Easily made a reservation here for 2 on a Monday night, the ambience and interior was great! Definitely had good service but there were almost too many workers walking around at all times, it made the place a bit overcrowded. We got the mushroom polenta which was good with the bread they had. I got the cavatelli and my friend got the pappardelle which were both very flavorful! read more

Scarpetta - Polenta - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Had a 9:30 reservation for 2 people. Have been here on several other occasions and had been underwhelmed last time but looking at the current menu thought we would give it another try. Left at 10pm after still not having a table ready for us. Staff at the desk clearly didn't care and made no effort to make us feel that our business was important to them. The bar area was overcrowded and loud to wait at so we had waited in the adjacent hotel lobby. My advice is go elsewhere read more

Food was bland bordering on terrible. Very disappointing considering the celebrity chef. Decor kitschy rather than elegant. read more

Youuuuu guuuyyyssssss... this place lives up to the hype IMHPO! The service, food and ambiance were absolutely "CHEFS KISS". We arrived early to our reservation and were greeted with a couple delish drinks (Hibiscus Iced Tea and Cucumber Cruise). Dinner: The bread service was an immediate affirmation as to the amazing meal that was to come. Three different breads and all were absolutely delightful. - SHORT RIB & BONE MARROW AGNOLOTTI - RAVIOLI CACIO E PEPE - CAVATELLI (seasonal) Dessert: Espresso Martini (top 3 EVERRRR) Service: Felicia was so attentive, yet we never felt rushed OR judged for arguing about how we needed to get our specific pasta fix for the evening. Is this place hyped? Yes, 100%!, but rightfully so. They just do the things right, ya know! Don't miss out, Always, XOXO read more

See all

FIRST TIME IN NYC~! There's so many great places to eat in NYC. My girlfriend has this place bookmarked for a must try. We were both very excited since they have such great reviews and I can definitely see why. Our waiter was Alex, he was great. Very friendly and personable. Gave us great recommendations on what we should try. We also found out during our visit that one of the managers was also from Hawaii. So that's always nice to bump into people from home ;] I really enjoyed the complimentary bread basket they give! It comes with an assortment of 3 different types of bread, my favorite was hands down the Stromboli stuffed with meat and cheese. The basket also comes with three accompaniments: butter, olive oil and eggplant caponata. Very impressive! The Grub. BURRATA ($24). YUM! This dish was so perfect made with butternut squash, roasted delicata, apple, and squash puree. TAGLIATELLE ($33) Another great dish, this pasta was served with escarole, sofrito, and goat cheese crema. SHORT RIB & BONE MARROW AGNOLOTTI ($39) This by far was my favorite of the three dishes we ordered. Served with garlic chip and horseradish! A HUGE MAHALO to Scarpetta and staff for a great night and excellent customer service. read more

See all

Came here on a Saturday and was pleasantly surprised. The ambiance was elegant, dimmed, and inviting. It's a perfect place for a date, birthday party, or special occasion. They make homemade pasta, and that seemed to be the popular selection amongst many tables. To start off, we had the Faroe Island Salmon (4.2 out of 5), and the burrata (3.7 out of 5). The salmon was light, fresh, and mildly spicy. The burrata was made to perfection (nice and creamy) but I was offset with it being served with warm, fairly firm vegetables. For mains, we opted for the short rib and bone marrow agnolotti (the winner! 4.8 out of 5) and the duck and foie gras ravioli (3.5 out of 5). Both dishes were hearty in flavor, but the bone marrow agnolotti truly won the show. For dessert we had the warm pecan bread (oh my gosh, amazing! 5 out of 5), and the espresso budino (4.2 out of 5). We paired our dinner with a beautiful red wine, which tied everything together beautifully. With dessert, we had the 30 year port wine, and honestly it's the best port wine I've ever had. It was sweet but not syrup-like, which I appreciated. Overall, it's truly 4.5 out 5 experience and I would highly recommend. I know we will be back! Ps. They have an in house sommelier, in case you have any questions regarding wine selection. Staff was super friendly and patient, which we appreciated. read more

See all

Exceptional hospitality with fantastic Italian cuisine. All the desserts are "must have" selection. One of only Dining experience in NYC. Highly highly recommended. read more

Impeccable. When you want top-notch service and a luxury experience, go to Scarpetta. Their wait staff is so professional, warm, and accommodating. The food. THE FOOD. I came here with coworkers and a client, and we all raved about our appetizers and entrees. We had two or three different kinds of bread with dips, seared scallops, and roasted cauliflower for appetizers. However, the star of the show was the creamy polenta. Have mercy. I'd eat it every day if I could. The truffled mushrooms are fragrant and delicious. For my entrée, I ordered the short rib and bone marrow agnolotti. I loved every little soft pillow of it. The serving size was perfect, especially after the appetizers. My friend offered me a bite of her spaghetti, and I will say: believe the hype. If you're not the kind of person to order plain, meatless spaghetti because you can "make it at home" (like me), you will rethink your life after eating Scarpetta's spaghetti. It was so fresh and fragrant that I knew I had to order it the next time I came back. What a delight to taste something you think you know all about and be completely surprised. Nothing needed any extra salt or pepper. It was all seasoned to perfection. The staff was so attentive, and it was a joy to watch them all lift the covers from our entrees in unison with a flourish. If you love Italian food made with care, head to Scarpetta. read more

Returned to Scarpetta after so many years and had a decent experience. The new space is nice. Unfortunately, we were late for our reservation and got downgraded to a hightop in the bar seating area, but welcome to NYC on a Saturday night. It happens. This time, I tried: + Tuna susci + Spaghetti + Short rib and bone marrow agnolotti + Duck and foie gras ravioli + Apple crostata The dessert was actually my favorite dish, though the pastas were all great as well. Only thing I didn't care for was the tuna - it had raw veggies inside, which is great when you're at Beyond Sushi but not what I was hoping for here. Service was great. Not sure if I'd return, just because better pasta palaces like Lilia and Rezdora have since moved in. It's still a solid choice for the area, though. read more

See all

Went for dinner, definitely would go back! Sat inside but the outdoor seating also looked nice. Wasn't super busy when we got there (around 6) but definitely picked up later in the evening. Service was quick, friendly, and knowledgable about the menu. Food was very good and they coursed out apps/entrees well. Loved the ambiance, modern/industrial feel with lots of greenery. read more

Stromboli or focaccia? A bread basket that serves sensational Stromboli. I've eaten here two years in a row for my birthday and it's always lovely, this year dining in this time. Ate: Bread service Tuna susci Short rib Black cod Lobster pasta Valrohna chocolate cake Total $184 The short rib and farro was incredible! Rich savory winey. My susci was clever and fresh tasting but would have benefited from a sauce. Black cod is one of my favorite Manhattan dishes. It's perfect with tomato flavor at bottom with fennel. Also, delicious was the squid ink pasta with lobster combining flavor and texture. Portions are small here, but quality is high.Chocolate cake is a mini Milton lava monster. Pricey sbd worth it!!! read more

See all

This review is for dinner. This place is a vibe - upscale (not stuffy) and trendy. It's definitely expensive and probably not a place I'd go to regularly, but I think it's a nice place to take visitors, have a date night, etc. The pasta entrees are quite small, so I highly recommend sharing some apps. Ordered the below: -Creamy Polenta; this is a must and my absolute fave. Super creamy and cheesy. We ordered two for a group of six. -Braised Short Rib: pretty good. Burrata: pretty good. -Charred Octopus: very good but not very big so each of us had a small bite. -Spaghetti: this is a must - it's the dish that they are most known for. It's spendy for what it is, but it's delicious. By far my favorite of their pasta entrees. Someone from my group grew up in Naples and said the pasta reminded him of home, which is quite an endorsement. -Short Rib Agnolotti: this is good, but quite rich. The portion is very small. -Valrhona Chocolate Cake: yum! Basically a chocolate lava cake. -Pannacotta: yum! So light and perfectly flavored. read more

See all

Very Sexy date night type of restaurant and bar.. The food is delicate and delicious. Definitely a standout in the neighborhood.

Scarpetta is an all around fabulous restaurant. Service is top notch, the decor is rich and moody and the food can't be beat. It's an Italian restaurant by the famed Scott Conant but the menu has a variety of dishes including quite a few fish. Be ready to spend some dough here as portion sizes are small (probably the size they're supposed to be but not the size we're used to) so you'll definitely want to start with some appetizers and nothing comes cheap. Don't pass up on the bread they serve the table. The onion was my favorite. The Yellowtail crudo is a beautiful appetizer and just like everything we ate it was so fresh. You can really taste the quality of the ingredients here and despite everything we ate I didn't leave feeling heavy. The Charred Octopus was another appetizer that is not to be missed. It's perfectly prepared and served over a light sauce and little potatoes. The Mozzarella in Carrozza (fried mozzarella) was good but I think for the price there are more exciting things to order. The simply named Spaghetti with tomato and basil is the dish Scarpetta is known for. Don't expect to be blown away but expect a perfectly executed dish. I order it every time. The hands down best dish of the night was the Short Rib & Bone Marrow Agnolotti. The agnolotti was just so thin and light, like a tiny blanket enveloping the tender short rib. I could have eaten 2 plates all to myself! Honorable mention goes to the Ravioli Cacio e Pepe as well as the Branzino with bluefoot mushroom, broccolini, guanciale and asparagus vinaigrette. There was not a disappointment to be had, and I told you we ordered a lot! Don't forget to round the meal out with a nice glass of wine or well crafted cocktail from their exquisite selection as well as a dessert. The Market Strawberries with basil granita and cream was refreshing and dainty while the Lemon and White Chocolate Semifreddo was enjoyed as well. read more

See all

Do not come here hungry. Came here for the first time and I'll start off by saying I had really high expectations especially after reading so many 5 star reviews. First of all I want to say that the restaurant itself is very nicely decorated. Once we sat we immediately received the most delicious bread basket. Our waiter came by and took our order...he looked miserable, not once did he crack a smile. We started with the octopus, burrata and yellowtail. My immediate reaction was "where's the rest of it?" The portions were ridiculously small. For the entree I had the lobster tagliolini Nero- absolutely delicious, portion was perfect. My husband had the ravioli cacio e Pepe and I felt like it was too creamy... the portion was very small. My friend had the duck .. it was ok. For the amount of money they charge for these small portions you would think I would at least get freshly grated cheese. The drinks were delicious. I had an aperol spritz and espresso martini. I also tried my husbands almalfi martini - so good! But served in a tiny glass. We sat with empty drink glasses for about 20 min before we were able to wave down our sluggish waiter and asked him to get us another round of drinks. Dessert- the chocolate cake and espresso budino- both were amazing! Besides our waiter being so dry, slow and miserable the service from the bus boy was great ... wish I got his name ... he was so friendly and attentive.. This was definitely a one and done for us. read more

See all

This restaurant is wonderful. One of our favorites in a city laden with restaurants. From the staff to the food and wine you will never go wrong. If your a wine connoisseur be prepared for expert knowledge. Fabrice (?) was our sommelier and his recommendations were perfect. I have done both business & leisure dinners here and never have to worry. Bravo & thank you Scarpetta. read more

LDV Hospitality and Scarpetta NYC present 'VINVIVO', a series of interactive wine classes by Alessio de Sensi. Excellent event, informative, delicious and palette enhancing. Well done! read more

See all

Scarpetta was a very unique dining experience. The quality of the service and the presentation of the food makes this place one of the great Italian restaurants in the city. A friend and I decided to give Scarpetta a shot during NY Restaurant Week and loved the diversity of the courses. I had heard Scarpetta was famous for its classic spaghetti and was shocked that such a simple dish could be so good. Scarpetta definitely nailed this dish and I would come back just for this, presentation, flavor, and all. Definitely add Scarpetta to your list if you want some higher end italian dining, plus reservations aren't too hard to get. read more

See all

What a phenomenal experience. Just like 10 years ago in Beverly Hills. This is an absolute must visit gem in NYC. Had the house salad which was a great start. The bread was unreal including a stromboli style I could munch on for hours & hours & hours & ... Finished with the marscapone Panna Cotta. Another elevation of a rather simple dish. Everything was fabulous. Highly recommend a visit if you're in Manhattan. Be prepared to be blown away with food and service. Shout-out to the guys behind the bar. It was too busy to interrupt to ask their names as I left. But they're timely, helpful & with personality. Fun visit. read more

Scarpetta - Bread assortment including a sublime stromboli style - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Food was exquisite! Good portions and we all left happy with what we chose. The service, not so much. Eric was our server and he's a great one on paper; very knowledgeable of the menu, helpful on popular items, etc. However, I've never dined out before, spending $900+ dollars on a meal to be met with such rude commentary and side remarks. I think he may just think he's funny (he's not) but excuse my language, frankly the guy was a di*k. It's a bummer because outside of Eric's sassy/ smart remarks and jokes that simply couldn't land (completely targeted and full of aggression) I would maybe have returned. I feel like they should certainly vet the staff better. At their price point, we're there for a great meal. Not to be treated poorly. If he's looking to do standup he should find a new job but let's not test it out on unwanting customers by being a smart ass. Extremely disappointed, and they should absolutely keep Eric off the floor, at least until he knows how to treat his customers with respect. read more

One of the non appreciated Italian places. Excellent pastas . Great entrees . Fantastic service . The only off thing is that the place is so dated . Feel like mid 70's . read more

It was just a wonderful evening. From the moment we were greeted by the hosts, drinks with the bartender to the table with Allie as our server. She was splendid. She knows the menu and understands how to recommend dishes and wine. She and the entire staff made everything seamless. The food was one of the best meals we've had and we eat out at least twice a week. read more

Overall nice experience. Positives: Friendly attentive staff Beautiful inside & out Well presented food Water glasses kept full :) Amazing complimentary bread & condiments Extensive inclusive menu Negatives: Small food portions 1/4 glass of wine for $20 Food was tasty but not excellent Restroom very far & hard to find Tables pretty close to each other I recommend but don't need to return. read more

See all

I've been here twice, and both times I've arrived on time for my reservation only to have to wait too long to be seated. The first time I came here, I had a reservation for 2, and it took over 30 minutes to be seated. The waiting area is just the super noisy and crowded bar up front with no where to sit since it's so crowded. The second time I came, I had a reservation for 3, we arrived on time, and we still had to wait 15 minutes to be seated despite the table we eventually were seated at being empty and ready the whole time we were waiting. On top of this, the hostesses are unfriendly and not very helpful. I walked up to the counter to let them know my whole party had arrived, and one of the girls who wasn't doing anything was just staring into the distance for a couple of minutes before acknowledging me while the other girl was busy. The hostesses have been unfriendly and unhelpful both times I have visited. Now onto the food. The food here is actually quite nice despite being extremely overpriced. The main gripes I have with this place are about the service. The first time I came, our server was excellent, checked in on us a few times, and very helpfully explained the menu to us. I never felt like anything took too long the first time. The second time I came, the service was friendly but extremely slow. It took a while for them to take our order, then the appetizers came out quickly, but the entrees took an extremely long time to come out. Overall, the food is decent but quite overpriced. I wouldn't come here if you aren't planning on spending a very long time here because the service from the initial wait for a table to the dining is extremely slow. read more

Food 7/10 Honestly really solid appetizers and the wine was decent too. I got the bone marrow pasta, and I think it was a bit too al dente for me. The portion sizes are surprisingly very small, so even though I was full, my little brother definitely wasn't. The octopus stood out, but the chocolate cake at the end was way too dry. Atmosphere 6/10 Cool vibes, but it was really loud, so I could barely hear my family. Service 7/10 Nothing bad, nothing mind-blowingly good, they did their job. read more

Service was exceptional. Food was teeny-tiny but pretty good. Short Rib pasta was tasty appetizer size portion. Black cod was bait-sized but also decent. We had several apps and entrees and dessert and stopped for pizza on the way home. Very nice experience. The bar is comfortable as well. We probably wouldn't return but I don't regret trying them out. Overall it was a good experience. read more

Awesome atmosphere & food. Might be the best scallop I've ever eaten, pretty sure my wife would agree. Great food just small portions in both appetizers & main course but it is delicious! Place was packed and that was a Wednesday at 8:00pm but just added to the experience. read more

Very nice decor with a wonderful staff who was very attentive. The food was good but not great. They tried to put creat something different with their own style but fast is not on point. Flavor was bland on the sea bass, duck was good temperature but the sauce flavor did enhance the duck. The razor clam was a disaster. 3 razor clams chopped into pieces made into a ceviche and served back on shell. Polenta was good, came with a mushroom sauce. Nice presentation but food is missing the spark. If your looking for a dating location this has a nice ambience. read more

See all

The restaurant is connected to a hotel and the restrooms are a bit inconvenient to get to since they're down stairs pass the hotel lobby. The place was jam pack. Tables are close to one another and the placement was inconvenient for my partner who kept getting bumped into when servers and other guests walked by. I'm average size and there was barely any room to put my jacket down in the booth without touching the party sitting next to us, so it was uncomfortable. The food is pretty good here, we made reservations almost two weeks in advance for a Saturday night spot. Octopus was really tender, and perfectly cooked. Black ink pasta was also really good, not salty at all as you would find at some places. The duck to me was the least impressive dish we ordered tonight. Fat and everything was rendered down well, but it was just not impressive. Cocktails were not great... this place has an extensive wine list and wine cellar, so stick with that. read more

See all

The food is good, but the portions are tiny for the price and the service is decent but not amazing. I'm not sure what I was expecting, but it's a bit underwhelming for the price point in my opinion. It is beautiful inside tho, a nice atmosphere, very loud though so heads up there. read more

See all

Nice Italian restaurant inside a hotel. Good ambiance. Very chill. Service is great. Food is good. Small portions tho.

long time waiting, I FINALLY tried this place and it did NOT disappoint!! Outstanding service, delicious food, and beautiful environment. Started lunch at 11:30am and didn't leave until 2:45pm. I was shocked then did not rush one course and they didn't try to kick us out because it was packed by the time we left. I can't wait to bring my boyfriend. Eat time we ordered was absolutely delicious. read more

See all

I've been wanting to come here for dinner for a long time. A good friend made reservations here for my birthday and we all go dolled up to go. Covid times means there is both indoor and outdoor seating. The set up outside is really romantic, reminds me of al fresco dining in Europe. We had a table reserved indoors and each table was separated by a clear plastic divider. The tasteful decor inside was such that the plastic dividers didn't take away from the ambiance. The low lighting and music was flattering and relaxing. For appetizers, we ordered to share the charred octopus and the polenta. Both were delicious. The octopus was tender and had a nice char and the right amount of tender chewiness. I wish there was more! The polenta was buttery and creamy. Also, the bread for the table was really good (especially the cheese + salami bread). I ordered the LOBSTER TAGLIOLINI NERO and really enjoyed the dish. I wish the lobster pieces were bigger because they got lost in the taste of the sauce and pasta. I was able to try the SHORT RIB & BONE MARROW AGNOLOTTI (I wish I had ordered this instead because it was so rich and savory and the taste lingered after you swallowed the last bite!) and the DUCK & FOIE GRAS RAVIOLI (absolutely mouthwatering, literally that first bite flooded my mouth and taste buds went crazy!) from my girlfriends' orders. For dessert we shared the ESPRESSO BUDINO and the COCONUT PANNA COTTA... the budino was really good even though I am not a huge fan of coffee. I still enjoyed the sharp, distinct taste. The panna cotta was MAGIC. I can't resist a good panna cotta and this was no exception. It was sooo creamy and the perfect hint of coconut. Definitely would come back here just to order the panna cotta! read more

See all

Dined at Scarpetta for the first time and it did not disappoint! The food was incredible and our server was excellent and so attentive! He could tell that I didn't love my wine so suggested another one and brought me a different glass of wine. We started with the BLACK BASS: lemon confit, pink peppercorn, ikraa caviar, dill, and the Market salad and for dinner: the spaghetti (best spaghetti ever!) and the PAPPARDELLE with rabbit ragu, kale, gremolata, mint and the BLACK COD with caramelized fennel, concentrated tomato. Food was 10/10, service was 12/10 (so good) and the vibes were amazing. Would definitely go back again and again. read more

Scarpetta - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great ambiance. Food was pretty good. Saw some groups of people celebrating an occasion. A more formal restaurant with a more business casual or business attire. The scallops were probably the most memorable dish as they were super tender and cooked perfectly. Short rib and bone marrow Agnolotti was very rich and creamy but a little bit too sweet in my opinion. I was also really excited to try the Spaghetti but didn't think it was worth all the hype. Service was fantastic but got a little bit slow at the end as they were getting ready to close which was not an issue at all. Overall good solid choice if you are looking to celebrate an occasion and looking for a better dining experience. read more

See all

Was really looking forward to having dinner here. It had been on my list of places to check out in NYC for the longest time but unfortunately, it really wasn't a good meal. Heard great things about the bread basket but it was pretty average. The dips were yummy - particularly the eggplant + whipped butter. We started off with the scallops and the yellowtail. They weren't bad - the yellowtail was pretty good and seasoned well. What was the most disappointing was the entrees. We had spaghetti with tomato and basil as well as lobster pasta. The spaghetti tasted like something I could make in my own kitchen with canned tomatoes. This was apparently the most famous dish they had at the restaurant. I was hesitant to order it because it sounded so simple but it really didn't live up to the hype. I ended up telling the server I wasn't the biggest fan and he replaced it with a cod dish, free of charge. This also ended up being pretty average. The server was very friendly but couldn't give us a straight answer on if we ordered enough food or not. The dessert was yummy. We had the chocolate molten cake with ice cream. The toffee on this dish was delicious. We ended up spending almost $300 for this meal and that's what upsets me the most because it definitely wasn't worth the money. Overall I don't recommend this place, sorry Tik Tok. read more

See all

So pretty inside this restaurant. The lights are dimmed and the rooms are perfectly lit. it's cozy and intimate. very expensive and upscale but the food is very good nonetheless. the service is at a european pace but the staff is nice nonetheless. i would definitely go back. esp for a nice date! read more

The food was so good here! I had the cacio e pepe ravioli and tomato and basil spaghetti. My server, Indira was so sweet and helpful especially when it came to figuring out what I wanted. I had an amaretto sour! The bread here is soo good. The vibe is cozy and perfect for date night. Love that there's a hotel just downstairs if you just want to crash and get a room for the night! The convenience! Make a reservation read more

See all

Upscale bar / restaurant located in the hospitable James Hotel. Came here for a week day lunch. They have a tremendous wine selection. I opted for a glass of Chianti. Great selection of whiskeys too. The bar is very nice. For food, they started us off with complimentary bread basket - too rare these days. The complimentary breads were great and came with oil, sauce, and cheese for dipping. I had the spaghetti as my main entree. Everything was made from scratch. The spaghetti was on the rich and yolky. Great dish but pricey at about $30. Service was very attentive. Restrooms were located inside the hotel. A bit of a walk to get to. They were gendered. read more

We love to come here for a late dinner and order the charred octopus to start. Service is excellent and the food is very fresh and delicious! Scarpetta has a great menu. read more

Scarpetta - Octopus - Italian Near Me - New York, New York