Excellent! A little expensive it so worth it! From the spicy margarita to the main entrees and dessert! So good! The service was amazing too! read more

Pecado Mexican - Seared scallops with chorizo, mushrooms, corn and sweet potato! Yum! - Mexican Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Beautiful restaurant Waiter was prompt and gave good service I had the queso with my husband It was very good I had the taco salad no meat very refreshing they kept the water glasses filled Was very happy read more

Short trip back to my hometown and was only staying long enough for one weekend Brunch and decided to check out Pecado since it's fairly new. We arrived around 11am on a Sunday with no reservations and was sat immediately. I absolutely loved the decor and the dim lighting, what a vibe not to mention the Reggaeton playing at the perfect volume to enjoy but still have a conversation. We both ordered the Jalisco Flower, I hesitated ordering this because of the grapefruit but wow you couldn't taste it at all and I'm really glad i got this over your typical mimosa. I was very intrigued by all of the selections on the brunch menu as they were all unique. We couldn't decide so we opt for picking two entrees and sharing . We went with the chorizo hash and the churro waffle with a side of yuca fritas. Absolutely speechless on how amazingly delicious both were. By the time we started to leave around 1 it did start to fill up with patrons . Highly recommends coming in for Brunch. read more

See all

My girlfriend and I went last night and had shrimp ceviche,wings,fish tacos and enchiladas. Everything we had was a 10/10 I was honestly surprised because that's a rarity. Place had a cool vibe to it and staff and gm were great. Only negative I can say is they need a tequila list of some sort. They probably have over 100 tequilas and no list. All and all great experience and we will definitely be back read more

Came in for our first time and sat at the bar with Mel and Josh. Both of them were absolutely amazing!!! We not only had great service but laughed so much as well. Both Mel and Josh were so knowledgeable about the menu and drinks that our experience was on point. We had spicy margs and passion fruit margs which were both incredible. I don't have a pic of the queso but that was outstanding. The atmosphere feels high end but is very casual and relaxed. This is a must stop on my list if you are in town! read more

Pecado Mexican - Mexican Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

I loved the vibe of this place and the food was absolutely amazing! 100% plan on coming back here.

When I first took a bite of the Tostada I almost cried. This brought back memories from my childhood. The food is beyond spectacular. The owner and staff are friendly and they come and check up on you. I love this place read more

See all

Popped in for drinks with a date. Bar service was great. Eduardo kept the 5-star drinks flowing; His energy was awesome! I'm obsessed with everything about this place. We got hungry and ordered the Chicken Quesadilla, Carnitas tacos, and a churro read more

Pecado Mexican - TAJIN rim, spicy house made tequila margarita - Mexican Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

I think this spot is a great addition to main street Bayshore. The food was great, drinks were great, pricing is exactly what you'd expect. All of the staff was really friendly. The decor and atmosphere was very enjoyable. From the music to the lighting. I do think the bartender could have been a bit more alert / observant on drink refills. I'd say that if my drink didn't sit empty most of the time, I would have had the want to order 2-3 more drinks -- The longer I sit and wait, the less I want to drink. However, this is a very minor thing. If you love verde, coastal, and all of the spots main street has to offer, this spot is right up there with the best of them. I think the menu is a bit more complex then verde and coastal, more to offer is nice. Also met the owner, he was friendly and very observant to each and every customer. That goes a long way especially when it isn't coming off as fake. Drinks 5/5 Food 5/5 Atmosphere 5/5 Service 5/5 5 star review. And no, I'm not getting paid for this review. read more

Pecado Mexican - Tres leches & churros - Mexican Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Yesterday afternoon I had came in for something quick with my family. Let's start off at the Front desk. One of the young lady's was eating McDonald. Odd. Any ways the young lady had sat me next to the door to outside. My husband kindly asked to be move if it was going to be cold because we have a new born baby that did not happen. One of the young man that gave us water forgot our chips and salsa. He had to be reminded to get our chips and salsa unbelievable !! read more

The best dinner I've had in a long time, the drinks are great. I recommend the Wagyu with chipotle butter. I will definitely be back!!!

I've been looking forward to trying this place since it opened and I'm so glad I was finally able to! Atmosphere is amazing. Service was friendly. The coconut margarita was our favorite out of the few we tried - both frozen and on the rocks! Good and drinks are a little pricey, but we all enjoyed our time and felt that it was worth it. read more

Pecado Mexican - Mexican Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

This place is dirty! I came here once before and won't be coming back.. all items overpriced even for a casual meal.

Went their for dinner and let's say this place is amazing I think what make this place so good is the service our waiter was so nice and just welcoming he gave us great recommendations and we took them and I love them all he was very attentive and made conversation with us which you rarely see. Thank you Cesar will be coming back read more

One of the best restaurants we've been to in a long time. The place is clean, modern and a great addition to Bay Shore. We enjoyed everything we ordered! The staff was amazing and it's overall a great vibe. Highly recommend it and will definitely be going back soon! read more

See all

Came here for my coworkers birthday celebration and was rushed the entire time. Actually I won't say the entire time the only time we had to think of what to eat/drink/ talk was when the waitress took a literal 30 mins to bring us back our margaritas.... As my one coworker was eating a taco the bus boy took the plate out from infront do her that still had the rest of her meal on it. The waitress knew what we were there for yet failed to show any type of assistance when it came to dessert, apparently after 5 mins of having the dessert menu "she could tell we were obviously having a hard time picking something" so she brought out a plate with whipped cream and a candle and didn't even sing happy birthday...? Service like that definitely effects tip! I won't be returning read more

I wish I could give this place 10 stars! This was the best restaurant I have eaten in, IN YEARS!!!!!! The place looks amazing, the food was ridiculously ridiculously ridiculously delicious, fast, fresh, and just holy crap amazing! The service was over the top exceptional! Ask for Edoardo he was the best server ever! I will be back 1 million times over! If you are looking for something new and smack you in your face fantastic, this is the place to be! read more

See all

Was excited to have a new Mexican restaurant in Bay Shore. Pecado did not disappoint. The atmosphere is modern yet cozy. We had a reservation and were seated promptly by the hostess. I had the Fall margarita made with cinnamon & apple cider. It was great. Our food was delicious. The chile relleno was filled with mushrooms & lots of cheese. It was so flavorful. The tamale & mole chicken enchiladas were good as well. Tres Leches was delicious & not too sweet. Our server, Danielle, was excellent and answered any questions we had. There's so many other dishes we want to try. We will definitely be back soon. read more

See all

Maria and Jazlyn were absolutely phenomenal, they were so welcoming and super nice they, made our experience better, I'll be back for sure thanks to them !! read more

Delicious food. Nice ambiance. Outdoor patio was very nice. Tasty cocktails. Service was good. read more

Pecado Mexican - Enchiladas - Mexican Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Love this place! The owner is friendly and accommodating. The staff are friendly and helpful. The food is delicious!!! And the drinks are great. Wonderful ambiance. I highly recommend read more

Drinks were ok nothing special worth coming back for. I sat at the bar and when I went to the bathroom the Bartender with the dreadlocks was asking my girlfriend out. Solid staff. read more

The servers were extremely friendly. The food was amazing. The ambience was nice. It was modern and clean. You could hear reggaeton playing through the speakers which was nice. There's also an extensive alcohol section, which is nice having a drink with your dinner and just to relax for a little bit, it is a wonderful place and it is a great date night or brunch with the girls. read more

Wow has this place gone downhill. I'm only giving any stars at all because the food and drinks are pretty good. But the service? The service has slowly gone downhill for us probably over the last 2 months or so, and it culminated with a visit to the restaurant for Cinco de Mayo. Before this last time, we were noticing that it was taking probably 20 minutes for the drinks to come out, and one time we actually got our food before the drinks. And once we got chips with no salsa, and despite asking again for it, it never came. It was frustrating, but never enough that we would stop going. Then Cinco de Mayo rolls around. We managed to get a reservation for 8:15, which is really late for us for dinner, but we decided to make it work. We got there at 8:15 on the nose, but had to wait a short time to be seated. We understood considering it was a busy night. We waited probably about 10 minutes for the waitress to come greet us, and she informed us that the bar is backed up and it may be a while for our drinks. We understood, and ordered some guacamole. Another 10 minutes go by, still nothing has come to the table, and we start to realize that it may be a good idea to order more because apparently the bar was not the only thing backed up. So we do, and then we waited. And waited. And waited. A total of 35 minutes go by, and we finally received our guacamole, but still no drinks. I go to open my napkin so we can start eating, and I am greeted with hardened guacamole on it. That was it. We will never come back to this place. It's a shame. We really liked it. But they either need more help, or better staff. I don't know. read more

Yesterday I took a visit here, Food was amazing. server was amazing. When I was getting seated one of the young lady in the front was very rude on her phone. She was lightskin long nails long curly hair. The second young lady ended up helping us after the first one couldn't she was very kind, smiley, communicated and made sure we felt comfortable . short curly hair looked spanish pink nails read more

Great food, the best wait staff. Jasmine is incredible super friendly and just made our night! Went there for our anniversary and it did not disappoint! Will definitely be going back!!' read more

In my opinion they have the best brunch on LI! They have both savory and sweet options so there's something for everyone. The ambience is great and the food is even better! The service was also a highlight, everyone that works there is super nice! Highly recommend. read more

See all

Delicious food and drinks, great ambiance. Menu is a bit limited, would love to see something like a tequila flight and mix and match tacos. On the pricier side. read more

I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone I know because of the horrible service they provide. The overwhelming amount of music and who knows who's in charge? The only spot is the bar which the people were extremely kind and friendly. Other than that don't come here a complete waste of my time. read more

Everything here is perfect. The food, ambiance, drinks. The servers are so predictable and attentive. Def recommend.

Overall great experience! From the tasty drink, delicious food and attentive wait staff I would highly recommend this restaurant! Only down side is some of the tables are very close to each other! I would definitely visit again! read more

See all

They have a great backyard patio with heaters when it's chilly Good food A bit pricey Similar to del fuego menu But way nicer inside Staff is excellent read more

The waiter was nice and kept checking up on us. The food and drinks were amazing. Lovely environment and the style is something different than most restaurants. read more

Of the many choices along Main St in Bay Shore Pecado is the best! Best atmosphere, best food and most of all service and welcoming from Chris and Vince at the bar. The tequila selection lacks nothing. I was treated like a local and went with what was recommended. The street corn was the best, and save room for dessert, the tres leche is over the top. I look forward to returning whenever I'm in Bay Shore. read more

Pecado Mexican - Refreshing - Mexican Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Wow. I have to say the place is great. The food is perfect and the staff is super attentive. Worth every cent

Place is super busy especially on a Friday night. Would recommend making a reservation way ahead of time !!

The food is so good and everyone is super friendly and polite. The only bad thing I have to say is that the tables are so close to one another and you can hear everyone's conversation lol but that don't stop me from going. Just a heads up, for big guys out there. read more

Was looking forward to trying this restaurant for the longest time. Beautiful aesthetics with a great looking ambiance. All that beauty couldn't hide the horrific service. The server was as lazy as possibly imaginable. She got a two entree wrong and didn't apologize. She never came to see how our food was after it was brought to the table. The food runner dropped the plates and kept it moving. Water glasses were never refilled. The salmon was partially raw on the inside. The skirt steak was like chewing fake rubber meat that had no taste, other than of salt. Everything was clearly over salted too make up for the tasteless food. The only positive was the fresh guacamole. There were only two tables plus ours in the restaurant, so it wasn't busy. To top it all off, the irony of this all is..... no one was even trying to fake it since he was either the owner or manager sitting at the back table with his lap top the entire time we were there. That tells me this is just coming practice the staff exhibits Save your time and money and avoid this location like the pandemic, bc for 140 dollars for this experience we could of had two 3 for me from Chilis and had way better service, quality of food and saved a ton of money. read more

Food was wonderful. Great suggestion for cocktail. Service was wonderful. Great atmosphere. Will definitely go back.

Excellent!!!! I love the food the attentive of the waiters, the manager of the restaurant stop several times in our table to make sure we love the drinks , the food is authentic Mexican delicious, I recommend this restaurant read more