I absolutely loved the unique and quirky interior of this place! Although the food took a little longer to arrive, there were so many interesting details to admire that I actually enjoyed the wait. The scallop pasta was absolutely delicious! The scallops were perfectly seared, incredibly tender, and simply melted in my mouth. The beet salad was just as amazing, and our waiter, who seemed to have been working there for years, was so warm and genuinely friendly. I visit St. George every time I go on vacation, and it makes me so happy to keep discovering wonderful little restaurants like this one. To be honest, a part of me wants to keep this place as my own little hidden gem! read more

See all

I came here to celebrate my anniversary since I was in town visiting. We chose this place based on the reviews. The decor is a bit eclectic, but fit the theme. We ordered the fresh caught special. My partner ordered their steak. Our server was great and answered all my questions. It was a perfect evening. Pros: we had to change our reservations last minute to an hour later and they were so accommodating. They gave us a bowl of in-house made ice cream to celebrate our anniversary, it was very sweet and special for them to do that. Both our dishes were perfect, the French onion soup was really good. I loved their fresh baked bread too. The blueberry crème brûlée was divine. Cons: this place was a bit hard to find. The signs telling you where to go were confusing. read more

See all

Outstanding food, excellent service, beautiful ambiance. One of the best upscale eateries in St. George. Located in beautiful historic Ancestor Square. A+, 5 Stars read more

We were in town for an event and wanted an upscale place to celebrate. COULD NOT HAVE PICKED A BETTER PLACE!! Food menu was AMAZING! We each ordered a different entree and everyone was just blown away! Wine selection is also terrific- lots to chose from. Great Ambiance and AMAZING service. Our wait staff was knowledgeable and understood when the first bottle of wine we ordered was not up to our expectations. She happily took it away and brought us a different bottle. THAT one was right on target! The restaurant was a bit of a challenge to find as it is located at the back of the SQUARE ( forget the name of the square). LOTS of parking in the rear. read more

Painted Pony - New American Near Me - Saint George, Utah

We had such a beautiful dining experience at Painted Pony. From the moment we walked in, the ambiance completely pulled us in--it felt like stepping into a refined, old-world English pub with an upscale twist. Warm, intimate, and absolutely charming. We started with the mussels, which were incredible--perfectly cooked and packed with flavor. For our mains, we had the mushroom tagliatelle with jumbo prawns and the crab cakes, and both were outstanding. Every dish felt thoughtfully prepared and well-balanced. The service really tied everything together. Our waiter, Will, was fantastic--attentive, friendly, and made sure we had everything we needed without ever feeling rushed. Overall, such a memorable experience. Amazing food, beautiful atmosphere, and top-tier service. Definitely a spot worth coming back to! read more

See all

While visiting Utah, I stopped by this place for lunch. I ordered the crab cakes and a Beet Salad with Salmon. The crab cakes were moist, seasoned perfectly, flavorful and packed with real crab. The salad came with two thick slices of beets and a large portion of goat cheese. Without question, the crab cakes were some of the best I've had. Both dishes were amazing as was the plate's presentation. The restaurant is beautifully designed and the decor goes well with its overall vibe. Kudos, to my server Dominic. He had a great personality and was very honest when asked about his recommendations. He definitely understands and values the importance of providing good customer service. read more

See all

We celebrated our 4 year anniversary here and it was so nice! The decor and ambience is so cozy and elegant. We had the best waiter. He was so fun and social and very attentive. The food was very delicious and so worthwhile. We like having a few fine dining places where we can go for nice food. We know it'll be more expensive when we go there but we want that sometimes for a finer experience and this place was that for us. We still felt satisfied with the portion sizes and quality for the price. They have seasonal menus so the other thing is you won't get bored with the options since they change. We will be coming back. read more

Painted Pony - Bacon Wrapped Gouda Stuffed Dates - New American Near Me - Saint George, Utah

See all

We stopped at Painted Pony during a road trip through St. George and were so glad we did. It's a beautiful, classy restaurant without feeling over the top. I had the beet salad and pumpkin purée soup, both were fresh and full of flavor. My cousins loved their French onion soups. The service was superb, attentive and kind. Such a great spot if you're passing through and want something a little elevated. read more

Painted Pony - Beet Salad - New American Near Me - Saint George, Utah

Delicious food Great ambience Superb service. Dessert is very good. Nice wine list read more

Painted Pony - A high end restaurant serves a maraschino cherry in their old fashioned cocktail. Unbelievable. Can they not afford luxardo cherries? - New American Near Me - Saint George, Utah

See all

The ambiance is on point -- classy and high-end. Started with an Aperol Spritz -- a bit bitter at first, so give it a stir, then it's perfect. The beet salad was phenomenal -- the goat cheese between the beets and the sauce were unreal. Easily a must-try. They served fresh bread that paired perfectly with the salad. The grilled tenderloin steak looked amazing and tasted even better. The seasoning and butter were to die for, and it melted in my mouth. The asparagus and mashed potatoes tied it all together -- smaller portions but just right. Paired it with an Obsidian Cabernet Sauvignon from Napa Valley -- divine with the steak. Overall, an elevated dining experience I'd absolutely recommend. read more

Painted Pony - GRASS FED TENDERLOIN - New American Near Me - Saint George, Utah

See all

The Painted Pony in St. George, UT - A Cozy Gem with One Miss (Pass on the Crab Cakes) If you're looking for a solid upscale dinner spot in downtown St. George, The Painted Pony in Ancestor Square is a strong choice. Tucked into the Tower Building, this New American restaurant nails the Southwestern-meets-fine-dining vibe: intimate indoor seating with contemporary regional art, fresh flowers, and soft lighting, plus a charming patio for when the weather cooperates. It feels romantic and relaxed without being stuffy--perfect for date night or a special occasion while visiting southern Utah.c91b9be2267e Service was attentive and friendly without hovering. Our server knew the menu well and made solid wine recommendations (they've got a nice list, and no-corkage Mondays are a nice touch if you BYO from a Utah store). Portions are generous for the price point--definitely not the tiny-plate nonsense you sometimes get at fine-dining spots. We started with the carrot jalapeño soup (bright, flavorful, and a nice kick) and the baked brie, which was rich and perfectly paired with the seasonal chutney and crostini. For mains, the bone-in pork chop and the hanger steak were highlights--well-cooked, juicy, and packed with flavor from the fresh ingredients and thoughtful sauces. The sides (mac & cheese and haricot verts) were solid too. We finished with the key lime pie, which was a bright, creamy winner. One note, though: pass on the crab cakes. They're a menu staple (around $16, served with something like pomegranate salsa or poblano aioli depending on the season), but ours were mostly filler with a noticeably fishy taste. Not worth the spot on the table when there are so many stronger starters and entrées.781e4d Overall, we'd happily return to The Painted Pony. It's one of the better fine-dining options in St. George--great atmosphere, strong service, and mostly excellent food at reasonable prices for what you get. Just skip the crab cakes and you'll have a winner of a meal. 4/5 stars. Recommended for visitors and locals alike. Reservations advised, especially on weekends. read more

See all

Had a fantastic meal tonight at the Painted Pony. What makes a meal fantastic? Well for me it's great food and even better company. We started out with the Blistered Shishito Peppers. This comes with a maple dijon vinaigrette and honey glazed pork belly. The vinaigrette matched well with the peppers and then adding the little bit of saltiness from the pork belly married the flavors well. We both got the Grilled Tenderloin Steak. This comes with herb whipped potatoes, some asparagus, and rosemary-brown butter, all topped with a balsamic reduction. The steak had a great sear on it and was perfectly cooked. The butter added a nice addition of flavor to the steak. For desert, I enjoyed the Frozen Lemon Soufflé. The lemon of the dish was the right amount of sweet with tart and it went well with the orange shortbread. My friend enjoyed the Blueberry Cheesecake which consists of an oreo crust and lemon curd. If you are looking for a high end meal with fantastic service come check out the Painted Pony! read more

See all

I'm giving it 2 stars because the bread was good! I ordered a glass of wine that was awful and when I asked it was opened 7 days ago! The duck dish had absolutely no taste and was gray and mushy, I'm guessing it had been around for a while. I just left the food complete waste of money. I went next door for sushi for half the price. read more

Adorable! Loved the ambience, food and the staff was exceptional. 10/10 (except I had a hard time finding it at first, give yourself a few extra mins to navigate through the centre) read more

Lovely meal at the Painted Pony. Sweet and caring serving staff. We asked about the coffee and she had never had coffee but told us about it. Food was great. View was charming. We were passing through but would 100% recommend it. read more

Painted Pony - The view from inside the restaurant (from our table) to the outside - New American Near Me - Saint George, Utah

There are places you go... and then there are places that feel like you've finally come home. The Painted Pony is the latter. We adore slipping away for lunch and settling onto the patio, where the world softens--shade drapes gently overhead, birds sing as if they've been hired just for the occasion, and time... well, time slows down enough to breathe. The service is nothing short of immaculate--attentive in that quiet, effortless way that makes you feel seen without ever being interrupted. And the food... oh, the food. The bacon-wrapped dates must have been crafted in heaven... or perhaps meant for the gods and somehow gifted to us. The tuna melt was so transcendent I found myself wondering if I had ever truly tasted tuna before... or if I had just been living a lesser version of the experience all along. And the beef bourguignon... my heavens. It was as if your grandmother--if she were also a five-star chef--had been waiting for you, simmering something rich and soulful to welcome you back after a long journey. Even the tea felt royal... and the mocktails were so delightful, so thoughtfully made, that not once did we miss the alcohol. The Painted Pony isn't just a meal... it's a return. read more

See all

This place is amazing. Sit on the rooftop patio- Order cocktails, order the baked Brie and mussels, definitely order the ahi tuna salad- hands down amazing. Husband got the burger and loved it!! Food double check, ambiance triple check, service- all the checks. We look forward to coming back!! read more

Painted Pony - SEARED AHI TUNA order it!!! - New American Near Me - Saint George, Utah

Great food and service with a unique experience. The pork chop was amazing along with the beet salad.

My son and I were visiting town and wanted an upscale dinner out. The Painted Pony came highly recommended and has been a staple in town for decades, so I figured we should give it a try. We had a reservation for a patio table, and when we arrived they let us know that they'd booked an additional table indoors for us so we could choose which one we wanted (the weather had turned bad and they wanted to make sure we were comfortable.) I appreciated that extra effort to look out for us and we opted to sit indoors. That turned out to be a wise decision, since we watched the storm roll in from the window. The service was fantastic and I was especially pleased with the accommodations they made for my dietary restrictions. (The chef must really like cheese since just about every dish had some sort of cheese ingredient in it.) The main dishes were ok. My son had a steak which he enjoyed. I had the Braised Lamb Shank which I found to be a bit overwhelming. While it was cooked well, the sauce was so strong in flavor that I could only have a few bites. Perhaps I'm one of the unusual guests that enjoys flavor but prefers it not to punch me in the tongue. Not a big deal, I'll order something different in the future. read more

See all

We always enjoy our meals and service here, the menus are well thought out, dishes played well and the servers always willing to answer questions about food intolerance needs. The ambience inside and outside is simply beautiful. We always find this restaurant to be a relaxing and peaceful place to dine. There are a few gluten free and dairy free options, I recommend reviewing the online seasonal menu in advance or calling ahead. The food is always incredible (except maybe the gf bread given with the oil and vinegar, that is the only thing that needs some work). The mocktails and drinks are incredible too! read more

Painted Pony - Mocktails - Lemon Raspberry Pomtini - New American Near Me - Saint George, Utah

See all

We visit St George a couple of times each year. The Painted Pony is always on our itinerary for their outstanding food and service. On our last trip, we had a server Derek who took excellent care of us. Thank you, Painted Pony, for another delicious and memorable dinner! read more

"Dining at Painted Pony was a delightful escape--where exquisite flavors meet a dash of savor. If you're in St. George Utah, consider P.P your culinary passport to sophistication with a side of smiles. Truly a tasteful experience worth trotting back for!" Thanks for a nice experience! ~CaliMan read more

See all

The fanciest and most delicious five star restaurant in St George I've been there four times I absolutely am in love with the ambience and pro staff read more

I was looking for a quick getaway for my birthday and we decided to head to Utah. I wanted to eat at a nice restaurant to enjoy my birthday dinner. I put in a search for "fine dining" in St. George and this place popped up. I took time to read reviews from fellow Yelpers and Ania K's review made my decision. The restaurant can be a little hard to find as it is somewhat hidden in this plaza but we did find it with five minutes to spare before our reservation time. As we entered, one could not help but notice the awards and articles that were hanging on the wall. We were greeted warmly by the hostess and taken to our window table with not much of view but that's ok we were there to dine. We were treated very well by the team of Nate and Anjuli. Their service was stellar. Nate was extremely helpful with recommendations which helped us in making our selections. The restaurant gives off a warm, cozy feeling. The walls are painted a deep red/gold with gorgeous art adorning the walls. The bar is small but intimate. This is a romantic restaurant for two as well a place to bring friends and enjoy special occasions. It has been open for 24 years and highly successful. Perusing the menu, this restaurant is known for their steaks and pork chops. The cocktail list is also extensive. I ended up ordering a French 75 although it was made a little differently than I have experienced, but still very tasty. My man went with the Pony Punch a tasty libation filled with rum and citrus. From there we moved on and ordered the Sesame Crusted Ahi as a starter. What was so incredible about this appetizer was the Ahi was served on a bed of arugula with a pomegranate mignonette and peanut lime vinaigrette. This dish was so light and the pomegranate mignonette just set off the delicious taste of the Ahi. After eating this we could not wait to taste dinner. There was quite a long wait between the appetizer and our dinner coming out but they were pretty busy on this weekday night. Not sure what the issue was but we waited patiently. I was torn on which entree to order but I went with the Grilled Tenderloin Steak accompanied with garlic - parmesan whipped potatoes, a cocoa-raspberry demi and asparagus. WOW! I was so glad I ordered this entreé. The steak was cooked perfectly and the garlic mashed potatoes were kissed with just the right amount of garlic, not overpowering. The asparagus were thick which I don't care for as I prefer thin asparagus but they were seasoned well. Hubby enjoyed his Bone In Pork Chop served with blue cheese walnut stuffed pear, chipotle corn bread pudding and a smoked tomato relish. The stuffed pear was sweet and savory all in one. Incredibly delicious as Nate had informed us it would be. For dessert Anjuli talked us into sharing a slice of their homemade key lime pie. It was delicious as was the mini ice cream sundae they brought out to celebrate my birthday. They also serve lunch and there is outdoor dining available on the inviting patio outside. Overall our experience here was five stars all the way and I cannot wait to return to try more of their dishes. read more

See all

I was visiting from Northern CA. I found this restaurant to be quaint with a wide selection of menu items. I do suggest that if your a man where a dinner jacket. read more

If you're looking for a great restaurant with great Ambiance, Service and Food, this is the place. As good a restaurant as you will find anywhere in the State. The price is what you would expect for such a nice establishment, and I would even consider it to be a good value when compared to fine dining in SLC. We were celebrating my daughter's 19th birthday and since we were out of town in St. George, we decided to take her out for something nice. She ordered the Grilled Tenderloin Steak, with whipped potatoes, Cocoa-raspberry demi, and asparagus. She ordered it MR (temp was probably a little closer to Med then MR) and it was delicious. 5/5 I love a good purée soup and their special was a Carrot Jalapeño Soup it was very good; the jalapeños didn't give it any heat just flavor that blended really well with the carrots. The carrot flavor was very mild. Loved it. 5/5 They change their menu seasonally with the exception of the Bone in Pork Chop, balsamic roasted grapes, curried sweet potato puree, haricot verts, it is their signature dish and a staple on the menu for years. I believe if a restaurant has a signature item, that they are known for and proud of, you should always try it, so I did, and it was amazing, one of the best Pork Chops I've ever had. The only problem is that there are other items on the menu that I would like to try but now I don't know how I will order anything else. 5/5 My wife ordered the Short Rib Ravioli, gorgonzola cream, cherry chutney, crispy shallots, and thought her meal was the best on the table. It was very good but a little on the sweet side, I'd still eat it and really enjoy it, but I liked the savory of the Port Chop a little better. Still a 5/5 My father ordered the Grilled Ribeye, mushroom arancini, broccolini, truffle crema. Excellent, I even stole a bite. 5/5 And my mother ordered the Green Goddess Salad and added Salmon for an extra $10 and loved it. 5/5 We tried the molten lava cake desert, it took a little longer to cook, maybe 30 min. but very good. 4/5 (I've had it before at other places) Our server was amazing, describing the specials and entrées with expertise and ease and making sure we all had an enjoyable time. Would highly recommend if you're looking for upscale dining in St. George. read more

See all

I'm actually flabbergasted. I ordered the ribeye with a char and it is unbelievably good. I came from Vegas for a solo trip for some R&R and I eat at strip restaurants often! This is hands down worth the trip alone! Will was my server and he knew the menu like he was announcing the dishes as the Chef! Service was beyond exceptional. read more

Painted Pony - Ribeye - New American Near Me - Saint George, Utah

See all

We had an incredible lunch at Painted Pony! Kaylee was absolutely fantastic, attentive, personable, and made us feel so welcome from the moment we sat down. She was energetic and you can tell she loves what she does which is rare. Every recommendation she gave was spot on, and it made the entire experience even better. The food was outstanding, but Kaylee's service truly set this visit apart. Painted Pony has officially become our new go to lunch spot, and we'll definitely be requesting Kaylee every time we make a reservation. Side note, I've always thought this to be a dinner spot - don't miss out on a great lunch too. Highly recommend! read more

Painted Pony - New American Near Me - Saint George, Utah

We've had dinner at this restaurant for several years, usually for birthdays and anniversaries. Had dinner there last night and was a little disappointed. The menu has changed and they must have a new chef. Ordered a whisky sour and it wasn't good. The purple color was because of cabernet wine added. I should have sent it back but didn't. The caesar salad was different and not worth the price. The good news is that the bison steak was very good; the crab cakes and the chocolate extremely outstanding. Our server, Nyken was the best, and the other workers were professional and helpful. We hope the menu will improve on our next visit. read more

Great place to fresh seasonal food in an incredible atmosphere. Went for lunch waiter was super fun and very knowledgeable/professional. There is something on the menu for everyone here and I'll be back! read more

Painted Pony - Beet salad - New American Near Me - Saint George, Utah

Food Quality: **** (Delicious, high-quality steaks) Service: *** (Friendly but a bit slow) Setting: **** (Cozy, upscale, great ambiance) Cost: *** (A bit on the pricier side, but worth it for the quality) Overall: **** (A great stop for a delicious meal while passing through) I was driving through St. George on my way from Colorado to California, and I'm so glad I stopped at Painted Pony. The steak I had was absolutely delicious--cooked perfectly, tender, and full of flavor. The quality of the meat was evident, and I was really impressed with how well it was prepared. The atmosphere is great for a more upscale dining experience, with a cozy, welcoming vibe. The setting is intimate but not stuffy, perfect for a nice, relaxed dinner. The service was friendly but a little slow, possibly because the restaurant was busy, so I'll dock it a star for that. However, it didn't ruin the overall experience. The prices are a bit on the higher side, but considering the quality of the food and the overall dining experience, it's definitely worth it. This place is now on my list of go-to stops when I pass through St. George--a must-try if you're in the area! read more

Painted Pony - New American Near Me - Saint George, Utah

The best service from Will & an outstanding meal while visiting beautiful St. George. Everything is made in house. I had cilantro carrot soup as a starter with homemade sourdough bread- fantastic! For my main course, I had the braised chicken with pumpkin polenta. The most fantastic fall combination ever. Although I was quite full, I knew that skipping dessert would be a big mistake here so I opted for the butterscotch crème brûlée with a ginger snap cookie. The restaurant is beautiful. The service is highly attentive and welcoming. I can't wait to return. read more

See all

The painted pony in St George Utah is a nice restaurant with inside and outside dining. Great atmosphere with local art. I had the brined pork chop which is a signature dish. For the price I was 50 50. The beat salad was very cold and the beets relatively hard rather than dedicate. The French onion soup was missing something on the flavor side. The bread was excellent with a crispy crust and tender inside. For me the bread was a highlight. My Manhattan Martini was a disappointment and tasted like it did not have the right proportions. Service was very friendly and accommodating especially since we did not have reservations. read more

See all

Very yummy food with really cool atmosphere and friendly staff. The service was top notch.

Ate here the night following my run for the St. George Marathon. What a wonderful way to celebrate! Their seasonal menu perfectly reflected the autumnal spirit. I strongly suggest ordering the chicken & fig dish and the pumpkin cheesecake for dessert! read more

I was just reading another review and she had the same experience as I did with my meal. I also had the chicken dish on Nov 8. I tasted it and my sister tasted it and both had the same reaction. It was repulsive!! Quite frankly I should have sent it back to the kitchen. But they were busy and I could barely get attention to get more water. This was my first experience at the Painted Pony and it will be the last. I find it quite interesting that another patron, the night before, was very much turned off as well ! So the sauce must have been leftover from a previous date of "creation" by the chef. Definitely not fine dining - especially for that $$ of money. St George is still in desparate need of some quality high end restaurants. I've tried the top 5 now and they have all been a major letdown. read more

Outstanding place in St. George, UT. Food is excellent, so is the staff, not too pricey. Have fun

We have dined here many times over many years and always have had good food. Tonight...not so. I had their chicken dish and it was barely, I mean barely, edible. The quality of the very small piece of chicken was horrible. Grisly, and quite challenging to cut, at $37 was a complete joke. The sauce was overpowering, the potatoes (substituted due to potential gluten ) weren't even warm. And, it took almost an hour to get our food. For a fine dining restaurant, it was a big disappointment. I know you can do so much better but it sure wasn't even a decent meal tonight read more

What a lovely surprise! Who would think that a quaint little town would possess such a magnificent culinary experience such as The Painted Pony! Usually a normal gas stop yet with a simple exploring find not only a warming culture but such a fabulous gastronomical treat. One that rivals many of the meals of our European travels enhanced by Hannah our servers in-depth knowledgeable and professionalism. Thank you for the memories! read more

Went two weeks ago with family while in town. The lunch was ok got the tuna melt it was ok the best was the Italian soda it was delicious. But the service was horrible. I had to get up 3 times to find a server and once I got up to pour our own water. I saw tons of waiters but maybe cause we were a walk in family they couldn't care less. It was disappointing and embarrassing cause I recommend it to the family. It was a Saturday afternoon. I feel bad posting this but I was amazed at how horrible the service was. read more