Cancel

Open app

Search

Magnolias

4.6 (28 reviews)
Closed • 4:00 pm - 11:00 PM
Updated 1 month ago

Order Magnolias Takeout or Delivery

Magnolias Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Magnolias

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Anthony M.

The live music back area and back bar were fantastic. The food was really good and the service was top tier. We really enjoyed the happy hour and that 20% off starters is awesome! I couldn't help myself so I had to get that lobster Cesar wrap and it did not disappoint.

Anna H.

I couldn't find a phone number for Magnolias, so I made a lunch reservation via OpenTable last week and noted my food allergies. The drive from Queens to Bay Shore took about an hour. A woman walking her dog said the area had metered parking only and suggested we download the ParkMobile app. When we walked in for our reservation, the server greeted us right away. Drink Nespresso Food *sharing is caring* Crispy Fried Olives: Even with the black garlic aioli, the olives were still way too salty. Black Pepper Bourbon BBQ Wings: Mmm, finger-licking goodness! Magnolia Clams Oreganata: Just one bite of the baked clams hit all the flavors on my palate. Chili Crisp Brussels Fried Rice: The server told me the kitchen modified the dish without coconut for my allergy. The room temperature was freezing like outside, and our food got cold. The bill showed separate totals for card and cash. We paid cash.

Cynthia Z.

We came here this Friday for lunch, and the ambiance is upscale, though a bit empty. We were literally the only ones dining at the tables, while everyone who arrived later stayed at the bar. The food was delicious however a bit cold due to the room temperature. ORDERED: Nespresso - I was bummed that they don't have any caffeine option other than the "plastic" Nespresso. Crispy Fried Olives - I love the plating. It's very creative. It comes with a side of black garlic aioli. Although the olives are a bit salty, I found the salt to be somewhat masked when eat with the black garlic aioli. Black Pepper Bourbon BBQ Wings - the sauce was delicious but the wings tasted a bit hard.. prob deep fried before being cooked with the black pepper bourbon bbq sauce. Magnolia Clams Oreganata - this is prob one of my favorite. It was delicious and on point. Chili Crisp Brussels Fried Rice - it was filling and tasty. The bill offered both credit card and cash options. We opted for cash since it was cheaper. They have parking outside but they were all paid parking. I used the ParkMobile app but it only allows you 15 minutes for each session. I literally have to reload every 15 minutes.

Cocktail menu
Steve R.

First visit to this fairly new restaurant. Was blown away by the food and the cocktails. We sat at the bar and were very well taken care of. They started us off with complementary pineapple, express cocktails. I'm not a Tequilla fan but this drink was outstanding. I ordered an old fashioned which was made perfectly. To start I got the lamb chops chop they were also tops, for main I went with the bourbon glazed wings. Outstanding ! My girlfriend went with the flank steak which was cooked perfectly. I think o going a new fave !! This restaurant has a nice city vibe to it. Drinks are made to perfection and the food was tops. I can't wait to return. A+++++++++

Pineapple Express
Catherine B.

Elevated cocktails and unique dishes in a warm cozy atmosphere. Outstanding service with shout outs to Connor, Charlie & Joey!

Welcome drinks, the girlies
Amneris M.

Cute spot! Great service! The food was ample and delicious. The drinks were fabulous! The fries stole the show! Chip like, but still soft inside.

Girlie Girl Martini
Marissa S.

This place opened like two weeks ago and it's already popping in there. I'm genuinely so happy for them. First off, the ambiance is a 10/10. The wallpaper alone is such a vibe. I've been twice now. The first time was on a Thursday around 6, and it wasn't crowded yet, but it definitely picked up by the time we left. The second time, which was yesterday, I went at 7 and it was packed. Highly recommend making reservations during peak hours. Now for the -1 star: * The wing sauce was homemade (huge plus), but the wings themselves weren't super crispy. To be fair, I'm a tough critic when it comes to wings. * Both times I went, the same guy was the only waiter for the entire restaurant. He was handling everything ...drinks, food from the kitchen, to-go containers, bussing tables, the works. He was fantastic, but that's just way too much for one person. Please, hire help. Food-wise, everything else was great. I got the fried rice dish the first time - absolutely delicious. The second time I tried the burger, which came with homemade ruffled potato slices. The portions are huge, too. Despite the minor stuff, I'll 10000% be going back.

Martinis
Barbara M.

Such an amazing time at Magnolias! The staff were all very friendly and helpful with the menu. Martinis and apps were all delicious! Very thoughtful menu. We were already saying how excited we were to come back before we even left!

Crispy fried olives
Christina H.

Such a fun and unique spot! The martinis were hands down the best I've ever had, made with care, and you can taste the difference. The crispy fried olives were the perfect bar snack, especially if you just want a small bite with your drink. I tried the lamb chops, which come as a trio, and they were perfectly paired with kimchi that had just the right amount of kick, which I loved. The rice was flavorful and came in a generous portion, enough to enjoy again later. Service was impeccable. I sat at the bar, and the staff made sure everything was spot on. I'll definitely be back, there's still so much more on the menu I can't wait to try!

One side of Drink Menu
Jenna P.

Very excited to welcome this Martini Bar to the area! It's clear that a lot of thought and artistry went into the menu and drink selections. Beautiful addition to Bay Shore's Main Street!

Cocktails
Jason T.

Booked a dinner for four on New Year's Eve as they shared an interesting Prix Fix menu for that night. The staff was beyond friendly and offered recommendations when necessary. The restaurant is classy and intimate. There are booths and tables, we had a nice corner seat. We started off with a round of drinks and all were enjoyed. The Point Set Match was a table favorite. We all decided to go with the Prix Fix option as none of us had been there before and it was a great way to try a little of everything. Based on a conversation about wings with the staff, we were also convinced to try the Black Pepper Bourbon BBQ and Buffalo wings. We were not disappointed! I'm not going to list everyone's dinner items but the Ceasar salad got rave reviews, flat Iron steak was phenomenal and the seared tuna was finished before anyone else even started with their meal. It was a great first experience and we are excited for more. I know one person in our party planned to go back for wings on his lunch break the same week. Definitely try this place out.

Pineapple Express is amazing!

They give you a welcome drink!! Best service in Bay Shore! Amazing food and drinks! We had A5 Wagyu, crab cakes, and then scallop risotto for the main.

Manhattan

See all

26 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 2
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

25 days ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Anna H.
96
1036
14713

9 months ago

Helpful 25
Thanks 8
Love this 19
Oh no 2

9 months ago

Helpful 5
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Marissa S.
215
14
16

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 1

8 months ago

Helpful 4
Thanks 2
Love this 0
Oh no 2

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of JM K.
1
15
2

10 months ago

Food was on point. Great entree pricing along with an excellent selection of cocktails.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of J P.
0
1
0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Babette H.
67
14
105

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Magnolias

You might also consider

Bayberry - Thoughtfully crafted, beautifully poured.

Bayberry

4.0(144 reviews)
1.8 mi
Full bar
Takes reservations

Absolutely loved Bayberry! A perfect brunch spot!…read more What a gem! We stopped at Bayberry for brunch between our boys' soccer games, and it was absolutely perfect! The restaurant is beautiful, warm, and inviting, with such a lovely atmosphere. It's located in a charming downtown area filled with restaurants and shopping, but Bayberry was exactly what we were looking for. I ordered the lemon blueberry Dutch baby, and oh my goodness, it was AMAZING! Beautifully presented and absolutely delicious. My husband enjoyed the chicken club, while our boys ordered chicken tenders from the kids' menu. Speaking of the kids' menu, how adorable is this?! It was presented as a sail on a little wooden sailboat! Such a thoughtful and creative touch. The kids' portions were just right, and the prices were very reasonable, especially considering the quality of the food and the overall experience. The staff was friendly and welcoming, the restaurant was beautifully maintained, and even the bathrooms were gorgeous! Another plus was the ample street parking, which made our visit that much easier. Bayberry checked all the boxes for us: delicious food, beautiful ambiance, great service, and a family-friendly experience without sacrificing a more elevated dining atmosphere. Would absolutely recommend and happily return!

I've been meaning to try Bayberry for a while & I saw a post about their happy hour so decided to…read moregive it a try. Happy hour at the bar is from 12-7pm with the bar bites available after 4pm. The place is very nicely decorated and exudes an upscale but unpretentious vibe. I ordered a glass of the pinot noir which was tasty and at $6 a nice bargain. I got the chickpea fries and was surprised by the texture. It was almost custard like with a slight chickpea flavor in a very light breading. Served with the harissa aioli it made for a nice app. After a while I decided to try the Filet mignon sliders, which I ordered medium rare, the bartender said they don't usually take a temp on those but he'd note it. The meat is sliced very thin but was tender and still had a bit of red. The arugula gave it a nice peppery bite. My only critic is the slider roll was very cottony, but the overall taste was very good. I'll definitely be back and will try something off the regular menu.

Photos
Bayberry - Spicy Tuna Bomb: Crispy spicy tuna roll, topped with spicy tuna, avocado, jalapeño, and sriracha.

Spicy Tuna Bomb: Crispy spicy tuna roll, topped with spicy tuna, avocado, jalapeño, and sriracha.

Bayberry - Some nights just call for the right spot. Consider this yours!

Some nights just call for the right spot. Consider this yours!

Bayberry - Balanced, bold, and made with intention.

See all

Balanced, bold, and made with intention.

Artemis Speakeasy - Lounge area

Artemis Speakeasy

4.5(59 reviews)
9.5 mi
•$$

Better late than never with this backdated review--life has just been lifing!…read moreI finally made it to Artemis on July 22nd after fiending to go since January. There's actually a hilarious story behind why I went. I was originally supposed to have a date that night, but let's be real: you'd think a 61-year-old man would know better than to take a 47-year-old woman to Dave & Buster's. I canceled the night before, dolled myself up the day of, and decided to take myself out instead. Best decision ever. The joint is dimly lit. But your eyes wind up adjusting. It's got a great vibe. Definitely excellent for a date night. The bartenders here are absolute rockstars. I started with a Painkiller. Even though it's no longer on the menu, they whipped it up for me anyway--and hey, it definitely relieved my pain, lol! Next, I tried a Corpse Reviver just because it had absinthe in it. It was different, but I really enjoyed it. Naturally, I had to finish with my signature drink, a Cosmopolitan, because I am the Black Carrie Bradshaw of Long Island. And it did not disappoint. The eats: I got the charcuterie board--fancy and bougie, just like me--and wrapped up the night with the brownie à la mode for dessert. Drowning my troubles in sweets is a must when the Long Island dating pool is an absolute wasteland, lmao. Did I want to spend my night around teenagers, kids, and skee-ball? HELL NO! I wanted a grown-and-sexy speakeasy vibe, and Artemis delivered. 5/5 stars--would 100% recommend!

I've been to Artemis a few of times now, and I really love this place. The atmosphere is probably…read moremy favorite part. It's got that intimate, speakeasy vibe that makes it feel a little different from your typical bar. The cocktails are creative, unique, and really well made. It's fun trying something new each time. My only minor complaint is that the menu can be a little difficult to read, especially in the dim lighting. Other than that, it's a fantastic spot for cocktails and a night out. I'll definitely be back!

Photos
Artemis Speakeasy - South Bay Sazerac. Yum.

South Bay Sazerac. Yum.

Artemis Speakeasy - Lounge

Lounge

Artemis Speakeasy - Inside

See all

Inside

Bar Lucy

Bar Lucy

4.4(35 reviews)
0.2 mi

My sister-in-law invited us to dinner at Bar Lucy to celebrate my brother's birthday. Although I've…read moredriven past it often and was intrigued by the yellow neon sign, it would slip my mind when choosing a place to dine. I'm so glad I've finally had a chance to try it. We started with three appetizers to share: the golden meatballs, the baked clams and the fried artichokes. All three were absolutely delicious. I chose ricotta cavatelli bolognese as my entree.It was rich and meaty and silky - something I'd definitely order again. I also tried my sister's autumn pizette, one of the specials. Thin crisp crust, thinly sliced squas, sausage, cheese and a drizzle of fig glaze. A perfectly composed fall dish. Everyone else enjoyed their meals (spaghetti & meatballs, veal parm, chicken française, and spaghetti with seafood.) We shared two desserts - tiramisu was just as I like it, moist but not wet with all the flavors melding into something greater than their individual parts. The tricolor cake was a slice of rainbow cookie, dense and decadent. Our server Michaela was charming and efficient. The atmosphere was sophisticated yet relaxed. Overall, a five star experience.

I was walking my dog down Main Street in Bay Shore and decided to stop for dinner. I grabbed a seat…read moreoutside with the dog, and about 20 minutes later a waitress came over. She was friendly, brought the menus, and got our drinks started. They also have daily specials throughout the week. I ordered the Meatball Monday spaghetti special, which came with garlic bread and a side salad for one price. To finish the meal, I had the tiramisu. The spaghetti was flavorful, and the tiramisu was light, fluffy, and a great way to end the meal. The service was good, the food was satisfying, and I'd definitely recommend checking this place out if you're in the area.

Photos
Bar Lucy - Interior

Interior

Bar Lucy
Bar Lucy

See all

Americano Pie Bar - Truffolini

Americano Pie Bar

4.1(496 reviews)
1.8 mi
•$$

Hello to all It's A Must A Must Visit from start to finish…read moreit's such a great setting . The Environment is so Energetic it's a workforce of Friendship there like Family. From Lorenzo the owner chef to Scott the ultimate Covers all the Bases . Then you Have the ultimate Foundation Ashley Victoria Talia Leonardo and everyone to many to name . lets move on to the food excellent the side Secret when they bring the bread to the table well you will know what I'm talking about trust me . Let's move on to Drink Spirits Excellent just watch the Bartenders in action then you have desserts . Ooops The Appetizers incredible. Americana is Ultimate Down time put your phones on mute challenge yourself actually leave phone in car . Americana Go once and you will be a repeat OFFENDER in the best way . Bon Appetite .

I had a wonderful experience at Americano's Pie Bar in Islip. From the moment we arrived, the…read moreatmosphere felt welcoming and comfortable, creating an easygoing setting for the meal. The staff were friendly, attentive, and professional, checking in without being intrusive and helping the experience feel smooth from start to finish. The food was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. Each dish arrived looking carefully prepared, with generous portions that made the meal feel well worth the price. The combination of appealing presentation, satisfying flavors, and substantial servings made the meal especially enjoyable. What stood out most was the balance between good food and excellent service. Scott, the manager, and Anthony, our waiter, made everything memorable. Everything came out in a timely manner, and the staff made us feel genuinely welcome. It was the kind of dining experience where we could settle in, enjoy each bite, and leave feeling satisfied rather than rushed. Overall, I would definitely recommend Americano's Pie Bar in Islip to anyone looking for a delicious meal, friendly service, and a pleasant dining experience. I look forward to coming back again. The short rib rigatoni and the prosciutto cappellacci were top-notch.

Photos
Americano Pie Bar - Interior.

Interior.

Americano Pie Bar - Ravioli

Ravioli

Americano Pie Bar - Beautiful decor

See all

Beautiful decor

Roadtrip Bayshore - Plantain Salad

Roadtrip Bayshore

4.5(165 reviews)
0.1 mi

We've been coming to Roadtrip in Bay Shore for a while now and it never disappoints. Every dish is…read moreinspired by a different state, which makes the menu so much fun to explore. We've been here for brunch and dinner, and everything is always delicious. Some of our favorites: the Texas street corn dip, maple chipotle wings, Napa Valley goat cheese bites, and the Bayou Creole seafood squid ink pasta (my kids call it the black pasta and they're obsessed). The Scottsdale seared mahi-mahi and Cowboy Bloom lavender chicken were amazing too. And don't skip the Hawaiian lava cake. The glitter mocktails were such a fun touch for the kids. It's a great family friendly spot with something for everyone. Service was amazing! We'll definitely be back.

As someone who has traveled to all 50 states, I couldn't resist checking out Roadtrip Bayshore. The…read moreconcept is fantastic: the menu changes regularly to highlight a different state, and during my visit it was Georgia week. The food was outstanding from start to finish. The Vidalia onion soup was honestly the best onion soup I've ever had, and I'm a huge onion soup fan. The crab cake bites were among the best crab cakes I've had anywhere, which is saying a lot because I've spent years searching for great crab cakes. I also loved the maple bacon mac and cheese, which struck a perfect balance between sweet and savory. My daughter enjoyed the Georgia wings and sweet potato fries with a marshmallow dipping sauce. Everything was packed with flavor. The cocktails were equally impressive. I had the Georgia-themed Old Fashioned, while my daughter tried the Guy Fieri-inspired Georgia margarita. Both were creative, well-balanced, and memorable. As a mobility disabled person, accessibility is always important to me, and Roadtrip did very well. There is plenty of parking behind the restaurant with an accessible route to the entrance. Inside, the aisles are wide, the seating is flexible with movable chairs, and the restroom is fully accessible. The only thing keeping it from a perfect accessibility score is the lack of automatic doors. Food: 11/10 Cocktails: 10/10 Accessibility: 9/10 Roadtrip Bayshore earns my highest recommendation. Great food, great drinks, a fun and unique concept, and accessibility done right.

Photos
Roadtrip Bayshore
Roadtrip Bayshore - Rust Belt Pierogies - Ohio Menu

Rust Belt Pierogies - Ohio Menu

Roadtrip Bayshore

See all

Alibi Speakeasy & Lounge - Cool!

Alibi Speakeasy & Lounge

3.9(60 reviews)
10.5 mi
•$$

We came here for the grinch pop up. It's a cozy lounge so tickets are limited per night. Grinch…read moreperforms a few songs and then allows for picture taking afterward. The show was short but a lot of fun! The Grinch played the character perfectly and interacted with the crowd. Drinks and bites are optional. I got the sugar cookie shots they were okay. I also got the Grinch has a heart because I'm a tequila girl but I wasn't a fan of this one. The sliders however were great.

I miss Main Street so much. And this is one of the reasons why. The Alibi wasn't a thing when I…read morelived here, but I'm glad I'm able to still head to this area and partake in these experiences. Alibi is currently running a Harry Potter pop up, and if you know anything about me, you will know I am a HUGE fan. The Alibi was decorated beautifully and there were two really cute Photo Ops by "Platform 9 3/4" and the Wand Shop. Come here for the drinks! The Hufflepuff was bourbon forward and reminded me of an Old Fashioned which further confirmed that is truly my house. It also came with an edible golden snitch. The server pointed it out before I gave them what I thought to be decor. I popped the chocolate golden snitch in my mouth after being directed to take the wrapping off first. We then did butterbeer shots and I can't even begin to tell you how delish they were...dangerously delicious. Food was had and it wasn't anything to write about but I'll try. Queso dip is made in house, which I respect. Loaded potato wontons were a great idea and were probably the best things on the table. You can't go wrong with pretzel nuggets. Chocolate cake is never a bad idea. I ended my visit with a chocolate frog drink. Very similar to an espresso martini. You know how hot they are right now. It came with a an actual chocolate frog which was nice. Finally one of the staff members came over to help us play Bertie Botts and we all picked a jellybean. I got lemon. Some of us got soap and warwax. So fun! It was so good, we are going to try to snag another rez for trivia. Reservations are for 90 minute seatings. You pay $15 for a ticket but you get a souvenir cup with your ticket. Not mad about this because the cup is actually decent and will be used. Their next pop up will be "Slime Time". Slime is not my thing but maybe you'll see me at the other pop ups.

Photos
Alibi Speakeasy & Lounge - Bar

Bar

Alibi Speakeasy & Lounge - Wand shop in Diagon Alley

Wand shop in Diagon Alley

Alibi Speakeasy & Lounge

See all

The State Room

The State Room

4.6(61 reviews)
12.4 mi

Not sure if my review should land here, but I need to place it somewhere. This is specifically for…read moreThe Loft area, which is next to The State Room and is the event space for the business. Gone are the days of the Brickhouse brewery. Now you have a super classy joint that resides right in Patchogue. A place that, I'm reminded by my husband every time we drive through, use to not be so classy. My sister requested that we have her baby shower here because she was such a fan of the food. And she was right. The food is fresh and delicious and featured in a very well thought out menu. Julien was a pleasure to work with during the preparations. Allowing access to the space during not busy times to help us plan our decorations. Day of it was all hands on deck. Julien, Anna and our amazing bartender with the handlebar mustache exceeded our expectations. The food was incredible. My sister had the best time and that's all that matters. And I have the State Room to thank for it. Posting few pics of the rooms before the guests arrives so you have an idea of the space :)

The state room is better than shands because I go there for drinks, and not the overhyped food…read more Their cocktail program and bar staff are superior to everything in the area. Their cocktail program drinks are out of this world and special requests are nailed every time. Truly wonderful in that regard and only that regard.

Photos
The State Room
The State Room - Sourdough Malfadine - small portion but delicious

Sourdough Malfadine - small portion but delicious

The State Room

See all

Magnolias - tapasmallplates - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...