I ordered this for pick up and it was ready to go super quickly! I ordered the BLTC (if I'm not mistaken there was a C) but it's your typical BLT and I added in some mayo, honey Dijon and black olives! Overall the sandwich was really good! My only issue was it was a bit tiny, compared to other sandwich spots. read more

It was way too cold and windy to be a functioning member of society, so delivery was the move. I went for their limited-time meatball sub special and treated myself to a bag of cheddar jalapeño chips. The Breakdown: The Sub: When it first arrived, I'll admit I thought it looked a little tiny. But after further inspection, I take it back--the bread-to-meatball ratio was actually spot on. The cheese was perfectly ooey-gooey and toasty. My only real gripe? It definitely needed more sauce. The DIY Upgrade: Since I was already home, I decided to "doctor it up" with some pepperoni, homemade pickles, and pickled jalapeños. That extra kick really took it to the next level. The Chips: Absolute stars. Super crunchy with that perfect balance of spicy-cheesy goodness. Verdict: A solid, cozy meal for a "stay inside" kind of day. If you order the sub, maybe ask for an extra side of marinara! read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - The goods... And chippers! - Pizza Near Me - Olathe, Kansas

We like Picklemans and hope they stick around! The sandwiches are fantastic with toasted bread and cold crisp finishing. The service is great!! Madi is consistently sweet and provides attentive service. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - #8 Club - Pizza Near Me - Olathe, Kansas

Restaurant was clean so no complaints about that. Service wasn't bad, they were attentive without being pushy so we appreciated that. We ordered 2 pizzas, a garden salad and a cup of broccoli soup. The Hog pizza I'm told was good, my gluten free half cheese & half pepperoni was just okay. Needed a bit longer in the oven. Was told the garden chop salad was good but the broccoli soup a disappointment. There were the hard stringy bits of broccoli instead of chucks of the top part. It was all good enough that we plan to go back and try other things read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Half & Half 10" Gluten Friendly. Not bad, just needed longer in the oven - Pizza Near Me - Olathe, Kansas

Pickleman's has Columbia, MO roots and a small Midwest footprint. Creative sandwiches and friendly staff, but in KC's sandwich scene, value and execution matter. This carryout order: Italian Beef (#9) - Beef dipped in au jus and topped with giardiniera. Juicy and flavorful. Bonus points for extra au jus for dipping. Best of the bunch. Chipotle Chicken (#17) - Chicken, lettuce, chipotle ranch. Flavor's there, but the chicken is coated in sauce before toasting, which makes it mushy. It would be much better if they grilled and seasoned the chicken first, toasted the sandwich, and added the sauce afterward like a condiment. Asiago Chicken (#6, previous visit) - Chicken, bacon, provolone, asiago Caesar dressing. Tasty but salty, and same issue: sauce before toasting. Grill first, add sauce later. I like that these proteins (Italian beef, chipotle chicken, asiago chicken, Hogfather) also show up on their tavern-style thin crust pizzas, which I still want to try. Why three stars? It's not the food--quality is solid--but compared to other sandwich shops, they rarely run deals or coupons. In a competitive market, value matters. read more

Poor value. $17 for "half" a sub (maybe a quarter), chips, drink and a pickle. For that price, its not that good. I won't be coming back. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - My $17 meal at picklemans - Pizza Near Me - Olathe, Kansas

We are back on a Friday evening to review their pizza. As soon as we walked in we were greeted. We felt welcomed and we ordered a cheese pizza and an Italian sausage pizza. They have this great deal where you can get a buy one and get one for 50 percent off. It's right on their little menu. Total for these two pizzas $19.80 The dining area was pretty cold inside. My husband mentioned it to the crew and they said they would take care of it. they did so immediately. They also indicated they would bring out our pizza. So that was nice. I love that it's thin crust. Very tasty. They do a great job of keeping the lobby and dining area clean and the crew is very mindful of each other as they are courteous to guests and each other. Great place to come and visit. read more

See all

When I looked at it I was like dang this sandwich is small BUT it is loaded with flavor! Super delicious,and I like quality over quantity any day! This place was highly recommended to me,and its a 5/5 for sure! read more

See all

Love Pickelmans - I have been a loyal patron coming multiple times a week sometimes since they opened. 9 time out of ten it is always the same gal in the drive- thru - I would like to see her customer service improve and be a bit more personable and not so robotic. read more

The quality of food. Not impressed enough to go again. The chicken salad side was lacking!

You know, for a fast casual chain sandwich joint, this Pickleman's does a pretty good job of delivering on a solid quick meal. This spring we have soccer every Saturday at Heritage Park and when it ends, our kiddo is hungry so we have often ended up at this Pickleman's as it's on the way home, and is a lot healthier than say, McDonalds on the way home for a treat. The folks working have consistently been super kind, and it's fairly affordable for the three of us to snag a sandwich after soccer. Each time the sandwich is warm, and tasty. I think our daughter would say her favorite part is getting bbq chips, but she always eats at least half of her ham sandwich as well. My only critique is that I'm often freezing when I'm inside, but that could just be a corporate decision on AC, who knows. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - turkey sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Olathe, Kansas

See all

I got the Italian club and it was a delicious, and I can't tell you how fast the team in there is working! I ended up ordering 8 sandwiches and then the team got it done within minutes! Take that Panera or other sandwich places! I can most accurately compare them to Potbellies that I had in Texas and for anyone that hasn't had them, that is high praise! read more

I was very excited to see a location of Pickleman's not too far from home and it is newly built and opened. From my experiences at both locations in Lawrence and all 3 in KC, the service is always hit or miss depending on time and location unfortunately. Of course we all have had co-workers that go above and beyond expectations while others just show up for their shift. Fortunately the recipe remains consistent with the bread and soup! The tomato bisque is as flavorful and smooth as I remember, complimenting the crunch of the outside of the bread with the fluffy center that soaks up every drop you have left of soup like a sponge! To my knowledge this is the first location with a drive-thru, that's HUGE! This is definitely an in&out type of restaurant, but you are always welcome to dine-in if you want your clothes to smell like a bakery the next day. Great options either way! There was a few technical difficulties with the fancy credit card terminal. I definitely love technology, but also realize it can be a pain at the same time. The staff also assumed I was eating my food in and didn't package any of it to-go as I intended. Small things that can easily be fixed. I will definitely be utilizing the drive-thru in the future. Also, I am very happy to see this restaurant spread its wings and fly! P.s will do my best to let my phone eat first next time(: read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Very exciting!!! - Pizza Near Me - Olathe, Kansas

My opening day dine-in lunch experience was okay, with room for improvement. My Chipotle chicken sandwich $8.99 was built to order at the counter, with a good amount of tasty grilled chicken chunks and somewhat spicy sauce on a fresh, toasted bun. The sandwich was smaller than I expected at 7" long by just 2.5" wide. The ordering process was not especially customer friendly. I picked the Chipotle chicken sandwich at the first station but did not specify a bread and wasn't asked which one I wanted, so I ended up with white. A variety of toppings were available in addition to the standard toppings that came with my choice of sandwich. I was asked if I would like other toppings, but neither the toppings bar nor a list of toppings was visible at that station, so it was necessary to instead ask for options. I found the service at the counter to be accommodating, while the dining area was clean and new without background music. This location offered a drive-thru. read more

See all

You haven't eaten a good grilled cheese until you have had a Pickleman's grilled cheese.

A $60 order including an 18% tip. Picked up order and we were missing the plain mac and cheese as well as the au jus for the Italian sandwich. Which is OK bc it did not have the giardiniera on it soooo there is that as well. I asked for extra mayo on turkey sand and it was awful. More mayo than turkey or lettuce ( i thought we got chicken salad by mistake). I guess extra is subjective. And there was the 18% tip for not making our order correctly. Pickleman's food is good but if the order is not made correctly and items and componts do not get onto the bag....then it is not worth it. Tbc, I did call regarding the mac and cheese and the manager credited my account including tip. I did not call regarding the other issues. I just won't return bc i don't trust that it will be made properly. Oh well. read more

They did not give me pickles and the chips were mid i came here having high hopes to get the world's best pickles but instead i was left in disappointment and a empty stomach that was not full of pickles. the reason why this place gets one star is because of the service and the feeling that i got to leave. there is pickle photos but no pickles. read more

I have always loved this place. Especially love the crunchy thin crust pizza. My go to is pepperoni and we usually get a garden chop salad to go with it. Also just a tip if you're eating here - they homemake all of their dressings so of course we have to get ranch on the side - it's the best. Super clean. Definitely a 5 star all around. Tonight in particular we had a bit of a situation and the manager more than made it right. So it is not just the food, but the kindness and service tonight that went above and beyond, and will always go a long ways for me. Thank you for having me in. read more

One time I ordered DoorDash from here and they gave me two of everything I ordered so I will pretty much love them for the rest of my life. Sad they closed their Overland Park location but this one in Olathe is great too. Always good food and kind service read more

Tried for the first time today, a convenient stop for a quick lunch. Not very busy for the lunch hour, only 2 other people at tables, maybe the end of the high noon busy hour? Ordering was easy, process was efficient. Reminiscent of Quizno's to be honest. Sandwich was good but on the small side of what was expected. Also a bit pricey for the size. Lunch for 3 people, 2 sandwiches with chips and 2 drinks and a half salad and drink, with a gratuity was just north of $60. I get that pretty much all fast/fast casual food is more expensive now, but I've had sandwiches twice as big nearby for much less. The price will make me think twice before trying again. read more

Pickleman's is a staple of mine! Delicious sandwiches, yummy pizza, and tasty cookies - no matter your order it will be great.

over the summer i was rudely greeted by a bigger blonde boy. He was extremely rude and even messed up my whole order. I have not returned since then. I also saw him touching his bum while preparing my order so I didn't even eat it. I am highly disappointed in this establishment . Get some real workers not teenagers... read more

My sandwich was fantastic! The Smokehouse Stack was Smokey and delicious. The cookies are fresh and you can tell they are made from scratch. We will definitely be back! read more

Always a solid choice for a quick pick up pizza. Service is fast and friendly. Also, they consistently have great ranch.

The food is fresh and tastes good, but I don't understand why they never give you napkins on to go orders. Are we required to ask for them?

I love when we find a place that serves fresh, delicious food but is also clean when you walk in and friendly staff. Pickleman's is all this and more! I love their lettuce wraps because I'm gluten free. My kids love their sandwiches and freshly made cookies. like for real, homemade cookies! We will go back again and again because this place just can't be beat! read more

Pick up order was ready and the perfect temperature. The perfect amount of dressing on the sandwich. Tomato bisque soup is amazing with a little kick. Will highly recommend. Staff was polite and welcoming. read more

So yummy and great customer service!! The tomato basil bisque was delicious! Would recommend

Never tried Pickleman's before. Was out running around and decided to stop in. Service out the gate was excellent, guy in there Tommy gave me the low down on the menu. Ended up with the Hodge Podge. Downed the whole thing, very good sandwich and very good service. Next time I'll try a pizza, I'll definitely be back. read more

I love Pickleman's. It is always very tasty and fresh. I get great service and love the drive thru! Highly recommend grabbing a bite here. Delicious, fast, and convenient! read more

The sandwich was good, kinda small for the money. But the girl that was working the drive through didn't understand good service. They need to step it up. read more