My sister-in-law invited us to dinner at Bar Lucy to celebrate my brother's birthday. Although I've driven past it often and was intrigued by the yellow neon sign, it would slip my mind when choosing a place to dine. I'm so glad I've finally had a chance to try it. We started with three appetizers to share: the golden meatballs, the baked clams and the fried artichokes. All three were absolutely delicious. I chose ricotta cavatelli bolognese as my entree.It was rich and meaty and silky - something I'd definitely order again. I also tried my sister's autumn pizette, one of the specials. Thin crisp crust, thinly sliced squas, sausage, cheese and a drizzle of fig glaze. A perfectly composed fall dish. Everyone else enjoyed their meals (spaghetti & meatballs, veal parm, chicken française, and spaghetti with seafood.) We shared two desserts - tiramisu was just as I like it, moist but not wet with all the flavors melding into something greater than their individual parts. The tricolor cake was a slice of rainbow cookie, dense and decadent. Our server Michaela was charming and efficient. The atmosphere was sophisticated yet relaxed. Overall, a five star experience. read more

Bar Lucy - Front wall - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

I was walking my dog down Main Street in Bay Shore and decided to stop for dinner. I grabbed a seat outside with the dog, and about 20 minutes later a waitress came over. She was friendly, brought the menus, and got our drinks started. They also have daily specials throughout the week. I ordered the Meatball Monday spaghetti special, which came with garlic bread and a side salad for one price. To finish the meal, I had the tiramisu. The spaghetti was flavorful, and the tiramisu was light, fluffy, and a great way to end the meal. The service was good, the food was satisfying, and I'd definitely recommend checking this place out if you're in the area. read more

See all

Welcome Bar Lucy to Bayshore! It's beautifully renovated inside with an awesome bar and amazing cocktails are served. We were greeted and seated by the friendliest host who mentioned it is restaurant week. They have a special menu in place $46 (sorry forgot that photo). You have a choice of one appetizers, one entree and one dessert. We will start off about talking about the yummy appetizers four nice sized baked clams which were so flavorful and moist with a lemon drizzle. We had to order the ciabatta roll to dip of course. For dinner, we each had the lemon fettuccine with shrimp and thinly sliced asparagus which was a great choice for a lighter & fresh dinner option. Now let's get to the dessert, the flourless chocolate cake. All I can say is WOW! Hands down the best. This Chocolate was absolutely delicious moist, hot, decadent chocolate with pistachio sauce drizzled plate. OMG. The waitress Kelly did not steer us wrong everything we asked she was correct about. Her energy and attentiveness was off the chart. Thanks for a wonderful dinner experience in your new restaurant. We will definitely be back soon. read more

See all

Let's start with the food. This was the first and only time I've ever had mozzarella sticks and they were fantastic. The pizza and the mac n cheese were average. The mac and cheese had too much of a soup-like consistency. Our waitress was ok. Nothing special. The drinks were fantastic. Not pictured, I had a spritz like drink that was great. I ordered dessert too but I honestly forgot what it was. Whole experience was just forgettable. They had this really tasty liquid dessert (espresso martini) which was probably the best part of the whole experience! Go and try it out! read more

Bar Lucy - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

WOW!!!!! This spot is DELICIOUS Absolutely loved everything I got! From their drinks, to apps, to pizzas, to entrées, everything was literally mouthwatering! They have a great happy hour and every day they have a daily specials so make sure to check them out! read more

See all

I had such an amazing experience here. Thank you so much to our server Lucy, she was so attentive and friendly. I enjoyed their pork chop with brussel sprouts on the side, and their lemon cheesecake was lovely as well. Will definitely be back soon! read more

Bar Lucy - Pork chop with gnocchi - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

First time here for lunch at this fairly new restaurant. The restaurant is bright and nicely decorated with a lovely bar . The service was outstanding , attentive and everyone was so friendly and polite . I ordered the cavatelli bolognese which was absolutely delicious! Made with homemade pasta and a yummy meat sauce . I enjoyed my lunch and will definitely be returning. read more

See all

Bar Lucy was great!! Very nice Italian ambiance and everyone from the host to bartenders to our server was very friendly. Ordered the Brussels sprouts to start and they were delicious! We went on Tuesday which was their pasta night. The rigatoni bolognese was yummy, but the Cacio e Pepe I would skip - tasted just like pasta in butter with not much other flavor. I will definitely be returning for the other weekly specials! read more

Bar Lucy - Cacio e Pepe & rigatoni bolognese - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

I have been going to this place for about a year. It is fantastic. The food, the potions, the service the quality is all top notch. Get the lemon cheesecake it's a life changer. It's a modern chill neighborhood vibe. read more

See all

Visited for the first time the other night and had a mostly good experience. We had a reservation and were seated right away. Our server was friendly and got our drinks quickly. I was surprised that, for an Italian restaurant, they don't offer complimentary bread. Instead, they have a warm ciabatta appetizer for $6. It came with a ricotta dip which was only ok. There was no hot pepper spread. It was fine for two people, but a bit ridiculous if you're with a larger group. Would not recommend. For entrees, we tried the lemon fettuccine and the house pizza. The pasta was actually really good. The pizza, however, tasted a little off--almost artificial. I was expecting a more traditional brick oven style, so that was disappointing. For dessert, we shared the multicolored cake, which was basically a rainbow cookie cake--and it was delicious. The espresso martini was also a hit--strong, smooth, and not too sweet. Overall, I'd come back, but I'd be more mindful of the menu next time, especially when it comes to the pizza and bread offering. read more

See all

Went there tonight with my wife for our anniversary. Let me tell we had a great time, great food and Kelly (our waitress) was on point. We frequent many restaurants in the Bayshore, Babylon and Patchogue areas, I would say this is right up there with the best of them. We started with the crispy fries shrimp and the baked stuffed clams which were both a nice amount and were spot on. Then we shared a grilled veal chop which was cooked perfect and a nice size. We ended it with an espresso and cannoli's. The place was very clean and decorated cozy, very friendly and inviting. From the host to the waitress and servers everyone was very accommodating. Give it a try, I promise you won't be disappointed. read more

See all

Great food, ambiance and service is what you'll get from Bar Lucy..from the drinks to the apps to the main dishes, everything is prepared wonderfully and delicious. A must try when you're in the area!. AAA+++ read more

See all

Let me start off by saying this happens to be me and my wife's favorite restaurant/ Bar in downtown bayshore. Clean friendly atmosphere. Stopped in for early lunch / drinks. Bartender/ wait staff & even the owner welcomed us in and made this experience top tier. We were the first ones to try their new lunch menu and was far from disappointed. Meat balls were packed with flavor and the gravy/ sauce was to on point. I think the owner has his nonna working in the back lol! food packed with authentic flavor. Awesome bartender and great drink specials. This is going to one or must stop in places whenever we're in the area. Highly recommended. read more

See all

So last month, we went here for a date night around 6:30. We were seated far enough from the bass player (it was jazz night), and he wasn't too loud...it actually made the whole thing feel extremely romantic. The ambiance is a cocktail (no pun intended) of modern and traditional Italian. I loved the pictures on the wall, and the touch of matches on the hostess table when you walk in was such a nice detail. I got a cocktail and a glass of wine, both were very good. We started with the pizza, which was perfect because it had a thinner crust. We didn't finish it as an appetizer and brought a slice or two home, but it was a great palate cleanser for our meals. The menu had a nice balance of traditional and more diverse Italian options, which totally matched the vibe. I even sent pictures to my group chat while we were there and said, "We have to come here." Our waitress was attentive and so sweet. read more

Bar Lucy - Wine - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Atmosphere was nice, loved the decor. Would have loved to hear some old school Italian music to match the vibe rather than Chappel Roan. The drinks were just okay. For appetizers we got the ceasar salad and baked clams. The baked clams were absolutely fantastic! The ceasar salad was mediocre. The red cabbage in the salad reminded me of one of those premade salads I can get at the grocery store. The ceasar dressing was not that flavorful. For dinner we got the chicken Milanese and the salmon. My friend really enjoyed the salmon. The chicken Milanese was good, I like the green beans added to the salad on top. My one critique would be it needed more dressing and to fry the cutlet a little less. The dessert was the showstopper. The cannolis were absolutely fantastic and flavorful and stuffed with just the right amount of cream. The espresso martinis were also delicious. Overall I would go back again and give it another chance with different items. The waitress was very kind as well as the manager who checked on us multiple times. read more

Bar Lucy - Dirty Martini and I believe the other drink was called Tour of Italy - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

New Italian restaurant in Bay Shore. Previously the Linwood. Ambiance is modern and fresh. For appetizer we ordered the shrimp arrabiata, generous portion with the perfect amount 5 jumbo shrimp, If you are a shrimp lover perfect choice. For drinks we ordered wine which was fresh. We were not sure what wine we wanted to order and they provided samples. Speaks to the service which was excellent! For main course we order the meatballs with spicy rigatoni and a side of burrata cheese. The meatballs were tender and well spiced. The spicy rigatoni was not spicy but tasted good. For dessert the lemon cheesecake was delicious, loved the unique touch of lemon on top. Will definitely be back! read more

See all

Came for dinner with two friends. We were seated in the side room, aka the Amalfi Coast Room, which is super cute and gorgeous. Our server was attentive and very kind. It wasn't too busy on a weeknight so food came out quickly. I had the mussels, the pasta fagioli, and brussel sprouts. The mussels were very tender and the red sauce was divine, with hints of the wine and garlic. The grilled bread was perfect for dipping into the sauce. The pasta fagioli was a HUGE portion, even though it was an appetizer! It was super hearty, also very flavorful, and the beans and pasta were cooked perfectly. I took most of it to go and it was delicious the next day as well. The brussel sprouts were fried and seasoned perfectly. Highly recommend! read more

Had a great night out with friends here! I enjoyed this spot when it was Linwood so I was looking forward to try it. Drinks were great, we really enjoyed the food and they were accommodating with any gluten free requests. Will be back! read more

We LOVE Bar Lucy. Food is great, reasonably priced, kid friendly, cute inside and waitstaff is awesome. read more

Bar Lucy - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Wow. This reset is really wonderful. If you love downtown Bay Shore (and can't walk there) you should reserve a spot at this place. Food, check, service, check, value, check! A little noisy if you're of a certain age but the food and service makes it worth while. read more

this was the old Lynnwood in Bayshore, the menu the best like it's predecessor service decor Well done totally different vibe from the other place. Give it five stars. A definite must see must try. read more

Thank you for our first visit. We made reservations for four, my best friend and our wives. We have been dining together for over 30 years. After leaving tonight, we had a conversation about how we all could not find anything to complain about! We are all business owners and consider ourselves food critics who always find fault! This is a first! Great Food, Service, Ambiance, prices and best bathrooms! Thank you! Lucky Lou's Rice Pudding read more

Had a reservation for two at 6:15 PM and we get there and we had to wait close to 45 mins. The food was okay, however, I wouldn't say outstanding. My friend got the lemon fettuccine and said the taste of lemon was overpowering. The drinks were probably the best part. I would go back for drinks not necessarily the food. In all fairness, the staff gave us a free dessert to make up for the wait but even dessert was mediocre. read more

First visit recently. Food and location were amazing. Service from Olivia and hostess was friendly and personal. Made us feel welcome. Would definitely recommend and return. read more

Food & service was excellent the restaurant was nicely decorated the only thing I would add is to serve breadbaskets

Walked in and was very impressed. We were seated right away. The acoustics was great and we were able to have a conversation without having to struggle to hear each other. Our waitress was attentive and friendly. The manager recommended a the Cavatelli which was outstanding. Ordered the meatballs & calamari and shrimp for apps and main course I had the salmon which was absolutely delicious. Asked for the sauce on the side and came out perfect. One of my friends order the flounder which was amazing as well. Highly recommend. We will be back.. read more

Honestly gross and not great service. Both my friend and I didn't like our meals even though they look pretty, she compared hers to chef boyardee. Also, who charges $8 for appetizer bread at an Italian place?? read more

The ambiance was great everyone was super friendly including our waitress. Very attentive. We started with the chop salad and the Brussel sprouts both were great. We then got the salmon and the shrimp oregonata and it was delicious. I have to say the star of the show is the lemon cheesecake. I am not normally a fruit in dessert person but wow I have still been thinking about this cheesecake. Can't wait to go back for a slice and an espresso martini! read more

See all

Second time coming..Amazing food, drinks and service. Bartenders are so friendly and made beautiful drinks. Can't wait to come back! read more

Bar Lucy - Dirty martini and old fashioned. Delicious - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

I have been a longtime fan of The Linwood so I was reluctant to try Bar Lucy. The decor is too bright and the two rooms don't match. The service was great & the owner was nice to check on us, but the food and drinks were lackluster at best. The Prosecco was flat. The antipasto & pasta dishes were tiny for the price. The salmon was nothing to write home about. Wouldn't go back. #missinglinwood read more

Went last Thursday evening for dinner, 6 of us. We were mostly disappointed considering all the good reviews we read. First we were all freezing, no heat on although we requested it several times. There was no bread basket , salt & pepper or grated cheese on the table and were told we'd have to pay for bread...in an Italian restaurant! No bread given! A first for sure! Husband ordered chicken parmigiana..terrible, chicken was dry and very tough. Others ordered linguine with clam sauce, said it was over cooked pasta and a very small portion. Two ordered the Caesar salad instead of pasta and it had very wilted lettuce. I had the ricotta cavetelli bolognese, although a tasty sauce, it was shy of enough of the pasta. We didn't bother with dessert. However, I will give kudos to the waitress we had, she was very nice, friendly and efficient . Not sure we'll ever give it another chance. Says I'm from CA..strange..I'm from West Islip NY. read more

Frank Bayshore * 1 Review * Dined 3 days ago My wife and I went to bar Lucy for the first time last night. What an unexpected wonderful experience! From the moment we walked in and were greeted by Marissa, to our server, Amanda, and we got to meet one of the owners Drew. Drew took the time to tell us all about his vision for the restaurant and what he was trying to accomplish. Well, he did it and then some! This place is Amazing. My wife and I felt like we were having dinner in one of our families's houses, surrounded by all our brothers and sisters and nieces and nephews. What a wonderful dining experience. And the food was authentic Italian, at its best! Bar Lucy just feels like Home... Frank & Rebecca C read more

Service was great Food was bland. I ordered the spicy vodka pizza. It was bland. The pizza was not restaurant quality. It was flat bread with minimal sauce and cheese was overdone. Very disappointing for the price. Drinks were good read more

I came to Bar Lucy twice and sat at the bar. I had drinks and the octopus salad and fried mozzarella. All were great. The ambience is very nice. I love the decor although I read here it is bright but I adore the pictures on the wall and the red seating. It makes it fun and cozy. I came a third time and I am basing this review on that visit. I went to Bar Lucy for my daughter's birthday. They had a nice roomy table for us and was greeted by the fantastic, energetic and lovely server Kelly. She made the evening wonderful. Kelly provided a little surprise for my daughter's birthday which was thoughtful. For our food selections, we started with the octopus salad which I had before and enjoyed it. The octopus was cut into pieces which I liked. We also had the fried mozzarella (again) but it is so good. For entrees we had the ravioli (had spinach) and my birthday daughter enjoyed it very much. My other daughter had the chick parm with fusilli pasta as the side dish and the chicken was an enormous portion. I had the pasta bolognese with ricotta which I enjoyed very much (added red pepper flakes). The drinks were great and the prosecco was not flat (I read a review here stating theirs was). My daughter's chicken parm which she thought was great and is very particular about her food, she enjoyed it a lot. I had a taste of the chicken and it was divine! All the entrees were large portions so leftovers were taken home. They brought out the flourless chocolate cake and Kelly along with the owner, Drew and some other people including us sang happy birthday to my daughter which was sweet. It was a great time and my daughters loved the food and drinks (prosecco, dirty martini, spicy margarita) as much as I did plus the service was very attentive. I also thought the cost of our evening was reasonable. Kelly has a lot of fun energy, gave us our time so she didn't talk to us much but she did check in a lot to see if we needed anything. Drew checked in on us as well and talked to my daughter as they had something in common they were discussing and that was fine. It's definitely a cute place, very clean and crisp, the decor/art is fun and the bathrooms are nice too. The wall paper is so pretty and welcoming along with all the art. You want to go for the food and drinks and Bar Lucy didn't disappoint us for a special event. Highly recommend Bar Lucy. read more

Amazing Service, food was fantastic and even had natural wine selection (my favorite!) Also such a beautiful interior after such a quick turn around from the Linwood! 10/10 recommend to all looking for a cute, delicious vibe! read more