Given the spotty reviews, I was admittedly a little apprehensive about choosing Poquitos as the venue for my boyfriend's birthday dinner, but I am so glad I did!
On a Tuesday night, our party of 6 had no wait/trouble getting a reservation and were given excellent service for the entire time we were there (about 2.5 hours?) Our waiter was attentive and friendly without smothering us, and the food was excellent. When I asked him for wine recommendations, he was honest in admitting he had little knowledge about the house offerings, and instead had a bartender come table side with a few complementary tastings so I could make an informed selection (awesome!).
Without further delay, here's the breakdown on what we ordered:
- chips and salsa: the chips are excellent here, not overly salted or greasy, and just the right amount of crisp. the salsa is flavourful, but lacks heat (could use a little more "oomph")
- guacamole: undeniably FRESH. chunky, with a made-to-order taste. I would say it lacked salt/garlic/something, but the quality of the ingredients certainly helped.
- I went with the evening's special, rainbow chard tacos. A bit risky, but in the end totally worth it! You wouldn't expect something like chard to taste good in a taco, but somehow all the ingredients worked. I appreciated the waiter bringing me some extra anchote salsa to turn up the heat on my dish since I am a heat-seeking machine! the rice and beans were also excellent, simply done without fussy extra ingredients. The entire plate had a clean finish on the palate.
- The boyfriend ordered carnitas, which were by and large the "fanciest" presentation of carnitas I'd ever seen. Given the speed with which he inhaled his entree, I'm assuming it was all good.
- A friend ordered the goat which he raved about as well, and two others ordered the enchiladas which looked lovely and not overly-smothered in sauce (a pet peeve of mine when it comes to dining at mexican restaurants).
- fried grasshoppers!!! For just $1, you gotta do it, at least once. FYI they taste mostly salty/limey, and go great with beer.
- Aside from a smattering of beers and wine, we also ordered the "El Dude" cocktail, which, unless you've been living under a rock your entire life, should sound familiar (ahem, Jeff Bridges fans unite!). Somehow, the tequila and horchata work marvelously together, so if you're a fan of classic white russians I'd say you'd definitely want to give this a try.
Some people have complained about portion size, but to everyone at our table the portions seemed just right. I honestly couldn't even eat all 3 of my tacos and finish my sides, but I also don't usually eat huge quantities of food. If you're the type to go for third and fourth plates at buffets, or be able to finish an entire plate at say, Claimjumper, then yes, the portions will feel small to you. Given the choice though, I'd rather have a smaller portion of something that tastes great versus a huge plate of bland/gross food.
What I appreciate the most about this restaurant is the creativity of vegetarian dishes (something other than bean and cheese burritos? amazing!) and the marvelous decor. The impecable service doesn't hurt either. Our waiter even offered to split our tab FIVE ways and divide up my boyfriend's entree and drinks among the five of us so he wouldn't have to pay a tab, and we didn't even have to ask him to do so (he offered once he knew it was a birthday gathering). In terms of ambience, I would say it's a bit more social/buzzy than Barrio, and less intimate/romantic. A great place for a small party/gathering, and you'd better believe I'll be back many many times! read more