It's a small pizza restaurant that has some great food and vibe. You might not feel that from outside but inside they have a decent dining space. The staff is friendly and helpful. Food is great. We had ordered a pizza, salad and garlic breadsticks and I can say all three were tasty. The material used was fresh. Will visit again read more

Placed a to go order for a custom 13", half cheese half Parma primo. I arrived 5 mins after I got my ready txt and for some reason the pizza was cold. I believe they didn't make it fresh n instead just grabbed slices from the display. You can see how the slices don't really connect. Had to warm it up my self and the Parma was good. Ik it would taste absolutely great if it was fresh tho. The cheese on the other hand had a rubbery texture n the cheese just wasn't up to par. The sauce portion was definitely it!!! The dijon vinaigrette was their closest thing to ranch. To me it's really good. U taste a bit of sweetness which threw me off in a good way. 25$ and I probably won't get delivery again to avoid staleness. Other than that, the environment was clean and spacious enough. Parking was available on a Saturday night (8pm) read more

See all

Quick in and out. Grabbed two slices of pie (pepperoni and cheese) to-go. Got the zas toasty and fresh. Son inhaled both quickly as soon as we got to the apartment. read more

See all

My husband's teammates highly recommended we try Pagliacci Pizza, and I'm happy they did. I called to place the order at this location, out order was ready within 20 mins. I wasn't even in the mood for pizza tonight, but our selections were phenomenal. The fresh and quality ingredients were very noticeable; and most importantly the pizza was not greasy. The Presto Primo was also really good, and very filling I only ate a few fork fulls and have plenty left (I ordered the small portion.) I would be remiss if I did not mention how wonderful the breadsticks are, I could have honestly been satisfied with an order of salad and breadsticks. Overall it was a great order, and safe pickup experience we have officially found out our pizza place; I highly recommend!!! read more

See all

Decided for a pizza last night and I was going to initially call a chain pizza place, but wanted to see what the local flavor had in store. So I decided on this place. I called in for delivery and ordered. Was pretty easy and smooth process. I got what I usually get....beef or sausage, green pepper and onion. Got the small. It arrived in about 25 minutes. No issue with the driver finding or contacting me. The pizza was hot, the toppings were good. I liked the fact that they use white onions and not the red ones like a lot of other places do. Only small point it seemed a bit pricey. 3.00 delivery charge that says it doesn't go to the driver. Not sure what that cost would cover, but after all said and done a small pie was 29. It was good, I would probably order again. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

See all

Absolutely the best pizza I've ever eaten. Let's just start with the crust. The foundation. The best part of the pizza. Hand tossed to perfection. It's light , it's rustic yet it's uniform and perfect. With a slice selection with cheese and pepperoni offered daily and a rotating schedule of two house specialties. It's expensive but after you take the first bite you know why. They use only high quality meats and veg toppings. Every time we visit the Seattle area we find a Pagliacci and have never been disappointed. read more

They moved! This Pagliacci is still on Main, but no longer in the Old Bellevue district. They are located in a precarious lot in the opposite direction, closer to the freeway, Sushiland and Hmart. The pizzas are still delicious and there is more parking than the previous location, but it can be easy to miss if you're going too fast since the shop is slightly below street level. read more

See all

We got the Brooklyn bridge pizza to go, it was mid. Not super flavorful and not a strong char. Felt healthy which I don't love when eating pizza. It was also pretty expensive but maybe that's a Bellevue thing. Overall not sure if I will return voluntarily. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Brooklyn Bridge pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

Loved the pepperoni. Unique flavor profile, tasted great! Super friendly staff and loved the service and vibe they had. I was a first time customer here, but will definitely be back in the near future. read more

Stopped here for lunch before my tattoo session and wasn't sure of what to expect as I believe this place is a chain or has a few locations. I was happy to know that I could order slices and not a whole pizza. I got two beautiful slices, one a classic sausage and cheese, and the other had drizzles of pesto, cherry tomatoes, and mushrooms and I would marry that second slice, it was tangy, nutty, creamy, and umami. The perfect treat and filling food before a tattoo sess. I wanted another slice after my two, but I will be back again! Service was okay, not super welcoming or warm. The place is very simple on the inside, not much space for a lot of people and only a few tables. I will be back again 5/5 on pizza 3/5 on hospitality/warmness read more

It'll be a sad day when the last downtown Bellevue location closes, which is set for later this year, to build a condo building. Go figure. Pagliacci Pizza is a classic Seattle joint that's been around way before there were any threats of development. Its Sasquatch graphic on the boxes are iconic and I like that with all the shops, you can get a slice or two instead of getting a whole pie. This Pagliacci Pizza is located in Old Bellevue on Main Street. The space inside is small and narrow, with a few tables inside, but the side patio outside is more comfortable and is especially great to hang out on during sunny days. Staff is always so friendly here, too, even during promotional deals, which brings a crowd of people, with a line outside the door. Parking can be tricky with a small lot, but it's walking distance to Bellevue Downtown Park where there's tons of parking. The pizza is solid. I usually stick with the Pepperoni slice, and two is enough, as the slices are large and cheesy. They do have a good amount of different pizzas on the menu, including salads and booze, like Washington beer and wine. I hope to visit again before it closes. It's one of the few restaurants on Main Street that's casual and affordable and is the only pizza joint in downtown Bellevue where you can get a slice to go. It'll be missed. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pepperoni & Hawaiian - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

Just great pizza. I mean really, really great pizza. Not pretentious. Not "Neapolitan" . NYC style at its best. Never had a bad pie and service is beyond reproach. Not sure why anyone would go anywhere else. Favorites are Brooklyn Bridge, Spicy Chicken, and a simple mushroom pie. Awesome. read more

$10 charge for a topping. The guy taking the order did not mention it. The pizza was not that great. $8 Small salad!!!

Ordered two slices to go, got home and only saw one. Called them back and they prepared another one ASAP. Slices were good, although eaten 20 minutes apart. Service was friendly and pleasant. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

There are a lot of Pagliacci locations, and we've been to half of them. Out of all of the Seattle and Eastside locations, this is our favorite! The crust and toppings are winners and the staff is always quick and accommodating. I like their new location, though have a soft spot for the original Old Town Bellevue shop. The building was mid-century modern, so it had distinct architecture to it! However, I'm glad that they have a new location that has more parking. We normally get slices here for a quick bite and whole pies for a full meal at home, and they are always delicious. The crust is rolled out nice and thin, much more than other locations, and has a great chew. Some of the other locations have a dense texture and bite to it; almost like eating a thick cracker. The toppings are balanced and every bite feels like you're getting a bit of sauce, cheese, meat/fruit, aromatics without overkill. Even the cheese slice is simplicity at its best and has a nice flavor of balanced tomato sauce and mozzarella! Their seasonal slices are artisanal in concept, but executed well. I highly recommend getting a slice or even a full pie. Their Fall specials that are currently running are fantastic - we've tried Autumn Harvest and Pear Primo and have enjoyed them immensely. Still have to try the Primo Sage, but I imagine that will be good too. :) As previously mentioned, service here is great. The team members are friendly and keep you updated on what's up and coming and recommendations suited to your tastebuds. During the pandemic, they've gotten creative and partnered with surrounding local businesses. I've even seen a collaboration with L'experience Paris! Social distancing markers are clearly indicated, though each time we've gone there's been 1-2 other customers, making it easy to social distance. Entrance and exit are clearly marked in 1 direction only as well. They make it easy to order via phone, online, and in-person. Even though there's another location closer to us, we'll continue to come here for our cravings! read more

See all

Was a litttleee too dissatisfied... Maybe it's the location or it was a bad day but $28 for a medium sized pizza where there was no flavor. It looked very pleasing to eat and I was excited until I was two slices in and realized there is nothing special about this place for it to be this expensive. The sauces they gave me made up for it. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

As a 7 year pizza cook/kitchen staff from a well known pizza restaurant in Illinois, this places sauce was pretty much tasteless, crust was more like a cracker thin. I love thin crust too but this was just bland and tasteless. The dough tasted/looks to be mass produced and frozen possibly. One of the worst pies I have had in awhile....would not recommend. Overpriced for sure. You would be better making your own pizza at home. Sorry, but I do not like your pies. The staff was very nice and the establishments was very clean. 4 stars for being clean and having nice workers. read more

I love it sooooo much Never been here before And tried one slice It was soooo cheap And everything was soooo great and fantastic Will come here again Really crunchy read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

While visiting my son we came to have pizza. 1st thing first Diet Coke in the house. One of the best Veggie pizzas that I had. Very clean establishment nice ambiance. A must try read more

17 in Brooklyn Bridge with roasted garlic added and 6 pack ipa Cost with tax 62$. Seemed pricey but maybe that's Seattle?! The pizza was good though. And the beer was cold. I ordered it to go and it came out on time. The service is decent. The interior is clean , cold, and stark . read more

It is not cheap but the taste is great The rim is crispy and the dough tastes good I love Hawaii and Margerita Other with meat are also good read more

See all

worst margarita pizza I've ever tasted and yet most expensive. I paid $38 for a cold tasteless pizza that was supposed to be made with fresh mozzarella cheese but instead it was made with tasteless dry mozzarella cheese. I wouldn't eat this for free if offered to me. such huge business in pizza does not know that margarita pizza it's made with fresh cheese. then the sauce was right out of the can tomato sauce probably the cheapest. my last time ordering from them. my pizza of almost $40 landed in the garbage right away. read more

Always consistent and clean food. The people working are always friendly and my pizza is done quickly. Good rewards program, too. I usually spend about $60 for a pizza and salad and have some left over for next day. read more

We ended up eating here twice on our visit to Seattle. We stayed in Bellevue and this was walking distance from our hotel. This was some of the best pizza we've ever had (and my husband makes delicious home-made brick oven pizza so we are definitely pizza snobs). The salads were also really good. They have a great selection of toppings, prices are fair and their beer selection was great. Service was also really good. Already craving their pizza and can't wait for our next trip to Seattle. read more

LOVEDDDD THE PIZZA! We ordered two different pizzas and a salad. The taste of the pizza is amazing. If you craving pizza I strongly suggest you go to pagliacci read more

Good pizza is hard to find, and Pagliacci is pretty good. I got the vegetarian pizza for take out and it tasted good. There wasn't anything special about it or anything that made it stand out, but I would go there again. read more

Great n.y.style pizza. Great crust great sauce. Would definitely return when I'm back in the area.

50 bucks for a large delivery seemed high but I was hoping it would be great. It wasn't. It was actually kind of bland. I rarely put salt on food but had to with that pizza. read more

Great quality and selection of pizza and salad is a must to order every time! We love this location.

My favorite is 12th Fan Primo! Service is great and a whole pizza is ready in 20 minutes.

They skimped on some ingredients in the pizza and everyone who ate some had explosive diarrhea

My husband and I love pagliacci pizza.... so we were pumped when we stumbled across one in Bellevue last night. We got a large spicy salumi pepperoni pizza, and it did NOT disappoint. Yum! read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

Pizza was good I had the Philly one which I like way better than the pepperoni. The guy with the long hair who took our order was putting in WORK. He was super nice when we ordered and he was helping multiple people when it got kinda busy and I even saw him jogging. Hard worker. The ambiance is really chill. They had some TV's playing news and sports. Very casual. read more

Come support local restaurants! Pagliacci consistently offers delicious pizzas and seasonal specialties. Kids love the make your own soda machine! read more

Thin crust pizza that is a family favorite on the weekend! We enjoy the one on Mercer Island the most.

I have ordered pizza exclusively and regularly from Pagliacci for decades. On 7/21/24, I ordered two slices and a Pagliaccio salad. I ended up eating the pie, and ate the salad the next day. The salad tasted off, with a slimy texture. It tasted old, and I threw it away. I called to give Pagliacci the feedback on 7/23. The person I spoke with advised me that if I wasn't planning on eating the salad the same day, I should have ordered the dressing on the side, if I didn't want it to be soggy. I described it as slimy, not soggy, and said that it tasted old. The employee told me that all the salads were made to order. Getting nowhere, I ended the conversation. I am taking minutes out of my day to write this because I did not call to get something for nothing. Indeed, I got nothing in exchange for the $8.49 I paid. I called to give feedback. What I heard back was that I was wrong about my experience. Previously, I have eaten day old Pagliaccio salad with gusto and it tasted fantastic. Owners and management, please read this and remind your front line employees to listen to feedback. read more

Amazing customer service. My kids have food allergies and the person on the phone took the time to list out ingredients for me and was very patient. As an allergy mom I really appreciate the extra attention he took. Made my day :) read more

We had the pesto and Roman Holiday... pizza was VERY good. Not much parking but worth it. read more

Personally, I absolutely LOVE Pagliacci! Honestly, it's my favorite pizza I've had in Washington, and I lived there for 25 years. It is my go to spot. Their centiolli is an aboslute MUST - if you have not tried it, you need to!! It's absolutely delicious - frequently I will go and just order that, or that and a salad. I like their pizza too, I typically just get cheese but I've tried the margheritta, pesto primo, tomato gorgonzola and the italiano, each of which I enjoyed. Other than cheese, the tomato gorgonzola is my favorite! Their cesear salad and the pagliaccio salad are both wonderful. Most of the time I am pretty boring when it comes to salad and stick with ceaser, but at Pagliacci I REALLY love the pagliaccio salad! It's absolutely delicous and they do not skimp on the toppings... I would HIGHLY recommend! Also, they used to have a pesto pasta salad that was just about my favorite thing on this earth.. I haven't seen it on their menu the past few times I've been in, but it's on their menu online, so it would be worth asking them about it if you like pesto and/or pasta salads! I like it so well I even bothered to develop my own copycat recipe, which is always a huge hit when I make it for potlucks! Overall I think they have an awesome selection on their menu, with lots of creative pizza toppings that you wouldn't see at most fast food or fast casual pizza joints. Service has always been friendly, interactions with staff are fairly limited since this is more of a fast casual restaurant but I've never had any complaints. Ambiance, I think the restaurant is nice to sit in. That said, there is a lot of empty space.. which is both a positive and a negative! It's nice in terms of feeling more open, but at the same time the seating is fairly limited and the restaurant can get pretty busy/crowded. Overall I HIGHLY recommend Pagliacci! It's really some of my favorite if not my favorite pizza, outside of some of the authentic Italian pizza that I had while literally in Italy, but I don't think that's a fair comparison. I really think Pagliacci Pizza is a top tier establishment, perfect for dine in, take out, groups, or solo meals! Plus, they have parking, which is very convenient particularly in downtown bellevue! If you are not dining in, I do recommend placing your order in advanced and then picking it up. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - The centiolli!! TRY IT YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED! :) - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

Bland corporate pizza with what appears to be a cheap variety of mozzarella and an unexciting crust - the dough is made in a commissary kitchen, not on the premises. Voted Seattle's best pizza by the Seattle Weekly for decades but now the Weekly doesn't exist, and the Pagliacci founders sold the business long ago. Their house salad with salami and chickpeas is good but they insist on tossing it before delivery instead of giving you the dressing on the side. Soggy, unexciting meh. read more