I'm a slut for New York style and this pizza is S tier. We got the spicy ultimate? Had pepperoni, gyro meat, jalapeños, ground beef. They did NOT skimp out on toppings what so ever. Gyro on pizza??? Who knew. The garlic BREADSTICKS?!?! One of the best things I've eaten stg. I wish I had more to say about this place besides straight GAS. Pizza TASTE 8.3/10 New York Slice 9.8/10 (Would be a 10 if it was actually from NY) Breadsticks 11/10 read more

This place is open late into the night and right around the corner from the Gay 90s and next to Sneaky Pete's. My friends and I were hungry after a night out and swung by here. First impressions were not so good, the pizza cheese looked hardened from sitting on the counter as everything was pre-prepped. We weren't allowed to sit down as one of the staff members said that seating was closed for seating at 1AM but it says they're open for at least a few more hours after 1AM? Prices are pretty high as well. However, they pass the pizza through the oven before serving it and I will say that it was pretty good. The crunch of our pizzas was insane and I did enjoy having a bite or two. read more

At 2am, this is a fine option. The pizza is... pizza. But nothing to go out of your way for. It's also priced a bit high for MN (this is coming from a San Diegan). A friend got the calzone, my advice is to skip that because it is pricey. Also, skip the ranch. For the Midwest, it was really disappointing. read more

Sal's on Fifth - Mac and Cheese Pizza with Breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Minneapolis, Minnesota

See all

Great late-night pizza spot next to the bars downtown! Pizza was definitely solid for Minneapolis standards and each slice comes with a big packet of ranch for free definitely midwest haha. A little pricey but understandable for being a late night drink option. Worth it in my option for what it is. read more

Pizza slice is very expensive.....but it's good. Is it worth it? Sometimes. Virtually no place to sit, no public restroom, so I wouldn't exactly say it was an inviting place to be. But have been occasions when I swore this was the best pizza in all of Minneapolis read more

Sal's on Fifth - Cheese slice, macaroni - Pizza Near Me - Minneapolis, Minnesota

Pizza was fine, nothing to ride home about. Slice prices are pretty high, no customization options, and we were rung up with a $2 and change ranch cup charge that we did not ask for. If it wasn't late we would've walked read more

I stopped at Sal's for a slice after a show at First Ave, as is my tradition, and then proceeded to get mugged on the Warehouse District light rail platform (totally not Sal's fault, though the perps were in line in front of me). I lost my slice in the process, but when I went into Sal's to get a bottle of water to flush my eyes (the muggers used pepper spray), they also replaced my lost slice (a tasty spinach and cheese that I ate in the HCMC emergency room waiting for the cut on the bag of my head to be checked out). Is it great pizza? Probably not. Is it great pizza for after a show? Absolutely. And are they just generally good people? I would say hes, absolutely, and that's enough to make me want to go back the next time. read more

Had fond memories of Sal's on Fifth after late nights on Hennepin Avenue, but last night realized it is not worth the price. After paying $19 for a slice of pizza and a calzone, I was not impressed by this venue. The pizza had decent crust with a good crunch to it, but the flavor profile was simplistic and not tasty. The cheese was really lackluster and would not order again. The calzone had the same flavor quality and was not appetizing. Happy they included marinara and red pepper flakes. Good location but would rather order elsewhere for the price. read more

Sal's on Fifth - Meat Lovers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Minneapolis, Minnesota

Best little pizza place in town. They had exactly what we wanted and very good service.

Genuinely in disbelief what happened here. The owner was yelling at a black woman for asking why her slice was $96 and not the $15, like the menu stated. He snatched a slice away from another woman and threw cash back at her and started screaming at them to leave. Proceeds to put both middle fingers in the air at these two ladies who did not cause a scene until this SCAMMER was outted. Taking advantage of drunken people, and projecting his racism on to others. I was a bystander for this entire thing and so were other people. Be ashamed of yourselves, establishment. Poor. read more

HORRIBLE SERVICE...Ordered three pizzas and still wouldn't allow BLACK MALE customer to use the bathroom, yet, allowed a WHITE Woman to use the bathroom immediately before him. They went so far as to accommodate the white lady they even moved trash cans that were blocking the bathroom door for her, but told the BLACK MALE that he wasn't allowed to use it. See link below... https://youtu.be/n576hr8uVWQ?si=8N-VUP_mrx8LItpv read more

A purchase of cheese pizza with parmesan sprinkle on top. The crust was soft and crunch and light. The cheese was a chewy-gewy yum. read more

Sal's on Fifth - A purchase of cheese pizza with parmesan sprinkle on top. The crust was soft and crunch and light. The cheese was a chewy-gewy yum. - Pizza Near Me - Minneapolis, Minnesota

The pizza i got was a triple meat. The location of the pizza is pretty solid, by all means they chose a good spot. However, for sure late at night it will be crazy. The reason why i gave this place a 3 star is because being that it is in the middle of most bar it doesnt take any credit card. So they're basically making you take out cash with a surcharge of $4.25 and then the pizza itself is $8.10. So pretty much a slice of pizza comes out to be about $9 plus tax. That is pretty pricey compared to other places. A slice of pizza shouldn't cost me $9 dollar. It wasnt that good, the cheese wasn't pulling and the meat is a little dry. For sure i will save money next time and not come back to this place. I remembered it being a lot better at a good price! Disappointed i wont be coming back to this place. read more

Love eating at this place when I'm drunk on Halloween. Good variety, something for every ghoul.

Wow I had no idea what an excellent pizza place this was! Big New York foldable slices, I am so happy to have something like this around here. I tried it for the first time through delivery and it was AMAZING! I am definitely going to order again! read more

Came in to grab a slice after the Metallica concert. At 11 at night, I expected the usual suspects: Cheese, pepperoni, sausage, maybe a buffalo chicken. Instead my eyes (and tastebuds!) were overwhelmed, and even a little confused, with all the options. Bacon cheeseburger pizza. Macaroni and cheese pizza. Even spaghetti and meatball pizza. Whoa... Curiosity got the best of me, so I grabbed a slice of mac and cheese pizza. It was surprisingly good and not nearly as weird as I expected it to be. The firmness of the crust combined with the creaminess of the cheese and the chewiness of the noodles added an odd sort of balance to it. Since my hotel is nearby, I might stop by again soon and try another of their specialty slices. read more

See all

$18 for two slices of pizza. Stay clear there is better pizza in the city for a better price.

Pizza not good. And $8 / slice !!!!! Oh and did I mention CASH ONLY with a $5 service fee ATM for your convenience. read more

I paid $70 for 5 slices and would not give me a receipt. took advantage of being drunk.

What the heck! Over $24.00 for my meal from this place. It's a kids meal! The cheesesteak is like 5" long and a tiny bit of meat!! Really disgusted!! read more

Sal's on Fifth - Tiny cheesesteak!! Kids meal not for an adult!! - Pizza Near Me - Minneapolis, Minnesota

We're from out of town so ofc we don't know how close or far restaurants are, anyway ordered through Grubhub pizza from this place and highly disappointed! First! Our order was pending forever & wasn't accepted by the restaurant.(15mins) usually it's anywhere from 2-5mins when ordering from a different restaurant. We were still patient. Finally accepted and was being prepared. Anywayyyy after 50mins we were done with this place. The order stated is was delivered but wasn't! Ughhhhh! Finally I contacted Grubhub to cancel the payment. Which they did and this was the Best part of this issue Great customer service via Grubhub. I got my refund thank goodness!! read more

Excellent variety and the pizza crust is like heaven, seriously! Perfect blend of crispy deliciousness.

Hello folks, During the pandemic it's hard to get good food delivered with plentiful portions and cost. I ordered the gyro sandwich with fries. The gyro was very good and large portions. The sandwich's comes with fries. My boyfriend ordered "Big Fat Greek Burger" and this also comes with fries. The burger was delicious. The fries were crunchy and firm. Bottom line, portions are "big" so bang for your buck, food is good and the order arrived very fast. So fast service. I will order again. I should have taken a picture of the food but I was too hungry to wait. I highly recommend this place. Enjoy !! read more

We ordered buffalo chicken tenders, a Stromboli and cheese curds. The tenders came with bbq sauce instead of buffalo and the blue cheese was so expired that it ran like water. It was awful. The Stromboli, I asked for no sausage or pancetta... it had both and it was baked until the sauce inside was dry. They didn't even read the order to correctly modify it for allergies and It was disgusting. When I tried to call to have it corrected or at least get a refund for those two items... the phone is disconnected. I've never written a bad review on here but this was a waste of $65. With a little care and effort it would've been a very different review. read more

Great place to grab a late night bite, good for takeout or delivery. Super reliable and affordable. Typically would recommend getting pizza by the slice but they have good pizza and burgers/fries. Service is great as well, highly recommend their tzatziki pizza/ burger read more

During this Pandemic, I have gone out and tries to support restaurants that I love. But try to do what I like to do in general which is try some place new. My friend Steve and I went in a walk as the night grew cold and windy. On the way back we took the light rail and it stopped near Hennepin near the Pour House. At 10:30 at night this was open. We went in. Pizza by the slice. But freaking pricy I thought. 2 slices of the Gyros / Mediterranean and a Diet Coke (Steve had a slice, they were big). $17. No credit cards. Well... luckily one of us had cash. Went outside and ate the hot and surprisingly very good pizza. Would I recommend it? Yes. Get something different. Support a business that's open later in a weeknight in the heart of Mpls. Thank you folks! read more

I've had decent food here in the past, but the customer service is simply non-existent. You're a dollar sign and not a customer. On a Halloween weekend out last year with a 10-min wait, I was handed the order of a customer before me who must have decided against paying and they rang it up demanding I pay for the meal that wasn't mine or even of interest to me. When I refused and told them it was not my order, they held the line up, pointed to the onsite security guy and yelled at me to leave. Will never go back to this excuse of a business. read more

Awful experience! Do not order using Slice app! I received a confirmation that my order would be ready at 1:13-1:28pm. I got there and the very rude and intimidating 1 and only worker said he had no order. So I preceded to explain that I went to google and it shows this app to order pickup. I also showed my receipt and bank info showing the money was taken. He was consistently rude and giving very mean glares and stares refusing to give my money back or food! Do not go there expecting any kind of respect, good service or cleanliness!!! read more

The pizza is off the chain! 2019 review So why the low rating? Because the place is filthy! You can be shabby like a NYC pizza joint without being dirty, Look at the welcome mat, worn, dirty, has it ever been cleaned? The windows are smeared and filthy. The floor was cleaner than the tables. I was there at 5 pm and it wasn't busy... get off your asses and clean the tables The knife & fork dispensers, more filth. Posh the lever and a fork falls into the dirty dispenser tray. The trash cans, not even trash cans are sopposed to be that dirty in the outside read more

Sal's is a busy stop after bar close, and features a variety of specialty pizzas, burgers, sandwiches, and sides. If you're a pizza lover like me, you adore a good pizza-by-the-slice place. I got a chicken alfredo pizza slice ($4.50 for a specialty pizza slice) and my roommate got the spaghetti meatballs pizza slice (listed as one of the business's favorites). My roommate loved his, but I thought my pizza could've been better. It was good and they put it in the oven for a few minutes, so it was crispy, but the chicken and alfredo did not have much flavor. Another reason why I would suggest going to other nearby pizza places after bar close or at any other time in fact is because this place gets ROWDY. The security man at the door takes his job very seriously, but I have seen many fights and arguments at the doorway of Sal's. There's only one security man, and this is the kind of place where they need to hire more for back up. That poor guy needs a break. read more

The pizza is pretty good but $8.11 by the slice? Avoid this place until they stop price gauging late night. The cost of ingredients didn't double. Really sad they chose to do this. read more

Fast and friendly, kind of like Mesa Pizza but not as good but it works in a pinch. Pricing is OK, not a Dominos but when you are hangry you don't care. The specialties like the gyro are much better than just their standards. Hawaiian is considered a specialty and is not that great. read more

They make a lot of different pizza. It almost seems like a supply issue as they have so many. It's located right next to all the popular downtown bars; therefore, it's frequented heavily in the evening around bar time. The pizza is good at this hour, they kind of nuke it in the oven a bit though. And there's no place to sit currently... read more

We left Jacksons Hole Bar around 11:00pm and planned to go to Sals for a quick bite. The pic attached is from 12:04 am, and its 100% not true. We walked there and it was closed. Annoying, as someone that travels, we would hope that their hours were correct for people that are not familiar with the area. read more

Sal's on Fifth - Claims it open and its not! Its 12:05 am as I write this - Pizza Near Me - Minneapolis, Minnesota

Things here aren't fancy. The slices are heated in the oven like in NYC- crust is piping hot and toppings are plentiful. The restaurant is sketchy inside. Order your food and leave. read more

Sal's on Fifth - Not fancy. Slices are warmed in the oven- like NYC. Crust is hot, toppings are plentiful. The restaurant is sketchy. $3.50 for a slice. - Pizza Near Me - Minneapolis, Minnesota

Absolute trash mozzarella sticks. Not sure if they just over fried them or if they were on a warming plate. read more

Sal's on Fifth - The said "blackened" mozzarella sticks. - Pizza Near Me - Minneapolis, Minnesota

Small sign saying cash only. 5 regular slices 30 bucks. 6 dollars a slice is criminal. Then only had a little cash. Cash only disrespectful at this point but no problem there is an ATM machine. Yes lovely 5 dollar service fee to use ATM. What a scheme. Completely unclean, ridiculously overpriced, rude to customer but on the bright side slice wasn't terrible - not great mind you but not terrible. read more

Sal, thank you for feeding all us 2am hungry people just looking for a good bite before we fall asleep and wake up at 1pm the next day. Are you better than Mesa pizza? Hmmm I don't know about that but I like how big the slices are! read more

The pizza is really subpar at best. I suppose it can qualify as okay drunk food but even then, you could have so many better things entering your body. I would give them a second chance but I don't plan to frequent this place again unless my charitable side decides to make an appearance. read more

Pizza tastes like cardboard and expensive. It's one benefit is that it's open late! Ordered delivery.