I would not eat here if you have an allergy or a child with an allergy. My son has peanut and tree nut allergies and they served him pesto with pine nuts in it! We told the server up front that he had allergies. We then ordered the snack plate. It came with some bread, which we asked the server to check if it was "safe for him". She went into the kitchen to check on the bread, but failed to mention the pesto!!!! It wasn't until we were half way through and I discovered it on the bottom of the plate. When we asked about it, she just said yes it is pesto with pine nut. No apology or anything. When I tried to address it with the manager, she ignored me. We will not go back and now we just pray we don't end up in the hospital with a reaction. They clearly do not take allergies seriously. If you have an allergy DO NOT take the chance and eat here. We will never go back!!!!!!!! read more

We loved the food! We had the eggplant pizza and the summertime pizza and both were delicious. The salads are also delicious. A highlight was the strawberry pie with homemade whipped cream. The service was terrific. All in all a great experience! I will go there again. read more

Fabulous pizza with a great selection of choice ingredients. Lovely casual ambience. Nice selection of wine and beer. Don't miss this place

Went with my hubby & parents on our first evening of vacation. Our tradition is to go out for pizza the first night but Grotto's was getting old. We walked into Pie after 7 on a Saturday evening. We waited only about 10 minutes before being seated. The inside is small but cute. The pizza selection was excellent - unique ingredient combinations you won't see everywhere. My hubby created his own pizza, mom had the Italian, dad had the artichoke/goat cheese, and I had the roasted eggplant. I sampled all, and everything was flavorful and fresh. (Helpful hint: their menu is on their Facebook page). Service was prompt and friendly. Nice to see a good quality, small business pizza restaurant at the beach. We will definitely be back on our next beach trip! read more

Pizza was creative and seasonal and, oh yea, delicious!!! We got the centine blend wine from Italy and it was great! Family friendly too!

Gluten Free crust was amazing!!!! Best I've ever had in all 7 years of Celiacs....get there early as space is limited but be willing to wait because it is worth it!!!! I ordered the wild mushroom but there were 9 in our party, everyone ordered something different, and everyone loved their pizza. So glad we ignored the negative reviews we saw because it was a major HIT for us!!!! read more

Always amazing!! Food is consistent, delicious and always fresh and hot! Service is always on point as well!! Only wish it was year round....you'll be missed in the off season! read more

Pizza was good- this crispy dough, a little heavy on the cheese for my taste. The selection was good, but nothing is haven't seen before. Service was prompt and professional. Unfortunately, it is a small space with no air conditioning. With the ovens blazing on, it was literally painful to sit and eat- I couldn't wait to get out of there... Very disappointing for an $80 dinner with drinks... read more

The pizza is good with a nice variety of unique flavor combinations. However, pies are small and overpriced.

Very good pizza! I had a white pizza with ricotta and carmelized onions as well as a pesto pizza with corn and tomatoes. We finished every bite with no extra to take home! The corn and tomatoes were very sweet and flavorful. The white sauce was fantastic. I wish I could make it myself. I do wish there was slightly more white sauce and pesto on each pizza. I would say the crust is maybe average but the cheese and toppings were so good it didn't matter. We were seated quickly, our waitress and busboy were very attentive and we enjoyed our overall experience. I meant to take pictures of the pizza but got right into eating it and got lost in the great flavor :-). I'll be back again. read more

Food was good but service was meh. The staff that wasn't our waiter was great so perhaps it was just him. Or an off night. The gluten free pizza was good and we were thrilled to have the option. read more

Generally disappointed in most everything. The salad was the best of everything we had. Nice size tasted very good, but my wife didn't like it because she thought it was very bitter. The summertime Pizza that I had was dry and uninteresting. Not really some place I would be excited to go back to. read more

We waited almost an hour for our pizza. It was good, not great, but good. It was not quite worth the price, however and it was definitely not worth the wait. It would also have been nice to have a few refills of our water glasses during the meal. Overall, terrible service and the relatively high cost make this place one to skip. read more

Pie Oh Pie - I used to love you. Last summer, we really enjoyed takeout from Pie and enjoyed their pies and their salads. I'm not sure whether it's my memory or the fact that I've gotten hooked on &Pizza, but Pie's crust is just not up to par. The toppings are brilliant, but the crust isn't just "Meh" it takes like a cross between Ledo's oversweet crust and the doughiness of Pillsbury's Frozen Crescent Dough. There's not an iota of chewiness and crunch you get with good pizza. Their salads are awesome though. I hope they improve the crust. And soon. read more

Was not impressed with the food. Tho nice servers, atmosphere, etc. I ordered the artichoke and sun dried tomato goast cheese pizza. Things I love and it would taste good together but the crust was really thick and dry. The tomatos needed time be cut or diced. They were huge and far far too many compared to the 2 pieces of artichoke hearts. Every bite was a full sized dried tomato. It was. Nice idea, but not well executed. The cheese was bland for my kids and pepperoni so so. read more

Ill try to keep it simple. We called in our order for pick up. The woman on the other end repeated our order correctly. Fantastic were off to get our food and supporting a new Pizza place in town. I picked up my order in an area that had no parking available because awesome beach goers as I am are staking the spots. So I parked illegally , ran in and got a few bags of food. I drove home unpacked the food and they never gave me the quintessential, monumental, expected pizzas, 2 to be exact in my bag. My 1 yr old and 6 year old were waiting like Vikings for them. The issue that I had was the Manger was unapologetic and continued her professionalism as if our order did not matter. Our order mattered just like the next guy, if not more because PIE messed up. By The time we settled down the pizza was cold, to much cheese, and very salty. The Caesar salad was good. I will not be returning anytime soon. Im not just a beach goer I live here, so don't treat people as if you will never see them again!! read more

You're better off ordering take out from this place. We sat for an hour in the restaurant before they even started making our pizza. We talked to the staff and they have been told to take care of take out orders before serving the restaurant. Def would not go back. read more

Favorite restaurant in Bethany. Pizza is fabulous plus have a craft beer and wine list that is top notch. Desserts are also wonderful. Highly recommend the eggplant or prosciutto pizza and mixed berry pie. Our kids also love this place!! read more

I have been here twice. And probably will go again if I am in the mood for an upscale, gourmet pizza restaurant. Pie tries to sell itself as an upscale restaurant. Do not wear your swim trunks and flipflops. There hours are not the best (only open for dinner). I arrived before my family did so I could try to save a table. They told us it would be a 15 minute wait. After around a half hour they finally took us back to our seats. I can see why they are always so crowded, the place is so small! Only about 10 tables total. If you expect to find fancy Italian cooked meals, this is not the place for you. Pie specializes in pizza and salads. In fact.. that is all they have on the menu. I picked a half cheese and half pepperoni pizza. After 45 minutes of waiting at the table, they finally brought out the hot, oven cooked pizza. When I bit into my piece, I knew something was wrong. It was not pepperoni.. in fact it was a spicier form of pepperoni. The waitress did not mention to me that there topping was different than normal. On my second visit, I got a straight cheese pizza. It tasted great and everything went smooth. The wait time after our order was still in the 30-45 minute range. 3/5 stars.. good pizza but bad costumer service and wait times read more

Best pizza in Bethany!! Shrimp pizza was outstanding, the wine in can was sooo good! Love it

Had one of the best pizza! Got the artichoke-sun-dried-tomatoes-goat-cheese-to-die-for pizza. Excellent. My husband had a delicious beef blue and kids stuck to the usual cheese-basil pizza. Ate in with two little kids. Nice ambiance and service was great. Hope we will get a chance to try it again before we leave... Yummy spot! read more

The food is excellent-- recently had really fantastic pizzas that were worth the 30 min wait. Completely. The place was rockin' on a Saturday night, as you would expect it to be. We sat at the bar for a while to wait for our food to go. Great selection of wine and beer, especially craft beers. The only thing that seemed a little off was the staff member working the bar/ "overseeing" things (though she was very nice)... seemed a little disorganized and dazed.... I feel like the place would run a lot smoother with a system in place, an experienced person taking orders behind the bar, and perhaps the supervisor and the bartender not being the same person? I dunno. Didn't seem to be working very well. We DID have a lovely young lady help us another time by the name of Lily. She was very sweet, on point, and efficient. Kudos to the wait staff! read more

Awesome. Awesome. Awesome. Great pie. Great atmosphere. Could use some more desert but hey that's just me.

The food was delicious and the service prompt. We had a "better than pepperoni" and an "Italian" pizza , fantastico.

Casual, relaxed beach dining. Delicious pizza - great wine and beer selection. Friendly service.

had dinner with friends, the pizza was very good. thin crust, delicious toppings. atmosphere is cozy and comfortable, service was good. prices are moderate. would definite go back. read more

Great local dive! Top notch from service to the menu for a small local restaurant. It is also a great value for the location. The snack plate is very large and I highly recommend! It has a great selection of Italian meats, shrimp, cheese, and salad. read more

Oh my goodness what in pizza heaven... This place is Incredible. 5 stars from all 6 people in my party (we did take out).

We've gotten takeout from here twice and I only wish we could try dining in since this place has a great vibe (and cold beer). We got the pepperoni, crab, mushroom all of which were really good. The pepperoni was probably the favorite. And for what it's worth they all tasted great cold a day later. read more

Ate there with friends on an off season Sunday night! It was crowded! A good sign. We were seated and waited on promptly. Both couples ordered salads- ours was very fresh with heirloom tomatoes- very nice. Our table ordered the Better than Pepperoni and Italian- both delicious. Also ordered beef and blue which was good except a disappointment- VERY LITTLE BEEF on the pizza. Would have given 5 stars otherwise. read more

My mom loves this place! Pizza, salads, flatbread... And key Lime Pie among others!!!! It might be a little loud- but it's worth it! Can do takeout too! read more

From Long Island I am cautious about pizza in Delaware. This pizza was good, not as good as the local joint at home. Certainly better than most of the other options around, but this isn't a place to get a slice. The small personal pizzas are an interesting concept that try to upsell the pizza to something more sophisticated, and the topping combos support that too. The crust just wasn't as flavorful as the average pie from home, but as far as local pizza goes it probably is the best you can get. read more

This was the smallest oval shape of pizza I've ever seen. The pizza to price ratio was astronomical, as stated by the purchaser. We left there feeling the pizzas were small, only to return home and discover that the pizzas were not even filling the boxes they came in. They were hardly even acceptable pizzas. All in all, disappointing. Service was great though read more

Good pizza and family friendly. Unfortunately this place has lost its luster a bit. Pizza was good - we had the Italian, Shrimp and Artichoke and Goat Cheese. The disappointing finish was the peach pie. They don't have ice cream to serve with the pie and they don't serve coffee. Guess they don't want people to stick around after dinner. read more

Some of the best pizza I have ever had. I'm not a fan of mass market pizza BTW. Pie is more artisan style but with a nice traditional slant too. They even offer any kind of pizza with a gluten free crust. I had the wild mushroom, I also tried the margarita and the artichoke/goat cheese (gluten-free) pizzas, they were all very good. Pie also has a nice selection of beer and wines. The staff was very friendly and attentive. Highly recommended if you like a good handmade pie. read more

Great place! The "better than pepperoni" really is. We also had the beef and blue - delicious but very rich. For dessert, the best blueberry pie I've ever had. So glad we found this place. We'll be back for sure. read more

The pizza was fabulous. The garden salad, though beautiful, was saturated with what tasted like plain vinegar. It was inedible by either my wife or myself. The waitress did take it off the ticket, which was wonderfully responsive. Still, it was a sour note (pun intended) in an otherwise sweet experience. That dressing needs to be re-thought. read more

Thin crust gourmet at its best. Ordered Summertime , beef and blue, and Better than Pepperoni. All were great , just depends on your taste. We got them for pick up and ate in the park across the street. read more

If you are looking for healthy food...gourmet flatbread pizza and fresh salads, paired with great wine, go to PIE! It's relaxed, upscale casual. It's not a high-output, pizza joint or a bar. It's perfect for a foodie. Get the Better than Pepperoni pizza and the mixed green salad. Both amazing. Highly recommend! read more

We had a great experience here. The server was really nice and personable. The pizza and apple/blueberry pie was delicious. The atmosphere was cozy and welcoming. Cool artwork on the walls. We will come back next time we are in the area. read more