Love this place. Never had a bad slice and my kid loves the spaghetti.

Yum yum yum this is the closest to New York style pizza I have ever been able to find in Arizona

After reading the other reviews, I really don't have much new to add. Momma Mia's was my go-to pizza place (as someone else already said). The same lady is working the counter. She even remembered me. I always ask for "the usual" which for me is the 2 slices of pizza and a drink special for $3.50. Good stuff, good price, fast service and large slices. read more

Great service and GREAT NY style pizza! This is my favorite pizza in Phoenix... and we all know there are lots of options! If you liked Mama Mia's... well, I see the same awesome pizza chef behind the counter so it is still great pizza just a new name and new owners... Give this pizza a try and it will be your new favorite!! read more

My son was wanting pizza and we didn't wanna do anymore driving since we just got in from a long road trip. Looked up the local pizzerias and this place had the best reviews. Yelp doesn't say they deliver but if you check out their website they do. Placed our order for delivery at our hotel for two slices of cheese pizza, spaghetti, and fries. The delivery was quick, and once we opened the brown bags the food came in we were a little overwhelmed by the amount of food. Wasn't expecting the slices to be so big ( I'd compare the size to Costco pizza sizes). We dug into the food and man was it delicious. Would definitely go back and recommended to anyone looking for good pizza and spaghetti. read more

Definitely one of my local favorites. Great pizza and even better pasta! The pizza is thin crust and reminds me of NY. Prices are very reasonable. I highly recommend... much better than the large chains. read more

I was very happy to see Mama Mia's reopen as Pizza on 40th. It is the same great pizza at the same great prices. I have been going to this location for years, and if you want slices of pizza, it is the best deal in town. The location is small and no frills, but the pizza and prices more than make up for it. The employees are very friendly too, especially Denise, who usually works the counter. read more

wow was this bad, talk about bland and absolutely no flavor.. if you cant pass the cheese only pizza in ny style then fugetaboutit !! everyone else in the party was throwing crap on there cheese pizza and saying how good it was, if it was so good you wouldnt have to add all crap to it. read more

Worst experience ever. We ordered online, got a confirmation, money was taken from our account, yet when my wife showed up, the rude girl at the counter would not honor the order! Then, she would not even help my wife, and refused to even LOOK at the order on my wife's phone, or the online bank debit showing they STOLE our $22 bucks! She just ignored my wife! Really?? Some idiot from the kitchen even speculated it was my wife's fault somehow. HOW? Her fault that she GAVE them our money and got NOTHING for it?!? If I could, I would give them ZERO stars. DO NOT EVER GO HERE, even if the food's okay, it's made by people who have no basic human decency or integrity. read more

I picked up a large cheese pizza last Friday night. I felt welcomed as the girl behind the counter was so sweet. A family was out front chowing down on some pizza, people inside bustling around getting the Friday rush of orders organized. It felt like a small family owned pizza joint you'd find in NYC. Drove the 10 minutes home and the pizza was still hot and it was honestly delicious! Not to mention it was EVEN TASTIER the next day heated up in the oven! I'm a huge fan of the craft pizza around Scottsdale (Pomo, craft 64 etc) but when it comes to the original, simple, nostalgic pizza - it's Pizza on 40th for me! read more

AMAZING!!! Great wings and pizza. Also great customer service. Will definitely be back.

3 stars right off the bat, as I paid extra for more ranch with my wings and it was forgotten about. They staple the bag shut so be sure to ask before leaving. read more

Textbook definition of "meh".... food is priced appropriately low. the food is average. You get what you pay for at this place.

Pizza is really good but it's so hard to choose between the pizza and a stromboli because of the little cup of marinira sauce they give you. I can drink the marinara sauce by the gallon! Today I decided to order the fettuccini. For $8 I got a drink, bread and a plate of pasta that was enough to feed at least 3 people. It was good however could use some salt. While they do have seating outside, always be prepared to take your food to go because there are always people there! read more

Had the cheese pizza and the meat lovers. It's rather pricy compared to other pizza places, but you do not get the typical cookie cutter pizza. It's a small place, so you may want to get it to go. read more

I just got an XL Supreme, no pepperoni with extra sausage instead, cooked well done (as usual), and it is sublime! They don't put too much stuff on so it a "real" slice. Don't go anywhere else in the neighborhood if you like a good, old fashioned Italian pizza! read more

This is THE WORST SERVICE I have ever had. I ordered my pizza tonight at 6:30PM. They said my order would be delivered to me by 7:35PM. I suspected it was a busy night. I called around 7:30PM to ask if my order had gone out. A girl named "Chelsea" said it was and it would be here shortly. I had to call back 3 separate times to find out where my order was. After 35 minutes, I had to call and cancel my order. I live 4 minutes from this location. There is no reason my pizza is 30 minutes late. AND ESPECIALLY no reason for a pizza shop to take an HOUR AND A HALF to make and deliver my pizza. Who knows how long I would have waited if I did not cancel the order. My refund will not be in my account for 3-4 days and I will not receive a confirmation till tomorrow morning. NOT TO MENTION. There was no manager on duty tonight. Ridiculous service. I was so excited to try the food here but I will never now. read more

I think the pizza and wings are ok but they could have tasted better. The service wasn't bad all... our order arrived clean and hot, ready to eat. Desserts are different from others I've tried and honestly they were pretty good. read more

I've been waiting for 10 years for a great pizza joint in my neighborhood, and I've found it! Had a deluxe minus the pepperoni and it was one of the best pizzas ever! Great crust, great flavor and not too much stuff to kill the pie! read more

This place used to be awesome. But recently their food quality has been rapidly declining. Most recent time I ordered a large pizza to be delivered and it got to my apartment cold and all the cheese slid to one side of the pizza. Seems like they're more worried about cranking them out rather than making a good pizza. You'd think after the prices went up the food would only get better right? And the new cashier they have always has an attitude or something. After I order I feel like I did something wrong. read more

stopped in last saturday about 1-1:30 pm or so to grab a couple of slices & a drink, total garbage just like eating plain dough and cold sauce. what crap !!the lady that took my order was also "dead from the neck up."talk about duh! couldn't even count the change back from a $10.00. one guy was coughing all over & couldn't stop, really incredible ! never would i recommend this so-called pizza place (dump)to any body that's breathing.the board of health should close this place down immediately !!! i wouldn't even give this dump a rating except you have to to get your review posted. read more

We ordered 2 18in cheese pizzas for delivery. They were there in about 30 mins and they were nice and hot. Maybe a little pricey but this is the best pizza I have had in the area so far. Crust is amazing, sauce is just right and cooked to perfection. Closest pizza pie to New York style that I've seen...even better than the ones claiming to be NY style pizza. The order came with plenty of little cups filled with parm cheese and red pepper flakes. This place will defiantly be my go to for pizza!! read more

The amount of food you get for a few bucks is in incredible. I have been going to this place since I was a kid, and they always treat you with respect. They also treat your hard earned dollars with respect too. Incredible food, incredible value, extremely affordable, doesn't get much better than that. read more

I will say that everything I tried on the menu was great BUT I have never had such horrible customer service in my life. We had food delivered on 3 different occasions and each time they messed something up, on the 3rd delivery that was messed up I sent the food back and called them and the response I got was "Listen lady we can never seem to get your order correct so why don't you just order from somewhere else" If you care to deal with very rude & incompetent people and have a good pie this is the place for you but they will never get another dime out of me... read more

Great pizza, just as Mamma Mia's offered. Different management and company name change, but the most of the same employees and same tasty pizza. read more

Just ordered 14" pepperoni & garlic pizza for pickup. It was ready& hot when I got there. The counter people were SO friendly & helpful! Offered plates & napkins without my having to ask and they even opened the door for me when I left! The pizza was perfect from the thin crust to the tasty toppings & generous helping of yummy cheese! read more

Best pizza in the city just about every time we go there. I'm not an easy pizza judge having read Rochester, NY's pizza blog guy pretty regularly in my time there. This stuff is up to East Coast's standards and not the sad, sad pizza realm that most of Phoenix inhabits. Crispy crust, good sauce, right amount of grease make a magical pie. Go try the 2 slices and a drink deal that runs all the time and tell me I'm wrong. read more

Pizza arrived early. Hot and ready. Crust had great flavor. Plenty of cheese and toppings. Will definitely order again.

Best pizza I ever had in Phoenix, if you love thin crust non chewy pizza, then this is the address you need. We ordered the veggie one and added chicken and artichoke. it was fresh and delicious!! read more

Cold pizza and extremely rude delivery guy. I mean, rude to the point of yelling and ignoring me on the phone. Pizza would have been delicious if it were hot. read more

RUDE SERVICE, DISGUSTING BUGS AND HAIRS. After being yelled by a little man who looked like Super Mario that I didn't call my order in correctly (according to him), I came home to one dish with a large roach in the sauce and a long black wavy hair (which looked like his) in my salad. I should have expected this when I saw how dirty the place looked when I picked up my order. I give this one star only because the app requires a star rating, and minus 5 stars wasn't an option. read more

The pizza is really good but the prices are better. It's like 5 dollars for 3 huge slices and a drink. It's a small joint too so you never have to wait a long time. The lady at the front was also very nice. read more

OMG why do we patronize places like this? Second time ordering, first was a pizza that resembled a sponge with mediocre toppings and then tonight...we went for Italian, yep wrong choice although we ordered ravioli and garlic bread. Same sponge texture on the bread, I understand, why leave it in the oven for two minutes more, it might get crispy. We got delivery and sure go ahead and forget the large Caesar salad but feel free to charge me for it. Called the place and got the "we're sorry" but don't really give a damn attitude, pretty sure it will stay on the bill. We also ordered chicken with fries for the little one, you guessed it...sponge fries, because why...it takes too long to cook something properly! Better half just went to the bathroom in a hurry, I suspect I'll be there soon. Make a better choice than we did! read more

This place has delicious dough. There is something sweet and overall tasty in this bread. It's worth getting.

Here's the deal. The pizza is AMAZING. Five stars for the pizza. Don't try to eat here; there's no room. The "dining room" barely fits three people. This is a definite "to go" or delivery pizza place. The wings, eh - they're fine. The five stars is for the pizza. Seriously, the pizza is top notch - nothing fancy, just delicious. I haven't tried anything else on the menu, and I probably won't. This place was awesome when it was Mama Mia's, and if anything, the pizza tastes even better now. I do have an issue with it being called "Brick Oven Pizza." There is no brick oven; it's not Brick Oven Pizza, so why even put that on the menu or, even worse, on the sign outside of the business? Another reviewer said it's like expecting a garden of olive trees at Olive Garden. I disagree; it's like calling your restaurant Chet's Open Pit Barbeque, where there is no Chet and there is no open pit in a 15-mile radius. I just don't get it. Pizza clearly doesn't need to be cooked in a brick oven to be delicious; the proof is right here. Brick oven pizza is cooked in a brick oven, and it has a distinct texture based on the unique method of cooking. This is not brick oven pizza, and it doesn't even resemble brick oven pizza - not in cooking style, not in texture, and not in taste. It's still delicious (five star delicious). I don't understand where the "brick oven" came from unless there's some crazy story about how they were going to install a brick oven, but it broke as it was being shipped from Italy and the sign had already been ordered. Unless there's some rational reason for having "brick oven pizza" on the sign, I would try to figure out a way to dodge the false advertising claim. Just serve the awesome pizza, and ditch the "brick oven" moniker. Let the pizza sell itself. read more

i'm from New Jersey and this is my favorite spot in town for the style of pie i grew up with. saw other people say they were heartbroken when Mamma Mia's closed and i can 100% understand- i was too. thankfully when it re-opened with this name everything was just as good and the lunch special is basically the best deal in town for east coast pizza read more

Ahh the old Momma Mia's.. Still just as delicious.. Still epic portions (typically 2/3 meals from the one order!). Eggplant Parm is my go to, the hubby always gets the Alfredo pasta! read more

Pizza is not as good as I remembered it being, but the pasta and salads are great. I'm glad the old Mama Mia's is back in some form.

This is my go to pizza place. I love how convenient and good priced this place is. I order the two slices pepperoni pizza with a drink and it is delicious. read more

cold, gross! then I called back to let them know how the 1 piece was cold she said oh no it wasn't! oh ok!!!? that place sucks never will I ever go there!!! read more