Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Preston Eatery

    4.8 (41 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 6:00 pm

    Preston Eatery Photos

    Business Info

    PRESTON EATERY ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Preston Eatery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Menu
    Nadira Y.

    I stopped by to grab some lunch and I was not disappointed! What an incredibly freindly atmosphere they have here. From being greeted upon entering, to mentioning they are there to answer any questions, and being thanked upon leaving. The service itself already makes me want to return. The food was delicious. They have many offerings: grab and go meals, desserts to go (bars, cookies, etc.), and sandwiches/salads that are freshly prepared. I ordered the chicken pesto sandwich ($9). The chicken wrap looked equally tasty and I will get that next time. The sandwich did not shy from chicken or pesto. It was very filling and tasted fresh. I also got the lemon bar and blueberry bar. Both were tasty. For the blueberry bar, I recommend heating it up for 20 seconds before eating. It was a game changer for me. They have weekly specials for their grab and go meals and desserts. Join their Facebook page to view the most updated weekly offerings. Overall, a high quality food and friendly local business. It is also woman owned, which is amazing. I will definitely be back to try other items and get some grab and go meals too.

    Outside
    Hannah B.

    Really neat concept! They have a small menu- salads and sandwiches made to order. Also, 2 huge cases of grab and go reheat options. Their menu rotates every week and they put the menu on their Facebook page or you can signup for their email. I got the chicken salad (yum), breakfast burrito (yum) and soup (haven't tried yet). It's fun to go in and get a few things to make the week easier.

    Sweet treats in addition to lots of 'grab and go' entree's!
    Mrs Anne Marie W.

    Saw a sign that mentioned grab-and-go meals, decided to check it out. In addition to a robust catering business they also offer meals to go like Italian pot roast and vegetarian shepherd's pie. They even had sweets with things like sliced cake, cupcakes, and the local favorite buckeyes. $15-22 per entre. Comes in a round foil tin, reheats in the oven, and would generously serves two people. Great alternative to home-cooked meal at home. Or meal kits with lots of steps! Vegetarian options, also gluten-free. I definitely recommend giving them a try!

    Blueberry Bar
    Griffen W.

    Top notch and fresh! I'm upset I live in Cleveland, but I will be back soon to try everything else!

    From Preston Catering's IG!! (11/22/2019)

    See all

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Preston Eatery

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Salad 723 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Chapman’s Eat Market - Smashed cucumbers.  Salt and soy.  Very good as a snack or with the burger.

    Chapman’s Eat Market

    4.5(240 reviews)
    8.5 miGerman Village

    Quick update: We were able to get a table in the front on…read morethe last day of service at 8:15. Thanks to whoever cancelled. The house was frantic as it was packed with several groups either adding on folls to their parties last minute or trying to walk in! Appreciate the staff handling everything with a smile. The chef was out delivering food and shaking hands as everyone shared their favorite memories of the restaurant. Coming off of Bourbon fest, we decided for light fare and got a closing drink along with the Off Menu red snapper crudo with rice paper crackers, watermelon salad, and pomodoro pasta. We shared everything and took half the pasta to go. The crudo was fresh and creamy with an avocado base while the watermelon salad was brine, sweet, and refreshing at the same time. Definitely have to try that at home. A great ending night for us and the Chapman legacy.

    Sad it's closed - A great gem in the heart of German Village. Inviting atmosphere, perfect for a…read moredate night, girls night out, or for an evening of unique eats & drinks. The service is fantastic with lots of great suggestions and personal feedback. Each dish has a unique twist to it that's guaranteed to be something new and delicious you haven't had yet. Definitely a must try!

    Photos
    Chapman’s Eat Market - Chapman's double burger and onion rings.  The onion rings are light, fluffy, and spicy!

    Chapman's double burger and onion rings. The onion rings are light, fluffy, and spicy!

    Chapman’s Eat Market - That's a burger.  Double burger in fact.

    That's a burger. Double burger in fact.

    Chapman’s Eat Market - Sweet corn and blueberry ice cream.

    See all

    Sweet corn and blueberry ice cream.

    Pat and Gracie's - FRIED CHICKEN COBB SALAD

    Pat and Gracie's

    4.1(63 reviews)
    7.6 miDowntown
    $$

    Pat and Gracie's is very near to capital Square, and is an excellent location for a lunch or dinner…read morewith friends or colleagues. Great for finding some food before attending a show at one of the nearby theaters. The menu is what I would best describe as comfort, food. Burgers, pot roast, chicken, pastas, and other selections, which are filling and delicious. A menu is available for review online. Parking is available on street and in a variety of garages and flat lots located throughout the area.

    I've had this place bookmarked for a while but never found ourselves in downtown cbus until today…read more We saw a matinee show at the Ohio Theatre (highly recommend) and then walked over to Pat & Gracie's for a late lunch. Arrived approximately 3:30pm - restaurant basically empty (maybe 5 tables total occupied). Went to check in for 2 and the host said he had reservations at 5. Huh? So I asked do you mean you can't seat us until 5? And he said no, that we need to leave by then because other people are coming. I thought that was very weird and unprofessional. I've never had an experience like that before. It's a basic sit down place, why would you think we'd linger for more than an hour and a half? Whatever, weird feeling, but we were seated. Seated in the walkway. Not like in a path but literally blocking the walkway where you step down. Why do I say this? Because people walking by kept banging into me. Not their fault. Why is there a table there? And why were we seated there when at least 80% of the restaurant was empty???? Ok whatever. Ordered food including their signature made in-house tots. Waitress comes back and says they were slammed in the morning and they're out of tots. (Man I feel bad for the people coming at 5. LOL) whatever except the people at the next table appeared to be served tots. Food was tasteless. The Mac and cheese had a weird texture like the roux wasn't cooked properly. My patty melt was mostly bread as the patty was too small for the bread. My husband had the signature chimi burger and it completely lacked any chimichurri flavor. Like at all. We were out by 4ish (plenty of time for them to prepare for their expected onslaught) and needless to say I've unbookmarked this place from my yelp. Maybe we'll try the Mexican place across the street next time. ‍

    Photos
    Pat and Gracie's - Women's Bathroom

    Women's Bathroom

    Pat and Gracie's - SPICY CHICKEN SANDWICH

    SPICY CHICKEN SANDWICH

    Pat and Gracie's - Pearl  Beatty

    See all

    Pearl Beatty

    The Old Mohawk - Smokey Bacon Gouda Bites

    The Old Mohawk

    4.0(461 reviews)
    8.6 miGerman Village
    $$

    A cute, homey restaurant with "small town", small business vibes. Staff was super friendly, portion…read moresizes were large, and the meal was delicious. It may not look like much, but it packs a whole lot of "great" inside of it! PROS: -Service is fantastic. The servers, despite being less than an hour from close, were super friendly, and they made me feel like I was part of everything. No clique-y vibes or disgruntled employees. Lots of joking and laughing from the staff when they weren't serving. -Food was delivered freakishly fast. We had barely got our beer when we had apps, and we had only managed to get the chili cooled enough for a few bites before entrees came out. The kitchen was really on top of things. -Really large selection of salad options. Their ranch was really delicious, but most importantly, all the salads felt like relatively "healthy" salads unlike many places that try to make them restaurant "quality" by stuffing them with cheese and other treat-y options. This could definitely be a place you could take someone who had to watch what they were eating for various reasons. -Prices were very, very reasonable, and we came away with a good meal without spending too much. -It was raining when we left, and staff was offering to walk people to their cars with their restaurant umbrella. Seriously, it was amazing. CONS: -No dedicated parking lot. There were decent available spots on a Thursday night at dinner, though. It just might be a few blocks walk. -As a chill night, it was okay, but I could feel this place feeling a bit crowded with tables too close together on really busy nights.

    I always forget about this Columbus mainstay and their turtle soup. Got the chance to visit again…read moreafter many years and enjoyed trying the chicken salad quesadilla. Salad had a nice texture and seasoning and I enjoyed the crispy tortilla. Great, friendly service. Parking is a bit challenging and the decor can use a bit of updating without losing their old timey feel.

    Photos
    The Old Mohawk - Lots of local artwork on the walls for sale.

    Lots of local artwork on the walls for sale.

    The Old Mohawk - Mohawk House Salad

    Mohawk House Salad

    The Old Mohawk - Greystone Ketchup

    See all

    Greystone Ketchup

    Preston Eatery - salad - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...