I truly can't find the words to describe this place besides... ODD. I made reservations back in June, I believe, for my bachelorette dinner in August. The woman, Grace, who I was dealing with for the reservation was pretty on top of things. I signed a contract, paid a deposit, and was told to pick a menu. Everything seemed normal, especially considering the party size (8 girls). Fast forward to about two weeks before the reservation, and I still hadn't heard anything from them regarding our menu selections. Since it was a large party, we were required to pre-select the menu. I sent two follow-up emails and... Grace was MIA. I eventually decided to reach out via Instagram, only to be informed that Grace was no longer with the company. My first thoughts were: Why was no one else assigned to handle this reservation? And had I not followed up, what exactly was going to happen with our menu? Fast forward again to the night of our reservation. We arrive, and the place is completely dead. The hostesses were very welcoming, but advised us to wait at the bar because our table wasn't ready. We waited 35 minutes at the bar for our table... in a restaurant that was completely empty, BTW. During that wait, I genuinely felt like I was in the Matrix. The entire staff seemed sketchy. Everyone was just standing around with their arms folded, staring at us. Even when we first approached the front door, there were two men standing outside who I assume were security. I have no idea. They didn't say hello, open the door, or really acknowledge us at all. At one point, we asked one of the guys inside to take a picture of us, and the reaction we got was so strange that you would have thought we asked him to solve a math problem he hadn't studied for. The ambiance was okay. The décor didn't exactly blow me away. We were also told that a DJ would not be coming on, even though Grace had originally told me that a DJ would start at 9 PM. Finally, we are seated. Our menus were freshly printed -- so freshly printed that the ink was still wet -- and every single one of us had a different menu. The waiter confirmed that the dinner selections he had were correct and that the menus had simply been printed incorrectly......mmmkay. While our waiter was going around the table taking our drink orders, he would immediately forget what the person before the next had ordered. Strange. That being said, the service itself was actually good once we were seated, and the food was better than I expected considering the absolutely horrible reviews I had seen on Google and Yelp regarding the food. Then, a manager--or whoever he was--came over with a bottle of champagne. My fiancé had sent the champagne to the table, but this gentleman did a pretty terrible job of explaining where the champagne was from or who had sent it. I later found out that this was the same guy who had spoken to my fiancé on the phone and attempted to overcharge him for the bottle. The website listed the champagne at one price, and this gentleman tried to charge him a completely different price--much higher than the advertised price. When my fiancé called him out on it, he tried to explain that the prices listed on the website were "outdated." ......How is that our problem? If you have a price advertised on your website, that is the price you should be charging. ‍ Anyway, overall, the experience was okay. Not terrible, not amazing... just very, very odd. This place must have new ownership or management or something because there are reviews dating back to 2021, but their Instagram page appears to be brand new. I'm not really sure what is going on here, but from the moment we arrived, it felt like nobody quite knew what the hell was going on. I even began to wonder if this was a money-laundering operation because the whole place was just... strange. The food was actually better than expected, and the staff was nice once we were seated, but the entire experience was so bizarre and disorganized that I honestly left with more questions than answers. One & done for me !! read more

It's a nice restaurant with a great view, especially if you go around sunset. The live music was also a nice touch. I ordered the lamb burger, which was good, and overall I enjoyed my food. The only issue was that the mushrooms had an unpleasant smell. The experience, however, could have been better. We arrived and were seated at our table, but then we saw some friends who were already there and wanted to join them. Their table had plenty of space, so we thought it would be easy for all of us to sit together and enjoy the evening. At first, we were told it was okay, so we moved over. However, shortly afterward, the host came over and told us that it wasn't possible and separated us again. What was strange was that our friends' table clearly had enough space for all of us to sit together, but she insisted that it couldn't be done. We didn't argue and simply tried to enjoy the meal, which fortunately was good. Aside from that incident, this could easily have been a five-star experience. Great view, nice live music, and good food. The seating situation was just an unnecessary disappointment. read more

See all

A few days ago I attended a Dan's Papers event out east in the Hamptons, held at the restaurant here, right on the water. The weather was perfect and the views were incredible, I don't think I'll ever get over how beautiful it is out there watching the sunset. SiSi's provided food, wine, and drinks, and there were so many brands and businesses set up with mocktails, cocktails, food samples, and desserts, you name it, it was there, and everything was delicious. I tried swordfish for the first time, or at least the first time I can remember, and it was so moist and buttery, honestly perfect. I also had the freshest oysters, and tried Maison Perrier, a prebiotic drink that was so good. They also had live entertainment and music and fireworks, I genuinely could not get over how much they packed into one evening. If you're interested in one of their events, they only have a couple left this summer, so definitely grab tickets soon. This was such a beautiful evening right on the water. I feel like sometimes we forget what's in our own backyard here on Long Island. Ten out of ten, highly recommend! read more

See all

Lovely outdoor ambiance in the Hamptons. Our table shared a bunch of things and we enjoyed everything. The oysters were good and I loved the crab pasta. The scallops were the favorite of the table, but they told us it came with five and it only came with four. Since there were five of us at dinner that was disappointing. Otherwise a tasty evening! read more

Our dinner at Si Si was outstanding. We loved everything we ordered. We tried bread/truffle butter, pastas - fav was quadrotti, zucchini stractiatella was outstanding and had slight kick which we loved, and creme fraiche cheesecake was delicious and very light. Highly recommend this place for date night or celebrations! They even have events during summer. read more

See all

Si Si? More like No No. Really disappointing experience from start to finish. The host told us to wait at bar, and then 20 min later I asked him how long it would be and he told us a table had been ready for us... the bartender wouldn't make eye contact with us and never came to serve us even after I asked for the menu... completely ignored us, and our waiter was sassy, dismissive, and acted annoyed anytime we asked for anything. Our whole chicken arrived intact with no carving or serving utensils, making it nearly impossible to eat, and no one checked on us to help. Worst of all was the handling of my food allergy. Our waiter told me something was safe to eat, then came running back seconds later yelling "wait" and took it away. Thankfully, I hadn't eaten it yet. The courses were also rushed despite the restaurant being half empty. Unfriendly, inattentive service and genuinely concerning allergy awareness. read more

Meh. Just not worth it at this point. The interior is stunning and the restaurant sits right on the water but the food has been lacking through the years. We ordered the fried calamari appetizer which was great. It came with artichokes, peppers and tomato's. My spicy rigatoni wasn't really spicy and the taste wasn't a true vodka sauce. My husband's lam burger was average. Not great. For the price you're paying, you'd expect more. read more

See all

You book ding room and they seat you upstairs with no people nor atmosphere. The food was mediocre at best. Would only come for a drink. Do not waste your money eating here. read more

Good on a non holiday weekend. The service was good, the view is spectacular, and the food is decent. The chicken was very fatty and lacked flavor. The Wagyu Strip Steak was perfectly cooked. This place has no side vegetable options either the exception of salad. This place seems to be hit or miss. When it's not busy, this place is great. When it's busy, (based on other reviewers and my own experience) this place can't handle the large crowds when everyone wants to come watch the sunset. This place has heat lamps for those chilly nights after sunset. It has an indoor and outdoor bar (which fill up fast). read more

See all

The location is stunning, the best view in East Hampton hands down. Years ago when they opened the food was actually good. Now it is beyond mediocre at best and very over priced (even by hamptons standards). The service has taken a major hit as well. My Husband waited 45 minutes for a beer after checking in and asking many times. (Mind you it was a Tuesday night and the restaurant was half empty). Management was very kind and hospitable but sadly it did not make up for the overall sub par experience. Very disappointing as a whole. read more

We had a very disappointing experience with this restaurant. Due to an unexpected storm at home, we had to cut our vacation short and cancel our reservation. We notified the restaurant immediately, yet were still charged a $200 cancellation fee--even though it was a Tuesday night and the restaurant had plenty of availability. I made several calls and was promised a manager would get back to me--no one ever did. I also followed up with three separate emails and received no response. This level of customer service is unacceptable and comes across as greedy and unprofessional. I would not recommend this place to others, especially those who value respectful and responsive service. read more

this place is a big pass, a total has been...unless you're a large group and can't get a reservation anywhere else (there were multiple large tables set up empty ready for big groups). we sat out on the deck. the furniture was so odd. they had tons of those cheap white rental chairs that you see at a wedding venue around the tables. then the wine came. such a small pour and warm. next the greek salad with mealy tomatoes. then the lamb burger with a long hair inside of it. lob salad was ok...i asked for the bacon well done and it was not. swordfish kabob just fine. ugh..sry sisi. never again. read more

The view of the sunset and the ships were beautiful. The grilled chicken was delicious with the veggies and the scallops were perfect. The scallops came with cauliflower dressed in sauce and they were so yum! The dips and veggies and pita bread were the perfect starter. Loved our experience here and got great pictures! read more

Si Si Restaurant - Mediterranean Near Me - East Hampton, New York

So much wasted potential. This is a beautiful restaurant parked on the water with spectacular views, comfortable seating and really delicious food. The food and drinks do come at a price and that price is pretty damned high but it's East Hampton and it's the summer so it's to be expected. When paying north of $25 for a drink and $50 for a plate of pasta there's the expectation of flawless service and this, my friends, is where they drop the ball. A+ food with C- service. Our server, while nice, couldn't really keep it together enough to serve a second round of drinks or offer us dessert, hence 3 Stars at what should be a 5 Star place. Also, the pandemic's over and so should QR coded menus. For what you're charging, print a damn menu, put it in a hand stamped leather sleeve and hand it out proudly. No one wants to squint at their phone when ordering anything, much less really expensive food. read more

Si Si Restaurant - Mediterranean Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Great views but terrible food. Incredibly small portions and very average tasting. We got roasted cauliflower and tuna tartar. Didn't even order entrees because for the astronomical price, the food was not worth it read more

See all

My friend and I visit Montauk every summer and tried to get a reservation at Si Si last summer but they had a wedding the weekend we were there and we're fully booked up. We were so excited to get a reservation and probably the most beautiful table in the whole restaurant this summer. To start we got the zaatar roasted cauliflower at the bar while having a glass of wine. After our app and drinks, we made a tour table and we're so pleasantly surprised with the view. It's definitely better to wait till later in the night so you can get to watch the sunset on the water! The spicy rigatoni was amazing unlike other spicy rigatoni's I've had. Definitely add the lobster (don't think about the price...just do it)! Si Si was beautiful and delicious, we will be back! read more

See all

This place is beautiful. The main reason we come here is for the amazing view. The pastas were good, and we enjoyed the mezze platter as well. I mean food overall is average but good. Our favorite dessert was the coconut panna cotta. Our server, Janko, was fantastic. Love this place! It's the perfect spot for sunsets. read more

See all

Went to here for breakfast. The bread was hard as a rock. Food came out at different times for everyone in the group.

The atmosphere can't be beat. When they served my wife warm white wine and she asked for a new glass, the waiter gave us some attitude. That was not our overall experience with the service but objectively warm wine isn't ok. The mezze platter and frito misto were quite good as was the spicy rigatoni, but the steak tasted like it had been left outside for a few days before being cooked. A $100 ribeye should be flawless. They did take it off the check but that should never be an issue. This was our second time there this summer. Our first had some minor service issues but the steak is why I'm leaving a review. read more

Absolutely terrible service. Beyond rude hostess. Bathroom was disgusting. This is supposed to be a beautiful Hamptons restaurant. Needs new management. Food was average nothing to rave about. read more

Si Si Restaurant - Sushi - Mediterranean Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

They didnt ask us for steak temps and served us raw steaks that had to be sent back. After waiting half an hour for deserts and 15 minutes for our check we were told we had spent too much time at the table. We are waiting on you ya slapnuts not the other way around. Would not recommend for the prices the service was sub par. When I asked to speak to a manager the hostess essentially told me to f myself. read more

I want to leave an honest review of this place. I stayed in the Hamptons recently and found this place because it was recommended to go there for best sunset views. Well weather permitting, because the day of my dinner it was cloudy so no beautiful sunset. I booked the place in advance and wrote in the notes that I would like to sit outdoor since I am coming with a small dog. Then I tried calling them in advance to confirm but they never pick up the phone. Someone from their office called me 14 min before when we were literally driving in to say that dogs are not allowed on premises at all...even outdoor. I would have appreciated if it was done before. Nonetheless, we got seated outside on the day of the dinner. There was no wait time and our server was a sweetheart. He was very nice and made sure we are taken care of, although their service seamed hectic. Orders were incomplete and delayed. The ambiance of the place is great, it's very bougie. The outside view is beautiful, would be greater if the weather cooperated. Food...not good at all, hence the 3 stars. I ordered seafood misso fritto and everything was sooo salty as if someone did it on purpose. I tried to eat it but realized I could not. Apparently my husband who had the lamb burger was struggling with it too. The burger and fries were oversalted. We told our server and returned the food. We didnt want to cause any issues so we said it was fine that we were full already. And I have to be honest the server was great, he made sure our voices were heard and gave us a complimentary chocolate cake to go. The cake was not good either, it was not tasty. For an overpriced restaurant, their kitchen should do better. I liked the vibes, I would go there just for drinks next time but bug no to their food :( read more

Si Si Restaurant - Seafood platter - Mediterranean Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Sí Sí is an exceptional restaurant with sunset views. The cocktails are absolutely fabulous-- I highly recommend the watermelon high, but you can't go wrong. My dining companion and I shared the Greek salad and octopus to start. The salad is a generous portion of cucumber, tomato, pickled red onions, feta and luckily for us, not too many olives. It's a refreshing dish to open the palette during a waterside dinner. The octopus was delicious and tender, served with plain-ish potatoes and eggplant yogurt. The mushroom pasta is to die for, and my companion enjoyed the scallops with well-seasoned roasted cauliflower. He also enjoyed the pistachio-crusted cannoli -- I appreciate the creativity but not a cannoli gal. Our server was attentive and friendly. He gave excellent recommendations and best of all, he didn't rush us to order or pay the bill. Go to Sí Sí around sunset for an elevated cocktail at the very least! read more

See all

I've been wanting to try Si Si for awhile now, as they have a really amazing Instagram, and they can sell this restaurant on so many points. From the views to the vibes, the food to the parties, this spot looked like it is "where it's at", and for the most part it truly lives up to it. The star loss only goes for the price of the meal. This place is expensive, and I mean baller out of control expensive, like $25 cocktails minimum expensive, and this is lunch I'm talking about, Dinner is even more high priced. Yes, this is the Hamptons, things are pricey I understand, but wow! $200 for 3 apps and 4 drinks. This is high. Anyway, everything else is wonderful. We arrived literally at 12 noon, right as they opened and were the first one seated. The whole restaurant empty. So relaxing and so nice. Very friendly staff, accommodating and professional, helpful and personable, great service from Host to Servers. The bussers might have been a little rushy with cleaning the food, but the place wasn't busy so they just wanted to look busy. The food is delicious, the drinks are amazingly made. We got Tuna Tartare (A) Fresh, Light, Tasty and perfect with the chips. Zuchinni Chips (A+) Lightly fried, tasty dips, plentiful amount, easy to share amongst at least 2-3 people. And some Salad with Haloumi Cheese, so good, also delicious. The weather was gorgeous, the water views were perfect and serene, and we realized after finishing, this is a restaurant included in the Hotel and Resort Area, which we weren't aware of. So this resort has 2 restaurants, a Bakery/Coffee Shop, Private Beach, Cottages, Tennis Court, and a few other things, very exclusive and posh. So remember, coming here will bring resort prices, but also, high quality and top tier food and beverages. 4 stars. read more

See all

We came for a bachelorette dinner with a prepaid prix fixe menu and open bar, expecting a fun night. What we got instead was one of the worst dining experiences we've ever had. From the start, no one gave us a cocktail menu. Instead, the server kept pushing large pitchers of unknown drinks without explaining what they were or whether they were included. They were not. We were never offered tap water and were instead served bottles of still and sparkling that had already been opened and added to the bill at $40 each without our consent. Throughout the meal, the server vaguely said things like "I'll bring you some stuff" without clarifying that it wasn't covered under our package. When we said we didn't like the drinks he kept bringing, he literally rolled his eyes and brought more, insisting "these are better." Then, they offered us espresso martinis, which we assumed were included. They were disgusting. The drinks were clear and tasted like whatever comes out of a Nespresso machine after cleaning it. They charged us for those too. As if that weren't enough, they brought us shots we never asked for. They spilled one all over one of the girls at our table and then realized they had actually given us another table's shots. So they took the half-drunk shots and passed them to the correct table. No apology, no offer to comp anything. In the end, we were charged over $250 per person for a completely mismanaged, dishonest, and uncomfortable experience. Do not come here for any kind of event. You will regret it. read more

This place has a very nice view but other than that there's not much going. Bland and overpriced food. Would just skip if you can make it to Montauk and get a better view. read more

We came here for dinner the night we got engaged and the service was amazing from start to finish!! We were offered champagne to celebrate and the manager offered to take sunset pics for us which were beautiful! They truly made us feel so special all evening. The food is Mediterranean and we enjoyed every item! Beautiful place that holds such a sweet memory for us! read more

See all

Absolutely stunning views and stellar service. Enjoyed my day trip from Jersey city. Food menu is very coastal/Mediterranean vibes matching the ambiance. read more

Everything was beyond words. I am definitely coming back and is worth the 2 hour drive from my house. I was here for the weekend for my bachelorette party and couldn't have been happier that my girls made reservations for lunch here. The tzatziki sauce is amazing as well as the branzino and their drinks. And the killer view of the water. They even have warmers if you wanted to sit outside at night for chilly nights. And to top it off, our server Angel was literally an angel. We wanted to just invite him for our weekend. All of his recommendations were superb and his glowing personality made the entire experience so fun. He was one of the highlights of my bach party weekend. The only neg thing was that there was a bday party with a rude girl who was being nasty to him and trying get out of paying her bill. Angel comped her group free drinks and handled it like a pro but I couldnt help myself and had to intervene by giving him a hug and telling him how amazing he is as I was leaving. To the owner: Angel , along with everyone else there, has a very friendly and kind personality. The quality of your restaurant is perfection. You really have an excellent staff. read more

Recently opened, Si Si offers a solid range of Mediterranean dishes, indoor and outdoor marina-side dining, and interesting wines and cocktails. Reservations are recommended, although the dining capacity is pretty large. Hosts are friendly, and wait staff are cheerful and enthusiastic - but a little disorganized and slow still, likely teething problems for any new restaurant. On a weekday evening at around 8PM, we were seated after a 5-10 minute wait from our reservation time, and the table was set as we were being seated. We had to remind the server several times to bring bread, and waited a little for our drinks to arrive. However, once we'd placed our order for apps and entrees, the food arrived before we'd drained our glasses. Highly recommended: Chopped Salad, Bucatini Verde and Za'atar Roasted Cauliflower. Just ok: Seafood Fritto Misto, Spaghetti Vongole. Bread service (very dry and stale), although the citrus oil was amazing. Expect beautiful marina views, tasty food and a little patience for this new team. My rating is a solid 3*, with one added for the exceptional location and views, and the fast and friendly complimentary valet service. read more

See all

I really want to like SiSi. The location is great, the food is delicious, but the service and overall operation was questionable. The atmosphere: was great being right on the water. Sitting outside at sunset is a must. The music, on the other hand, had a party vibe, which didn't quite fit the style I would expect. The staff: were friendly but the service was not good. For my party, we didn't have issues, but multiple tables around us did. For a restaurant that charges a high price, it is expected that everything is available on the menu. Typically, specials will sell out, but on the night I went 4-5 main dishes sold out, leaving some tables questioning why they came. I understand selling out of one or two dishes, but certainly not what seemed like half the menu. The food: was delicious. The meze appetizer was really good, but $49 for a cold plate of dips is a steep price. The chicken was tasty, but the short ribs really were the highlight of the meal. The tenderness of the beef and the amazing sauce were a great combo. Like I said, I wanted to like this place, but the service and wait times were a bit too ridiculous. read more

Si Si Restaurant - Short ribs - Mediterranean Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

Overall very pleasant experience at Si Si. The food was not exceptional but it was solid and the spacious outdoor patio had unbelievable sunset views. The outdoor area was large and would be great for a big group dinner. Highlight of the night was the scallops! read more

Si Si Restaurant - Mediterranean Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

Location, location, location. This is such a wonderful place to go to watch the sunset. It's truly breathtaking. The service is very hit or miss and I've been a bunch of times. It seems like the restaurant just isn't stocked properly. One time they ran out of forks!?! Then another time the bus boy was running around looking for a Togo bag. Just odd ways to slow service down during busy season out east. I think management could work on that. The food is decent. Good Wagu filet, the fries were yummy too. But there's nothing green and fresh on the menu. Like a house salad or grilled asparagus or roasted broccoli. Just the lobster Cobb and some creamed spinach. Oh, And the sushi was served with no soy sauce. Kinda weird considering they have several rolls and two separate sections of sushi on their menu. Plus it comes with wasabi and ginger. So this is why they miss so often. There just not thought going into the guests experience. I hope they improve, because it's such a wonderful location with so much potential. read more

It was so much fun going to Si Si! Between the food and atmosphere, it was what I needed for our girls trip. Service was great from the beginning with the host staff and the servers were knowledgeable about the food items. I definitely plan on returning read more

Si Si Restaurant - Mediterranean Near Me - East Hampton, New York

What a view. This gorgeous restaurant is right and the water. The food is delicious- I had a lobster salad & calamari and broccoli robe. Everything was perfect read more

Si Si Restaurant - Cobb salad - Mediterranean Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

Waited 2.5 hours, mains never came, waiter was AWOL, we left hangry. Sad times. Horrendous service.

My latest experience here (I've been here a dozen times over many summers) was so terrible it is motivating me to leave this review. AMBIANCE: The view is TDF. Without question. We take out boat so it's so great to dock right there. The restaurant itself is lovely. Our waitress was friendly and accommodating. One star for all this. Zero stars for everything else. FOOD: The food was inedible. My partner ordered pasta was so *undercooked the pasta had crunch to it, the sauce tasted like it came out a cheap jar, and arrive barely above room temperature. Two of us ordered the scallop entree. Both so salty (and I like salt) that neither couldn't be eaten. When we told our waitress, she was apologetic and got us a replacement entrees. That was to be expected, right? The next one - also inedible. So salty that it clearly wasn't an aberration but some strange culinary/chef choice? Who knows. Then after pushing the inedible food around the plate, the general manager comes over to us and, with real sincerity, tells us that he will comp our meals. We thought he'd comp *all the meals. But only comp'ed the three of the four ones we could not eat. Still got charged for one of the replacements meals which was also not edible. As if *not charging us for their inedible meals was some sort of gracious act. Ridiculous. PRICE: Next, price. Fine. It's the Hamptons. It's peak summer. But $70 for one glass (on the rocks) of Casa Dragones Reposado is egregious. Seventy. Dollars. Single pour. And there are no prices on the menu. The waitstaff don't offer prices. And that's on me, too. I shoulda asked. I will never go back to this restaurant again. There are better sunsets and better food elsewhere. read more

I came here for a birthday and the server was very friendly and knowledgeable on the menu. He was the best part of the restaurant. However there was a clear disconnect between the server and the helpers/bussers. We asked for a straw and napkin 3 times to 3 different bussers and none of them told our server. We ordered the oyster appetizer which was very good, but we had a long wait for our dinner. Unfortunately our food came out with a large hair in it, so we sent it back. Thankfully the wait was not too long for the 2nd meal to come out. Overall this place has a very nice view and feel to it. But the service and food quality does not meet the price point they charge. The manager was kind enough to comp our meal with hair in it and offer a free dessert. But at a place like this , you'd expect perfect service for the price you pay. read more

I was blessed and fortunate that my daughter took me to Si Si in East Hampton this past weekend for my birthday dinner! OMG From the impeccable service to the amazing food to the beautiful sunset, Oh my God what a wonderful, wonderful experience! A big shout out to everyone, especially to our amazingly kind friend Luigi who made me feel so incredibly special for my birthday! Thank you!!!! read more

Always a must here in the Hamptons! They added sushi to the menu and it's great. Table of 6 everything was just perfect --incredible sunset!