I had a group of friends over for a visit yesterday, and I wanted to provide them with something other than the usual "pizza" thing that everybody and their cousin does. I ordered two days ahead of time 12 regular lamb gyros and 2 chicken gyros. I told the woman that I would pick them up at 5:50 and so yesterday at precisely 5:50 there were my gyros, all wrapped and ready to go in a nice foil container to help retain heat. They were amazing, and several of my guests inquired where I got them. Staff was polite and professional and the gyros were clearly identified so we instantly recognized and could differentiate between the two types I ordered. Gyro flavor was delicious. Ingredients were fresh and flavorful. I have no reason to visit any other gyro place, when I know where I can go to get one that is perfection. read more

Was served very old grainy humus, they replaced it for a fresh one no issues. The fresh one was average to below in flavor. Gyro meat was great! Inside was well kept and workers were chillin, in a good way. I do not recommend this place for Greek food. All the food was average to below overall. read more

This is t first time here. I have passed this place many times and have always wanted to visit. So...here we go. They have private parking in back which was great. We started with the spinach feta pie. That was outstanding! I ordered the Greek steak and rice. It came with plenty of sauce on the side. We shared a Greek salad as well. It didn't have dressing on it so I was a little surprised. The service was fine. Did not have any issues ordering. We asked to sit outside and they brought our meal to us. The place was extremely clean and well taken care of. Nothing was outdated. I am recommending Gyro Shoppe to all my Yelp followers. read more

No. 1 Gyro Shoppe - Welcome to No. 1 Gyro Shoppe - Greek Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

I had a taste for Mediterranean food and am so happy I found this restaurant. The cashier was friendly and explained the menu options. I ordered the chicken kabob which is served with a salad and rice, along with sliced pita bread. Everything was delicious. The chicken was moist and full of flavor. The garlic sauce that serves as salad dressing and a dipping sauce was unexpectedly good. When I arrived I was the only customer. However, within 10'mins the restaurant was busy. This has been added to my list of restaurants to visit when I'm in the area. read more

No. 1 Gyro Shoppe - Chicken Kebob - Greek Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Ordered 2 jumbo gyros to go. Service was fast and efficient. Gyros were delicious good amount of meat in the jumbo. Place is small but looks nice and clean if you want to dine in read more

Nice cozy atmosphere at this establishment. Was a nice place to enjoy a quick meal with the family. Cashier was nice. Options were good. Prices were fair. We all enjoyed what we ordered and had a good time. Portions were ample. For a quick bite, we will certainly return. Fair-to-Good value. read more

Stopped in last week after church this place was packed. Now that I have stopped here I see why. The food was delicious and delivered to the table hot. The French fries were so good soft in middle, but crunch on the outside. This place was super clean including the restrooms. They do have a bigger jumbo Gyro 9oz of meat if you want the big portion. They also have Hummus appetizer that looked so good maybe next time. read more

No. 1 Gyro Shoppe - Mini Gyro meal - Greek Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

The ingredients were all fresh & The restaurant is extremely clean. Great service with friendly people & super clean restrooms. Wonderful experience read more

No. 1 Gyro Shoppe - No. 1Gyro Shop, Hilliard Cemetery Rd. - Greek Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

AMAZING food. new favorite restaurant in town for sure. needs more business, this place is WILDLY underrated!!!! local, family run, great gyros and great service. highly recommend. even has drive-tru! read more

No. 1 Gyro Shoppe - gyro shoppe - Greek Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

The service here was great. The staff were really nice and helpful. Our food came out pretty quickly. The restaurant itself looks like it was an old bank or something, probably not a restaurant originally. The food was great! The chicken teriyaki gyro was surprisingly tasty and the jumbo gyro was for sure jumbo. Would fire sure recommend this place if you like gyros and you're within 30 minutes of here. read more

No. 1 Gyro Shoppe - 6 oz. Teriyaki Chicken Gyro Sandwich - Greek Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

Love their food so much I'm there all the time. The price is so good too for all that you get with a combo and they always make it super fast. read more

Food is consistently good. fries are crispy. Cheese sticks are Yummy . They don't skip on the meat.

Would leave a 0 if I could. Picked up some after work to take home ordered 6 regular gyros with NO ONION. Got home (across town) and half were chicken and ALL had onions. Pitas were rock hard (obviously got lunch leftovers). Called and the did offer to re-make the order if I drove 15 miles back across town in rush hour traffic. Nope. Sent an email with pics to the email address on their homepage. No response (shocker). No chance I'm coming back and definitely will spread the word. Unacceptable experience. read more

I have been here twice now and the experience has been consistent enough to say that I probably will not return. The food is good, but the value is not what I would like to see. I got the jumbo gyro combo and calamari. I have experienced shrinkflation pretty much everywhere like everyone else whenever I spend money, but I was legitimately shocked at the calamari. There were 6 rings of calamari for $9 - good, but nowhere near worth the price point. Aside from good food, there's not really any redeeming qualities to eating here. The dining room was very dirty and there was an unpleasant smell hanging in the air. The wait is not excessive, but the service both times was poor in my opinion. I've heard good things about Crazzy Greek, might check them out next time... read more

No. 1 Gyro Shoppe - 9. Nine oz. Jumbo Gyro with Fries Combo and calamari. I ate one ring, but that's what $9 gets you... - Greek Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

Super filling gyro combo. Genuinely surprised at how good everything was. Fries were well seasoned and crisp. read more

No. 1 Gyro Shoppe - Medium 7. Six oz. Gyro with Fries Combo - Greek Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Great prices on their combo meals. They have a "small" gyro, but there is nothing small about it! Also have fresh brewed ice tea and all the accessories (lemon, sweetener, etc). Staff is friendly, restaurant is clean and tidy. They also have a drive through for those on the go. read more

Tasty gyros and Greek food. Definitely fresh and flavorful. This has become our "go-to" gyro shop. read more

Friend recommended this place. Ordered the jumbo gyro (9oz) combo that came with a drink and fries ($10). Food was ready in 2 minutes! Their fries were perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside and the seasoning was five stars. The gyro was stuffed with tons of meat and tasty. Staff was friendly. Overall, definitely recommend and would come again. read more

No. 1 Gyro Shoppe - Delicious fries - Greek Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

Good place for a quick bite during a long roadtrip. The food was tasty and veryyy affordable. Staff is polite. Indoor and outdoor seating available. read more

No. 1 Gyro Shoppe - Gyro entrees - Greek Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

I have ordered here a few times I get the jumbo gyro combo. Never do they put enough sauce on and that should not be a request. I ordered online and asked for ketchup and vinegar and guess what not in the bag. Someone picked it up for me and it was stapled shut but nothing is worse than having to eat everything plain and dry. Please if someone asks for condiments give it to them. I was craving vinegar and was left dissatisfied. read more

Our favorite Greek restaurant - we always get lamp chops and the beef kebobs - both are always fresh and delicious! The pita bread is amazing, usually ge the calamari with the spicy dip too. read more

I had the large gyro combo. Good stuff that I haven't had in awhile. The fries were very good. My friend's onion rings smelled very good. He didn't offer me any. So I have to take that as a good sign. read more

On par every time. Their gyros are amazing and love their French fries. We mainly go throught the drive thru and they do a great job.

I've been here a handful of times over the past few years and have never been disappointed. I normally get the mini chicken gyro with fries and it's the perfect amount of food for me. The fries are always fresh and flavorful and the gyro is always filled up. There's plenty of seating and even some seats outside. I definitely recommend giving them a try! read more

I needed something quick and cheap, and this place came through- with a tasty meal that got me on my way. The building is fairly new (or newly redone.) Nice inside and out. Walk in, and it's a pretty typical fast food setup, plus a case with apps and desserts. I got a #5 combo- mini gyro, spinach pie, and drink. Added a piece of baklava, and had a good meal for $10. The gyro was on a nice soft pita, stuffed with tender, lightly seasoned meat, and some fresh lettuce and tomatoes. Not huge, but not tiny. The spinach pie was kinda like a turnover, and was again mild, with good flaky crust and lots of spinach. The baklava was very good: moist (sometimes it can be dry,) full of honey without being overly messy. Service was good, value is good, flavors were good. I'll definitely keep this in mind. They had a big menu, so you can get something little or a full meal. read more

No. 1 Gyro Shoppe - #5 combo (mini gyro, spinach pie) plus baklava. - Greek Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Number One Gyro Shoppe has a new Hilliard location. It's a nicer area than the original. The food is still better than average Greek fast food. It usually is pretty fast. They also have a drive thru. I had the falafel pita. It's about $6 for a sandwich. The falafel doesn't come in a combo, which stinks. Almost every other kind of sandwich does of course. They have the usual stuff like gyros. Appetizers include hummus, which tastes like it was made fresh. They have a case of baklava and other sweets. It usually won't take long to get your food. It has a drive they like the other one. Taking your food from the inside seems to be faster though. read more

No. 1 Gyro Shoppe - Falafel Pita - Greek Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

For drive thru Gyros this place is the bomb!!! This place is inexpensive and the food is very tasty!!!

Columbus offers a lot of variety when it comes to Gryos. No. 1 Gyro in Hilliard was all you could ask for when it came to price and quality of food ! I got a regular sized original Gyro which was about 6$. They also offered a variety of bowls, salads, and desserts. read more

No. 1 Gyro Shoppe - a car parked in front - Greek Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

food is amazing. Good gnocchi, top best Greek, fast food, quick efficient, and delicious. Service was great, and the amniance was even better all right this place of 50 out of five for sure delicious. read more

I have eaten here a million times- always my favorite but today when we got our take out order home, my chicken gyro was missing the feta we added, it had very little sauce, and the chicken was very dry- so supper disappointed. They also did not put straws for our drinks or ketchup for our fries in the bag. read more

It's a fast food chain, sometimes it's good, sometimes it's just OK.. it's never truly exceptional and never terrible.. I'd say it's just somewhere in the middle.. read more

Whenever we don't know what we want to eat, we come here. From gyros, salads, and their baklava, you can't go wrong.

So we went through the drive thru at around 6:15 at 8/25. We were the third car that was pulling in. We sat in front of the ordering screen for several minutes. We kept saying hello, but nobody would respond or tell us to wait a minute which I would understand if they were trying to catch up on the people that had already ordered. Instead, the girl that was wearing the headset at the time, proceeded to mock us because she didn't seem to understand that she didn't Turn her headset off, so we couldn't hear her. This behavior is very unprofessional, and in all honesty it's Soward, my desire to ever come back to this place. That's a shame because the food there is really really good, but I have a hard time wanting to do business at a place that insults their customers just because the customers aren't getting any response of any kind from the ordering screen. read more

Easily the best fast greek food around. Always fresh, always hot, and super flavorful. The chicken breast on my salad is so tender I cut it with a plastic fork! read more

No. 1 Gyro Shoppe - Greek chicken salad Chicken breast so tender I cut it with a plastic fork. - Greek Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

We sat in the drive through for about three minutes with no response but could here noise coming through the drive through speakers. We weren't sure if they knew we were there so we said hello. The girl manning the drive through unaware of how to operate her headset then proceeded to mock us "hello! Hello!" unaware that we could hear everything she was saying. Really quite unprofessional. Rating 1 star because really who needs that experience. I'll just eat somewhere else. read more

I've tried the gyro and a few other items in the past. The food could be better. My biggest complaint is the meat portions. I tried the gyro sub today and was once again quite disappointed in the small portion of gyro meat included in the sub. It was mostly lettuce, onions, feta cheese. It could have easily passed as a vegetarian sub. read more

Love this place's name. Right to the point, and includes an alternate spelling of the word "shop". This is just a good, solid place to get some gyros. We've never dined in, only went through the drive through. Every time the gyros have been a good size and consistent quality. I wouldn't say it's breaking ground for the gyro industry or anything, but if you want some gyros this is a good place to go. read more

No. 1 Gyro Shoppe - A wrapped gyro - Greek Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Very good gyro's. Nice portion and very good. We also got the garlic hummus which is mild on garlic flavor. I got the calamari, perfect, breading has a little spicy kick and so does the dipping sauce. Everything was made to order, so it was hot and fresh. Only complaint, is the were using cheap ketchup packets, why hand out cheap ketchup when you are making good frys? read more

Delicious gyros, really good for what is just a little fast food joint on the side of the road.

Kinda ripped this place when they first opened about 3 years ago, so thought I would update. Gave them another shot a while back, and have been coming back ever since. Very solid, great spinach pie, great tzaziki and great hot sauce. Much much better now, love the fact they have a drive thru as well. I always get the combo with the mini gyro and spinach pie with a side of fries. I tell them to make my fries spicy (sort of like cajun fries from 5 guys), then I get a side of tzaziki and a side of hot sauce. So good, so amazing. read more