Pecado was very good! It was our first time there and we loved it. They have a really nice restaurant, as well as a really cool bar. I would also go there just to grab drinks because the vibe in there is dope. They start your table out with warm tortilla chips and a spicy salsa. It'd definitely had a kick to it (which we liked) but might be too much for some with a low tolerance. We ordered the guacamole as our app, and we asked for it medium. They offer regular / medium / spicy. The guacamole was very good, and it was a good portion. For dinner, I had the steak quesadilla which was 5/5 stars, literally the best steak quesadilla I have ever had. It's was so good, and the waitress offered 2 different sauces, cilantro crème & chipotle mayo. Both of them were delicious and I would advise to get these with your quesadilla. My fiancé had the shrimp tacos, they were 3/5. While they weren't bad, they just weren't great. She wound up asking for a piece of my quesadilla and I took one of her 3 tacos. Something they don't offer is allowing you to choose different types of tacos in your order. They come in orders of 3, so you have to order 3 shrimp tacos and was not able to make one of them steak or chicken etc. It is something they should consider, it's nice to have the option of more than one main "meat". read more

See all

10/10 HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS PLACE!! Food is amazing, the service is always good. The place alone is beautiful and the outside is also nice but only in the summer lol. I recently moved to Bay Shore and this is my favorite place to come too!! read more

See all

My friend and I went here to celebrate a late Birthday, the service was excellent, a little too much at times as the waiter was constantly checking on us but I guess better then not checking on us. The food was tasty, I had chicken tacos and my friend had chicken enchiladas. We initially ordered a flavored margarita but tasted too much like orange juice, the bartender offered a remake and we ordered a classic lime margarita, it was much better. Everything was fine but it was pricey, drinks are $15 each. The bill for the 2 of us was about $130, no appetizers. We did order churros and they were delicious. Overall a good experience. read more

Pecado Mexican - Mexican Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Came here for Cinco de Mayo celebrations with friends. First off, this place is beautifully decorated- it's so much bigger than it looks from outside. I ordered the coconut martini- it was ok- super strong- I drank half & had a good buzz. We ordered guac & chips - the guac was so good-super fresh. I ordered Enchilada Suizas which was good too. They had a DJ who played great music & created a fun vibe. Prices were comparable to other restaurants in the area. There's 2hr metered parking on the street, but If you park a few blocks down, there are no meters, and you can walk off some calories on the way back. It was a good time! read more

See all

5/5 stars! Today I dined there with my close friends our host Brianna was absolutely fantastic! From the moment we walked in, she greeted us with a warm smile and sat us right down. Her kindness set the tone for a wonderful dining experience at Pecado Mexican . The host (Brianna) and server (April) attention to detail and genuine enthusiasm made us feel valued and appreciated. We can't wait to come back and experience their exceptional service again read more

Love Pecado! Food, service, drinks and ambiance are amazing! Their barria taco are to die for! I wish they allowed to mix and match tacos. The make delicious guacamole too! read more

See all

Looking for a fun date or friend gathering spot in Long Island? Love Mexican food? I highly recommend Pecado located in Bayshore. Food and drinks was great! Ambience is nice. Service was good and staff was very welcoming and kind. If you love sweets like me, definitely order their Churros. Warm and crispy freshly made Churros paired with vanilla ice cream and chocolate ganache is a dream made in heaven for the sweet toothed. I'll definitely be coming back and trying other dessert options on their menu. The Queso Fundido and Yuca Fritos are my cousin's favorites. Queso Fundido- melted cheese mixed with chicken bits, topped with bacon and parsley with tortilla on the side. Yuca Fritos are fries made from Cassava Root. I really liked the sauce that came with it. My reservation was at 8:45 and they were still packed and busy. Overall, it was such a great experience. Definitely try this place out!! read more

See all

I came here with a few friends for brunch, the food was delicious and the drinks were also very good. Carolina was our server and she was very pleasant. The service was great. I would definitely return for the food and service. I enjoyed the music as well. The restaurant was very authentic Mexican. Definitely recommend. read more

Pecado Mexican - Juevos rancheros - Mexican Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Omg! Hands down one of the best Mexican restaurants on Long Island! The food is so delicious! The flavors...oh my! We had the wings (sweet style). Delish! The crema with them is outstanding. The salmon was cooked to perfection. Even the sautéed spinach was amazing!! The enchiladas were some of the best that my husband has had since he lived in AZ. For dessert, get the Churros. They are to die for! Ask for Eduardo to be your waiter. Very personable and friendly. We will definitely be back! read more

Pecado Mexican - Churros - Mexican Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

This place did not disappoint. Between the food and the tequila and service. We will most certainly return many a times. Decor, music and cleanliness, very good! Eric was kind, attentive and informative. I rarely give 5 stars, this place definitely deserves it! read more

Pecado Mexican - Mexican Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Open air restaurant which was very nice, they accommodated us without a reservation on a busy Friday night which was also appreciated since my husband and I had an impromptu date night. I was waiting to try this place and the food didn't disappoint. The shrimp ceviche was delicious, my husband had the queso fundido which was also tasty. I had the mahi mahi tacos and he had the carne asada tacos also very very good and perfectly seasoned. The drinks were great and our waiter was prompt and attentive. read more

See all

Enjoyed dinner here !! I would definitely recommend this spot. The decor is immaculate and beautiful. Drinks - loved my margarita and BFs mezcal cocktail.. but the Paloma was weak. There is also only one bartender so drinks take forever. Food- we loved everything we ordered. We had the Barbacoa and carne asada tacos. Both were very good. Although, if you don't like raw tomatoes the carne tacos are smothered in pico. The churros were honestly the highlight ... they were perfection. Don't skip them. Service - we were seated right away with reservations and our server, Danielle , was working hard. How were she was the only server I saw. Between that and the one bartender .. just didn't make sense. Overall I recommend.. but they need more staff. read more

Pecado Mexican - Mexican Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Nice New Mexican place in Bay Shore. Went there on a Friday night and had reservations, but looked like the walk ins had a wait. So make sure you call or book ahead. Decor is nice, new and clean. They have a big glass room for the tequila, like a wine cellar, which looks cool but eats up a lot of space. Comp chips and salsa is a solid start and should be expected. First drink (CAP FOR SANCHO) didn't appear to have anything spicy in the listed ingredients, but had a serious bite. Make sure to ask your servers; they will give you the skinny on anything. But that was an unwelcome surprise. Guacamole was fresh and spicy; just wish it was made table-side (although they don't really have the space for it). My wife said it was one of the best she's ever had, and she is VERY particular haha. Queso fundido was a hit, cheesy deliciousness. The enchiladas mole presentation was nice, and it was yummy but didn't knock my socks off. Wife enjoyed the COCHINITA PIBIL. They upcharged to add some taco shells which was understandable but also didn't leave me feeling valued. I like when new spots do little things like include something to make you want to come back. Personal preference - not expected. Specials looked cool that I saw at other tables, like a whole red snapper. Dessert list was underwhelming but true to the Mexican theme. They could use a chocolate item to balance it out. Had the churros and they were really good, filled with dulce de leche. Churros can be really hit or miss, sometimes stale or underwhelming, but these were fresh and soft. One strike against them was the bus boys were constantly trying to bus our table and move us along. Once or twice is understandable. But it was more frequent and became annoying and a fixture of the experience at the restaurant. All in all it's definitely worth a try. Elevated Mexican. Not sure I'd put it on Verde's level, but left content with the choice. It was my birthday, and I chose this place because it was on my radar as one I really wanted to try. It would've really elevated the experience if they took note of that and offered/comped anything (besides putting a candle on a churro). Probably would've encouraged me to return, and had a lasting impression. read more

See all

Surprised to be one of the first customers to try this new spot on its opening night. It's on one of the more quiet area of Bay Shore's Main Street - which is nice since it's easier to find parking. They also will be opening their back patio which will be accessible from the back lot in September. The restaurant has a very clean and simple style, with a all-glass wine room that will sure to be stocked with a wide selection. The "modern" decor and LCD imaging/TVs that display photos of models and not streaming - which is a nice departure from the typical restaurants. The Janna On My Own cocktail was delightful - with a smokiness and spice that blended perfectly together. We ordered the shrimp ceviche that had beautiful chunks of avocado and the perfect blend of fresh herbs and citrus. We also ordered the Mahi Mahi entree that was paired with roasted sweet potato and guacamole. My only critique was the guac could've been saltier. The owner, Ian, came to introduce himself which I was happy to see. Chef Carolina also came to see how our meal was - and with fully cleared plates - we were gracious with our compliments. They treated us to a selection of their homemade deserts - the Tres Leches & flan. Those were also delightfully sweet and decadent. We are looking forward to watching this place become a staple in the neighborhood. Good start to a bright and long future ! read more

See all

Amazing service Eric was wonderful! The food was delicious, it was packed and we didn't have a reservation, but luckily we were seated for a table for two and I cannot say enough good things about this place. outstanding. read more

Pecado Mexican - I can't even remember what I ate as I gobbled it up before I remembered to take a photo ,it was so yummy! - Mexican Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

My husband and I went to check this new Mexican restaurant on Bay Shore. The place is very nice and the service was great. The manager was checking our table and explaining the dishes during our dinner. That was nice of him. My favorites were the avocado fries, sweet plantains, and enchilada vegetariana. If you go now, ask for the seasonal pumpkin flan dessert, is amazing. read more

See all

The prices here are absolutely ridiculous! I went there with a large group (about 8 of us) and when we saw the bill, we literally choked What we ordered: - 2 VIRGIN mojitos (mind you this is club soda, fresh limes, fresh mint and simple syrup). They were $12 each! Are we serious? - about 5 people ordered regular margaritas and one person ordered a virgin margarita (note some people did not drink and some people had 2 drinks) - 2 orders of guacamole for the table - everyone ordered 1 thing for their meal. I had a salad for over $20 (which was delicious btw and the literal only reason I would even consider going back) and everyone else ordered a mix of tacos, enchiladas, etc coming in at around $25 a pop or more. - a few desserts to share Our bill was over $700. It was absolutely insane. Do I think the food was good? I can speak for my salad when I say yes, but as far as everyone else at the table, their portions were small and it was verbalized that it wasn't anything special...especially for the price. The service was fine and the ambiance was cute. Overall, if I wanted this type of cuisine I would go to verde ‍ I probably won't be back here unless I have a desire to drain my bank account to still leave hungry. read more

We just had a dinner at Pecado for the first time and WOW! We sat at the bar. The BEST red sangria I've ever had! Chips and salsa- YUM! Chicken quesadilla- perfection. I had the salmon tropical- was exactly what I'd hope it would be and my husband got the carne asade fajitas - delicious! We did a side of plantains- so good. We had Victor as our bartender/ waiter and he was so charming and made us laugh. Great customer service. Definitely will return and will bring some friends next time! read more

See all

Came here soon after attending a Yelp Elite tasting event and was just as pleased! I started with a passion fruit margarita that was well balanced and refreshing. Highly recommend!! After, we ordered the corn elote to share as an app, and it was very flavorful and unique. We actually decided to save some for our main dish. For our entree, we shared La Parrillada. It's a skillet that features a shareable combination of meats, shrimp, and vegetables, and comes with a side of rice and tortillas. We were in Heaven! The seasoning and execution of the dish was flawless. We were stuffed afterwards, but somehow, one can always make room for dessert. We ordered the churros to seal the deal and boyyyy was it sealed. They were super warm, filled with dulce de leche, had the perfect ratio of cinnamon to sugar, and slowly melted into the cloud of vanilla ice cream that came with it. That combination along with the chocolate dipping sauce created the perfect bite. What a way to end a fantastic meal! We'll certainly be back soon. read more

See all

What an amazing meal. I highly recommend this restaurant if you are in Bayshore. The ceviche de camaron is so good that I actually wanted to drink the left over sauce after we finished. I understand why their plátanos con chorizo is most people's favorite. As soon as the carne asada came out, you can literally smell the charred aroma from the perfectly cooked skirt steak. The mojito and the clarified margarita are delicious. There are no words for how good the desserts were. All homemade! Everything is so fresh and made by Chef Catalina. All the workers and servers were so friendly as well! read more

See all

Food and service are always amazing. The decor is beautiful. It's one of my go to places and will continue to be!

I literally can't get enough of this place. I was first introduced here from a Yelp Tasting Event that was here, And I fell in love. I brought my whole family back to try it and everyone was satisfied. Best Mexican food I have ever tried. Can't wait to go back. I can't even say one dish taste better then the next. Everything on the menu is delicious and you won't be disappointed. read more

I am going to give a 3 star review because the food was excellent but the service was terrible. The waiter seemed annoyed to be there. He never checked on us. It just wasn't a good experience however I will go again because the food was just amazing! read more

Restaurant ambiance was very nice, food was delish, service was friendly. Thoroughly enjoyed my experience here. Would recommend and will be going back! read more

Amazing huevos rancheros and dulce de leche French toast. Amazing drinks. And amazing staff. What more could you ask for. Can't wait to try the dinner menu. read more

Pecado Mexican - Huevos Rancheros - Mexican Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Food is excellent, great service and atmosphere. Staff was friendly and attentive. The drinks were banging. Def recommend for a night out read more

Yesterday afternoon I had came in for something quick with my family. Let's start off at the Front desk. One of the young lady's was eating McDonald. Odd. Any ways the young lady had sat me next to the door to outside. My husband kindly asked to be move if it was going to be cold because we have a new born baby that did not happen. One of the young man that gave us water forgot our chips and salsa. He had to be reminded to get our chips and salsa unbelievable !! read more

The best dinner I've had in a long time, the drinks are great. I recommend the Wagyu with chipotle butter. I will definitely be back!!!

This place is dirty! I came here once before and won't be coming back.. all items overpriced even for a casual meal.

My girlfriend and I went last night and had shrimp ceviche,wings,fish tacos and enchiladas. Everything we had was a 10/10 I was honestly surprised because that's a rarity. Place had a cool vibe to it and staff and gm were great. Only negative I can say is they need a tequila list of some sort. They probably have over 100 tequilas and no list. All and all great experience and we will definitely be back read more

Went their for dinner and let's say this place is amazing I think what make this place so good is the service our waiter was so nice and just welcoming he gave us great recommendations and we took them and I love them all he was very attentive and made conversation with us which you rarely see. Thank you Cesar will be coming back read more

Came here for my coworkers birthday celebration and was rushed the entire time. Actually I won't say the entire time the only time we had to think of what to eat/drink/ talk was when the waitress took a literal 30 mins to bring us back our margaritas.... As my one coworker was eating a taco the bus boy took the plate out from infront do her that still had the rest of her meal on it. The waitress knew what we were there for yet failed to show any type of assistance when it came to dessert, apparently after 5 mins of having the dessert menu "she could tell we were obviously having a hard time picking something" so she brought out a plate with whipped cream and a candle and didn't even sing happy birthday...? Service like that definitely effects tip! I won't be returning read more

Maria and Jazlyn were absolutely phenomenal, they were so welcoming and super nice they, made our experience better, I'll be back for sure thanks to them !! read more

The ambiance is great but the price of the food for what you are getting is sadly not worth a return trip. 3 tacos for $24 is steep and you are not even given rice and beans along with it. Some people in our group ordered virgin mojitos and were charged $12 each drink for club soda, simple syrup and mint leaves. Margs were around $16-$18 for 4 sips and a cup of ice. Lastly, they had birria tacos as a special which didn't come with any consommé dipping sauce (any place I've ever been gives you the sauce) so I asked and was charged $2. Place is a rip off. Go across the street and check out verde! Overall, our bill was almost $700 and it felt extremely underwhelming. read more

$70 bucks before tip for a lunch for two?! One order of three palm-size shrimp tacos. One "cup" of yuca fries. A friend ordered a shrimp and chicken fajita combo and a virgin cocktail. I ordered a seltzer. The food was tasty and our server was sweet but the prices are not so sweet. read more

I went here on a date night after hearing such good things. The vibe inside was very nice. Our server was excellent, our cocktails were delicious and they make some of the best guacamole I ever had! Literally so rich and green in color. Our tacos were tasty. Overall you definitely pay for the experience and it'll be worth it. read more

See all

Mexican spot, a little more upscale. Delicious food with weekend brunch. So many delicious choices. Service is always polite and professional. read more

Amazing spot for Mexican! A cool modern ambiance and vibe. The drinks were spectacular i dont like sweet cocktails so I was glad the margarita and Paloma were refreshing and strong. The pork was my favorite dish of the night. I never had such delicious flavors before and do not eat pork often but I was so happy I tried this dish!! Totally unique I ate every last bite. From start to finish the meal was amazing. Tres Leches is a must for dessert! Will definitely be back again soon! Happy I found a new go-to spot for Mexican :) read more

See all

The most mouthwatering guacamole I've ever eaten!!! The food was fresh and delicious and the cocktails were even better. I had the carne asada con huevos with Paloma cocktail served in a highball. I was stuffed but managed to find room for a slice of très leches shared with a friend. I had a wonderful experience topped only by the engaging and personable waiter - Eric. I look forward to the next time I'm in the neighborhood. read more

Yesterday I took a visit here, Food was amazing. server was amazing. When I was getting seated one of the young lady in the front was very rude on her phone. She was lightskin long nails long curly hair. The second young lady ended up helping us after the first one couldn't she was very kind, smiley, communicated and made sure we felt comfortable . short curly hair looked spanish pink nails read more