Excellent service, right size portions and delicious Italian food. Always a great place to go with family or friends. Casually fancy.

If you're having trouble finding street parking keep a look out for free parking lots you can park in. My friend and I were welcomed wonderfully by the staff. We got a table fairly quickly and were greeted by a wonderful waiter Dennis! He was sooo happy and greeted us with a smile! The food was DELICIOUS! The Troffolini was incredible! What made the sauce special was the sweetness of a pair. The baked clams were incredible! Not only did our main dishes look beautiful, but they tasted fantastic! A perfect place to catch up with a friend or go for a date! Thank you to everyone at Americano Pie Bar for their great service! read more

See all

I've been here several times because the food has always been good, which is exactly why this experience was so disappointing. I also want to give credit where it's due. Our server appeared to be new, but she was incredibly patient, friendly, and genuinely trying her best. She handled every question with kindness, and I truly appreciated her attitude throughout the meal. The manager also made a great first impression by greeting us shortly after we were seated and even taking our drink order himself. At that point, I honestly thought we were in for a great experience. Unfortunately, things slowly began to unravel. A few items I ordered to accompany one of our pizzas didn't come out with the pizza itself, so by the time everything finally arrived, the pizza had gone cold. While frustrating, mistakes happen, and I didn't make an issue out of it. The bigger misunderstanding involved another pizza I ordered. I was trying to order a white Grandma pie after seeing a calzone listed with the option to make it on a Grandma crust. When it arrived, it had red sauce. The manager explained that the menu description included "Grandma sauce," which referred to red sauce. I hadn't realized that, and once he explained it, I understood where the misunderstanding came from. To his credit, he immediately offered to remake the pizza, which I appreciated. At that point, I considered the issue resolved. Unfortunately, the conversation didn't end there. While discussing the original pizza, the manager explained that it had ricotta cheese on it. My initial reaction was that I hadn't noticed any ricotta, but after he explained it, I acknowledged that perhaps I had simply missed it. From my perspective, the misunderstanding had been cleared up and the conversation was over. Instead, he looked at me and said: "Maybe you don't know the difference between mozzarella and ricotta cheese." That comment completely changed the experience. There is a big difference between explaining a menu item and making a personal remark toward a customer. By that point, I wasn't arguing. I wasn't asking for anything additional. I had already accepted the explanation and acknowledged that perhaps I had simply missed the ricotta. Rather than leaving it there, the conversation became increasingly confrontational. When I explained that I found the comment disrespectful, instead of trying to de-escalate the situation, the manager continued defending it by insisting that I had argued earlier. At that point, the discussion was no longer about the pizza... it had become an unnecessary debate with a customer who had already accepted the explanation. That was the moment we decided to leave. Mistakes happen. Orders get mixed up. Menu descriptions can create misunderstandings. None of those things determine whether I return to a restaurant. What determines that is how those situations are handled. A manager sets the tone for the entire restaurant. Their responsibility isn't just to resolve problems... it's to make guests feel heard, respected, and welcome, even when there's a misunderstanding. Unfortunately, that's where this experience fell apart. The food has always been good, which is why I've returned in the past. What I'll remember from this visit isn't the pizza or the misunderstanding over the menu. It's being spoken to in a way that felt dismissive and belittling after I had already accepted the explanation. Hospitality isn't measured by how a restaurant performs when everything goes perfectly. It's measured by how it treats people when something doesn't. Unfortunately, that's the lasting impression this visit left with me. read more

Amazing food and service as always. Generous portions and a great value. Heather was a fantastic mixologist! read more

See all

Having been here a few times now all I can say is this place never disappoints! Everything from service to decor is great. Food is delicious every dish that we've tried one better than the next ! This has become one of our go to spots on the restaurant rotation for sure. read more

Americano Pie Bar - Ravioli with prosciutto - Italian Near Me - Islip, New York

Always a great choice. Yes plenty of Italian options on Long Island that are very good. Americano is well deserved to be high on list for consistency, quality, great service and range of great options from their awesome pizzas, chicken, beet salads, pastas, and deserts. read more

Filet Mignon Hero was delicious. The meat was so tender - cooked medium well. Fries were crispy. Pizza was tasty and fresh. Had to swap the spicy soppresatta out for prosciutto since they were out. Still tastes great! Espresso martinis (with baileys) were delicious We celebrated an engagement, and the waitress was kind enough to bring out champagne for the table. Very generous Ambiance was nice and casual with a large bar that is a good distance away from the dining room. Keeps the noise away at a distance read more

See all

Americano Pie Bar was excellent. honest, attentive service and the pear pasta was absolutely delicious. Definitely a spot worth coming back to. read more

I visited Americano Pie Bar with my family on a Sunday afternoon. I had no clue they're such a big brunch spot! I definitely need to come back to divulge in that because the vibes were very celebratory and lively. On to the food!! We started with baked clams, buffalo wings and the beet & goat cheese salad. The baked clams were very delicious and well seasoned. The wings were excellent; lightly breaded, slightly crunchy, and very sauced. The beet & goat cheese salad would be one of the best I've had if it wasn't a little too doused in dressing. So, pro tip, ask for the dressing on the side. As an entree, I had the salmon which was absolutely excellent. From seasoning to cookery, the execution was perfect. My mom had the cod which was cooked perfectly but under-seasoned. Yall, she pulled the mini hot sauce and tajin out her bag to "jazz it up," lol. The risotto was great though. My husband had the sausage and peppers with risotto. He said they were pretty good but the flavor notes fell flat after a few bites. Service was pretty okay. The hostesses were prompt and friendly. Our waitress seemed quite busy so she wasn't as attentive as we would have liked. We didn't bother to order any drinks because we rarely saw her and couldn't be bothered to task her with anything else. In a nutshell, order the wings, salad, and or salmon, and be sure to get cozy because the wait may be a while. read more

I love coming here. The food is always excellent, the service is great, and the cocktail menu is impressive. Whether you're with a small group or a large one, it's always a good time. I tried the pistachio tiramisu for the first time, and it was absolutely amazing! read more

See all

Our hungry group of 6 decended on APB this past Sunday for a Brunch gathering. We had Yelp rezzy and we're seated in a large comfortable banquet for 6. Our exceptional server Brooke was on top of her game handling our orders and refills like the pro that she was!! We shared apps of Wing,calamari and mussels..all good! My main was a salmon lake plate with 2 eggs and Bon had the Brunch Burger...both good. Overall a good experience with exceptional service but with a loud din due to large BD party making conversation difficult. read more

Americano Pie Bar - Exceptional group! - Italian Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

Delicious food! Been here three times and the food always comes out hot, quick, and delicious!!! Service was attentive. Not super upscale but also not casual! Espresso Martinis were absolutely delicious. Would come back! read more

Americano Pie Bar - Italian Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

Amazing food and service! Fresh bread while you wait for your amazing food! Try their new secret menu item "gnocchi bread bowls" delicious!

The food choices and when you order one of the sandwiches on a chibata roll maybe you should cut it for the customer, how do you expect anyone to open their mouth that wide ‍‍. Service was good and thank goodness for dessert read more

Food and drinks were delicious and service was excellent. We were a group of 10 and weren't available to book online which is my only complaint. I had some challenges reaching them by phone to reserve a table, but did eventually. read more

We came in on a Saturday evening, around 5:30/6pm without a reservation. Surprisingly they sat us right away. The restaurant seemed busy but not too loud. It was a nice cozy atmosphere. Our server and the rest of the staff were very friendly. Our entrées were delicious and we liked them so much we would order again. For dessert we got cappuccinos ( delish!), "chocolate cake" (would pass on this) and gelato (delish). Overall, would recommend and visit again. read more

See all

The food is very good a little pricey, but for the place how casual it is with the wine list the drinks, the different pies and food as well worth it. The service is great. The waiters and waitresses who dressed nice nice place for a date night or to go with family to chill and relax great bar area with TVs if you just wanna drink and do appetizers read more

See all

Everything we ordered was a 10/10 -- from the perfectly baked French onion soup, to the crispy fried calamari, and the flavorful capellini cakes. We also had the Caesar salad (always a favorite), and it did not disappoint. The food is consistently incredible every single time we come here. Definitely one of our go-to spots -- and we'll absolutely keep coming back! read more

I received a gift card for this restaurant so when I was in the area I decided to stop by with my mother and kids. I was definitely surprised at the ambiance, the restaurant is a little more formal than what I was expecting. Beautiful and inviting however I felt we were dressed a bit too casual. We were greeted with a smile and sat at a booth. We ordered 2 pizzas, the margherita and another with the upgrade of grandma bread and vodka sauce. I also ordered zoodles with chicken. They have several gluten free options. We ordered iced coffees that were delivered promptly and were delicious! The food was delivered in a timely fashion and everything was great until my daughter discovered pancetta in the pizza, it was not mentioned at all in the menu. Our server was kind and had a new one made for us, it took longer than expected so we had her pack it to go. Overall the experience was great, they seemed to get very busy and we had to wait longer than expected but overall I would go back. read more

Americano Pie Bar - Manu and table - Italian Near Me - Islip, New York

I went to Americano tonight with a group of 6 people and this was hands down the best service we ever received. The manager Victoria, took care of us from the second we walked into until the check to make sure everything was going smoothly. She was extremely professional and personal to our group. It was a Monday night and the restaurant was busy! That just shows you how good this place is. From the apps to the entree everything was 12/10. The pizza was crisp yet tastey, the baked clams had the perfect balance and lemon we couldn't stop dipping our bread in the sauce! The linguini and clam sauce was one of the best I've tried. We were celebrating a birthday and Victoria made sure to make it extra special for us. I will definitely be returning. read more

Service is always top tier. Loveeeee coming for their brunch. They always take care of us. Going back again soon!! Love their pepperoni pizza ultimate fav read more

The food is consistently amazing. The service is always spotty. This place is never ran the right way. Always have a reservation for 2 in place and sometimes I have to wait 30 minutes because the hosts can't do their job. DONT COME HERE ON WEEKENDS YOU WILL BE DISAPPOINTED read more

used to be wayyyy better. service was bad went here on valentine's day. everything took a long time and they gave us the worst table next to where they wheel the dirty dishes in even though we had a reservation. we asked nicely to move to a table vacant nearby and they took a long time with that and seemed upset. the clams oreganatta was really dry and breadcrumbs burnt. tiny clams for our app and everything else was tasty but the service and atmosphere isn't the same. girls in the bathroom even said 'the drinks are great food is great, but i'm sorry the service is terrible now. this place used to be more upscale what happened' read more

The food is really good here. It's a shame we live about an hour away. Here are some pics. Not going to waste your time talking about it, it's good I promise. The staff is nice and attentive. Will definitely be back. read more

See all

I only tried the pizza, it was delicious. Definitely need to return to try their dishes. They have a variety of types of pizza.

Food was good and service was quick. They wheee very accommodating when we asked to split the bill. Would recommend for just 2 people or a bigger group. read more

On top of the great service and quick food delivery, the quality of the food was really good. The calamari was cooked to perfection and the bread was deliciously fresh. I really loved the bread. We got full quick. Thete was no need to order more food Overall, it was a fantastic dining experience that left us satisfied and impressed. read more

Americano Pie Bar - Calamari - Italian Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

You have to try the Chicken Caesar Piadina. It's basically their amazing pizza dough grilled and folded like a wrap, sprinkled with mozzarella, chicken cutlets, and this super fresh, chopped homemade Caesar salad. It's like a pizza and a salad had a delicious love child! I know this sounds crazy but you would think it would be so heavy but with the salad it made it actually lighter than you would think. SO good! read more

Delicious food and a wonderful staff with an upscale vibe. I will certainly be back.

The service and food was outstanding. The entire establishment, including the restroom was spotless. Highly recommend. read more

Americano Pie Bar - Beautiful decor - Italian Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

Great food. Great Service! The restaurant was busy and lively! I would recommend this restaurant!

Party of 8 ... service was just ok took awhile to get waiter to table to take order For drinks, apps and main meal. Plates menus left on table no room for apps and no one bothered to attend to it. Took a while to get drinks after we ordered. fried calamari was soggy/chewy. Main meals fish special was way too salty and had to be returned. Someone had a heavy hand on the salt shaker because it wasn't just the fish. Chicken franchise was also. We celebrated a 21st Birthday and decided not to stay for any desserts we took our business elsewhere. We have been here many times before but this was a huge disappointment. Oh also to mention the waiter finally came and asked how everything was and I responded by saying it's just ok! No question on what and why was it just ok... lol read more

Great food, lots of options. Price is right. Service and ambiance, excellent. Highly recommend.

Food was delicious, service was excellent as well! Everything was hot and delicious, no complaints at all. We did the bottomless brunch for 2 hours and you can mix and match beer, mimosa, and blood Mary's! The atmosphere was bright and fun as well! read more

See all

Really enjoyed my meal here. Very pretty place. Dim lights, awesome decor. Makes for a perfect place to celebrate a special event or for a date night. Love the menu. They have everything from tacos to pizza. We were greeted by an incredible bread basket upon being seated, excellent service throughout our meal and everyone loved what they ordered. I really enjoyed my big mac pizza and I also tried the upside down pizza as well which was also great. Will definitely be back! read more

Americano Pie Bar - Big mac pizza - Italian Near Me - Islip, New York

Great food, great atmosphere and our server Dennis was very accommodating and attentive.

Food was DELICIOUS! The food came out quick and we could tell it had just been made. The service was great, friendly staff.

Everything we ordered was fresh and delicious! The chicken. The steak. The salads and the wine were wonderful. The service equally wonderful. My single complaint is the lighting. It was super bright. White stark lighting that is reminiscent of a Home Depot parking lot. Certainly not a deal breaker. But harsh and something to consider. read more

We've passed this place so many times and have been meaning to try it. We ended up doing a take out order which was packed very well. We ordered baked clams (good dipping sauce), margarita pizza, penne firenza and penne pollo caprese. Everything was delicious! Can't wait to try it in person! read more

See all

Service was not great. they had 3 tables to be cleaned while my party and another one waited. And only go for brunch if its to drink. food was horrible for brunch. we will not return. read more