The service is excellent, the pizza is FIRE, and the overall feeling is like a comfortable neighborhood bar. Roxies smile is the cherry on top! read more

The pizza was great but there were cockroaches on the table. There really isn't too much else to say. It has a good vibe and all, but if they're going to sell food, they probably shouldn't have cockroaches running on their tables read more

Rusty's - Bars Near Me - Tracy, California

Finally got to stop by and try the food. Nice size establishment with low key no thrills, nice. luv their crust,quality ingredients, pizza less then $9. You can loss. Great spot for a meet up or catch a game. read more

Rusty's - Nice place to hang! - Bars Near Me - Tracy, California

See all

I was skeptical when a friend of mine recommended this place. Pizza and wings from a bar to go? I figured I would give it a shot anyways. Ordered a medium chicken supreme pizza and the buffalo wings. The wait time was about 45 minutes when I called which seemed long, but it was about 730 so figured the dinner rush. When I arrived the small door when you enter is there to pick up food so you don't have to enter the bar if you don't want to. The gentleman there was attentive and let me know half my order was ready and grabbed my pizza said it would be a few more minutes on the wings. Something to note this place is cash only, they do have an atm on site, but come with cash! When I got home the pizza was still warm and looked amazing! It matched the look and was super tasteful. The cheese was sharp, chicken cooked well, bite from the onions and artichokes, and who doesn't love bacon? The wings were good, could be crispier in my opinion. Sauce was flavorful and not overly spicy. This may be my new go to when I'm in the area. Side note it is a bar. It's loud, there are locals, but everyone was friendly and nice. Even a dog to pet! read more

Rusty's - Chicken Supreme Pizza - Bars Near Me - Tracy, California

Rusty's is one of those types of places that is so unique and special you just can't recreate it anywhere else. I've fallen in love with this place. I always see the same people working and the vibes are immaculate. A dive bar with amazing food and cheap drinks. When you come you have to get the lemon pepper and robs rub wings. The wings here are the best I've ever had in my life and are absolutely life changing. They give you a bunch of ranch as well. The pizzas are so delicious. Rumor has it they've never cleaned the pizza oven so all the yummy flavor and char comes from it. My other notable mentions are the fried pickles and onion rings. The drinks are cheap and STRONG. Usually around $8-$12. It's become one of my go to places and I dream about their wings. Worth the drive from the bay! read more

See all

The beer is cold, the Wednesday only Pastrami sold out, so I know it's good, the regulars are really friendly, Rusty and his daughter Brooke are the nicest people ever! My new hometown hang. read more

The best medium rare steak you can ask for!! Rusty cooks it just perfect! Only served during lunch hours. MON -FRI The atmosphere is friendly with the right music playing on the jukebox ! read more

Rusty's - Quality thick Steaks here!! I love it!!! - Bars Near Me - Tracy, California

This is the best pizza I love it... everyone has to try it... everyone is always very friendly as well. You can have a drink while you're there make it much better and all family is welcome. read more

Food shears on point! Great quality Services! We love us some Cheyanne! Best pizza in Tracy! read more

Rusty's - Rustys Pizza Best in Town - Bars Near Me - Tracy, California

The pizza is the best service is awesome a friend recommended it I'll never go anywhere else the crust is thin topping are great be even better with crumble sausage the flavor everything is fantastic My new place to go even if live 25 miles away read more

Walking up to this place, felt like I was walking into a biker bar. Came here late at night and it felt like a community bar, where everyone kind of knew each other. They had the Sunday football games on almost every TV. We took our order at the window and the cashier was very polite. We also ended up getting a picture of beer from the bartender. We didn't wait too long for our food. The pizza, Rusty's combo was very crispy and loaded up with toppings. I enjoyed the buffalo wings more than the lemon pepper, and they did not lack any flavor. The fried zucchini had a good crunch and was not soggy. I was recommended this place by a friend of ours and I definitely would come back. read more

See all

I occasionally stay in Tracy for weeks or a month at a time. Alot of the locals have recommended Rusty's. I finally had a chance to check it out 2 weeks ago. I was not disappointed. I'm considered a "picky eater" by most of my friends, especially when it comes to trying a new eatery. After a few drinks, I had the urge to order a small pizza to try it out and it turned out being the best pizza I've had in a long time. Everything was perfect from the cheese, to the toppings to the crust. The gentleman serving us was Nick. After getting to know him, he's a cool dude and loves his sports. Service was on point and he let us have our fun there. I went on a Monday, so it was not that crowded, but I've heard stories of how it gets pretty crazy on weekends. And it's cool because they have a juke box and a good amount of TV screens showing different sporting events. But I honestly prefer when it's not crowded (just a personal preference), so for me, it was perfect ambiance. Cheers! read more

Best pizza in town!! And love their ranch. My only complaint is that they sometimes do not pick up their phone. So I had to drive down there one time and waited for two hours. And yes- I called about 5 times. I was over it when we got to inhale the all meat pizza. They also have some great appetizers. We usually add on a side order of tots. read more

Their pizza is to die for! Super crispy. A little on the salty side but that's what beer is for. If I lived nearby I'd be a regular.

Love this place , great pizza , great staff and ice cold beer and the bartenders are pretty awesome too

The pizza here and stramboli were great! The food was fresh and hot. The flavor was great and the service was solid. We will definitely come back read more

I came here for the famous Rusty's pizza. My mom loves it, so I came and picked one up for her. The pizza is great. The staff were very nice also. My only critique would be their "cash only" policy. I don't carry cash often, so the stars have to align in order for me to get food from here. Even charging a debit/credit card fee would be welcomed, but it's only a small gripe. Good food and good people. read more

Fun place to have a beer and eat some good pizza. Thanks for a great time!! read more

I hate leaving negative reviews, especially for places I used to love. Unfortunately, the pizza and food here just isn't as good as it was only a year ago. Maybe it was just an off night, but this is the second time now that the food was not so good. I'm very tempted to even try a third time. To be clear on the food I ordered was a pizza. and wings. The dough just isn't the same and either is the sauce. Not to mention they put pepperoni when I asked for sausage. Thanks for reading my review. Like I said, this place used to be one of our favorite pizza shops. Hopefully they go back to using their original recipes read more

For sure coming back to see rusty and brookie!! Thanks yall for making my first visit to Tracy ever a memorable one.. from the minute I opened the door I knew it was gonna be good. God bless America read more

Saw this place on the list for "must try" pizzas in the tri Valley. Now im wondering if these shops pay to get on that list for visibility. Not gonna trust that BS list again because of this disappointment. This is one of the top two worst pizzas I've ever had in my life (which is why I feel compelled to write this review). There was one other pizza that was worst only because it was raw dough. I can't seem to trust Yelp Tracy for very much these days. The pizza uses canned mushrooms with a weird metallic taste, and the olives didn't look good either. The cheese didn't even really melt all the way, and the crust was like one of those elementary school pizzas I used to have as a kid, kinda bread-y and dry. It was also a super greasy and lukewarm pizza. Ugh. I've had better frozen TJ's pizza. But I guess my daughter loves it bc it's just like school pizza. Yelp reviewers just gotta stop lying about how good this is, yuck. And seriously, after seeing some of the videos of other reviews - watch out for roaches hitching a ride back to your house! Pizza with a free side of infestation. read more

It's my favorite pizza spot since moving to Tracy. I love the fries and wings, too. I believe the kitchen closes at 9 pm. The service is always great, and the crowd seems pretty cool. Bring cash as that's all they take, but there's an ATM if you forget to. I love that the prices here aren't getting jacked up, unlike most other pizza spots. This is definitely a dive bar vibe and a chill place to have some drinks after a long day. I always recommend Rustys to my friends and family. read more

Unfortunately the quality of the pizza was poor. It was very dry, sauce was non existent, and the meat toppings you can tell were not of high quality. Price point was fair for the size of pizza. Just had high hopes from word of mouth and some of the reviews. Very disappointed, will not try again or suggest to others. read more

Small locals bar great atmosphere. Best pizza I have had in a long time! I will be back next time I am in Tracy

This place is totally for the old school locals that were rooted in Tracy . I loved the vibe and all old memorabilia. The pizza was fabulous and delicious . I also appreciated the lady that too our order , she was super sweet and accommodating to my daughter . read more

Rusty's - Pizza - Bars Near Me - Tracy, California

See all

I'm not one to give 1 star, but this place truly and utterly deserved it. The Service -- service is non-existent for us. Service is completely handled by the bartenders even if you get a booth/table. Not sure if this was an isolated incident but it seemed like even if we went up to the bar to ask for drinks, we'd never get served. The bartenders would just continue talking with the other bartenders or with the customers and refused to acknowledge us unless we hollered them over! When we got our food, the server just slid the food on our table and left without saying 1 word! The Food -- this place is def reheating frozen food and it shows -- the food was warm at best. Furthermore we saw a few cockroaches by the front where we placed an order and instantly regretted ordering. Lastly, this place is cash only... why is a place cash only in 2023? read more

Best pizza I've ever had. You can eat in and watch the game. This revue is making me hungry. There's pizza and then there's Rusty's pizza ! Greatest friendliest service too. Wonderful vintages sports memorabilia and pictures to looking at too. A real Tracy Landmark. read more

The pizza side closes at 9pm??? Uuugghhh!!! It's 2024 and they only accept cash???? I haven't even tried the pizza yet, but since I just got a recommendation at the bowling alley down the street I'll try the pizza. read more

Rustys is a fun place to be. Best Pizza around. Ice cold drinks and fun entertainment. I saw a review from a gal that is making some pretty bad accusations about one of the patrons. I believe this to be false. Anyone that knows this man including the owner knows this information to be false. Let's all be nice and don't trash perfectly awesome people! I don't feel it's right to slander anyone. read more

Recently went there and my friend ordered pizza there. He found roaches in his food. Never ordering food there again. When we told the worker they didn't care not one bit. read more

Rusty's - There in clearly a roach right there. - Bars Near Me - Tracy, California

Yuck ice pops, mustache, gummy bear what do you think about the food dude, tell me Gummy, gummy, bear My son wrote this review they were great, rusty leaves every night with a big MURSE lol loaded with cash !!! read more

Best pizza I've had in the area and, I love the bar scene atmosphere. My wife and daughter love the steak salad and the steak sandwich is also great! read more

Rusty's - Bars Near Me - Tracy, California

See all

Beware: Cash only. Only food is pizza (no wings, sushi or other stuff as advertised). Extreme dirty dive bar. Response to the owner: Yesterday we were told only pizza. Nothing else. read more

The Pizza is the best in town and it's not even close. They don't try to price gouge you like other places in town. Be prepared to get attitude if you don't know what you're doing, complain or expect a corporate ass kissing. People complaining aren't local or just moved here. There's a crappy corporate chain right next door if you want someone to call you sir/ma'am, tell you to have a great day and take your credit card payment and be nice to your crappy kids. You'll get attitude if you cause a fuss and I wouldn't have it any other way. Employees are known to drop 4 letter words on customers trying to order. That's just how it goes. It's a long running local dive-bar that happens to make fantastic pizza. It's not a restaurant. Don't bring your family and expect a wholesome experience. Go there, get drunk, get loud and enjoy some great pizza. The steak sandwiches are also great. read more

We've purchased pizza from them several times and never have been disappointed. Their pizza is the best hands down!!

I had their pizza during my grandson's graduation party and I loved it. It was very delicious. Too bad that they don't deliver and too bad that they're not part of any type of delivery service but the pizza is good. read more

First time ordering from Rusty's and it didn't disappoint the pizza was delicious ! The kitchen is located in a dive/sports bar we ordered take out and didn't hang inside for to long but seemed pretty chill wouldn't mind being back to watch some games and have a beer . It is Cash only so be sure to have that in hand. We will definitely be back . read more

Rusty's - Medium pepperoni/pineapple also a medium combination / tots / wings - Bars Near Me - Tracy, California

Rusty and his family are nothing short of amazing! His daughter is a friendly bartender that will help You find the perfect drink. His kitchen staff is super professional and friendly. They literally have the best ranch I have ever tasted. Made in house fresh. The pizza is top notch. I've also had the fries, chicken fringes and some others, every dish has been delicious and affordable. It was my husband's bday and we had to waste some time while his car was getting tinted. We hung out at Rusty's and Rusty took our daughter's order. He is so humble and kind. Such a gentleman. I have zero negatives to say, been going here since I turned 21, 16 years ago. Best dive bar with 5star food in the Central Valley. read more

This is really unfortunate because I love Rusty's. Me and my girlfriend were there for lunch today, 01/20/2025. When we got through with our meal I noticed a cockroach right on our table. It was under the napkin dispenser and heading towards our pizza. We quickly moved our food to another table and packed up and left. Like I said, this sucks because I love Rusty's. But cmon guys! read more

I have been going to Rusty's years! Always loved it. However, something has changed the food isn't what it used to be. Maybe it was 2 dudes and a beard! He kept running his hands through it, and dealing with food. SO GROSS! read more