Love love love pickup's pizza. It is always our go-to treat for pizza take out. Friendly staff, and easy in and out process.

We Pickup's! We always get the pan, with its buttery crust and crunchy cheesy corner pieces are the best. Our fave is the Ditka, the pickled sweet peppers make this. The thin crust is great too! I have to say, you must to get the Spinach salad with bacon, goat cheese, pepitas and sweet onion dressing. So good! And they're Deadheads, so you know they're cool. read more

We came into town on vacation hungry and looking for dinner somewhere that was not overcrowded. We ended up finding this little pizza place with the BEST pizza ever! The man and woman (didn't catch their names unfortunately) taking orders and manning the oven were super friendly and if we ever head out that way again-this place was added to our list of must-stop places. We ate at a LOT of places on vacation, ranging from fine dining to fast food and all of our family agrees-this place was the BEST and we wish this pizza could be shipped out of state...sigh... read more

Best pizza I've had in a very long time. We loved this pie. We got the Da Ditka with white sauce pan style crust. Delivered to Bonfire brewing. They were fast and amazing. I would drive from Vail or BC just for this pizza. Solid goodness. read more

Do not doubt the reviews! This place is fantastic, and not in a "only a few options around" kind of way. I mean top 5 pizza places in the state of Colorado. The staff is incredibly nice, and if you can be patient for the phenomenon they are about to serve you, ypu will no doubt come to the same conclusion. I had the farm salad abd sprouts pizza. Their white pizza's are beyond delicious, and the pan crust is a must!!!! read more

Pickup's Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

We ordered a large lasagna pizza and it was great. We're not from Eagle but if we were we'd order from here often. I also loved how the pizza came in a paper bag instead of a pizza box. read more

Was a little skeptical about this food truck, but we ended up being very pleased with the pepperoni pizza we ordered. Even after a 15 minute ride home, the pizza was very good. Crust was excellent, we generally prefer thin crust but the original they offered was great. I've had better pizza in Italy, but this place will be our go to pizza place in the Gypsum area. read more

Amazing delicious that was THE stop I totally recommend the flavor and everything fresh we were a group of 7 and all of us love it !!!!! The cheese sticks my favorite. Was 3 large and 2 salads and the picture show what almost left because we eat everything. read more

Pickup's Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

See all

just moved to eagle and am so excited there is a great pizza spot! pizza is one of my favorites and Pickups did not disappoint. i got the pan pizza both times. the crust is by far the best i've ever had! the pizza is a tad saucey so next time i might say light sauce! loved that they used fresh pineapple! read more

THE GOAT PIZZA IS TO DIE FOR. Nice vibe here, Grateful Dead mural on the wall and the staff is very sweet. Would recommend

Stopped in an ordered. $26+ for a large rectangular pizza. Seemed a little slow. Was told 20 minutes. Came back..10 more to wait. Pizza was okay. Kind of high for what you get. I rate pizza 7 out of 10. read more

This is a hidden gem about a mile from the I-70 exit. Most of the customers seem to be locals rather than tourists which means you won't be served overpriced mediocre food. I got their lasagna pizza and it was definitely one of the best pies I've ever had in my entire life. Prices are very reasonable and there's a park nearby where you can take a short walk while you wait for them to bake your pizza. read more

Best Pizza I have had in the Vail Valley - hands down. Cool, quaint, neighborhood joint with great service to boot! Highly recommend. read more

I LOVE this place!!! I think this is the best pizza in Colorado!! I'm lucky to live right up the street, so I can enjoy there pizza any time I want. If you are driving through and just want a quick stop for pizza, drive the few extra miles off the highway for this pizza, you will not regret it. The staff is hard working and awesome! read more

Oh yeah!!!! This was delicious!! Had da Ditka and it was da bomb! Totally recommend... read more

Nothing but 5 stars here. Ollie made me at small thin crust crispy pie. It was awesome. $14 Fresh veggies, good crust and cheese, and eating within 12 minutes. 2 people can share a small but damn, I ate the whole thing. Thumbs up. read more

Our yearly trip through the Vail valley wouldn't be complete without a stop at PPC. The ricotta cheese sticks are my daughters favorite. The pan pizza is where it's at though. This place has a variety of toppings as well as specialty pies that should satisfy almost any pizza fan. read more

Pickup's Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

Pizza is very good, service is great, prices are a little high for my taste and how much food you get but other than that worth every bite!

Great, clean, and health conscious options. Staff seem like they care about the quality of pizza, as I am! I loved the uptruck vegetarian with added goat cheese. A great "foodie" spot, if its still ok to use that term. read more

The best pizza I think I can honestly say, ever. Friendly people, comfortable space and a truly delicious! We ordered the thicker crust Pele and the combination of their bacon, chilies, and pineapple with their special crust was masterful. The locally sourced organic ingredients make this a place we will definitely be eating from again! read more

See all

I LOVE the pizza here! I will travel from Glenwood to Eagle just for this pizza!

Loves the Italian sausage , pepperoni deep dish ! Def look forward to next time in town to try other pizza !

best pizza in Colorado cheese bread is delightful too

The staff was very polite and working their butts off. The pizza was just average especially for the price. I was hoping based on the reviews this would be our new spot. Maybe we were there on an off day but it tasted like frozen pizza. read more

I was skeptical when I saw five stars being from Chicago, but this place was the bomb! read more

Pickup's Pizza Company - I was skeptical being from Chicago but this was the bomb! - Pizza Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

Praise baby Jesus This pizza is so good. Chicago style. Try the Dikta. Wow. Fast and efficient delivery to Bonfire Brewing. Doesn't get any better. read more

We ordered take out last night and if I could have given 3.5 starts I probably would have but leaning towards the 4. Took two pizzas back to our hotel - the lord and lady deep dish and a thin crust pepperoni. I want to say that it might be that we do not eat much deep dish but what completely caught us off guard was the fact that the cheese and toppings were smothered under a large portion of red sauce. No way to taste melted cheese, sausage or spinach all that hit was bread and tomato sauce. Although the super unfortunate part was the burnt baby spinach leaves on the edges and throughout. We enjoyed the thin crust pepperoni so much more! Only draw back was the burnt edges and how the pizza was cut in squares. There were no "good" crust edges because all the middle pieces had no edges. Farm salad was nice with spinach and arugula yet we realized after reading the menu again it was missing kale. All that being said we would certainly give this place another try for their signature pizzas with the thin crust!! read more

Pickup's Pizza Company - Lord and Lady covered in sauce with burnt spinach - Pizza Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

See all

Awesome pizza place with a locally sourced menu. I've had 3 or 4 pizzas now and everyone has been excellent. There's a pin ball machine you can play while you wait and they play smooth jams on a record player. :) I haven't tried it yet, but I hear that at Bonfire Brewery you can order a pizza via a direct line and have it delivered straight to the brewery! read more

See all

Delicious pizza and pretty dang fast service! I'm not a SUPER huge pizza fan but I'd say 9/10 pizzas I've had from here are delicious. The goat (or maybe it's feta? Whoops I can't remember at the moment) cheese with pepperoni and green olive is one of the best around! read more

Best pizza I have had in a long time! Friendly service! Came to Eagle for a dog show and found this cool little pizza parlor, best unplanned stop we ever made! Super happy we made the decision to look for pizza! Very yummy, you will not be displeased! BUT make you own pizza, it's preferred and everything made was yummy! Very recommended!!! read more

Best pizza in Eagle, no exception. Deep dish, Chicago style. No skimping on the toppings and fast service.

Visiting from Utah and decided to try Pickups. We were not disappointed in the slightest. This is some of the best pizza we'd ever had! We got one thin crust and one pan pizza. Both were excellent. The first pan pizza came out a little burnt and when they brought it to our table they apologized and said that they put another one in the oven for us without us saying anything. I wish we lived closer because this would be my go to place by far for pizza. So dang good! Will be stopping here anytime we are remotely close to Eagle. read more

Good pizza and salad, also the girl waiting on me very friendly and helpful, I will definitely visit again when staying in Eagle.

The pizza was phenomenal! Seriously. I have such low expectations for pizza places as of late, but this was exceptional. We had onions, pepperonis, basil, and something else on our regular pan crust. If you are anywhere near Eagle colorado and you are wanting a pizza? This is your place. read more

Favorite pizza in the valley ! A little pricey but it's the freshest pizza made around here ! Thin and thick crusts are amazing

Stopped in here while out in eagle for the weekend! It was great! The vibe is chill and casual. They have several options for crust but we all got the thin crust and it was great! I had the pelé and it was very good and perfectly spicy. Can order by the slice as well but we were hungry and each got our own "small" pizza! Good choice! read more

Simply the best pizza ever! After living in Europe for over a decade we loved the Mediterranean style, thin crust, cheesey, simple & flavorful. Can't find those since arriving in US. Living in CA we have try to find something decent. They were hard to find. Was going to Moe's BBQ but they were closed. Check yelp review & landed here. Wife ordered the "Oh Kale, No" pizza. It was simply the best pizza since arriving in US 3yrs ago. I'll let your taste bud made your own judgement. The 2 blokes was pretty chill and take pride in their work! Awesome guys! Keep up the good job! Will come again if we're near Eagle. read more

Pickup's Pizza Company - Oh kale no pizza! Delicious & packed a kick on the spicy chart... - Pizza Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

See all

Great take out pizza. A really cute place. The staff was very friendly. They made one our pizzas made to order perfectly.

I cannot stop talking about this pizza! It was sooo delicious! We got the deep dish with pineapple and bacon and hot red peppers. If I come back to the area I will definitely go here again. read more

best pizza in Eagle county. Pickup Pizza offers a Detroit Style deep dish that is the perfect amount of fluffy on the inside and crunchy on the out. Classic Mexican style Coca-Cola, and great options for toppings. Price is substantially higher than Dominos or Pazzos, but the quality is worth it! read more