.7 mi
•$$

I made a 4:00 PM reservation for two on Open Table…read more We arrived a few minutes early and were sat at a booth in the indoor dining room. We ordered appetizers- Arancini and Calamari. Both were delicious. I had the. Chicken saltimbocca and my mom had the veal parm. The food was delicious and we had no room left for dessert. Side street parking was a quick walk away. No coffee.

I'd always heard wonderful things about Pomodoro, yet it took me so long to try it! It looks so…read moretiny from the outside, but goes further back than you'd originally think. I love their Arancini appetizer - the sauce it comes with is the perfect tomato flavor without being too heavy on garlic, and is well balanced. The balls themselves are always so creamy and fresh. I've always loved my pasta meals here, and have sadly yet to try their pizza. Despite its small size, I haven't had to wait too long for a dinner table for two here. The food is always fresh and tastes authentic and rich. My only gripe is that I'm always seated in the first 'greenhouse' looking section, that only fits about 4 tables, and the acoustics are just awful. My boyfriend and I joke that we always seem to be sat next to the loudest and most insufferable people when we come here - you feel like you're in the middle of everyone else's conversations and can hear every word, and there's always, somehow, a person right near us going on some rant or political tirade, and to be honest it kind of ruins the meal for us. Due to the proximity and small enclosed space, it's impossible to tune other people out. There's also no sense of privacy for your own conversation, which always gives me the ick to have others so on top of me at a restaurant. Perhaps next time we come we just need to request a table in the further back part, and hopefully that would improve things because I do love the food here. Free street parking is not too difficult to find in this area, although you may need to go a little ways down Wood Street or even take a side road. There is a bit of reckless driving in the area due to this being a business essentially in a neighborhood, so be vigilant when crossing the street or picking up your order - people doing takeout have a habit of blocking a whole lane to put their car there with the hazards on, but it's a pretty dangerous and inconvenient place to do this. Please just find a real parking spot if you're grabbing takeout.

Photos
Pomodoro Pizzeria - Holiday decorations

Holiday decorations

Pomodoro Pizzeria - Arancini

Arancini

Pomodoro Pizzeria - Beautiful white lights at Pomodoro

See all

Beautiful white lights at Pomodoro

Pio’s Pizzeria

Pio’s Pizzeria

3.7(35 reviews)
1.4 mi

Today I picked up a Margherita pizza, half with eggplant. It was packed on a Friday night but my…read morepick up order was still ready earlier than expected - their online ordering process is so easy to use! The crust was fluffy and I actually wanted to eat it unlike most crusts. It was tasty and I love how they do the thinly sliced eggplant pieces, but I ordered this because the photo on their website showed more cheese than is usual for a Margherita pizza, which was enticing, but what I got did not have nearly as much cheese on it. This felt a little misleading and bummed me out, but it was fresh and good otherwise.

I was in Bristol tonight to help my grandmother finish her holiday decorating and we decided to get…read morepizza for dinner. For those paying attention - yes I did have pizza for breakfast, lunch and dinner today. After listing off the many awesome options this town has - Brick, Leo's, Nello's, Bristol House of Pizza, we settled on Pio's. Pio's is a pizza place born from Pomodoro, Bristol's most popular Italian restaurant, where the demand for their quality, hand tossed pies grew larger than the tiny restaurant could handle. So they opened a pizza and grinder shop a few blocks up the road. You walk into the place and it feels like it's trying to be a more hip version of a neighborhood spot. There's a small bar and a few tables for dining in. It was bustling for a Wednesday night, people were coming in and out to pick up dinner on their way home. Back at my grandmother's, we enjoyed the pizza together. The crust has a crunchy exterior soft and chewy interior. Holds up well, no flop for those who care. Toasty notes from the cornmeal mix used to keep the pies from sticking as they bake. The sauce savory but a thinner layer, I personally would order extra sauce next time as that's my preference. Tasting it you can tell they didn't just open up some cans and season it, this is a sauce cooked with intention, a deep rich tomato taste only achieved by simmering for hours The toppings are clearly fresh, no canned mushrooms here and hand cut bacon bits. The cheese was salty and stretchy. The bacon lent a smoky taste and the mushrooms added an earthiness that took the taste to a different level, various flavor notes dancing across your palate in every bite. My grandmother loved it, and I certainly enjoyed it as well. So next time you're in Bristol, be sure to check it out!

Photos
Pio’s Pizzeria
Pio’s Pizzeria
Pio’s Pizzeria

See all

Bristol House of Pizza

Bristol House of Pizza

3.8(69 reviews)
1.6 mi
•$

The service was amazing she was so nice and did an amazing job on the foo, the food was absolutely…read moregreat and I will be a returning customer as I have been for meany years. The atmosphere of this place is a kind mom and pop shop that try's there best to give everyone the best service possibl!! even if the customera give my server a hard time her deals with it in kindness and respec. over all a grate place and if you looking to get some good food for cheap you should come to Bristol house of pizza!!

Bristol House of Pizza has been a fixture since I was growing up in town in the '80's. It was…read morealways a treat to get pizza here and I loved the Greek style crust, the toppings, and so much cheese! When I saw that BHOP was participating in this year's Lord of the Pies, I was so happy to return here after so many years. Bristol House of Pizza definitely didn't disappoint! The pizza was just as I remembered it - crust was crispy around the edges, lots of cheese, flavorful sauce. It was really good! Service here is order at the counter. The person who took our order was friendly and efficient. We ate in the dining room, which has doubled in size since the 1980's, and it is attractive and comfortable. Especially liked the tables by the large windows looking out onto State Street. BHOP also always had great sandwiches, and although we didn't try any ourselves during our visit, the sandwiches that we saw at other tables looked amazing. Pasta and entrees are available too. They also have beer, wine and cocktails! So good to be back in one of the restaurants I remember from growing up, and really great to see that the food and service are still awesome!

Photos
Bristol House of Pizza
Bristol House of Pizza - Pepperoni slice

Pepperoni slice

Bristol House of Pizza

See all

Moving Dough Pizza

Moving Dough Pizza

4.4(40 reviews)
3.6 mi

Moving Dough lives in a converted house in Barrington, with a flag out front and Christmas lights…read morestrung up in the windows. Red bows, string lights wrapped around the frames. Inside, red ladder-back chairs, blonde wood tables, a pop art pizza slice on the wall. Paper plates. No cups, even though they sell 2-liter bottles with those 20 ouncers. It's really, at its heart, a nicely appointed takeout spot. A small space, maybe 20 seats, but friendly, the guys throwing the pizzas talked with us while they made pies. Easy, natural. Like being at someone's house. That's their food truck DNA showing through. Joey and Jay started making pizzas at backyard cookouts in 2021. Friends kept asking for more, so they bought a wood-fired truck. They blew up around Rhode Island and Massachusetts after that and opened this brick and mortar shop in 2023. We started with meatballs. Two of them in marinara with pecorino on top and fresh basil. These were exceptional. Tender, moist, herbaceous in the best way, seasoned like someone's grandmother taught them how. The sauce had real flavor, bright and rich at the same time. They were almost identical to Bettola's, which is high praise. Best meatballs I've had from a pizza place in months. I kept thinking these would be incredible in a sandwich or calzone. Then came the Sicilian pie. 16 by 12 inches, thick crust, split down the middle: half cheese, pepperoni, and olives; half grilled chicken. The crust showed serious color variation (gold to deep brown to char spots). That brick oven's running hot and nobody's micromanaging every inch. Look at the crumb structure in those cross-sections. Big, irregular air pockets. Wild shapes that only happen when time does the work. Not the uniform bubbles of rushed dough. Light, airy, crispy on the bottom, sturdy enough to hold whatever is on top. Golden brown undercarriage with real structure. In no way doughy like most Sicilians turn out. That 24-hour fermentation they talk about? It's real. You can see it. That light, airy structure leaves you full but not bloated. The pepperoni and olive side delivered. Good snap on the pepperoni, quality cheese melted perfectly, clean tomato sauce balancing sweetness and acid. Just fresh tomato flavor doing its job. The chicken side is where it gets interesting. Grilled chicken is the canary in the coal mine for pizza competence. It separates the pizza makers from the pizza fakers. Get it wrong and it's dried out on top or rubbery underneath because they don't understand that chicken needs to cook ON the pizza, not ahead of time. Moving Dough gets it. The chicken was moist, properly cooked, not dry or rubbery. They kept the cheese and sauce ratio the same as the other half, so a touch more sauce would've helped with moisture and flavor, but the fact that the chicken survived the oven tells you they know what they're doing. That's the New Haven DNA of the shop. The crust is a platform. Toppings get the spotlight. The sauce carries flavor. The cheese does its work. The crust holds it all together with that crispy foundation and doesn't compete. It works. I'd go back for those meatballs alone. But I also want to try their regular round pies, see what they do with The Hot Chick or The Tenderoni. Who goes to Barrington for pizza? Moving Dough puts it on the map.

Came and did our backyard wedding party, had so many amazing pies , nicest people ever. It's not…read moreoften you get everything you wished for and then more. I put their pizza in kind of an NY, New Haven hybrid, the best kind of pie. I would put it against any pizza anywhere!! Cup and char pep was my absolute favorite. Please consider this company for any catering needs! Thanks again from Indian lake!!

Photos
Moving Dough Pizza - Interior (limited seating)

Interior (limited seating)

Moving Dough Pizza
Moving Dough Pizza

See all

Leo's Ristorante - Lasagna!

Leo's Ristorante

3.2(186 reviews)
1.7 mi
•$$

Love everything we've ever had at Leo's. Best Italian in the area. Delicious homemade sauce. Lovely…read moreatmosphere. Good service. But it's the food that makes it.

We noticed Leo's once when we were driving through Bristol and thought it looked like a charming…read morerestaurant so we decided to make reservations for Father's Day. Our reservations were for 6pm and we arrived about 15 minutes early and were seated promptly as the restaurant was not busy. To drink, I ordered the citrus rush, which is grapefruit vodka, oj and cranberry juice. It was really refreshing and tasty without being too sweet. For my meal I ordered a cup of soup and the baked Italian fish. My son also ordered a cup of soup and spaghetti and meatballs. My husband ordered the shrimp florentine, which was a special. We waited a while and noticed that another table nearby that arrived later than us received a bread basket and their appetizers. We never received a bread basket and never received our soup. They finally brought our entrees. I told her she could just take the soup off the bill since we never received them. My fish was pretty good, although a bit overcooked. The sauce on top was very good. I really liked the spinach on the side. My husband's meal included feta, which he will not eat. This was not explained when she described the specials and he asked her twice what was included. He scraped off the feta and proceeded to eat the rest. My son said his spaghetti and meatballs had a strange taste that he didn't care for. All in all, we found the experience to be a bit underwhelming.

Photos
Leo's Ristorante
Leo's Ristorante - Lasagna!

Lasagna!

Leo's Ristorante

See all

Riccotti's Sandwich Shop

Riccotti's Sandwich Shop

4.1(188 reviews)
0.0 mi
•$

YUMMY!! got the spinach pie ($10) and it was so hot and steamy and melted in my mouth.read more

Went in there today was told it was a local institution. My girlfriend's family has been going…read morethere for 30 years. Did completely disappoint the Brian special, which is something I've been serving there for years, which is chicken tenders with honey. Mustard cheese, and bacon was not good at all. It wasn't chicken tenders. It was grilled chicken. There was barely any chicken in there. There was no honey mustard. We ordered a small Brian special a large Brian special and a large Italian sub and an onion ring. The order was over $50, which is astronomical. All the food was substandard. I wouldn't ever recommend getting it. I wouldn't have been happy if my order was $30 it was that bad and on top of it there was a customer in there from the area that was placing an order for the following day, an elderly gentleman and they told him his order was over $80 and he was confused and he asked for a smaller size as they said they didn't do it. They try to talk to him about inflation. Just was a good towel was a total rip off another guy went in and got just a sandwich in a bag of chips and it was almost $19. I mean you know that's just just ridiculous. Definitely not worth eating there at all ever.

Photos
Riccotti's Sandwich Shop - Renovated space is beautifully done!!!!!

Renovated space is beautifully done!!!!!

Riccotti's Sandwich Shop - Various subs

Various subs

Riccotti's Sandwich Shop - Bacon, lettuce, tomato, ranch dressing, and avacado spread

See all

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, ranch dressing, and avacado spread

Fair & Square Pizzeria - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...