Best pan pizza I have had ever. Love that they have multiple choices for cheeses, the onions are roasted and the peppers are so good.

Love this pizza! Great ingredients, mostly local and organic. Their shishito pepper pizza is one of our favorites. read more

Best pizza in the valley. Tried the OH KALE NO and THE SPROUT, both on (actually delicious) gluten free crust, both were to die for! Can't wait to have another pizza night! read more

best pizza in Eagle county. Pickup Pizza offers a Detroit Style deep dish that is the perfect amount of fluffy on the inside and crunchy on the out. Classic Mexican style Coca-Cola, and great options for toppings. Price is substantially higher than Dominos or Pazzos, but the quality is worth it! read more

What an awesome pizza joint! Old car parts on the walls, comic books on the tables, and amazing food. We had the Lasagna Pizza which came with ricotta, mozzarella, homemade sausage, fresh basil, red sauce, on a thin crust, and this thing was delicious! A very short drive off of I-70 while we were on our way to Glenwood Springs. Food came out in a timely manner and the staff was great and answered all our questions. Check these guys out! read more

They never disappoint! Had their lasagna pizza last night it was delicious!! Baked to perfection, keep up the good work and excellent customer service. read more

Fresh ingredients, loved the flavors. Enjoyed the pan pizza the best . Nice place to sit and eat and they have pinball!! They get a five star rating for eagle county high country pizza. Score would be different if located in city. Best pizza in eagle. read more

Just in town for the night on work. Good concept! But can tell ingredients aren't the freshest. And for the price you think the pizzas would be a little more extravagant... $26+ after tax for one large pizza. Good concept like the menu just not the execution. read more

Omg hands down the best deep dish in the whole valley! These guys really know what they're doing!!! Please open one in Vail soon

Easily the best pizza I have ever had. The fresh toppings are amazing and the fresh salads are a great accompaniment. It doesnt make you fill bloaty so eat all you want! read more

Great find after a long day in the sun in Glenwood Springs and on our way back to Vail. Get the Gonzo!! Great pizza and love the atlas covered table tops. Will make a point to come back! read more

Yelp to rescue! Fab find ...cannot beat pizza and sald options. Fresh ingredients and pairings. Bacon is to die for...do not pass up their spinach salad. We sat at bar and had the pleasure of hearing the owner's story...so glad he ended up in CO...we will be back for visit!! read more

The owners are amazing! The food is creative and fantastic. The deal they having going with Bonfire is a no brainer. Best beer and pizza in eagle. Will definitely be back! read more

Amazing pizza. The pan crust by itself is life changing, but then add the toppings and OH MAN! The only pizza joint that I use. A bit expensive for a pizza, but then again T-bone is a bit expensive for a steak. read more

Best freaking pizza around! Their deep dish is the only one to get and the balsamic basil dressing on the salad is amazing! I like the whole garlic gloves and sauce on top. I think they call this style of pizza Detroit. Just get it and experience it! read more

Excellent pizza and salad. Friendly staff! I look forward to trying lots of other pizza choices!

BEST. PIZZA. EVER. This is one of my favorite pizza places EVER! I'm from New England and we love our pizza. I fell in love with the Flatbread Pizza Company chain back east. I went back recently and the Flatbread pizza was not nearly as yummy as Pickup's. Pickups tastes like it was wood fired, has a great tasting crust, locally sourced tasty toppings and is just overall amazing, oh and the staff seems pretty chill. Wait times can be from 20 minutes to over 45 minutes. We just always plan for a longer wait, just in case. It's so worth the wait (if there is one). Pickups now has a couple tables, video game and a menu with different pizzas you can order. You can also make it your own and tell them what you'd like. There has been a time or two where the pizza doesn't quite taste the way it normally does. Don't get me wrong, it wasn't bad, just different. If that happens to you, try them again, they are sooo worth it. They are fairly new and are probably working out the kinks. Just wanted to be honest with ya. Best food in Eagle and best pizza in Colorado or anywhere I've been...and I've had a lot of pizza. My favorite is adding roasted onions, tomatoes, mushrooms and some fresh mozzarella. Support your small business so we can all enjoy them a long time! read more

I am not from the area, but wanted to try something local. Happy I stumbled upon this Pizza place.Great pizza, good food... will be back...

Chicago style thin crust? Wait, that's a thing?? YES IT IS, and holy cow this place knocks it out of the park! They also offer Detroit style deep dish with its luscious caramelized cheesy crust... oh my, things my dreams are made of! Either style of crust can be topped with your choice of sauces and toppings, all organic and locally sourced. A whole lot of yummy pizza goodness!! read more

Super awesome pizza joint with friendly owners and really delicious food. We stopped here on our drive back down to Denver. Had the ricotta breadsticks which were perfectly simple & flavorful with cheesy goodness. Loved the pizza combinations and super fresh ingredients. We had the Kale pizza and I loved the combination of sausage, kale, roasted garlic and peppers. The crust is perfectly crisp. They cut their pizza into squares which I personally am a huge fan of! Will definitely be making this a regular stop when driving past! read more

Best pizza west of Denver! Best pizza in the Vail Valley! As the name implies, pick-up only. The only deliver to Bonfire Brewery at end of block. read more

Best Pizza I've had in a long time. Staff is GREAT! Pan pizza is cheesy, buttery, and crispy. Highly recommended.

Excellent thin crust pizza with a very cool staff. Their to go pizza comes on cardboard saucer in a paper bag. Convenient for an on the go meal. read more

Loved the peppers! Great thin crust pizza, fresh and fast even on Super Bowl Sunday.

Definitely go here over the other 2 options in town. Great service, super friendly staff, fresh ingredients. Highly recommend!

Great little pizza spot! We were traveling through to Breckenridge and needed to eat, so dropped in and got a Ditka to-go. It was delicious, obviously made with quality ingredients, and had a crust that was light with a nice crunch on the edges. Not really a dine-in joint, but there were a few stools around a counter where you could watch the cooks at work. We were still talking about the pizza three days later, so will probably go back and get another on the way back. read more

Very good and nice service! We were just here for a race and ordered 5 pizzas for 12 people. More than enough and each were delicious. Would recommend! read more

Seriously. For real, one of the very BEST pizzas we've ever eaten. The crust, the sauce, the toppings. Everything was perfect. The price point is spot on, if not a bit low. LOVE LOVE LOVE. Go get a pie today!! read more

If this had a 6 star rating, I would give it to this place. The pizza was absolutely incredible!! They were really fast and super nice when I came in to get the food too. It was pricey, about $50 for 2 large pies, but I could honestly care less and will gladly pay that again, that's how good this is. We got the goat and da ditka and they were equally amazing. Also they deliver to Bonfire brewery. And any pizza joint that supports drunk people at breweries has my vote lol. read more

Great service, fun atmosphere and they deliver to the brewery down the street. I'll be back when I'm in Gypsum next!

Well, I could pay $13 for a movie and $6 for a box of popcorn or pay $6 for an iTunes movie and $14 for the best pizza around. No contest for me stay home with my Pickup's Pizza! read more

Not a bad little neighborhood joint! We prefer take out as the dining room so very small and does not serve alcohol.

Besides the fact that their pizza is crunchy, and cheesy, with fresh toppings, and full of deliciousness. They are also incredibly enjoyable people and have created a humble and welcoming space for all people. Thanks Tim and Angelica! Loved the roasted garlic! read more

Yeah, this pizza is great! I've now tried both the pan and thin crust styles and both are fantastic, but I've found that I'm normally going with the pan. Friendly staff and fun atmosphere, stop here if you're in the area and craving some great pies. read more

Pickup pizza is the place I go when I want a pizza that is covered in toppings. These guys have beat out Pazzos in Eagle for sure. And the fact that they partner with Bonfire Brewery, you know they are local. The only reason they did not get five stars is because the price is a little much. read more

Just had a taste of home!!! Wow Finally real pizza, Chicago style. Not at all greasy like it's local competitors. The owners are very friendly and genuine. The owner/operator brings chef quality flavors to our valley. What a Gem! Looking forward to tasting the Big Daddy of pies Chicago Style Deep Dish from this Chef some day. Well done guys. read more

awesome pizza! I had a pizza delivered to the Bonfire brewing company outdoor patio! Fast and easy transaction. My beer never got warm and the pizza was hot and tasty. I can recommend a build your own on thin crust. Reasonable read more

I really love this place, it is so good. Pizza is fresh tasting. They cut it into squares and place it in a paper bag instead of a box. My husband and I almost ate a whole pizza before we realized it. read more

I'm so happy my coworker told me about this little pizza place it is delicious. My daughter and I went in on a Tuesday night. We enjoyed the homemade dressing with our wonderful salad. Awesome and unique to know it is sourced locally and the pizza was just perfect and I love that they top to Pizza with grated cheese. BEST PIZZA... ! Thank you so much for the best service as well. read more

I'm on the Pickups meal plan these days!! These guys truly love what they are doing and it shows in the tasty pizzas I have had here! Always friendly and they have pinball!!! All fresh local sourced ingredients! read more