Order Redeemer Pizza Takeout or Delivery
Redeemer Pizza Photos
Redeemer Pizza Popular Dishes
REDEEMER PIZZA ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Redeemer Pizza
Recommended Reviews - Redeemer Pizza
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Never again Redeemer, in a city with many other pizza options. We ordered carry-out and as pizza connoisseurs, we treat it like royalty in the car. On a grown-up's lap with 2 hands on the box at all time and minimal movement. When we opened the box, one of the pizzas had been just destroyed with the cheese and toppings all on one side, the other pizza arrived fine. Appearance aside, the taste was OK, nothing special. The crust to cheese/topping ratio was very poor. Overly greasy with mediocre taste and poor presentation.
Pizza is good! I like the crust. We opted for slices since we weren't sure if we'd like it. Perhaps next time we will spring for a whole pie, but the slices are generous and a great option. We also tried the Caesar and I thought it was great. It's an interesting little space. Definitely not much for atmosphere, but I can see how the vibe would change at night with the open divider between Redeemer and Meadowlark. We ordered from the counter in the back and it was pretty quick.
The pizza is delish! A bit of a limited menu, but awesome choices. Pretty pricey. Extra toppings are $3 or $4 for premium (meats primarily). Different pizza menu than other places. The pizza comes out piping hot and delicious. Ranch was bomb. Only other complaint is it's not a place I'd want to come and chill. Pretty small and the restaurant is hot. It's primary seating is the patio.
New York style pizza with a sourdough crust. Came here on a food tour and had a choice of the pizza of the week, cheese or pepperoni. I got the pizza of the week. The cheese was good, the crust was GREAT, the artichokes did not do it for me, they were pickled, I wasn't a fan of the sourness on the pizza. It's a great space for late night pizza when hitting the club next door. I'd like to try the other pizzas. I'll be back RiNo!
When you're in Rino and crave a pizza, this is the place to go. They have an interesting collection of pizza choices so something to suit everyone's tastebuds.i believe we got the cacio e pepe and it was a delicious pizza with the garlic sauce and pepperoni. We did order it with ricotta but they forgot. They were very nice and removed it from our final charge. I'm not sure if you could order slices but we ordered a whole pizza to share between 3 adults. The dining area is quite small. When we came in, there weren't a lot of tables available. It's a popular choice for everyone post 8pm.
Pretty good pizza at affordable prices. Thin crust that's really high quality. At lunch you can only order from the window and use the patio. The service was ok, I mean there isn't a ton of interaction ordering at the window and then picking up but the guy at the window was really helpful and nice. It's a super casual place but the pizza is good if you're in the area. I'm not sure about parking. I was there in the middle of the week and was able to find a spot very quickly but not sure about weekends or busy days.
Amazing New York style pizza in Denver! This was part of a Food Tour my bestie and I took during our annual weekend trip this time to Denver. Amazing service, the pizza wasn't too salty, and they were mindful of my dietary restrictions. It was a casual spot in an alley but the whole neighborhood was filled with cultural gems and amazing food. What an amazing East Coast treat out West in Colorado!
As someone from New York who grew up eating pizza religiously, I don't say this lightly: Redeemer Pizza is the closest thing to home pizza I've found in Denver. And I'm so thankful for it. Our go-to order is the Cacio e Pepe pizza, and we always add ricotta (okay, sometimes they forget it -- and yes, that is genuinely disappointing), plus sausage and basil. When I get home, I drizzle hot honey on it and... shut up. It's unreal. Truly elite. We also love dabbling in the weekly pies -- always creative, always worth trying. And the fall salad? Simple, no frills, but not to be dramatic... it's my favorite salad in Denver until proven otherwise. Redeemer just gets it. If you're from NY and craving that familiar pizza comfort -- or if you just appreciate really good food done right -- this place deserves your loyalty.
Came here for lunch after everyone kept mentioning it. You walk in and go all the way to the back of the restraint to go to the outside patio. You read the menu and then you order your food. I ordered a redbull watermelon grown up drink. It was just fine. Then we ordered two slices of pep pizza The chicken Caesar hoagie Garlic knots. The slices of pep pizza were great. Hoagie could have been better if it wasn't drowning in ranch with every bite. I always forget that Caesar always comes swimming in it. I tried to remove some sauce to enjoy the rest but it didnt work. I did enjoy it up till then, and it had a great crunch! The garlic knots could have been a bit more garlicky but they would be fine when you are throwing some drinks back. They had great music playing and we came early-ish that it was us and another party so it was great. You can tell it gets crowded and it's fun. Glad we tried it and you should as well.
I stopped by Redeemer's Pizza in Denver after seeing a reviewer rank it in his Top 10, so my expectations were pretty high--and while it was a decent meal, I don't think it quite lived up to the hype for me. I ordered a slice of cheese pizza, and though they feature a sourdough crust, you couldn't really taste the distinct sourdough flavor; however, dipping it into a side of their tasty spicy ranch definitely elevated it. The absolute highlight of the trip was easily the garlic knots with chili oil, which were insanely good and packed with flavor. On the side, my aunt and Mimi got salads that came in huge portions, though they were pretty light on the dressing. Overall, it's an okay spot with a few great standouts, but not quite a top-tier favorite in my book.
Local pizza shop that was recommend. Walked in reminiscent of classic pizza parlors. They also have a patio seating that is heated as well which is nice. The people that worked there are nice and friendly. Unfortunately, the food is a little bit lacking in my opinion. The garlic knots is very doughy inside. It comes with her honey, which is a plus. The pizza that was recommended is the mushroom pizza. Unfortunately, they put some sort of balsamic with the dressing on the pizza, which makes us a little bit under the sour side. The cheese is OK. Honestly, it feels like an oily flatbread with a bunch of mushrooms on top drizzle with balsamic vinegar, then sprinkle with some Parmesan on top. It's just OK nothing crazy but definitely not a pizza that I would write home about.
I've had pizza from a lot of places in Denver, and we weren't wanting to go out so we decided to order pizza out and we were looking for a place that was different and that delivered, they have a great menu where you can order any kind of pizza build your own pizza etc. So we decided to go with just the traditional pepperoni pizza, we also ordered their garlic knots which were surprisingly delicious. Loved that they put mozzarella cheese on the inside of the garlic knots, the crust on the pizza was perfect and overall, we were extremely happy with our order. Will definitely try their other pizzas and look forward to going there in person. We will definitely be getting pizza here again, and yes, if you're looking for a place to order pizza for delivery, I would highly recommend this place.
1 month ago
5 days ago
Never again Redeemer, in a city with many other pizza options. We ordered carry-out and as pizza connoisseurs, we treat it like royalty in the car. On a grown-up's lap with 2 hands on the box at all time and minimal movement. When we opened the box, one of the pizzas had been just destroyed with the cheese and toppings all on one side, the other pizza arrived fine. Appearance aside, the taste was OK, nothing special. The crust to cheese/topping ratio was very poor. Overly greasy with mediocre taste and poor presentation. read more
19 days ago
Pizza is good! I like the crust. We opted for slices since we weren't sure if we'd like it. Perhaps next time we will spring for a whole pie, but the slices are generous and a great option. We also tried the Caesar and I thought it was great. It's an interesting little space. Definitely not much for atmosphere, but I can see how the vibe would change at night with the open divider between Redeemer and Meadowlark. We ordered from the counter in the back and it was pretty quick. read more
The pizza is delish! A bit of a limited menu, but awesome choices. Pretty pricey. Extra toppings are $3 or $4 for premium (meats primarily). Different pizza menu than other places. The pizza comes out piping hot and delicious. Ranch was bomb. Only other complaint is it's not a place I'd want to come and chill. Pretty small and the restaurant is hot. It's primary seating is the patio. read more
5 months ago
New York style pizza with a sourdough crust. Came here on a food tour and had a choice of the pizza of the week, cheese or pepperoni. I got the pizza of the week. The cheese was good, the crust was GREAT, the artichokes did not do it for me, they were pickled, I wasn't a fan of the sourness on the pizza. It's a great space for late night pizza when hitting the club next door. I'd like to try the other pizzas. I'll be back RiNo! read more
9 months ago
When you're in Rino and crave a pizza, this is the place to go. They have an interesting collection of pizza choices so something to suit everyone's tastebuds.i believe we got the cacio e pepe and it was a delicious pizza with the garlic sauce and pepperoni. We did order it with ricotta but they forgot. They were very nice and removed it from our final charge. I'm not sure if you could order slices but we ordered a whole pizza to share between 3 adults. The dining area is quite small. When we came in, there weren't a lot of tables available. It's a popular choice for everyone post 8pm. read more
Pretty good pizza at affordable prices. Thin crust that's really high quality. At lunch you can only order from the window and use the patio. The service was ok, I mean there isn't a ton of interaction ordering at the window and then picking up but the guy at the window was really helpful and nice. It's a super casual place but the pizza is good if you're in the area. I'm not sure about parking. I was there in the middle of the week and was able to find a spot very quickly but not sure about weekends or busy days. read more
Amazing New York style pizza in Denver! This was part of a Food Tour my bestie and I took during our annual weekend trip this time to Denver. Amazing service, the pizza wasn't too salty, and they were mindful of my dietary restrictions. It was a casual spot in an alley but the whole neighborhood was filled with cultural gems and amazing food. What an amazing East Coast treat out West in Colorado! read more
9 months ago
As someone from New York who grew up eating pizza religiously, I don't say this lightly: Redeemer Pizza is the closest thing to home pizza I've found in Denver. And I'm so thankful for it. Our go-to order is the Cacio e Pepe pizza, and we always add ricotta (okay, sometimes they forget it -- and yes, that is genuinely disappointing), plus sausage and basil. When I get home, I drizzle hot honey on it and... shut up. It's unreal. Truly elite. We also love dabbling in the weekly pies -- always creative, always worth trying. And the fall salad? Simple, no frills, but not to be dramatic... it's my favorite salad in Denver until proven otherwise. Redeemer just gets it. If you're from NY and craving that familiar pizza comfort -- or if you just appreciate really good food done right -- this place deserves your loyalty. read more
11 months ago
Came here for lunch after everyone kept mentioning it. You walk in and go all the way to the back of the restraint to go to the outside patio. You read the menu and then you order your food. I ordered a redbull watermelon grown up drink. It was just fine. Then we ordered two slices of pep pizza The chicken Caesar hoagie Garlic knots. The slices of pep pizza were great. Hoagie could have been better if it wasn't drowning in ranch with every bite. I always forget that Caesar always comes swimming in it. I tried to remove some sauce to enjoy the rest but it didnt work. I did enjoy it up till then, and it had a great crunch! The garlic knots could have been a bit more garlicky but they would be fine when you are throwing some drinks back. They had great music playing and we came early-ish that it was us and another party so it was great. You can tell it gets crowded and it's fun. Glad we tried it and you should as well. read more
2 months ago
I stopped by Redeemer's Pizza in Denver after seeing a reviewer rank it in his Top 10, so my expectations were pretty high--and while it was a decent meal, I don't think it quite lived up to the hype for me. I ordered a slice of cheese pizza, and though they feature a sourdough crust, you couldn't really taste the distinct sourdough flavor; however, dipping it into a side of their tasty spicy ranch definitely elevated it. The absolute highlight of the trip was easily the garlic knots with chili oil, which were insanely good and packed with flavor. On the side, my aunt and Mimi got salads that came in huge portions, though they were pretty light on the dressing. Overall, it's an okay spot with a few great standouts, but not quite a top-tier favorite in my book. read more
Local pizza shop that was recommend. Walked in reminiscent of classic pizza parlors. They also have a patio seating that is heated as well which is nice. The people that worked there are nice and friendly. Unfortunately, the food is a little bit lacking in my opinion. The garlic knots is very doughy inside. It comes with her honey, which is a plus. The pizza that was recommended is the mushroom pizza. Unfortunately, they put some sort of balsamic with the dressing on the pizza, which makes us a little bit under the sour side. The cheese is OK. Honestly, it feels like an oily flatbread with a bunch of mushrooms on top drizzle with balsamic vinegar, then sprinkle with some Parmesan on top. It's just OK nothing crazy but definitely not a pizza that I would write home about. read more
I've had pizza from a lot of places in Denver, and we weren't wanting to go out so we decided to order pizza out and we were looking for a place that was different and that delivered, they have a great menu where you can order any kind of pizza build your own pizza etc. So we decided to go with just the traditional pepperoni pizza, we also ordered their garlic knots which were surprisingly delicious. Loved that they put mozzarella cheese on the inside of the garlic knots, the crust on the pizza was perfect and overall, we were extremely happy with our order. Will definitely try their other pizzas and look forward to going there in person. We will definitely be getting pizza here again, and yes, if you're looking for a place to order pizza for delivery, I would highly recommend this place. read more
I'm giving the benefit of the doubt since we were semi disappointed. We ordered where it said 25-30 minutes for pickup. We arrive in about 23 minutes. The pizza was ready and in a box with others above it, so guessing it was there for a while. But we still had to wait on our garlic knots (which were delicious) for 3 minutes. The staff was great, and we loved the location and vibe of the entire place. The pizza itself was very tasty, but it was not crispy at all. We were only in Denver for a few days, and wanted to find the best pizza in town and were just honestly let down. read more
5 months ago
i looooove redeemer pizza!! the food is always amazing- i think i've tried every single pizza on the menu, and have never been disappointed. the mushroom is always a crowd pleaser! service is lovely, and they truly do care about the quality of their food. inside can get packed on weekends, but there is always the patio with lots of seating. also, they have some great weekday specials! read more
The special for this week had red sauce, double pepperoni, whipped ricotta, and chili honey. The slices were huge and I loved the crispness of the pepperoni. Dough had a great chew- only thing I would change is leaving the pizza in for a couple seconds more so it had a nice little char on the bottom. Otherwise it was so good! We went around 10:30pm and sat in the back alley-ish area next to the order window, weather was nice and you could see into meadowlark next door which is interesting lol. Service was fast and pizza was good, I'll be back! read more
3 months ago
Just visited for the first time and beyond impressed! Some of the best pizza, super fast service and fair pricing. There's a small seating area in the front and a larger covered patio at back. We got their weekly pizza special and brussel sprouts and were blown away by how good everything was. They had a steady line of delivery orders but our pizza was out within 10-15 minutes. They also have high chairs read more
REDEEMER NEVER DISAPPOINTS!!! Planned a stop at Redeemer recently on our way to a Broncos home game. We headed straight to the patio and ordered the garlic knots as well as a pepperoni pizza with two sides of chili honey (a must). This was our first time having the knots - they were not what we were expecting, but good. And of course the pizza was amazing!! There were four of us dining so we ordered the knots to help fill us up before the game...but next time I think we will just order more slices. While we were there the table next to us got the chicken sandwiches and they looked amazing, so I think we will try that next time as well! read more
11 months ago
2 years ago
4.5 stars. How has it taken me so long to come here? Redeemer has an edge over soo many pizza places (as someone who generally doesn't like pizza) for a few reasons: their crust is AMAZING! And the seasoning on their garlic knots is immaculate. I appreciate that they're open late Sunday night because that's often when I'm out in RiNo for events. My friend and I ordered the Diavolo which was delicious. Excellent amount of toppings and spice level. I didn't like the All the Mushrooms pizza that everyone else got. The balsamic glaze was too sweet. My partner ordered a Caesar Salad that was super dry. Then again, I'm not the type of person who would order a salad at a pizza joint. I like that there's alcoholic beverage options as well. I ordered an Aperol Spritz to unwind from the event we were at. My friend who is a regular here immediately escorted us to the back patio where there's a separate ordering window. Plenty of seating but I can see Redeemer getting busy. Would come back to satisfy my future pizza cravings! read more
1 year ago
Stopped in for a pizza I have only eaten here one other time and it was great .... Today not so good I ordered and before I could even surf my phone the pizza was on its way to the table could not have been 5 min Its no way I ordered the standard Pizza was luke warm ...very soggy and little to no cheese ...no char ... it seem to be a reheat to me ... Very unhappy I won't dog them as I live here You gotta do better on a standard pizza If you won't eat it don't serve it If im paying for it make it fresh ... it was no more than 5 people so it didn't appear to be to busy A local ... read more
4 months ago
Last night I ordered delivery from this place. I spent a lot of money on two specialty pizzas, and they delivered two boxes filled with random old slices that have probably been sitting out all day. I hope their fresh pizza doesn't taste like this... If I wanted cheese pizza I would have ordered it. read more
1 year ago
2 years ago
Came here on a random Monday for a date night. The pizza and salad were awesome. Never disappoints and it a good shareable size. The only thing that seems a little stingy is the price of the side, sweet chili and ranch. Should be like 50 cents not a dollar or more! They have a front house and back experience which is fun and lively. The food takes a few minutes to come out, maybe more depending on the day and time that you go. We only tried the NY style so next time we are going to go for the Sicilian. A good pizza spot with the pizza being priced well. But everything else including the sauces and drinks are a bit much. Two pizza slices, two sauces, one salad and two drinks should not be $50. Overall 4/5 stars read more
8 months ago
Pizza is one of my favorite foods and @redeemerpizza has never let me down and has quickly become one of my favorite spots. The pizza neon sign alone lets me know that I'm in the right spot. Everyone was so welcoming with a laid back and casual vibe. The service was amazing too! The use quality ingredients and the dough is PLUS their apps NEVER miss. They do a different special every week and it always hits the spot. MY ORDER: NY slice special (San Marzano tomato sauce, grande mozzarella, bell pepper, red onion, castelvetrano olives, aged Gouda), garlic knots with chili honey, onion rings and prosciutto, aperol spritzes! BEST BITE: every single bite was top tier but their chili honey AND their ranch may be the best I've ever had. I'm not a ranch guy but I would drink a pint of theirs read more
1 year ago
3.5 arancini... Redeemer is well known in Denver. They serve a good pie that is woodfired and sort of thin crust. By sort of I mean the edges have that typical blistered woodfired feel...the rest of the pie is not too thin crust and a tad more doughy. The texture and flavor are okay but I much prefer Marco's for the woodfired style and Blue Pan for the thicker style. I did really enjoy the Burrata and Garlic knots: The Burrata is rich and creamy and is served with fried artichoke pieces and the combo is really delicious. The Garlic knots use a dough that is rather sweet (something that was different for me). They were warm and delicious and the filing was oozing with lovely cheese.....add to that the hot honey and it is a mouth bomb. So besides the pizza being good not great the back patio was really depressing and cold. Pretty much everything back there was self service: you order at the counter and clean up yourself. Sure you items are delivered to you. I would highly recommend, suggest, implore, command,...okay beg you to dine inside as the experience looks/feels/tastes much better. Things are served on plates and just feel better...back patio made me feel like a hood rat scoring a dime bag of sumthin. Location is great as there are tons of bars, restaurants etc around. read more
We finally made it down to Redeemer. We had the Diavolo pizza, because we weren't sure if they would do half cheese, half pepperoni. This is a SPICY pizza, with jalapeños, pepperoni, and hot peppers. The crust was good. A bit too much crust for us, and half was very badly charred and therefore inedible. The combination of toppings was awesome. It's not a huge NY pizza. It's even smaller if you don't eat the crust. I had two slices, and my mouth was on fire, lol. You order in the back, and there's a water station with plastic cups and pitchers of water. Crushed red peppers and Parmesan are in packets by the water. You do get a table thingy, and your pizza is brought to the table. This is a super casual place. It's not overly decorated. Every table has a napkin dispenser, which is nice. The pizza wasn't overly greasy. N had a beer, and I had a very interesting mule that turned out to be nonalcoholic, so N had the bartender add some tequila. The mule was delicious. Very interesting flavors. Came with a slice of dried orange. Was it worth puffy allergy face? Um. I do prefer more pizza, less crust. However, toppings were yummy. Would have liked a bit more cheese. N's cheese slice was also burnt and the cheese was somewhat skimpy. We had ordered the garlic knots, but canceled the order due to concerns that they too might be burnt. They take 20 minutes, but we waited and waited, and when we asked, were told they would be a while. read more
Finally made it back in to try a full pie! We went with a pepperoni pie and were not super impressed. The pizza was certainly not bad, but also not great, and, in our opinion, not worth the price. Not a ton of flavor. We also tried the garlic knots and those were delicious! I'd come back for those, but would skip the pizza next time. read more
3 years ago
I'm not sure if their Winter Squash pizza is still available, but if it is, you should get it before the special goes away! I got takeout from here and the pizza was fantastic both fresh and leftover. I'd love to come back and try other pizzas they have. read more
1 year ago
The pizza dough is 10/10. I've tried the tomato pizza, and the corn and sausage pizza and they were so delicious. My favorite topping was the dio mio sausage. The aperol spritz went wonderfully with my meal. The restaurant is in a fun area of RiNo. The art and decor in the restaurant is great. read more
Page 1 of 7
More info about Redeemer Pizza
Redeemer Pizza Reviews in Other Languages
Ask the Community - Redeemer Pizza
Does the $10/person reservation fee on Tock count towards your final bill or is it an additional cost?
The refunded my card for the reservation
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
14 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
4 months ago
3 years ago
4 years ago
3 years ago
7 months ago
4 years ago
3 years ago
4 years ago
3 years ago
2 years ago
3 years ago
5 years ago
3 years ago
