This is really unfortunate because I love Rusty's. Me and my girlfriend were there for lunch today, 01/20/2025. When we got through with our meal I noticed a cockroach right on our table. It was under the napkin dispenser and heading towards our pizza. We quickly moved our food to another table and packed up and left. Like I said, this sucks because I love Rusty's. But cmon guys! read more

Love Rusty's! Great atmosphere and service! The pizza is to die for too! The football crowd is awesome

We were turned onto this place by a friend and have been there 4-5 times after hunting . People there are always nice and it's fun to hang out and wait for our pizza. Pizza is always great! read more

Moved to tracy from Sacramento not to long ago. Had to check out the hype about Rustys finally. Service, food and atmosphere is phenomenal. BUT- there was one particular individual that really gave me the creeps. Apparently he's a regular and always does handyman work for the owner from what a fellow drinking buddy told me. The guy took out a bag of white substance and and as I looked closer I realized it was METH!!! WTF!??? People come there to eat with their families and children and this moron (who also kept trying to flirt with my niece) was selling meth in the back patio to very young customers. Tried to get his license plate but saw that he has a handyman business. Looked it up online and theres a picture clear as day of him doing cocaine!! Cmon Tracy!! WE ARE BETTER THAN THIS. This guy needs to be put behind bars. It sucks that he's a regular. I do plan on going back but this time unfortunately I'm afraid to bring my neice. I wanted to tell the owner but he left before I could. Again, the food and atmosphere was awesome until the goblin-like creeper showed up. Hate to make this a negative review but people need to be aware when bringing their children. read more

See I never leave bad reviews but these people are just rude all the women in the kitchen are rude everytime we go have 0 manners and they are taking shots getting drunk In the kitchen. Always have attitude with snarky remarks saying it's a Saturday what do you expect when they left us on hold for 15 minutes. Food is good but people are rude. read more

Sitting at the bar trying to enjoy my beer when a coach roach runs across the bar... i've always ordered pizza here n come for drinks no more! read more

We ordered take out Pizza, all vegetables with Italian Sausage. They were nice but the cashier that handled the money also makes the pizzas! we all got sick! We will not go there again. We tried the place because a friend recommended it. I was disappointed I drive by there a lot and always thought of trying it out. Some of my friends goes frequently. read more

Ordered pizza as we had heard it was the best in town. Was not really impressed with it. Pizza, like any food, is really something that is varying, so just because we were not impressed, doesn't mean someone else will not be. We did ask for extra cheese and it did not seem to have extra cheese. read more

Great pizza!!! I heard about this place having some really good food. We ordered a pizza and wings and it was confirmed.

Been coming here over 50 yrs .larrys, Tommy's, Tracy joes, now Rustys. We come from Modesto for the pizza. Not again, pizza was not the same. Should have got a frozen one from store. The girl working at noon on sat was rude, I think she made it how she wanted and could care less, read more

Asked for wings to b done twice times so they weren't fatty... but no want to bring them back to do them correctly I'm not doing that

Absolutely love rustys. It's a local dive bar great community we all support rusty, his business, and his workers. I saw the last review and uhmmm they have never served or advertised sushi? Lol. BEST pizza in Tracy and an awesome vibe. LOVE this place. Walk in and meet rusty yourself. He's awesome. As far as cash only, there is an ATM conveniently placed by the kitchen. They do have certain hours of selling the whole menu, but pizza is sold 11 am-9 pm. read more

They also have the best SUSHI and Corndogs! I love this place! Try their nachos and mushroom cheeseburgers as well! The sushi is the best!

Good food, free flowing drinks, nice folks. Nothing you can complain about. Shout out to Roxy...awesome service!

They are open for dining. Love their combo pizza and the selection of beer. Still has many specials and a great crowd. If you are Covid scared. Stay away read more

Rusty's - Bars Near Me - Tracy, California

Amy goes above and. Beyond for her customers. She brings so much personality that it's infectious and we always have a great time. Her bartending skills are amazing and how she can keep smiling when her bar is packed amazes me. You can't get that great service in most bars these days. She's a big reason why we still go to Rustys and always will. read more

My wife and I walked in for the first time what an awesome place of all the years I've lived in tracy who would think that there a big RAIDERS hang out lots of raiders fans good atmosphere cold beer and there pizza is a staple great pizza service was great very friendly I will definitely be going back this time to try there wings good feeling. read more

Cool little hole in the wall spot to kick it at and meet some local yokels. The bartender Izzy was cool af. He introduced himself immediately and shook my hand. That was a very honorable thing to do. If you love music, get a TouchTunes account and play all the music you'd like from that app there at Rusty's. The only thing I didn't like is that they had most hip hop blocked out of the jukebox but with no rhyme or reason. In one hand you could play DjQuick's SBP but on the other hand you couldn't play many well known rap music. Not to mention I couldn't play any Bobby Caldwell, and that's just a damn shame. read more

Okay so I was not sure about this little place but I herd nothing but great things about it so I tried it and feed 5 other people who absolutely loved it I got some chicken wings and a pepperoni pizza and it was all so tasty I would absolutely recommend this place THANK YOU FOR AMAZING SERVICE AND OPENING THE DOOR FOR ME GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE read more

Rusty's definitely has some of the best pizza in town. Flavor wise, my pizza was delicious. it also had a good crust and a good toppings to cheese to crust ration. Still, there are a few things that keep it from being the very best (at least for me). First off, I like a little more sauce on my pizza. I like to be able to taste it and on my most recent pie I could see it, but not taste it. I also wish they used fresh mushrooms. there is a big texture difference between canned ones and fresh. the canned ones tend to be a bit gummy. There was a time when fresh wasn't always practical, but I'm betting they do enough volume that it wouldn't make a difference. We also really liked the Stromboli. Service was fast and they have really affordable prices too. I will try another non-mushroom combo and ask for xtra sauce next time and see where that lands. Right now they are a solid 3.5. Recommended. read more

A great local Pizza at a great price! In comparison to the other big names with over inflated prices, long waits and just okay pizza

Awesome pizza amazing staff and it was an awesome bar It deserves more than 5 stars come here I would recommend, warning It is a bar.

Not gonna lie 10$ for 6 whole wings is absolutely mind boggling. I was genuinely hoping it'd be more for my first time trying them. Nonetheless they are good read more

Love the food , beer and definitely the owner : it's about fun and they sure have fun it's like family : Rusty is an amazing man with style and his staff is amazing ! Love this place and always look forward to the great pizza; Pat and Tom read more

Best pizza and wings in Tracy area. The people that work the kitchen are very nice. Ordering and pickup are outside of the bar area. read more

I've been in and out of this joint for more than 50 years, always good to great pizza. It's had at least 3 or 4 owners, but they all have held the course providing Tracy with a fun dive bar and yummy pizza. Food and drink prices are damn low by contemporary standards, FREE fried chicken on RAIDERS Sundays. How ya gonna beat that !!! Good folks, good food and an established institution. Thanx to Larry's, Tommy's and of course RUSTY'S Pizza. read more

It's Friday I know most Restaurants are busy but I decided to go with this one. Placed an order for pick up lady said 1 hour and 15 minutes, for a large 10 slices and 1 order of wings (6). I get there it's not ready I waited 20 more minutes just to get home to find my pizza order to be wrong! I was calling and the line is busy. Next time write down the order or re-check the ticket so you know you have the order right! Oh and when I called to order I asked how many slices do they have in an XL she said ( Large is 10) I said no xl she responded we don't have XL. Well you could of told me in the beginning! Whoever answered the phone is just rude! Never will order here again! read more

This is a dive sports bar with full bar service and a small bar menu. Mostly pizza, wings and fried appetizers. We enjoyed our time there and the only drawback I found was that it is cash only establishment with a high price ATM service. Lots of TVs and a jukebox. read more

This place is a local find, hole in the wall bar. Honestly, best pizza in town! If you like finding great local establishments with a lot of character, this is a stop you must make. Always fun, great music, good drinks and amazing pizza. Cash only!!! read more

Rusty's - Bars Near Me - Tracy, California

This was our first time trying Rusty's and we were very dissatisfied. No major complaints on the bar itself but the pizza wasn't what I expected. There was a burnt taste to the crust and some pieces were very heavy on cheese where others had barely any. The overall flavors were not good and my 8 year old son refused to eat it. On a positive note...I can say the cheese squares were good. read more

In Tracy just for the evening (08/29) and stopped in. The pizza was great, I had more than one type. Cash only type of place so be prepared. Friendly atmosphere but it was a weeknight. Saw one negative thing not really worth mentioning. This was a positive place with a great product. I dismiss my earlier review. read more

Rusty's - Bars Near Me - Tracy, California

So usually the pizza is absolutely delicious at this place. But I came here on july 31st Sunday and the pizza was terrible! Worst pizza i have ever had. It was dam near raw. The dough was also under cooked. Horrible. Tasted like chucky cheese pizza. My group ordered a large and we had about 3 slices and we just left the rest of the pizza. Thats how bad it was. LIKE I SAID I ALWAYS COME HERE CAUSE THE PIZZA IS DELICIOUS BUT NOT THIS DAY. read more

Rave rave rave...... Rusty's has been our go to pizza since moving here three years ago. Drinks are good, service is always ok and food (lunch or dinner) is always well done. Rave for today..... went in last night and they had just run out of wings, so I ordered my pizza and sat down. Rusty walks by and I looked up st him and said "rusty your out of wings" and boom..... he was gone. He was back less than ten minutes later with a load of wings for the cooks and when my pizza was being eaten an order of wings hit my table.... oh yeah...... that's taking care of your customers. read more

Best pizza ever, I don't know what it is but, Rusty's is the best pizza out there it's delicious , and for the price! Can't beat it. The combo is my favorite . Tracy's little gem, I'm mad that I did not discover this place sooner. They pile Pepperoncini's on the pizza! It's beautiful pizza art! Call it in take cash and when you get home enjoy! read more

Pizza is very tasty and a very reasonable price. So glad they were open during the pandemic to pick up pizza. Always bring cash though. They don't accept cards. The wings are good too read more

This place blew my mind in so many ways. Kids were starving and so we needed to stop and grab food quick. I didn't even look on Yelp or Google but just saw Rusty's as we drove by. I told my husband to make a u-turn and we parked easily. walking in, I was reminded of every amazing restaurant that I went to as a child. Authentic wood. Old School advertisements. Plastic mustard and ketchup squirt bottles. Honestly, I was so enamored with the atmosphere that I wasn't really counting much on the food. The food was shockingly amazing. We ordered a cheeseburger with bacon, medium rare. It was juicy, thick and hard to put my mouth. French fries were perfect. Chicken sandwich with bacon and swiss. Yum! And the potato salad, as advertised by our waitress, Veronica, was amazing. I'm not even a really big fan of potato salad, but this one made me happy. Delicious. Service was amazing. Food blew my mind. This is definitely on my to do list when I travel past. read more

See all

We were coming from the bay and wanted some wings, so decided to stop somewhere we haven't been before. Customer service was great and the bar looked pretty damn cool. But couldn't dine in due to covid. I was kinda unsure about the place being that it was my first time here, so I just ordered some buffalo wings and chicken strips... sonnnnn! So damn good for bar food! Can't wait to try the pizza next read more

See all

One of my favorite bars in town. Where me and my boys have a great time drinking and talking. The bartenders are always happy to make my drinks good people and good drink. read more

Some of the best pizza in Tracy, it is a dive bar but good people. Gets loud so if you want a quite meal think twice. Again, great pizza though and the beer is always cold and never flat read more

Best Ranch in Tracy Ca. Fresh buttermilk ranch with a side of pizza is a must when i visit. Even a side of a hamburger with my ranch goes amazing. But seriously great and 5 star ranch. They now hold the industry standard for me. read more