I love me a Pagliacci chopped salad. It's always fresh and the taste is consistent. It is a little pricey but worth it. A slice of pizza will run you $5 which isn't too bad. I personally enjoy that they use fresh pineapple on their Hawaiian so I will go for that if I don't get a salad. Also, I love that they don't punish you for wanting water since they automatically leave water cups out. The water comes out from the machine so cold and refreshing. It's the small things! read more

So good!! Sad that they have no ranch, but the aioli sauce they have is pretty good. I love ranch with my pizza, but the pizza is so good, you don't even need ranch. Service was nice, friendly and fast every time. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Original cheese - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

See all

Every time I come to Bellevue, we order Pagliacci Pizzas delivery. I especially LOVE the prosciutto chanterelles pizza!! Available in the fall when chanterelles are abundant in the northwest, it is quite a treat for me since chanterelles cost 45 dollars a pound in San Francisco / Bay Area. ( available when in season at Bryan's market in SF, and the Organic Natural Market in Castro Valley ). But in Bellevue, they cost around 20 dollars a pound ( or less sometimes when on sale ) at PPC market and at Whole Foods in Bellevue. PPC would sell them by the pound and you can handpick them. Whole Foods sell them by the basket. But enough about the chanterelles. Pagliacci also has pizza with figs and salami I think, I forgot the meat but I just love the figs on them. They have many other combination according to seasons. We ordered with a Ceasar salad and some seasonal pint of ice cream, you can order with cans of sodas or martinelli's apple juice in those cute round bottles. Delivered everything to your door is fast and easy. read more

See all

The service was very good here. The workers were friendly from start to finish. They have gluten free options for crust. We had two 11 inch pizzas which were plenty for two people. We got a Hawaiian and veggie. Both were good. read more

See all

I don't care what the ratings are or what people say- but know this, every time I go to pick up my order, this place is full of people! That's just my first mention. Secondly, my family and I love their pizzas! Maybe others don't know what to order? We always rotate between the Parma Primo, AGOG Primo, and Margherita pizzas and they never disappoint! Dont let the goat cheese turn you off, all of the flavors meld so well together. We enjoy every bite, every time! Definitely on the pricier side for pizza but if you never try it, you'll never know... quality of ingredients over quantity 100%! read more

My go to pizzeria and salad. Sometimes I even come here for just their paggliacio salad.... It's a delicious mix. I always ask for the dressing on the side though. It's the most delicious pizza ever if you eat it fresh. If you wait 30ish minutes, it goes down to 3 star pizza. But when fresh, the pizza is crispy and crunchy. read more

Always a good idea! Pagliacci has so many unique flavors and seasonal options. I tried their Argentine with all the veggies possible and it was so good, I went back for more. Hope it becomes part of the permanent menu! read more

See all

I generally like their pizza. I do have critiques with the seasonal specials at times. This time is the sausage and mushrooms. The mushrooms were slimy. They needed to be sliced thin and allowed to crisp up a bit during the cook. This would have added that extra layer to the overall experience. read more

What a fantastic discovery! This place has its own parking lot, a rarity that deserves major kudos! As you step inside, you're warmly greeted with bright smiles and the irresistible aroma of freshly baked pizza. The atmosphere is very clean, well-organized, and spacious, with about 7 tables for seating , bar table with bar stool for enjoying a meal. You can also grab a pizza to go or savor a slice at the bar. Selling by the slice is my absolute favorite! The beverage selection is impressive, featuring a soda machine, varied canned and bottled drinks, and even free water and beer on tap. But the true pièce de résistance is the mouthwatering pizza that will leave you craving more. Having spent seven years on the East Coast, I can confidently say that this pizza reminds me of the best of New York City places like Scarr's. The crust and sauce are absolute perfection. Pagliacci Pizza is a game-changer, and I'm eager to return and try more of their incredible pizza, including their pizza of the day menu. Will I be back? Absolutely! Oh and they also get 5 Star for customer service! The lady the helped us today was so nice and friendly. read more

See all

In the mood for pizza!! Pagliacci has the best salad. Today we ordered our usual menu plus their special pizza. Pagliaccci salad - overly dressed Centioli - they used to covered with cheese, now more only in the middle, leaving about inch of the outside part without . Lil wood primo - taste like cheeseburger Remember, pagliacci is now more to go and quick lunch type of restaurant. Restroom: 2 gender neutral restrooms Parking: their own parking area read more

See all

Bread sticks really bad tonight My son in law picked up pizza and bread sticks - this is the first time WE are unhappy read more

Came in 30 minutes before they close for a slice of pizza Oh, they have barstool tables and a couple of low tables in the lobby. Lobby was clean and organized. Well kept. Even though they were closing in 30 minutes, they still attended us with hospitality And kindness Pizza slices are a good portion Definitely coming in to try more of a variety during earlier business hours read more

See all

Pizza is fresh and super good. We ordered pineapple and pepperoni and I really liked it but husband said it could've used more sauce. I'm not a pizza sauce girly anyways so it was perfect for me. We also got the breadsticks and it was love at first bite! The restaurant has sliced and whole pie options with nice indoor seating. The staff were very nice too and we will definitely be back when we are in town! read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

See all

Went into Pagliacci Pizza last night & it was so so good! The pizzas tasted so fresh and authentic. 10/10 would recommend this place to anyone. Their staff is so attentive & so so friendly which makes this place that much better! read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

See all

Pagliacci is very standard but still good. I'm from New York and nothing will compare to New York pizza but this still scratches my itch. There's more than enough parking at this venue in a very populated area of Bellevue which is nice considering parking can be nuts around here otherwise. Every day they have different specials but you can order whole pies with whatever you want. I recommend getting whatever slices they have on stand-by since if you get a custom pie, it just feels way too expensive compared to the slices. The cheese is flavorful and the ingredients are fresh. Nothing bad to say about this pizza! read more

Pagliacci has the BEST Pizza! Their crust is my favorite. It's light and airy and crispy, with the best chewiness. Their combinations of toppings are so unique and quality, and delicious! I also love their Caesar Salad. Their Caesar dressing and croutons are so savory and so good. I do think they could do better with the chicken they add to the salad.​​ read more

Delicious pizza and really appreciate the gluten free crust option. Our family had a great time

Good Pizza and they sell it by the slice as well! They do a specialty pizza daily the day I went it was a soppressata pizza it was delicious. There is seating and they have a TV. It seems like a cool place to Hang out as well the staff was super Cool when I went. I will go back when I am in the area. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Napkin - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

The pizza is pretty tasty, but we had ordered a gluten-free dairy-free pizza and they failed to mention that their gluten-free dough has dairy in it... If the allergy were more severe, this would have had serious consequences. I would not order from here again. read more

Love their seasonal items and they make it well here! Also ample parking to make pickup a breeze. Overall very nice pagliacci.

The restaurant is nice and they have plenty of seating available inside. The staff seem nice and the service was quite quick. If you order by slice from the counter, they pop it in the oven to heat it up for you before serving. Original Cheese: I do really like how crispy the crust is and how warm it came out of the oven. The cheese was warm and gooey which was lovely. However, there is way too much crust in relation to cheese/sauce. I could taste mostly crust, and very little of the cheese/sauce itself. For a $4+ slice of pizza, I definitely had higher standards for what this slice of pizza would be like, which it did not meet. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Original Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

TLDR/ Price: Exorbitantly High, Service: Middling, Cleanliness: Subpar, Verdict: Probably not worth it. I ordered two slices to eat in before I got there and then made my choices for our larger order based on the flavors of those two. We ended up ordering 4 pies to go. Verde primo, Grand salami primo, Pesto primo, and Seasonal Rosemary-Potato-Chicken. Overall, the flavors were on point, and the service was okay. Not bad, not great. The staff was not as friendly or as helpful as at basically any other pizza chain I have been to. Even after I shared my love of their brand and the nostalgic memories I had at a different location, the warmth and joviality that you hope to find at a pizza parlor just wasn't there. The gender neutral restrooms were not as clean as they could have been, but the fun Italian movie posters were a nice reminder of the artistic flair of other locations that this one only hints at. Aesthetically speaking, the pizzas looked a little sad, not what you would expect for almost 40 dollars a piece. At previous visits to other locations the higher per slice price tag was worthwhile because the pieces were very large; nope, not this time. My vegetable slice almost looked like a medium piece. If you are looking for quality, for exotic decor, for that quirky movie vibe, for flavorful and beautiful pizza...look elsewhere. I won't be going back to this location and if this is where the rest of the chain is headed, then they won't be a Seattle/Bellevue staple for long. It honestly makes me wish I had just gone to the Seattle location, even though it was way out of my way. This might be ok for to-go ordering, as they did check to make sure my pizzas were correct, but parking, uncomfortable- seating, and the overall annoyed vibe from the staff made eating in seriously terrible. They get two stars, one for checking to make sure my pizzas were correct and one for having a Coca-Cola freestyle machine. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Fun pizza box art - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

See all

They sell pizza by the slices or whole pies. Offer a variety of drinks. The pizza is thin, New York style. It's good and has a variety of options. Staff is friendly read more

I love Pagliacci can't go wrong with a pizza or salad here. Service is great! Pizza crust is good and it's so nice they have a dairy free cheese available read more

Ordered a whole pie to dine-in. Extra pepperoni, black olives, and green pepper, well cooked. It was a really good pizza, nice buttery, chewy crust and a giid amount of toppings. I would have liked it even a little more cooked. We had a Caesar salad to share while we waited. Great dressing and croutons. Nice way to wait for our pizza. Very nice service. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

Just walked in to pagliacci's on a very busy Tuesday night. Was immediately greeted by Jack, who was slammed with customers and to go orders, he didn't skip a beat. I sat and waited while listening to him greet everyone who came in with a welcoming disposition as it got history and busier. Pagliacci's has a gem with Jack. read more

Overall, pretty good spot! Sauce was on point, not "metallic" or acidic tasting, nice and savory and a twinge of sweetness. Cheese was good, not overpowering. The crust was crisp and has great texture. Ratio of the sauce, cheese, and pepperoni was good. Two of the main downsides were the thickness of the crust. It's a liiittle too thick under the sauce and cheese, making most bites a little doughy. If it was just a little thinner, it would be super solid. The other thing is that the pepperonis were just ok. Nothing that special, kind of tasted plain. Perhaps just a little bit longer re-heating it in the oven would have crisped it up for some added texture, but taste was a bit plain. Decent spot for a quick bite! read more

Love their pizzas. Good fast service for to go. Order ahead. Always nice . They don't skimp on the toppings.

We wanted a lighter lunch so decided to stop by this pizza place! The free parking lot had plenty of spots when we went around 2 pm, though the restaurant itself was quite crowded. It's a pizza by the slice place, and each slice is $4-6. Our slices were quickly warmed up by the cashier, and our 4 slices came out to ~$20. There are a few tables outside where we opted to eat because it was a nice day, and the pizzeria was well stocked with cheese and red peppers to add for flavor. The asparagus and prosciutto pizza was made well but wasn't to my personal taste, but the cheese pizza was great, really flavorful sauce! I just wish it had been heated just a bit hotter. Overall though good pizza and we had a satisfying meal! read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

I had just eaten dinner on a Friday night and about two hours and some number of drinks later I was hungry again and wanted something with a lot of carbs and just something greasy and unhealthy. I was scrolling through Yelp looking for something still open, within walking distance, and something that I haven't tried before. I looked up burgers at first but then I remembered pizza was a thing and Pagliacci was everything I was looking for. They recently moved their downtown Bellevue location from the Old Bellevue area closer to me which was perfect. I called at 9:30pm and was able to pick up my order at 10pm. I ordered half south philly and half spicy chicken on a 13" medium pizza ($21). The south philly was pretty cheesy and I liked the sausage and onions. There weren't many mushrooms and the toppings in general were lacking. One slice had only one piece of meat and another only had one mushroom. The chicken on the spicy chicken wasn't spicy but the pepper is what gives it that kick. Overall both were good although I preferred the spicy chicken a bit more as it had more flavor. If you were wondering, I ate the whole pizza. As a second dinner. I have never felt so satisfied and disgusting in my life but I have no regrets. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Left: south philly. Right: spicy chicken. Medium size 13" ($21) - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

We came in and waited for a long time. No one acknowledged us, even giving us water or a greeting. We decided to leave. Too bad because I know the food would have been good. disappointed with the service read more

Pizza was great. We stopped by for lunch, and it was not too busy. The pizza was fresh and left a great impression. read more

See all

I have been craving a pizza, but I have to have gluten free crust. I called Pagliacci's and asked several questions about the gfree pizza. The hostess went above and beyond to accommodate a pizza with my celiac and other food allergies in mind. She suggested options to make the perfect pizza for me. The final result was amazing! I will be frequenting Pagliacci's and will travel here from NY to have it again! Thank you for making it easy to enjoy the foods we don't always get to enjoy with Celiac disease and food allergens. read more

I live so close to this that I didn't think anything of it when it showed up in the middle of quarantine lockdown. I had never heard of the well known name in Seattle, but started to gain interest when the parking lots were full every single night, and people were in a huge (relative to COVID standards) line of people waiting outside for pizza. I finally decided to go in and see if they even had some vegan options. They didn't have any options for slices of their already-made pizzas, which was a bummer coming from an avid Sizzle Pie visitor and Portland native. However, you could order their 1 or 2 veggie pizzas, and customize it with a vegan cheese. Now, I'm as skeptical as anyone about vegan cheese, and I've been vegan for 6 years. Some places just DON'T do it right. This one wasn't so bad! I really really enjoyed their cheese, albeit a little runny, the flavor was really good and I didn't feel like I was missing anything from a pizza experience. That being said, I was hoping for a few more options from a place that has the creativity and quality of a place like Sizzle Pie because Seattle, and especially the Eastside are missing an opportunity for delicious vegan options, especially quick-grab options! read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Vegetarian made vegan! Added arugula and their seasonal rosemary potatoes. - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

I don't get everyones fascination with pagliacci. I lived near the one in columbia city for years and always thought it was "meh". I visited Brooklyn growing up many summers and brooklyn is truly the only place I have loved pizza. This is absolutely a step up from tutta bellas, pizza hut, domino's, and papa John's, but not awesome enough for me to ever go out of my way to buy. The crust isn't thin enough and the texture was off in my opinion. My dad tried this place out after a friend from New Jersey suggested it to him. If he had told me where he was going I would have declined and had him pick up something better like dim sum on his way home from Bellevue today. Oh well. Lesson learned for my family. If you like low quality pizza from the places above I mentioned, I am sure you will love this place as it is better - but it's a far cry from NY style pizza. They get one star for the creative pizza box. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Overwhelmingly meh. - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

See all

Late dinner on our first night in town and they were close to the hotel so we gave them a shot. Pizza was ready for pick up just before the scheduled time. Place was easy to find and seemed to have plenty of seating for dine in. The to go orders are at the end of the long counter on some shelves near the register. The employee mopping up stopped to get me Parmesan cheese and red pepper flakes that were ready to go behind the counter. Very friendly even as they were clearly closing up for the night. Pizza looked and smelled amazing and my son and husband approved. Will be back next time we are in Bellevue! They sell pizza by the slice so I would love to come try all they have to offer. Great combos! read more

This pizza is the only pizza that our family will eat. The service is amazing and we love all the staff that works there.

Paggliacci Pizza is incredible. Im a huge fan of pizza, and have tried many many pizzas and Paggliacci is on a level of its own. I recently tried the PSR combo with pepperoni, cascioppos Italian sausage, ricotta, mozzarella and romano. For me its the ricotta and italian sausage that makes the PSR so delicious. I cant say much for the atmosphere or staff because I ordered mine to go. The person working was nice though. I would like to try more pizza, but everytime I order pagliaccis, I cant help but order the PSR. Its just that damn good! read more

This location is far better than the one at Bel-Red Road. Quick service with a counter up front to pick-and-choose individual slices. Both of the slices that I got were large in portion and still tasty after reheating in the oven. Crust is on the thinner side and crispy on the rim. ----- The Hawaiian: Hempler's Canadian bacon and fresh cut pineapple over mozzarella and our seasoned tomato sauce ($4.25 per slice). A good amount of topped ham that was not sliced too thinly. Pineapple pieces were fresh and subtle in sweetness. ----- The Italiano: spinach, roasted garlic, mozzarella, fontina and parmesan over a crushed Italian tomato base finished with a sprinkle of sea salt ($4.25 per slice). The huge chunks of roasted garlic were surprisingly good despite its powerful aroma. Topping with three types of cheese showed in its thickness compared to the other slice. ----- Inside is spacious and relaxing as it is not cramped with tables. A couple of outdoor tables are well shaded from the building. The city of Bellevue has public Wi-Fi that is accessible inside. The parking lot out front is not that large. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Left to Right: The Hawaiian and The Italiano ($4.25 per slice). - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

It's a small pizza restaurant that has some great food and vibe. You might not feel that from outside but inside they have a decent dining space. The staff is friendly and helpful. Food is great. We had ordered a pizza, salad and garlic breadsticks and I can say all three were tasty. The material used was fresh. Will visit again read more