Arizona has good pizza? Whaaat? Okay, when I'm craving pizza in Arizona, I'll come back here. read more

Old Town Pizza - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

Stopped by for the first time. Was out shopping and walking around and wanted something quick! Was craving pizza but didn't want to have to order a whole pie, so looked for a place that sold by the slice. Always seemed to be busy when walking by so figured should give it a try. I got a slice of cheese. Ny style slice. And it was good. The crust was firm and crispy and the sauce/cheese ratio was good. Their ranch was also good. The person I was with got Sicilian slice and said it was okay. We then got the garlic sticks to split. Website said knots but then it was sticks that came out. The dipping sauce was good but the bread was soaked in garlic and out of the order of 4 I only opted for one since it was soaked and a little to heavy on the garlic imo but to each their own. Again, loved the slice of cheese and would get it again. read more

Old Town Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

Great spot to grab some delicious pizza in old town Scottsdale. Been a few times and always like how friendly the staff are. I just grabbed a few slices, which they heat to order. Love their ny and grandma slices read more

Old Town Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

The pizza was so good, we ordered again in the same week. I prefer the thin crust over the sicilian. The cup and char pepperoni is a must. 18" is the only way to go. Crust, sauce and quality toppings. Staff is super nice. read more

No delivery so have to pick up but decided to give this a try. The Garlic twists were delicious and crisp and come with enough marinara which was appreciated. The pizza was too thick to be true New York style and slightly too doughy. Slightly thinner and more crisp would have been preferred but still solid. Really a 3.5. read more

New York style done right. I had the slice with pepperoni and the crust was awesome and the crisp was perfectly even and had the taste to go with it. Right amount of sauce and Grande cheese makes this pie a good choice for your New York fix. They have lots of other styles I'll have to get back to. The crew was super friendly and attentive. Slice and soda in a can for less than $10 bucks. I like my pepperoni a little more cooked gotta curl up those edges for me. read more

Good local spot to grab a slice of pizza. Amazing quality! So delicious!! Definitely recommend! read more

Great spot for NYC style pizza! The crust was a little crunchier than true NYC pizza, but it was just as thin and still incredibly delicious. We loved the meat and pepperoni slices. The cheese Sicilian was also good but we definitely preferred the traditional slices. Aside from that though, the staff and atmosphere were awesome. We actually accidentally left a shopping bag in the store, and when we went back to look for it, the cashier had already put it aside, and she immediately recognized us and returned it to us before we could even ask. So 10/10, great food and people. Highly recommend! read more

Amazing pizza. Friendly staff. Quick service. Cozy place to get a pizza. I'll be back here again soon!

In a pinch we needed to stop for lunch after walking around Old Town and popped in the Old Town Pizza. It was phenomenal! The pizza was huge and everyone in our group agreed it was one of the best if not the best NY style pizza that they had. Perfect blend of flavors, sauce and fresh ingredients. The crust was soft yet had a little crisp. Glad I found this place and cannot wait to go back. The service was great, friendly and helpful. Thanks! read more

Old Town Pizza - Pepperoni 8 slice pie. - Pizza Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

This is by far the best pizza shop in arizona! Im usually in old town area on Thursday's/Fridays and I always stop here for a slice for an " Italian statlion and sweet heat" slice and a cold pop! The pizza is incredible and the owner is even better, alongside the sweet girls at the front. They literally feel like family :) read more

This pizza is DELICIOUS! Perfectly crunchy crust, melty cheese and bursting with flavor! It's a tiny to-go shop featuring a small outdoor patio with a few tables. This place deserves all the praise for exceptional food and service. Been here 3x and look forward to going back. read more

Old Town Pizza - Sweet Heat by the slice - Pizza Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

Tried Old Town Pizza and honestly it was a solid experience overall. The pizza came out hot, cheesy, and the crust had that nice crispy edge without being too dry. read more

Ordered a pepperoni pizza with 2 ranches online. Visiting from North Carolina. That was simply the best pizza I've ever had in my life. I did not expect to fall in love with a pizza in Arizona. Service was great and had the pizza ready quick too! read more

Welcoming and fast service not to mention the pizza is wonderful we love the grandma pie. read more

See all

Great pizza !! And great Calzones!!! Highly recommend!!! Hard to find such high quality pizza and calzones for great prices in this area!! You have to try them !!! read more

Old Town Pizza - Bomb calzones wow !!! - Pizza Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

WOW! Really really good! The hot roni and the honey bee ones are so good. The not only do they have a great taste, but the texture/composition is great and they're huge slices. I'll definitely be going back read more

Great little pizza place in Old Town Scottsdale. Very reasonable prices with amazing pizzas and amazing service. 5 stars

My pizza and bread smelled and tasted like soap. Had one slice and tossed the rest. What an expensive waste.

Pizza was amazing! If you're looking to eat some pizza that tastes like the pizza in New York, this is the place to try!! Made fresh! 10/10 would recommend. Service was nice, and you can sit outside when the weathers nice and enjoy your pizza! read more

Old Town Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

Pizza was amazing, crust to toppings! Everything was delicious and made to perfection! The owner knows what she's doing, she brought out the pizza to our table and her staff is amazing. I know she's just getting started but she's got something great going. The ambiance fits right in with the old town feel and perfect outdoor seating to enjoy your pizza. I recommend giving it a try and you will not be disappointed! read more

Old Town Pizza - Caesar salad and NY style margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

Best eggplant parmesan hero Ive had in a long time....if ever. Pizza is very good....sandwiches even better.

I drive an hour to eat here, worth the drive. Quality ingredients and outstanding service. A great casual stop, and a convenient location. Calzones and Strombolis as well as salads are very good. Family owned, check them out. read more

Great food, amazing pizza and friendly staff! I will be back for more! I need to try everything on the menu! Thanks gang. read more

The family is awesome, great grandma slices too. Not many spots in town do a thin grandma style pie. Parking can be a pain.

I would give this place 8 stars if I could. Listen...I am a pizza maker and I'm my opinion, this is the best NY Style pizza in Scottsdale. Skip Gus's, skip Joe's, and when you are on Old Town trust me...this is the spot! read more

I saw 5 star reviews and decided to order a pizza. I asked for pepperoni and green pepper. $2.50 for extra toppings. The green pepper was miniscle slivers of green pepper. More like $.50 cents worth. But the biggest reason they get One Star . . . they obviously took a pepperoni pizza, already cooked, threw some green pepper on, and threw it in the oven. The bottom of the crust was dark brown and tasted burnt. Avoid this place! read more

New York Style pizza was delicious! Great to see the owner cooking and the food reflected her desire for a good product! read more

Old Town Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

Ate here for the first time today. I had a white slice, my Husband the Pepperoni. it was delicious. very tasty and had a thin crispy crust. The staff was very friendly and accommodating. will definitely be back for a whole pie. read more

One of my new favorite spots, the pizza is traditional New York style with delicious crispyness, definitely not for people who have the taste buds of a 5 year old, the owner is such a champ and has a great staff, especially the girl with the big hair she has great spirit and knows customer service read more

Best pizza in Az hands down!!! Coming from a New York native on the hunt for a good slice. Nothing compares to old town pizza. The owner is so nice and welcoming!! read more

Live in the neighborhood and decided to try this spot. The previous pizza place wasn't great so it was great seeing a NY style replace it. I have to say this was delicious and the staff was so friendly. We picked up and it was ready when we got there. Adding it to the pizza rotation moving forward. read more

Dana makes THE BEST NY style pizza in Scottsdale! What are you waiting for?? GOOOO! Everything from the quality of ingredients to the love she puts in make in each pie it's just spectacular! read more

Walked in just before they closed on a Sunday night. Requested two slices, a white and a cheese-a little well done please. They both hit the spot. I could tell the cheeses used were good quality and the red sauce was perfect. Affordable and fast. Nice people too! I'd post a picture but it's in my belly. read more

My husband and I first tasted Dana's (owner) pizza at Lil' Capo at Westgate, us being Bronx born and raised fell in love with her pizza, some of the best since we moved here in the 80's. She recently opened up her own pizza place this past August in Old Town Scottsdale. Again, we went yesterday and I had a Sicilian slice while my husband had a pepperoni slice, absolutely delicious. Can't say enough about her New York pizza, oh and BTW Dana is from NY with what she mentioned was 25 years experience. For all of you who know good pizza, this is the place. read more

Old Town Pizza - pizza - Pizza Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

Great pizza, great people. The pizza was crisp and flavorful. Nice location where you can sit and people watch. Dana, the owner and her staff were friendly and energetic. Great to have a place now where you can get a great slice. My 13 year old son was very happy! read more

Easily the best pizza in Old Town Scottsdale. Great crust, quality ingredients and an owner who clearly knows what they're doing. I tried a slice of the "Italian Stallion" and the Capicola and Provolone are the ticket. The Sicilian slice is great too, and I'm not usually a fan of Sicilian style pies because if it's not done right you're chewing for days. Not the case here. The crust is fantastic. I'll definitely be back. read more

See all

Mom and I are from NJ and we have been trying every pizza place in the area for 6 years! We have almost giving up on finding a great New York pizza and tonight we finally found it!! The crust was soft but crispy and the sauce was delicious. I ordered my pizza with fresh mozzarella (much better than regular mozzarella) sausage and extra sauce. It was perfecto!! Thank you Old Town pizza! You've been down the street all this time. Wish we found you sooner! read more

Absolutely delicious pizza! Great service!! Delilah this is wonderful! We will definitely be back!! read more

10/10 pizza and the staff was so sweet! The food came out quick. Recommending this place to everyone! Great job hiring !