Revello's is the most well known of the Old Forge Pizza places. Its arguably the best, depending on who you talk to. Giving Revellos bad reviews because you don't like the style of pizza is moronic. If you don't like Old Forge style pizza, don't go to Revello's. Going to Revello's is like taking a trip in a time machine. You can open your eyes and think its 1975. The pizza is at its best plain. The cheese combination can turn people off if they are not expecting it. The crust is just crispy enough, without being too greasy. The service can be very slow, and the place gets packed. Besides the pizza, I can't recommend anything else on the menu. We usually just get take out because of the crowds, but its definitely worth dining-in at least once. Revello's has "par-baked" pies, which you can bake at home. I recently had the honor of being the first customer to pay with a credit card at Revellos, but its for take out only. One of the staff members joked that the credit card machine was the first new technology since they installed phone lines. read more

Revello's is solid. I'm a huge fan of the white pizza (which is really more like a grilled cheese pie), but the regular pizza is also yummy. We don't come to this place for the sides or the wings (Frog Pond is better for that stuff) but just for some plain old Old Forge style pizza. We've typically had pretty good experiences here, but the day after Christmas was totally crazy. The place was jammed and the servers said they were 2-3 people short, which lead to a really, really long wait, a free-for-all seating situation and disjointed service. That said, we'll be back because I can't live without that white pie in my life! read more

Place went down hill big time, pizza was cold and soggy this visit. Last time it was not baked properly. This is what happens when you have a young kid making the pizza . Take pride in your business before its completely shut down. Never again, done with this place. 16.00 in the trash read more

The absolute best Old Forge-style pizza. Anyone who disagrees is either on drugs or working for the competition. Try the white pizza, too. It's basically cheese and carbs and will not get along well with your stomach but it's SO WORTH IT. The same waitresses have been working there for decades; if you're lucky you might hear one of them say "heyna". read more

Oh yeah. Old Forge Pizza. Red and white and a bucket of Yuengling. Good, good times. I miss it (I'm from near here originally). If you're from Chicago, this won't be your kinda pizza. Then again, most people don't refer to lasagna as pizza, anyway. People still drive in from miles around. Last time I was there, a guy had driven an hour down from Binghampton and was driving back up with five trays. Folks come in two hours from NYC because you can't get Old Forge cuts in Manhattan anymore. Plus the decor reminds me exactly of my favorite pizza place: Santarpio's in East Boston... wood panels, gritty interior, rat pack music on the sound system. read more

Exactly what I hoped it would be. Was looking forward to a glass of table wine, a salad and some of that fabulous old forge style pizza that you can't get in Jersey. I also had dream of what the inside of the restaurant should be like since a lot of my childhood was spent at my families pizza restaurant down the road in Dupont (since closed). Did not disappoint. Sat at the bar early in a Saturday evening. I ordered my table wine (they had several types to choose from) and a salad to start. You can add their famous mozzarella cheese to your salad, which I did and it was great. The salad was perfect- nice and cold and fresh. I got a "cut" of white and a cut of red. The White was so interesting - never seen it done like this before since the cheese was inside the pizza. The red was outstanding- so light, perfect size. And it didn't come out in 30 seconds from a tray of previously cooked cuts- it was hot and fresh. The first bite brought back a rush of memories- almost got teary eyed. Was so good I had to get another cut for dessert (and another glass of table wine). Staff was friendly and busy. Great family owned establishment. read more

I grew up on Revello's pizza and remember the older lady waitress (we specifically went there sometimes to see her) and recently went back and the pizza stayed the same (great) the service went from 5stars to 1..... Totally awful and after reading these reviews on how awful she is I wonder why they keep her? 53 years in business and they losing customers daily because of her! I'm one read more

This pizza is amazing. I live in Philadelphia and ALWAYS miss this pizza. Stock up on this pizza. You won't be disappointed.

This used to be one of my favorite pizzas, but we just got takeout and were disappointed. It tasted like a grilled cheese with some sauce. The sauce didn't have the flavor that it used to. We got double crusted broccoli too and it was way too heavy on the rosemary and the top looked a little burned. I had heard it wasn't what it used to be but hoped anyway... hopes dashed. read more

Been here an hour. Still no food. Place is maybe 60%full. Food is coming out is spurts. 3 of us here. One is done eating. Two of us still waiting. Waitress is ditzy or on the spectrum. Very slow, never here. Looks like she might have two other tables. Struggling with register. Used to come here all the time 20 years ago. Won't be back. Service is seriously terrible. Order for the remaining two came and it was wrong. This place sucks. Been here for over an hour for a few cuts of pizza and a drink. Still waiting in this half empty restaurant. read more

Pizza places are numerous in this part of PA. We chose Ravellos due to its popularity. It wasn't very crowded for a Saturday evening and I was grateful they had the NCAA Final Four on display on multiple large screens. They have a good selection of cold bottled beers, including the local Yeungling which was quite good. It was as a was pouring my beer into my tiny glass, I noticed the pictures of Hillary Clinton who i evidently had made Ravellos a campaign stop. My wife ordered a glass of Pinot Grigio. She advises to stick with the beer. Pizza here is served as a rectangle of 12 "cuts". There are two basic pizza types, red and white. The white is inside out -- cheese sandwiched between layers of dough. The red has thick crust, lots of tomato sauce, and can be ordered with a usual choice of toppings. The pizza was quite good. The service was very friendly. Our server has been working at Revellos for nearly 42 years. I would be happy to come here again. read more

My father-in-law wanted Revello's for his birthday. I picked up a tray of red and a tray of white. I grew up in Moosic, but never had Revello's. This was my first time in 25+ years. The red was okay, not my favorite OF style pizza. The white was pretty good. I'd say it was one of the better white pizzas I've had. The prices are a bit high. $31 for two trays of pizza. Also, the take out is in the rear of the building, which makes for an awkward walk if you go in the front door. read more

Atmosphere not that much. Pizza was ehhh. Tasted like a grilled cheese sandwich crossed with pizza sauce minus the grilled. They promote themselves a lot but not worth the hype. I'll pass on this pizza and I love pizza. read more

Service is AWFUL. Went in and no one was out there, so we just sat wherever we wanted. We ordered 6 "cuts" and an order of fries but were given the pizza way before the fries because she "didn't want to bring them out at the same time(I think she just forgot) it's like pulling teeth to get refills for ur drinks and the pizza just isn't that good. Time to step up the quality of there ingredients!! read more

Stop number two. What a mistake! Creepy inside. Pizza was disgusting. Yuck dough, sauce and cheese!! Sorry Revellos!

Waited for waitress to come back. Never asked if we needed anything after initially bringing food. Had to find her to tell her we were all done. Did not pay any attention to us during visit. There was no one in place and service was very poor. I don't think will come back here. read more

Cardboard + cheese + sauce - flavor - personality = Revello's

It's a tradition if you live in Northeast Pa to visit this place. To go or in house, the pizza is great. They have other items but I have never tried. It's hard to get pizza on Friday's its so busy. Best square pizza I believe I've ever had! read more

I'm an area native and this is the first time I've ever been to Revello's. I will not be back. It's terribly expensive ($20 for a tray of pizza with pepperoni and onion!), there were only 4 other tables occupied in the place and the service took forever, and the pizza was just OK. By the time the waitress finally brought our pizza it was barely warm. Not to mention she walked by my husband's empty glass 3 times, and we finally had to flag her down to get a refill. During the 25 minutes between ordering and finally getting the pizza she never once stopped to ask if we needed anything. After all was said and done, the pizza and three beers cost us $32.00. We could have gone to another nearby restaurant and gotten the same thing for half that cost, and the pizza would have been hot, and the service would have been better. Don't waste your time with this place. read more

The star is a generous one. Good service for the most part but this crap they pass as pizza isn't worth the money. My 9 year old cousin could make something better. Not traditional pie at all which is nice but some flavor would be helpful. read more

This place is a treat for me whenever I come to visit the valley. Seriously amazing food, I love the white pizza.

This place looks great from the outside and i wish it was much better. I stopped in for a red and white cut and was stunned. The truth is the competition kicks their face in. I'll never go back to Revello's when a true artisan is a mere .08 of a mile down the street and many close by that fair much better. I was going to be generous and give 2 stars but my girlfriend nudged me and told me it was very weak and deserves one measly star - I truly wish this place was better. read more

Service was very slow and there were only 3 tables to serve including mine Food was luke warm and made me sick the next day

Was there Sat night, disappointed! Crust was very thick, cheese was tasteless and the onions and mushrooms were microscopic! Yuk!

Revello's Pizza is an over hyped Ellio's pizza. The sauce is bland, the crust is mediocre, & their is way too much cheese. I grew up in NYC & I know what good Pizza is. Every borough in NYC has a great Pizza restaurant & their are many different styles. I can think of at least 5 Pizza restaurant's here in the Northeast that are within 20min of Revello's that put them shame. read more

Place has really gone down the drain. Think they expand too much too quickly . Typical order was 2 trays of red, 2 trays of white. Couple sides of meatballs and sausage . Reds shells are under cooked. They ran out of white at 5:30pm. A pizza shop running out of pizza?!?! Meatballs were cold in the middle. They really lost touch with there roots of what they used to be read more

I missed Revello's Pizza with moving to Florida. My wife and I wanted to have our new friends and neighbors experience the pizza we spoke so much about. I looked into having 3 trays shipped. $85.00!!! The pizza isn't that good. Good luck. We'll miss you. read more

If you like pizza on a McDonalds tray and this Old Forge stuff then your in the right place . The service was absolutely horrendous . I think there was one girl their bartending, cooking and washing dishes. read more

Revello's gets a lot of hype for their pizza but on the numerous occasions where I have tried it, I was never all that impressed. I love Old Forge Pizza, so it isn't an issue with this type of pizza, it's just that Revello's isn't all that special. read more

Food and service really not up to par. The wait to too long for simple cheese & pep pizzas. We were visiting the area from the West Coast, and so very excited to eat at Revellos, unfortunately we were disappointed, cold food, and very poor service. read more

This seemed to be the only pizza place open on Sunday - and we couldn't leave the world pizza Capitol without trying some so we stopped in to try it out. The white pizza was amazing!!! The other pizza just OK. Not impressed with sauce - tasted like ragu. The service was impressively awful. The waitresses sat at a both near us and we had the pleasure of listening to all their life's details while they failed to bring us menus, while our drinks sat on the bar with the ice melting, and as our pizza got cold while we waited for the silverware they offered to being to or table. Sure it was a Sunday afternoon and sure we were the only table in the place - but it just seemed disrespectful. Two stars because the white pizza was insanely good. read more

Just the best. You have never had pizza if you have not tried the white! Do yourself a favor and get there soon.

The pizza taste like if they just took the sauce out of a jar...no other flavors there. We didn't like the texture of it, not even the cheese tasted good. We also had an order of boneless chicken bites and they were awful. Not going there again. So much for them to be in "the pizza capital of the world" read more

I live in Arizona otherwise I would be spending every day or maybe not every day but every Friday that is the best pizza I think in the whole world and I've tried a lot of pizzas even in Europe read more

My friends an I went here Monday the 11th an we will never go back. Firstly there were four groups all paying separate. 2 groups had cash an the other two paying with cards. She tried to tell The two group's that it would be easier if they used The atm machine so that we all paied cash but the atm charges you a fee to use it so they decided not to do that an it's nit like they didn't except cards. The waitress tells us that they don't "really" do separate checks which tells me that your lazy an don't feel like doing separate checks. I have been in restaurant businesses for 16 years an I haven't been to a place that doesn't do separate checks. She was So worried about getting her gratuity %20 tip charge that she screwed herself. She was very unprofessional about the whole situation. If she had given us separate checks like we had ask the whole thing would have gone much smoother but she was so worried about her tip she had to eat the "$6.00" that we were supposedly short on. We all did the right math on our phone's while she was trying to do it in her head. Then as we were all gathered out front of the restaurant one of our friends went back in to use the rest room an the waitress fallowed her into the bathroom an proceeded to tell her that we were "$8.00" short on the bill. Now if she had done what we asked for she wouldn't have had to eat the "$8.00" an would have gotten a bigger tip. Now as for the meal the pizza was good but I was very disappointed when I ordered an an $11.00 plate of pasta with meatballs an only got a small side dish an not even a soup or salad to go with it. Very disappointed an will never return there. read more

OMG, there isn't ANYTHING like Old Forge, PA pizza. Forget round pizza that tastes like cardboard. This is worth the trip. I can't leave w/o 3-4 trays (each "tray" has 12 "cuts"). When my son was stationed in the Army I'd ship him a tray. It is THAT good. read more

Revello's Pizza - THE WORLD'S BEST PIZZA!!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Old Forge, Pennsylvania

Not impressed. Other places in Old Forge are better. Salerno's and Arcaro & Ginelle's are a lot better.

We are sitting here at Revello's Pizza and there is only one waitress and no bartender. The place is packed. The waitress is running around like a cat shot in the ass. This is a family run pizza joint. Do you think some of the family would come and help? A table of five came in and ended up leaving. The waitress is trying her best, and doing a good job. Still, where is the family ? Too busy counting their money? read more

My wife and I recently bought a house in Old Forge and are on a mission to try as many local pizza places as we can. First up, the famous Revello's. I have to say, I was not impressed. There was nothing about the pizza that stood out. The crust was heavy and the sauce was bland. The pizza wasn't bad, but it wasn't great either. read more

Ketchup & American cheese on a saltine, served on a plastic tray. Okay, not literally, but it may as well be. It doesn't deserve the hype. I wish I had more to write, but in a town with more pizza cafes per capita than anywhere else, Revello's is simply not up to par. read more