Sad excuse for an Italian sub. Weird hotdog bun with minimal meat and cheese. Very disappointing.read more

Absolutely best pizza we have tried in the entire area. The staff was welcoming and so nice. It was…read morejust an absolute pleasure to do business with them.. Highly recommend and we will be returning as customers. Liz was the best!

Everything! I've been coming here since I was a kid. Literally nothing has changed and that's a…read moregood thing. I love the little music jukeboxes that they have. It's so nostalgic. The square pizza is my favorite. It doesn't even need anything extra because it's just perfect the way it is. I like that they burn the top of the cheese. That's my favorite part. It's always super clean. Everybody's always super friendly. And the price is great! Worth every penny. This pizza never lasts in my house , And they are definitely in my top 3 in the area.

Really cool ambiance. Found this place in Lonely Planet's Eastern USA book. GPS took us through…read morenostalgic neighborhoods. It's located in the middle of an older section of Scranton. Had to wait a while, but it was worth it! Very good pizza! Be sure you call and order in advance!

Food and service were great. Would recommend their homemade lasagna. Everyone loved what they got…read more Grandson got a personal pizza, SIL got a personal Sicilian pizza and daughter and wife got chicken wraps.

Traveling with a dog means takeout so we ordered dinners for delivery to our hotel. The chicken…read morestrips with wine and mushrooms over linguine was accompanied with a nice side salad and garlic bread. After a day on the road, this was a surprisingly good dinner - beats the usual fast food road diet.

This is what a labor of love looks like when a man spends his weekends making pizza (and wings)…read moreafter working a full time job all week. This is why the hours are short and limited to Friday, Saturday and Sunday. I salute this gentleman for what he does and had a nice chat during my first visit picking we up some wing bites and a Detroit style pizza. For sure the best Detroit in Scranton and the boneless bites are right up there with Nina's and Haggerty's, my two local favorites. I am really impressed with this place and wish we would've tried it sooner. (No dine-in, pick up only.)

The outdoor seating was heavenly on a pleasant early summer day. Wonderful view. The food was…read moregreat, portions sizable, prices reasonable. Our waitress, Ashley, was super, very attentive and kind. Just a very, very nice dining experience. Would definitely recommend and hope to return soon.

Ashley provided very good service…read more This is our go to lunch spot when traveling on Rt 81 in PA. Food takes awhile but is always served hot and amazing. Had their pizza with ricotta, basil, hot honey and meatballs. Pizza was fantastic. Chicken Parmigiana was delicious with their ala vodka sauce. Private parking near hotels. Outdoor seating, full bar and tables or booth seating

As Old Forge proclaims itself as "pizza capital of the world" for it's unique tray style of square…read morepizza, I made it a point to try it out when in the Scranton area, and I chose Mary Lou's Pizza due to the positive reviews online. Unlike some of the other well known pizza spots in Old Forge, they are open for lunch and also have an indoor dining area. I ordered in advance since pizzas take a while to cook, and was ready right on time when promised. The lady that answered the phone was really pleasant in taking my order and answering questions I had, and also made it a point to chat with us when we came in. I appreciated the genuinely friendly conversation and her checking in to ask how the pizza was after we tried it. The interior seating area is cozy, clean, and modern, with tasteful pictures of Italy's landmarks on the wall. We went with a tray of the red, which is the standard pizza with cheese and red tomato sauce. While it looks like a Sicilian slice, it's feel is airy and much lighter, with a great crunchy crust. While the sauce and cheese were decent enough, they didn't measure up to the quality I'm spoiled with in the New Jersey/Philadelphia areas. The crust was really the star of the show, and gave vibes of a unique taste akin to a French bread and/or Ellios pizza crust the way they used to make it decades ago. While it wouldn't be in my wheelhouse for a style of pizza I'd regularly get, we were satisfied with the taste of the pizza and the overall experience. Since I haven't tried any of the other Old Forge pizzas and have nothing to compare it to, I'll chalk the pizza up to a 4.5/5 for its own unique special style, and am happy to round up for the satisfying experience and friendly service. I'd recommend giving Mary Lou's Pizza a try to others looking to experience Old Forge pizza.

A nice history. We tried the "Old Forge" style pizza- meh. It's like focaccia bread with red sauce…read moreand cheese on top. It had a good crisp. Maybe a nice snack with a glass of wine or part of an aperitivo- but we definitely prefer thin crust, round pizza. We did buy Mary Lou's homemade fettuccine for later. Meravigliosa!! The server was kind and accommodating. We even got to meet Mary Lou! Worth a stop for sure.

We visited recently with family. They were take out only but my in-laws pulled some strings for…read moreindoor seating. This place was great and a shame they aren't doing indoor seating again. I felt like I was in the godfather. In summer they even have bocce courts outside that look like a blast. Service was amazing with constant refills and even some canolis on the house. I really enjoyed the anti pasta to start, pizza was an appetizer and I had the veal parm as the main entree. I ate so much it hurt ... literally. Their old forge pizza is okay in my book although I like others in the area way more. Their sauce/gravy had great flavor. The veal parm was okay but not something I'd order again. My wife got a delmonico and it was the real star. Others in our group got a white cioppino which they loved.

Up from the Philly area today and couldn't be happier with Arcaro & Genell!! The pizza and the…read moreservice was incredible!! Highly recommend the white pizza!!

Ever since the new owners came in this place has been dynamite. My fiancée and I cannot resist…read moretheir buffalo wing pizza. We come from Nj often to visit family and this is our must stop every single time. They have a few staples in my eyes. The sweet sauce isn't too sweet and hits just right! Their uncle guys is a slightly thicker dough, with a great sauce to cheese ratio. Their buffalo wing is just incredible, it's even better on the square. It truly shows how the new owners really care about this spot, they take pride in their pies! I know a lot of people in the area stick to their normal spots but I really think this is a true gem!!

Welcome to Friday night pizza night everyone, today we are visiting "That Guy with The Dough". I…read moreheard, I should have said read good reviews on this place, so I decided it's time to check it out. It's more of a takeout place but they do have two tables set up if you want to have it there. Today's pizza is basic and right to the point, a patron behind me told me after asking what the popular choice it's their sweet sauce pizza was, so that's what I got. Now sitting there, I noticed they do a good amount of take out. I also saw the same door dash guy a few times. Now, how was my pizza you ask? This came out nice and hot, the crust was nice and crisp, the sweet sauce was amazing. I do want to add the employees were very nice being my first time ever here. I do recommend everyone to try this place out. Until next video, be blessed and stay safe. Watch my video review https://youtu.be/D0-VMZ7vZhw check out their online menu https://www.allmenus.com/pa/moosic/728527-that-guy-with-the-dough/menu/

Please get the Penne alla Vodka. We keep coming back here for this! Chicken francaise is good too!…read moreService is always great. Im from California and I come here every time I visit.

I'm not a huge fan of "The Office." Maybe a quasi-fan! This was a cool stop on our long weekend in…read morethe great city of Scranton, Office fan or not. I thought I knew and experienced most pizza styles: NY (fold it), Chicago, school cafeteria, Connecticut "Apizz", CT bar pie, Detroit, etc. I was clearly wrong. Alfredo's introduced my son and me to Old Forge pizza: mozzarella and American cheese with sauce served in squares. Really unique and the American cheese sticks to the roof of your mouth. Surprisingly good if you're not a strict traditionalist. Our pie came in yummy squares and the crust had a delicious, slightly flaky quality to it. The Caesar salad was delicious with generous shavings of good parmigiano Reggiano. Our waiter was a true gentleman - kind and explained the Old Forge way to these NY born-and-raised customers. They have comfortable indoor and outdoor seating. The staff was friendly and the place was very welcoming. It's clearly a favorite red sauce joint. I could see why the place has won the Scranton-wide love it's received. Of course we grabbed an Alfredo's "Home of the GOOD Pizza!" t-shirt on the way out!

Delicious food! I was in like a table of 11. I got one of their specials, a fried Pork chop with a…read morebutter dip. Really good, the dip makes it really filling! The pasta is really good as well, and I myself am a pasta fan. The only con for the whole visit here was the table room, felt crowded, maybe that is just a group thing, but still. Good food. Great selection. I love it all!

The lady that owns it is terrible. She yelled at us when we ask to move our table …read more I wouldn't go there with a gift card