Good things are worth waiting for... or calling in your dinner order at noon to secure your prime time! Pomodoro Pizza is the most exclusive pizza of Bethany Beach with limited quantities prepared and yes... it is easily the best too!! With a focus on the order at hand, everything is authentically done, thoughtfully crafted, and well prepared. Simple and satsifying! We called in at eleven for a 6:00 pickup and were already the fifth order. They only take a single order per fifteen minute window, so it can be multiple hour long waits during the dinner window! We ordered a cheese, a pepperoni, a white with roasted peppers, and a pomodoro special (pepperoni, sausage, bacon, green peppers, mushroom, and onion). A true New York style pizza. The slices are huge. The toppings are thin. A folded bite is essential! The interior is just a small pickup counter, a cooler of soda bottles/cans, and a refrigerator of some off-menu salads and cannolis. The owners are so wonderful and will greet you warmly as you enter, but they do deal with a lot of complainers that are disappointed that they didn't plan in advance for their dinner pickup. read more

See all

Located on the boardwalk at Bethany Beach! Great choice for my pizza craving. Definitely got the NY pizza vibe. I tried the cheese pizza and it was hot and delicious. The prices were fair. Service was friendly. There's no indoor seating but there's a few benches right outside. I highly recommend this place. read more

This is the best pizza in Delaware. Idc what your friends from other states tell you when you visit here. All locals know this is the best pizza. Argue with a wall. read more

Another go to spot in Bethany. A staple of the town - with all of their pizzas all being great. There isn't any sitting area as it is mainly a takeaway spot. The service is very great as it has been the same people working it since it has opened about 10 years ago from what i remember. All they always remember faces. The ambiance is great as it is quick and easy and you can grab your slice quickly and take it to the beach. Favorite spot at the beach to eat. read more

Pomodoro Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bethany Beach, Delaware

As always the very best pizza in Rehobeth, Bethany and Fenwick. The foods, service and ambience. Five Stars

Still amazing. And their white pizza is a new winner in our household. Split a white slice and a cheese slice with my 8yo and she loved the white more than the cheese. Tons of garlic and full of flavor. Can't go wrong with Pomodoro! read more

Oh my! My wife and I stopped in for a slice. What a great experience. The ladies behind the counter greeted us and we chose a slice of pepperoni for my wife and a slice of cheese for myself. I couldn't believe how good this pizza was. We had called a few nights earlier and was told that it would be a two hour wait to pickup the pizza. We had to try it. Today, we called ahead and told them what we wanted and asked what time we could pick it up. We got there twenty minutes early so we could get two slices and sit on the bench out front and watch people while we were waiting for our pizza to be ready. Yes, it's that good. When anywhere near Bethany Beach, you must stop by for a slice. read more

The best pizza in the area. The crust is perfect. Couldn't get enough of it. I used to like Dough Roller in OC but I will drive to Bethany to get Pomodora! Nice family that owns it. read more

Definitely the best pizza in Bethany Beach area. No indoor seating so it's basically a carry out.

Great pizza for takeout. Self service. It's pricey but I would gladly go back because the pizza was great.

Best pizza in Delaware! And that's coming from an Italian NY'er! Unfortunately take out only read more

Excellent pizza. Got a cheese and chicken/pesto/artichoke. But they ran out of artichoke. Pesto was ok. Cheese was great, tho a tad greasy to me. Stick with a pizza with sauce like bbq or tomato sauce. Crust was excellent!!!! No more 18" on the menu to order But a 16" was plenty big. read more

From the moment my family stepped inside this little pizza shop, we knew we would love it!!! We just felt like we were home, even though we aren't from New York haha. This pizza place reminded me of so many pizza shops from New York. The women working behind the counter are true gems. They were super friendly and made us feel like we were part of their family. As for the pizza.....oh the pizza!!!!! It is New York style with a perfect crisp to chew ratio with the dough. The sauce was seasoned just right and the cheese had that melt and pull that turns your life into pure joy! This place is a must when at Bethany Beach! Enjoy!!! read more

See all

Excellant NY pizza! It's got that great taste! The shop is very small is the only downside, they need a new location as it's very popular so expect a wait at peak times! It's definitely worth stopping in for a slice! read more

My brother is well swears by this place so I was in the mood and there was no line and they were selling slices at the time so I grabbed the cheese slice. I wish I could've afforded the more pricey ones with toppings as the sausage delicious and other people were enjoying it, but I went with the plain cheese $.50 surcharge for using Apple Pay. The crust was really good and the cheese pizza coming out hot from the oven was delicious. read more

Pomodoro Pizzeria - $5 slice (50 cent Apple Pay charge) - Pizza Near Me - Bethany Beach, Delaware

The family that owns this is absolutely the nicest family you could ever meet. On top of that, the pizza is amazing! Five stars!

Pizza is AMAZING! Top 2 in the area of BETHANY BEACH, in my opinion, ***MUNCHIES*** being the other (both N.Y. style of Za) both worth the price of admission. Parking is the S. O. B. at POMODORO PIZZERIA but that's the worst of it all. RECOMMEND having two people in the car and you can dbl. park, run in a grab pizza then bounce and enjoy. Salads are made fresh but WAAAAAAAY over-priced. Service is what a pizza joint should be. Pop'n out pizza, again parking best to have two people so you can run in and dbl park. ***OTHER TID-BITS*** THEY DO OFFER SLICES UP UNTIL ABOUT 2:30/3pm... otherwise it's full PIES. Honestly, it's worth it to just buy WHOLE PIES anyway. Went to buy a Greek salad, would sufficiently feed 2 people and it was about $16-$18 SIDE SALAD. Hope review helps, highly recommend it!!! Enjoy! read more

Best pizza in the area for sure! Only thing is the secret is out and they can't keep up. You have to call a day ahead of time, recommend calling when they open at 11, otherwise you might have to wait until the next day. They sell out fast. read more

Great pizza and super fast service! Almost no wait at all. Takeout only, but there are benches outside to sit and seating around the corner.

Absolute best pizza in the area. I've had a place in Bethany for 25 years and am so glad Pomodoro's made a home here! Order early!

Being from NY we compare a lot of food to NY standards all I can say is that Pomodoro Pizza comes close. A small place in Bethany Village up near the boardwalk. Always busy so go get it don't wait for delivery. Good price and variety of toppings. CIAO FOR NOW read more

Sometimes the wait is insane, but the price isn't bad and the pizza is delicious. Was worth "glutening" myself for

This place is a little slice of pizza heaven. Every time we go to get a slice, it's perfect. The taste never changes and the crust is perfection. The only bad thing about this place is it's not open after the tourist season. read more

Got a sausage mushroom pizza on Sunday evening. Pizza was terrible. Hardly any cheese and the toppings were all bunched in the middle. Very disappointing. read more

Brooklyn born, Jersey raised here. Overall, the pizza on the Delaware beaches is crap. Everybody claims 'New York style', but it's always a lie. This place is the exception. Crispy crust, perfect amount of cheese, great pepperoni. The lady who serves you is Rose. she calls you honey if you're nice to her, and I always am, since she looks like my grandmother. Take out only, find a bench and enjoy the sea breeze and a 'roni slice. read more

Great pizza. As close to a NY slice you're going to find south of Mason Dixon. The advice to just order up and pick up is good. They are usually busy. There is a reason for that. But a salty slice, or two, hits on a hot summer day. Enjoy. read more

We went into Bethany purposely to try the pizza after reading some tempting reviews from different sources. When I made plans, I did not realize it was strictly a take out place. Hearts and stomach were set on pizza and when we looked as to their exact location it wasn't until then we figured out there are absolutely no seats. We went anyway to see for ourselves as I has read 1 review mention table, which was untrue. There's a SMALL counter against their front window, but don't plan to stand there to eat, only really there to give a space for napkin dispenser and condiments (parmesan cheese, salt, pepper, hot pepper flakes, oregano, and garlic powder). Plus if you try to stand and eat at the counter, you'd be in the way of all the other customers getting drinks from the self serve fridge or getting sprinkles of condiments at counter. Yes, this establishment is SMALL. Currently if you want to come to buy a slice of pie, only offering that option until 4p, after that only full size pizza orders. We came to try one of their specialty Gourmet offerings and we decided on the chicken broccoli with sun-dried tomatoes. Takes about 25 minutes so plan for that if you're feeding the parking patroled lots. (Park mobile is $3.60/hour with fee and no fraction of the hour allowed). Pizza looked and smelled delicious and we received fresh out of the oven. Since we wanted to eat this fresh, we planned on tailgating in the parking lot down the street. We mentioned that when we checked out and they graciously told us about some less used tables behind candy kitchen. We took that information, walked a couple blocks and found the tables and enjoyed a nice outdoor space to try our pizza (they gave us plates & napkins). Upon tasting, felt something was missing in flavor. After more bites, we figured out it definitely needed something to elevate it to perfection and that ingredient was probably fresh garlic. Portions of chicken and broccoli were good, fresh and dough was good (thin NY type - i like many varieties), however by the time the 2nd slice cooled off, the ends that weren't coated with anything became too chewy & dry to finish, so we didn't eat the ends of the crust. I don't like that, it feels wasteful and thoroughly enjoy a good dough. Shame we weren't in a restaurant setting to eat this and too far to bother walking back, as I would have utilized the garlic powder and parmesan cheese to doctor it up. BUT, with that said, shouldn't have to if it's good right out of the oven. We did enjoy, just wasn't perfection, but we haven't discounted them either. If we found ourselves in Bethany, wanting pizza and not interested in a restaurant experience, we would try them again. Had a couple other pies we were debating on getting and I'd consider trying still. I'd also ask to add fresh garlic to this one & try again or depending on the selection, try a bite before leaving to see if it needed any extra umph added. The place is clean with VERY friendly people who are helpful and truly care about you as a customer. Definitely a lot of regulars visit and a family run business so supporting them is important. read more

Pomodoro Pizzeria - Slice of the broccoli chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bethany Beach, Delaware

See all

Always heard this is the best pizza, NY style. Had my first slice 2 weeks ago- walked in around lunchtime and they had 4 varieties available by slice. Owner warmed up my cheese. Sat outside on the bench and ate it- beautiful day. The crust is thin, and crunchy on the bottom but the top layer is tender and yeasty. Was delicious with the sauce and cheese. I here there can be a long wait if buying a pie for takeout but this was quick. My bill was under the charge limit but the owner said not to worry about that and didn't charge me extra. I will return. Sorry they are not open through the off season. read more

This place is our favorite pizza place at the beach. Judging by order time it's the favorite of a lot of people also. Not sure why it's better I just like read more

Pizza and the beach are a good combo. The pizza is good without being extraordinary. There were many flavors to choose from. The employees are friendly. read more

Pomodoro Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bethany Beach, Delaware

See all

We have had Pomodoro Pizza a few times over the years and the pizza is pretty tasty! Today we called and it took a few times to get through. But if you get the busy signal, keep trying! The employee on the phone was very friendly and efficient! We called around 3pm and requested a pickup time for 5pm. The pizza was ready before our quoted pickup time as well, which was great! We ordered the white spinach pizza and the ingredients were evenly distributed and fresh. It was a little too overpowering with the garlic though. Otherwise, it was a good pizza. read more

Pomodoro Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bethany Beach, Delaware

Searched high and low for a good pizza after moving to the area and finally found not just a good pizza but the best I've tasted in a long time. Tasty thin crispy crust topped with flavorful toppings. I tried the white pizza with spinach, ricotta, and tomato and the margarita pizza. Recommend them both!! read more

This pizza by the slice was AMAZING! My only let down is that they didn't have ranch. Would recommend though!

Wonderful pizza, and they now sell by the slice, so one need not order the huge pie. However, call first.Their web site said they were open at 11 day, yet I drove out there today in eager anticipation only to find that they were closed after all. read more

Great pizza and a salad that was amazing. What more is there to say. It is located in downtown Bethany, so is a bit of a challenge to pick up your Pizza so recommend you use the I drive, you fly approach. The pizza is worth the effort. read more

Towards the end of September and only a 20 minute wait despite it being Saturday. We got the 18 inch pepperoni and it fed 4 of us. Red sauce, cheese, and pepperonis were spot on, but the crust could have been slightly thinner. A near miss that is probably as good as it gets at the beach. read more

Long timers, kind owners, great pizza (even if you're from NYC!). Get orders in early during tourist season.

The pizza is fantastic! The owners are so kind, pomodoro pizza keeps me coming back to Bethany Beach. read more

Pomodoro Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bethany Beach, Delaware

I truly believe this the best pizza in the Delmarva area. We never miss grabbing a pizza from Pomodoro when visiting the beach.

The white spinach pizza is phenomenal! Don't be discouraged by the line, the pizza here is worth the wait. The owners work very hard and are always so pleasant! read more

Pomodoro Pizzeria - White spinach pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bethany Beach, Delaware