My husband and I love trying new pizza places. We are very open-minded when it comes to trying different styles of pizzas. New York style deep dish, etc. I'm sad to report we were very bummed. We ordered the following: 1/2 Sicilian and 1/2 Spicy Pep. A slice of pepperoni and Lemon Pepper Wings. Not let's break it down. The Pizza: overall the taste of the pizza was very good. However, I must admit that the sauce was a little bit on the bitter side and by the time we ate it, it was extremely soggy. The pesto on the Sicilian pizza tasted a little sour and was not my favorite combination. The spicy pepperoni was probably our favorite of the two. Sidenote, we ordered our pizza to be well done but noticed that it was not. Like I said, the pizza was just very soggy. Lemon Pepper Wings: we love a good lemon pepper wing, but I will say that these wings were extremely salty. The salt was very overpowering. Like I said, we were disappointed, but will be giving Prime Pizza another opportunity. Instead of take out, we will be eating it right then and there and seeing if that changes things. Ohh and the ranch is amazing!! Best ranch I've had in a while!!!! read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

Wait did a little longer than expected, but I knew a new place. You're gonna have to wait other than that. The food and atmosphere is amazing. Truly can't wait to go back and try this place again read more

See all

The service at Prime Pizza was great. Pizza was good. Just a little long wait due to the restaurant is new in town. I took off one star due to the garlic knots were cool by the time I got it home. But the pizza stayed hot. Overall will try again. read more

Prime Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

See all

Pizza was good! Pepperoni was really good. Reg cheese needs just a little more sauce and a little more cheese. Service was excellent and the place was clean ! read more

We were so excited to go to this Prime Pizza after always having to drive out to Burbank! We ordered by slice and it was very fast. They told us it was a 5 minute wait but called us up in less than 2 minutes. Our pizza was COLD. Not even remotely warm. We were really disappointed. I understand that there was a line and that quick service is desired but at the cost of cold pizza...???? We're very disappointed. My boyfriend said that if this was our first time trying Prime, we would NOT choose to come back. But we know how good it CAN be from the Burbank one. I hope they fix the quality issue. The pizza itself was really good. As good as it can be when its cold. Another note. We got the text message that the pizza was done 5-7 minutes into eating, which makes me wonder if our pizza should have been cooking longer per protocol. Again, hoping our next experience is better and that the pizza is actually warm. read more

Prime Pizza - spicy pepperoni scillian - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

See all

Best pizza in Brea thus far. I wish they had more seating because sadly, they are a victim of rapid growth and success. Still worth the wait and the lines. read more

My first time here and it was great. The customer service was perfect and friendly. I love the fact you can order half and half for your food. I got half the pepperoni and half supreme. By far the best pizza I've had. Thank you to Christy and the staff for a great experience read more

Got a pizza today. Kaci c said the pizza was freshly made. I was suspicious because there were several pizzas on a rack in front by the register. Five minutes after paying for it I was done. Obviously not freshly made. I told her it was impossible to be freshly made. She said it was. The pizza was cold and not very tasty. I regret the purchase. Especially because they lied. I will never get pizza from this company. I really don't want to give it any stars. read more

Horrible wait for 4 slices of pizza. An hour and a half! Pizza was okay/ it's one of those one and done deal for us.

The pizza tasted worse than frozen pizza. The garlic knots with raw garlic was god awful and not edible. Service good and was a little busy. I took the food to go do I can't really say anything about the ambiance. read more

Where to begin we ordered on the app at 6:49 and the pick up what time was 915. OK fine. Let's try it. We get there at 9:10 wait till 915. We get a text saying the pizza is ready but the pizza was ready a long time ago cause we got it cold and soggy and it's very disappointing as a guy there lied right to my face and said he just put it in one of the box was very warm. The pizza was cold. The cheese was not melted, and the pizza was soggy. This place is overhyped on Instagram and TikTok. It's not worth it not worth the weight not worth the aggravation. The worst part was them lying to me right to my face. Won't be back here again. read more

We ordered a cheese pizza and a chicken chopped salad and some of the homemade ranch dressing. It was all very tasty! There was one small problem with the order, so my husband called and spoke with the Prime Pizza manager, who took great efforts to make it right. Great experience and good food. Glad to have a good New York style pizza place in Brea! We will definitely be back! read more

Helpful staff and delicious pizzas. Can't ask for more. Honestly surprised this spot isn't rated higher.

Was looking for NY Style Pizza Pie and this one was close by so I tried it! I would say the pizza felt a little overcooked (crust was darker and crunchier than I liked) which made it taste more bready/toasted when I bit into it as supposed to cheesy/saucy. I still enjoyed it! The garlic knots were not as toasted as I would have liked them to be, but the flavor was there! Would definitely order again and try different pies! read more

See all

My girlfriend and i come here frequently their pizza is good its always hot and fresh. Customer service is okay they do bring out the food quickly so thats a plus. read more

1. Spicy pep 2. Vodka 3. Caesar's salad 4. Ranch is amazing 5. Sparkling water 6. Round is better than square read more

As a born and raised new yorker this place is definitely the closest you'll get to a NYC slice in all of OC. I got the 4 pie deal with salad and knots for my impromptu moving in party. Admittedly we did eat it a lil cold but the flavor was still there. Even better as leftovers. Great way to settle into the new place but still feel like home. The marinara sauce for the garlic knots was insane! Everything came packed up separately so our salad and croutons didn't get soggy. They provided all utensils too. I know most places you have to specify if you want them nowadays so it was a nice not needing to unpack the kitchen right away to enjoy our meal. Also the whole meal was ready early on a saturday night! We were def getting hangry so it was really great timing for it to be done 15min earlier. Definitely ordering again. Their square pizzas and pastas are def next on the try list. read more

If you don't mind waiting 4 hours for your pizza to be delivered and no response from the restaurant when your concerns are expressed, this is the place for you! read more

We ordered a whole pie and got half Supreme and half White. The pizza crust, sauce, toppings, and toppings are all flavorful and delicious. Staff is friendly and courteous. I only wish that the pizza was able to hold the topping better, definitely had to fold the slice to prevent the pizza from flopping and spilling the toppings. There is also very limited outdoor only seating. read more

I have never wanted to try a pizza place/business more than I want to try this establishment. To all the recent one stars, how would you feel if hundreds of people showed up at one at your place of business at once. A social media post hype up the business, which was nice. With that, grew an unexpected crowd. What we they do to, hire last minute staff, buy a bigger establishment to accommodate the crowd. NO. Thats unrealistic. And what blows my mind is the reviews saying how great the pizza was but they couldn't accommodate you, you, the person who decided to follow a social media fad. That's on you, not the business. I CAN'T WAIT to try this place read more

Enjoyed our wonderful pizza today a rectangular pepperoni pie, New York style on sourdough. It was really good, we also got to meet their staff which was very friendly. Christy introduced herself and was very excited about her position with the company, she is what a manager should be talking with customers. I had a great experience and will return to try the other pizzas. Thank you. read more

Mid pizza with service to match. When they serve the person that walked in the door behind you and cut in front of you that's all you need to know. read more

Met Christie at Brea Fest 2026 and she was so awesome and fun to talk to! The pizza was also so tasty.

The pizza brought me back to my trip from New York! The service was welcoming! Small cozy spot with outdoor seating I can't wait to come back! read more

The pizza was crispy. I gave this 2 stars because customer service matters to me. I spent more money buying a couple of combos than I would have on a whole pizza, yet I was told I couldn't get even one packet of cheese or crushed red peppers because I didn't purchase a whole pie. I paid the same amount. As a first-time customer, this was disappointing, and I just expected a better experience. For being a new business that just opened. this left a bad impression. I don't think I'll be back. read more

Average pizza, better options out there. Crust was tough and grainy. Pizza a little greasy. This one is a skip for me!

Wait was a little long... but well worth it. This pizza was fantastic. Garlic knots and salad were great too. This place is a 10/10, and hands down the best pizza around brea. read more

Luv the pizza Buffalo wings are great and the chicken Caesar salad tasted wonderful Prime pizza just became my favorite pizza store~ The staff were super friendly Thank you for the friendly service ~~ read more

Since I came back from NY in 07...I've been looking for anything that comes close to ny pizza. While I didnt have prime when I was in ny....this place def did not disappoint! The shop itself reminded me of ny...black n white tile, well lit, Friendly workers and pizza slices for sale on display! The parking lots a good size...could get crowded on a weekend though. There's no seating inside but there are benches and seating outside. Lots of choices on the menu! Pizza, salads, garlic knots...even fresh juices that they bottle themselves (their lemonade...fire!) My friend and I got half sausage and kale (never had kale on a pizza)...and half arribiatta (spicy tomato) both were really good!! While I love kale and sausage..I do gotta say I think I liked the arribiatta better! Light spice, good amount of cheese, and thin sliced onion. Crisp, thin under carriage..lightly chewy crust...this pizza came really close to reminding me of ny :). My only critique: for pizza...its pretty expensive. Bout $27-30 for a 18" pie. +drink...you're almost at 40$. I can get the same sourdough ny style pizza down here for about $5-8 less. With all that being said though, id def go back to try different pies!..lmk what you guys think!! read more

Delicious pizza and yummy garlic knots! I love that they are not in the main Birch Street area downtown, so there's decent parking in a walkable distance. Can't wait for next week to order again! read more

Freakin delicious. Can't wait to come back to try the other flavors. Got the white slice and spicy pepperoni. Seating is limited, they have two small tables outdoors. read more

Wow wanted to try since the Brea location opened. It wasn't crowded but it definitely wasn't worth it. Pizza was cold and stale. Maybe from yesterday. The crust was too hard and chewy to be made today. Lemon Pepper wings tasted like someone Spilled the whole bottle of seasoning on the wings. It was too sour to eat because of too much seasoning. Probably won't go back. I feel for my money and price fresh Pizza should always be made. read more

The best NY style pizza in North OC with great flavor, perfect crust, and a must-try spot.

Service was great, the pizza wasn't. I keep seeing this place being hyped on social media so wanted to try it. I thought it was just ok nothing special or memorable. I'll try it again but I don't have any high expectations. read more

Customer service needs major improvement. Came here for the first time to grab some pizza slices for my kids. The cashier seemed annoyed waiting for my order. It was the attitude that was transparent. Then I asked another employee for a bag to go as I am currently disabled walking and was denied. What bothered me was the tone of this employee. No apology but her tone was like it was a stupid question. Won't be going here again that's how bad the service was. read more

My bf and I have been waiting for brea to get a good pizza place and this place is so freaking good!!! wait was a little long about an hour and 30 minutes but that was expected as it is like their 2nd weekend open and they are getting a lot of social media attention! ordered online and showed up about 10 min before it said it would be ready and waited inside on the bench until it was ready! Staff was super nice too! It's a small place, no seating inside and is brand new so don't be mean! have patience! also the ranch was SOOOO good like actually lives up to the hype. Pizza was perfect and crispy and the spicy arrabbiata pizza was so incredible!!! (added pep) Staff said stop by during the week for better wait times! read more

Just tried their pizza. Very good. Different toppings were great. Will definitely go back

This is very good thin crust New York style Pizza Recommend it heartily they sell by the slice or whole Pie quick service as well we ordered on a Friday night when the place was named with people and it was ready in about 40 min Only critique is that the don't have Sausage or mushroom pizzas by the slice only cheese and pepperoni read more

Giving this place 5 stars because the service was good and it was my first time trying this pizza place and the lady on register seemed to have been aware and read the room so she recommend the spicy pepperoni with our order and told us to try the garlic knots stating they were really good as well. Definitely coming back! read more

Unbelievable!!!! I don't know what's going on with primes social media person or the management at the Brea Prime but it's a straight switch and bait, false advertising. Today on Pi Day, 314, they advertised find the Golden Ranch bottle and win a gift card for $314 then when you show up they said it doesn't start till 4:00 p.m. after waiting hours to be the first one to find the bottle then they changed their Tone and say it's totally random. Completely false advertising in a illegal switch and bait. I think this might be the last time I go to Prime Pizza and if anyone ever asked me about prime pizza I'm going to tell them that they continue to have false advertising and don't come through on their promises read more