This pizza joint is to die for. Hands-down one of the best pies I've ever had and I am definitely gonna come back. The service was so fun - the employees are so great and friendly and super considerate, and it was so fast! Thank you again for having me team and I can't wait till next time read more

Yummy! Best pizza in the area , by far. We had the lasagna & a cheesy bread. Man, t ricotta was so good , there were 4 cheeses used . Top tier Italian in my opinion. Thank you See you next time! read more

Last time we ate here was 5 years ago, so when I realized we were in the area again during our ski trip we had to revisit ! The Lasagna is our "go to " one half regular the other half no meat !! It was just like we remembered !! read more

I grew up in Chicago and Pick Up Pizza's Gonzo pizza takes me back to those days. They just need a bigger beer selection ( no dark beer, reds or browns) But the staff is great, Jen always has a smile and a quick beverage to quench your thirst. read more

Great pizzas! Very unique and well made. We ordered sprouts pizza and another with white sauce - they were both very good.

Pizza was very tasty, definitely a change from your normal hand tossed style pizza you find at most places. However, out of our group, quite a few pizzas came out with the wrong crust or toppings. The restaurant was happy to fix the ones we wanted fixing which was nice of them though. read more

Geez Pickups. I love your pizza. The location is a little off the beaten path for those that are traveling to the area. Eagle isn't exactly downtown Vail. But if you make the journey, it's worth it. Even if you know what street Pickup's is on, you may miss it. I know I've driven by it a bunch of times. We did finally get the gumption to find Pickups and grabbed a "pie". Is my east coast showing? The pizzas that we've ever ordered have all been rectangular. The Lord and Lady, Oh-Kale-No and the MD are probably my favorites, but you can customize any pizza you want. I really don't think you can go wrong with any of them. I'm partial to thin crust, NY style, but these pizzas are DAMN GOOD. The crust is crispy and tasty. All ingredients and toppings are great. I feel like the pizza is always baked perfectly. There wasn't a lot of room to sit inside as there was a large party, but there were a few picnic tables outside and we claimed one of them. They have some beers and a small wine selection if I recall correctly. While we were eating, we noticed a steady stream of people getting pizza to go. That's always a good sign. I would eat here a lot more often if I could. Their Edwards location is closer to me and just as good! read more

Service was the best! Super friendly and accommodating. We called 15 min before closing and they stayed open for us - and even better, they stayed open late to let us eat at the restaurant. Best of all the pizza was awesome! Crispy crust that had basically fried cheese as part of it. The signage from the street at night made the place very hard to find but definitely worth the search! read more

THE PIZZA CRUST OH MY GOSHHHH!!! My SO & I go to Utah for the best pizza, but this spot.. changed my mind. The pizza sauce is amazingly sweet but just right, the cheese was nice & melted. We ordered the cheese bread too, a size small was larger than I expected!! I ordered online so we didn't have a chance to experience the atmosphere. My SO said it looked like the spot to sit down & enjoy your food though! It took our order 20-25 mins to be done but it was busy when we got there for pick-up so no doubt that it took a the time it did. Very satisfied! 10000/10, definitely will order again soon. read more

One of the best pizzas ever. Service was great. We called ahead to save time. Quality food.

Great pizza and salads! I was a little taken aback by the to go packaging as I've never seen pizza packaged that way before but it worked great and the pizza was delicious. Shishito peppers seemed to be a fan favorite here. They were on a lot of pizzas and in salads. Even an app option. But I didn't mind. They were delectable. This pizza place was a great find in Eagle. read more

See all

Came here twice for the 5 days trip we had for vail. Best pizza we've tried! Ordered 2 large pizzas. The lasagna in thin crust and the up truck veggie in thick crust read more

Pickup's Pizza Company - The thin crust is the lasagna, sausage replaced with chicken - Pizza Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

See all

My family has always enjoyed the pizza there but as someone who is gluten free, my most recent gf pizza was very disappointing. The crust was more like cardboard than the slightly softer crust I've had in the past. It tasted like it too. It was snapping when I tried to brake a piece off. I ordered a pizza with red sauce, mushrooms (which were very sparse) and extra cheese and can't imagine what it would have been like without the "extra". A sprinkle of cheese? I am a local and love that we have this restaurant in our town but come on, Pick Up! You can do better! Please get a good gf crust! I gave a 3 star for the business but as far as the gf pizza is concerned, I would give it a 1 (or zero). It's the worst gf crust I've ever had and I'm a long-time gluten-free-only diner. read more

I love Pickups Pizza! Spend the extra money to order from this restaurant instead of Dominoes. It will be so worth it!

These are a group of young boys that sure know how to make and serve a daaaanng good pizza. Easily some of the best pizza I've had! Definitely recommend the deep dish over the thin crust, but that's a personal preference, I guess :) read more

See all

Absolutely my Favorite place in Eagle. Best deep dish I've had. Friendly staff and fast service.

Super disappointed. Ordered the 'No Pants' pizza that was suppose to have a white sauce. It didn't have any sauce at all, just some some dabs of cheese sprinkled on it. It was very dry. We called to complain and was on the phone for 5 minutes while the staff scrambled to figure out what to do. Then we were told that the 'sauce' absorbed into the crust and that is why we didn't see it. Which doesn't even make sense unless it was al oil based sauce. Which clearly isn't a 'White Sauce' They argued quite a bit and the 'manager' insisted that he put the sauce on himself. Hmmm. read more

Pickup's Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

See all

Love this place. Guys inside are cool and have a good time while they work. Makes a small room feel bright and fun and it definitely is small in there but it don't bother me. Went 3 times with my fire crews and these guys were nice, food wasn't burnt, and I'd def go back when I come to visit outside of work. read more

Pickup's Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

Delicious. I would recommend. I prefer their thin crust pizzas. The personal size is the way I always roll.

Best thick crust pizza around. Always consistent and delicious. Also pretty good thin crust but the thick crust is outstanding! read more

Their mozzarella ricotta cheese sticks were amazing. Perfect bake perfect base and oh so cheesy! Tried their thin crust veggie pizza too. Nice touch with those shishito peppers. Jalapeños are overrated. Now I want shishitos on all my pizzas. The crust was nice to with a veggie loaded pizza. Packaging is a little weird in paper bags instead of boxes. Cheese got stuck to the top. read more

Just the right meal after 36,000 vertical feet. Awesome thin crust pizza with delicious toppings. The sauce is just wonderful, and the cornmeal to make the crust crunchy,,,perfect. We started with a salad and the basil vinaigrette and then had two small pizzas. We tried the Lord & Lady and a Create Your Own with thin crust, red sauce and mushrooms. Not a lot of seating but the staff was very friendly. Lots of pick up and delivery happening. $$$ read more

Pickup's Pizza Company - Create Your Own (sm) - Pizza Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

See all

Visiting Edwards Colorado and had a craving for pizza. The reviews led me here. These reviews are not off base. Excellent pizza! Flavorful dough, perfect sauce and fresh veges. I got the MD pizza which was sauce, goat cheese, sausage but I subbed pepperoni and I ordered the caprese salad. The pizza was incredible and what I would expect in a true pie. The salad was just ok. It wasn't a true caprese but I have to say the dressing that came with it was fabulous. But if you want a true caprese, that's not it. The pizza is worth every bite and calorie! read more

Best pizza in the Vail Valley. The deep dish pizza is Detroit style which reminds me of Buddy's pizza in Michigan. Love the shishito pepper toppings. The Uptruck and The MD pizzas are my goto. read more

Holy PIZZA! These people have it goin on! If you want AMAZING ZAAAA then hit up Pickup's Pizza. This pan pizza is by far the best in the eagle county, and same for the thin crust!!!!!!! As a local I will always choose this spot, I'm just tried of paying extreme prices for sub par food. But here you will find great food and great service. I'm past happy but proud to have them here close to me. Y'all will see me very soon!!! Thanks again for the great pizza dudes read more

We called right before closing and they stayed open to accommodate our late order. They were super nice, friendly and professional. Hats off to Edward's Pick Up Pizza. You made some starving people from out of town truly appreciate your food and kind gesture. Pizzas were tasty - crunchy on the outside and perfect soft, fluffy cooked dough in the middle. Toppings for The Uptruck were perfect variety of vegetables. We will be looking forward to ordering from Pick Up Pizza, again. read more

Fantastic "No Pants" pizza.Had it last night and I'm still thinking about it. The staff is very friendly and how can I describe the pizza accept to say Food Orgasim. read more

I was in town for just one night, looked up in yelp and I found this place has great reviews so I wanted to try. Also, I love their menu!! I got a small thin crust Uptruck with goat cheese. I love they use Shishito peppers.. mmmm, this pizza is very light ( I mean a good way, most of pizzas are just too fatty or too salty), crust and sauce is pretty good, too. Taste great with a red wine so that's a plus!! Only bad thing is.....145 miles away from my home read more

Pickup's Pizza Company - The Uptruck with thin crust and goat cheese... mmm so good!!! - Pizza Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

We love pickups... when you can actually get through to order..... the past few months their phones have been either down, or they're closed (no idea which? Maybe short staffed?).... Either way if they have changed their hours they need to update them. It's just annoying. read more

Quality here has really gone done over the 2 treats I've been a customer but still the best pizza in the valley unfortunately. Recently we've experienced pizza with minimal sauce and air bubbles causing up to half the pizza too be inedible. Step your game up read more

Mmmm MmMMm MmMmMm.... cool little place in Eagle, where we were staying with a cozy/hip ambiance and some delicious pizza! The place is a litte on the smaller side but we went after the rush. We even called in the order so that the pizza would be ready when we arrived based on some reviews that said the pizza took awhile to make. The told us that it usually takes 15-20 mins to make if they're not busy and that was exactly how long it took. We left our hotel, since we were just 3 mins away, and got there exactly at the 20 min mark and our pies were just about ready to come out. They were fresh out of the oven hot and delicious! The small pies were 4 squares and definitely more than enough for one person. The pan size was exactly what you would expect, filled with fresh ingredients. The red sauce was delicious and so was all the ingredients/cheese. The boyfriend got the lasagna pizza and loved it, I thought it was a bit lighter in flavors. I got the build your own "margherita" with mozzarella, basil, garlic, and tomatoes. It was good, though the tomatoes were a bit tart and the basil was a bit on the sparse side. The crust was good and stayed crispy, even in the center. We really liked the food here and the root beer was yum! Service was almost a serve/help yourself type deal once they bring your pie to the table. The fork/knives are by the register and so was everything else. I thought it was slightly on the pricey side for 2 small pies but it was good and that's all that mattered. read more

See all

Best pizza in Eagle. I love theirUp Truck on thin crust. They have topping options you don't find everywhere else. Would love to see pesto, artichoke hearts and Kalamata olives added to those options. read more

This pizza was amazing. While on our way to Utah we realized that it was getting late and we needed to find food quickly. We called to place our order, a caprese salad and a large uptruck with pepperoni. I don't know what I was expecting, but this far exceeded any expectations that I had. When we arrived to pick up the pie I was so impressed with the presentation. Beautifully charred crust, obviously fresh ingredients, and I loved the little hand sized square cuts. Wrapped in foil and placed in a large paper bag. A bit unwieldy in my lap, but we ate half of the pizza before even leaving the parking lot. The arugula was fresh, crisp and peppery and the salad dressing was amazing too. We dirt bike in the area frequently and often camp over night. This pizza is so good that it will warrant future treks down from the local track just to stop and grab this thin crust deliciousness. We ate the remainder cold for breakfast the next morning and I can confirm that it was still quite tasty. Worth every penny read more

We took all the siblings out to dinner the day after Thanksgiving since no one wanted to cook. We ordered a large thin crust(round) and 2 large thick crusts (square) for 6 people. We had LOTS of leftovers. Which is great- since this pizza is delicious! We spent about $70, including a few drinks. The thin crust is thinner than a NY style crust- it is almost a 'cracker' crust and while it was delicious, I won't likely order it again. The thick crust was very bready - which I like but my husband thought it was too doughy. The pizza takes a while to make, but it's worth it! read more

Thin crust was must better than thick, thick was dry. Thin pizza was delicious. Very nice staff! Thanks!

Great people, great pizza, great service! Looking for a fantastic local pizza joint, look no further.

Pizzas look great if you don't want to wait for eternity to get one. Don't bother tipping. If you ask if your pizza is ready, they will ignore you. Won't be back. read more

I've had pizza in NYC. Pizza in NC. Pizza in Vegas, CA, and Seattle. And this was some of the best. I was able to dine here en route to Fort Collins, and, my, it was delicious! I will definitely return! read more

I absolutely love this restaurant. Frankly I feel like it's one of the best restaurants in Eagle. Conscientious owners, great pizza.

We came into town on vacation hungry and looking for dinner somewhere that was not overcrowded. We ended up finding this little pizza place with the BEST pizza ever! The man and woman (didn't catch their names unfortunately) taking orders and manning the oven were super friendly and if we ever head out that way again-this place was added to our list of must-stop places. We ate at a LOT of places on vacation, ranging from fine dining to fast food and all of our family agrees-this place was the BEST and we wish this pizza could be shipped out of state...sigh... read more