Imagine my anxiety when I needed to make restaurant reservations for my two daughters' joint birthday dinner -- checking on Open Table for its listing of restaurants, Googling other restaurants, and cold calling even more, just a few short days before December 24, 2011, Christmas eve. Procrastination . . . . yet, in this case, my last minute efforts paid off.
The food at Shor American Seafood Grill at the Hyatt Regency Hotel in Waikiki was excellent. One birthday daughter (E.) ordered the filet mignon; at 7 oz., it was thick and grilled to smoky perfection. The other birthday daughter (N.) ordered the Grill Em + Fire Em locally caught monchong, with pineapple lemon salt on the side; the fish was so good that the seasoning almost seemed better suited as only a garnish. One other guest (Grandma J.) ordered the roasted monchong, with tinkerbell peppers, lemon chive potato puree, and asparagus salad; I can only assume it was divine since I heard periodic oohs and aahs from grandma's end of the table. The other two of us (C. and I) ordered the special, an opah fillet topped with two small prawns that were grilled and so sweet that they must have been amaebi, I swear; this dish was, in a word, "great."
The two desserts we all shared were unique and a fine way to end our meal. We ordered the chilled mango soup with seasonal berries. The mango puree was creamy but inexplicably light, with a hint of ginger that beautifully balanced the mango's sweetness. We also tried the house-made ice cream sampler -- a trio of bacon buttered popcorn, ginger lychee, and coconut sorbetto. The consensus was that the bacon buttered popcorn ice cream was the most interesting of the three, surprisingly good despite the image the name may conjure, and that the coconut sorbetto was the best.
There were only three negatives: First, the five of us were seated at a table designed for only four, so daughter N. had to position herself awkwardly at the corner between daughter E. and Grandma J. Second, the workers just could not figure out how to keep a nearby door leading to the lanai (which was closed off for the evening because of weather) from opening and shutting in synchronicity with the gusts of wind.
Third, while I really cannot explain or articulate the reasons for my feelings, the employees just seemed to be trained and better suited for a hotel coffee shop (which was the previous venue in the same spot), rather than for a higher-end restaurant serving entrees in the $30-$60 range. They lacked the panache that I expected from a restaurant of this ilk.
Overall, despite the three negatives, I give Shor American Seafood Grill an enthusiastic thumbs up!. read more