I haven't had any of their pizzas from the window before, only as takeout. As a takeout, I thought it was ... fine, not that amazing. But the slice I tasted for the first time was great! I got a slice of italian and it was piping hot and amazing. The entry to it I found... difficult, I ended up parking in the wrong spot and walking over to it, and the inside felt a little small. But overall, quite tasty? Maybe the trick is to only get their single large slices and getting them fresh so they're extremely hot. The tomato sauce was very fresh and there was very nice cheese without it being heavy- everything great about a pizza slice! read more

pagliacci is a nostalgic spot for me as i came here since i was little. indoor seating and limited parking spots. it sucks that you can only get slices of the available ones that day instead of any flavor on the menu. food: - itiliano: slices available the day i went - da vito primo: slices available the day i went - pagliaccio salad: as good as always read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

We ordered pizzas from here for football night, and they didn't disappoint at all. The servers were helpful and provided plates and condiments for us. We got two 17" pizzas (a little ambitious for the two of us :D): Funghi Salsiccia and AGOG Primo. It took 20min to bake and both pizzas were super delicious and fresh. We enjoyed them very much - only able to finish half a pizza... lol. We will order take-out from here again for sure, just maybe less or smaller pizzas. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Funghi Salsiccia, 17" - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

See all

Now that we've been getting pizza from here about every two weeks for 5 months, Pagliacci gets another star for several other things. One is the density of the toppings. I never feel like "I should have ordered extra" as I do with most other pizza places. Two is the consistency. I can really rely on getting a great pizza every time -- and they are eager to correct a rare mistake. And three is the inventiveness, especially of their limited-time pizzas. I usually pick my own toppings, but Pagliacci does a perfect job of it and I'm always excited to try a new combination. Also this is one of the few pizzas in my life where I eat the entire crust. That's a real achievement by Pagliacci! read more

IMHO. BEST PIZZA in this area. I always try to stop in for a slice or two iif I am in the area and hungry' read more

See all

The pizza is delicious. I love that I can get a quick slice if I'm in a hurry. Never had a slice I didn't like.

Small little place but with big taste! I'm usually not a pizza fan, but this place has an interesting rotational style menu of different pizzas through the week. We came by and grabbed a meaty slice, spicy chicken and plain. They heated up the slices for us and put it in separate small boxes. If you want a pie, order ahead of time. Friendly and good service. There is hardly a place to sit around to in inside, more a grab to go kinda place. Must try! Definitely worth it if you enjoy pizza read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

Good pizza! I had this catered so cant speak to the dining or store experience, but the food was good :) I had the pepperoni and the one with sausage, mushroom, and onion and they were fantastic! Super good flavor, thin crust, and plenty of cheese. I would definitely come back. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Sausage/onion/mushroom and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

Nothing really worthwhile on the menu, and downright hostile staff. You can find better food elsewhere. read more

Something I pride myself on is always being abreast of local food deals. Pagliacci's free slice day was one of these deals - two free slices seemed too good to be true, but I found out from a friend that this is actually something they do several times a year! With a deal this good, I was doubtful of my chances of actually getting the free pizza - I assumed that lines would wrap around the building and that they would run out of pizza before I could get to the front of the line. However, the line moved quickly, and I had my pick of slices when it was my turn. I had the Italiano and Hawaiian pizza slices. The Italiano was pretty standard, but the huge, thick slices on the Hawaiian really made it stand out. I'm a total pineapple on pizza person, so it his slide was perfect for me. read more

See all

We ordered a pizza online last night for pick-up since we were looking for quick and easy pizza. We've had Pagliacci many times at various locations but this Bellevue location is the closest to us. The pizza is pretty tasty here! Can be a hit or miss, sometimes it can be cold or too oily. Whole pizzas are on the pricier side in my opinion ($31 for a 13" pepperoni and mushroom pizza) but it's the only takeout pizza place we've ordered from and we enjoy The service was good! The lady at the front was very nice when we were picking up our order This location is very very small and cramped inside so seating is limited. I'd recommend to order to-go. The parking lot is really small too, probably max 5 or so spots. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - 13" pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

I really wanted some pizza so my friend brought me over here. It's a cute corner shop with a few parking spots and is a take out place. I saw they sold pizza by the splice which was great. I went with one of their veggie slices - vedura primo and a cheese slice. They heated it up pretty quickly and gave some red chili flakes. I loved how crispy the pizza was and the pesto base on the veggie pizza was delicious! I also loved all the toppings it came with. The cheese pizza was also really good. Overall a great experience! read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Vedura Primo - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

SUPER good pizza!!! We go to the cute little corner shop in Bellevue when I'm in town and the pizza is so bommmmmb it's worth the price! We got the Brooklyn Bridge, which was super yummy with just the right amount of sauce, cheese and veggies! Not too much and not toooo little! The pizza was the largest size we could get and it was about $35, which was a tad expensive for my taste, but.... still don't regret it! I wouldn't order it all the time but ... I also probably wouldn't get a different establishment's pizza! Shared with my dad, mom, brother and grandma and we ALL got our fair share of slices. Each of us had at least two good size slices. FULL and HAPPY is what I happily declare the outcome of our trip! We ordered to go, order was made perfectly and was ready a few minutes short of when they told us it would be! PERFECT and PRECISE! Will definitely make this OUR PIZZA SPOT for every single family pizza night moving forward! read more

Pagliacci is a good pizza place if you are looking for a place that is usually close, convenient, and fast. It never amazes me with its flavor, but it is always good enough to go again if I want to get a fast pizza. I went here last weekend for a quick dinner and got a mushroom and pepperoni pizza. It was just average, like always. The service is always excellent and friendly. This Pagliacci is not a pizza place you will eat at, but it is suitable for some takeout. Tip: Get the pizza slices they have in the front! read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Mushroom and pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

Stopped and grabbed a pizza here since it had good reviews and close by. More of a take out place that serves by the slice or whole pizzas. Ordered the pepperoni. Looked good and did not taste bad. A little oily (from the cheese) but folded up nice. Bottom crust was ok, a little tough but the crust crust was crispy with that chewy factor which is always good. Staff was not over friendly but I was not there for the staff. I would rate it a 3.5 but they don't have that so I gave it a 3 read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Inside looking at kitchen and pizza ready by the slice - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

See all

First time grabbing slices. We got cheese and it was delicious with the crispy bottom. Also got a real sugar coke! Yum. Quick place to stop in for a bite. read more

I would actually rate Pagliacci overall at 3.5, but the pizza a 3. The restaurant was clean, the staff was nice, and I liked the option to just buy a slice. The pizza was OK, I've lived in Chicago and New York, so it takes a lot for me to give a 5 on that front. I prefer my pizza with a bit more cheese, but for something quick to avoid cooking at home, it's fine. read more

spot on pizza, LOVE the crust. The toppings could be a little better, it was just too cheesy without much flavor. had to really douse on the hot sauce and chili flakes/parm. But the crust is the hard part to get right, and they definitely know what theyre doing. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

Place is small, so seating is limited, but parking is a decent size. It's a cute little shop and you can see the workers making your pizza. Service is friendly and relatively quick. The pizza is good and you get generous portions, though the pizza is a bit pricy. I would recommend coming in whenever they have deals. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

$5 plus they put the tip on you right away for a slice? Then the guy doesn't even say thank you but expects you to say thank you for a flimsy slice tgat is over rated? What a joke. read more

Pizza is a must once a month from Pagliacci. We are always treated kindly from the staff there and delivery drivers.

Both of pepperoni and the pepperoni and sausage pizzas were very good. Very much like New York style. Greasy pizza and thin and a little expensive but much better than most chain pizza places read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pepperoni and sausage 4/5 - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

Finding a good Pizza place in Washington State is like trying to find a Mariners highlight reel. It almost seems non-existent. Pagliacci Pizza seems to have this  area's biggest pizza base. I would love to see someone top that. The prices are reasonable, and this is a popular spot for lunch. The line moves pretty quickly, and staff is pleasant and helpful. There is lots of space inside and lots of windows to look out of. Parking can be challenging on the lot on the right read more

Pizza by the slice is the best, especially if you don't want to commit to one flavor profile for a whole pie. Service is quick and pizza was good...what else can you ask for? read more

Pagliacci Pizza advertises selling pizza by the slice but is clearly not their forte for this particular joint. The slices range from $3 - $4 each with hardly any selection. Only a single slice of Agog Primo ($4) and a few slices of PSR Combo ($3.75) and Extra Pepperoni ($3.50) were out. Original Cheese ($3) needed another fifteen minutes. Two customers came for these slices but immediately left after seeing the choices. ----- PSR Combo Slice: pepperoni, Cascioppo's Italian sausage, ricotta, mozzarella and Romano on our seasoned tomato sauce ($3.75). Slices are heated up for thirty seconds, but isn't enough to restore the cheese that had hardened from sitting at that counter that doesn't even have heat lamps. The crust was thin and crispy. The pizza was a tad oily and lacked tomato sauce in my opinion as I felt I was primarily eating dough. The sausage and ricotta toppings were decent and added flavor. ----- If dining in, a bar counter with six seats as well as two outdoor tables are available for seating. Inside is rather disorganized and rowdy: unwiped tables, no cups by the water dispenser, and have to request for silverware and napkins. Most of the customers come to pick up their orders, which I'd bet would give a better experience. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - PSR Combo Slice: pepperoni, Cascioppo's Italian sausage, ricotta, mozzarella and Romano on our seasoned tomato sauce ($3.75). - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

Ordered an Hawaiian pizza here and the Canadian bacon gave me the worst food poisoning ever! Had to go get medical help while fighting with food poisoning. read more

My favorite pizza chain in the PNW! I love their crust recipe, gourmet toppings, as well as their fresh salads, and gelato of the month. I appreciate that it's not as greasy as other pizza places, and is comparable to New York style, which I really enjoy! Heads up - This location is best for take-out because they only have a few seats. If you want to do dine-in, I prefer the old Bellevue location. read more

Favorite place to get pizza for most our roommates. We always try the specials. Usually fantastic.

I've been such a huge fan of Pagliacci's since I used to get slices at their Cap Hill location during most of my lunch breaks. It's always so darn delicious and they have a stamp card for slices. Since I'm currently at home quarantining, my review is based off of getting the pizza delivered. We called it in, which went to a centralized number. It was quick and easy to place the order and pay over the phone. Our place is fairly close so the order came in 20 minutes or so from calling. I ordered a medium margarita pizza since that's my favorite. It was tasty, just as I expected. The only reason I didn't give 5 stars was because it was $28 for a medium (not including tip of course). I feel like it's a bit over priced. I don't know if the location is open for picking orders but if it is and that makes it cheaper, then I'll do that next time. read more

Pags is one of our go-to delivery options! They have a great crust, and offer a lot of interesting toppings and combinations - but the extra pepperoni is great if that's more your thing. They've also been doing a great job adapting to Covid-19. Staff are masked up and sanitizing surfaces frequently. They have online ordering easy, no-contact delivery (and an option for pick-up!). Their delivery drivers place your order at the door, and step back to a safe distance until they're sure you received it. But, I especially love that they've been doing community giveaways! Periodically they've been adding an extra item to all orders of a full pizza (while supplies last). No strings, not extra cost - just a way to support other small businesses, since their delivery system allowed them to be a little more flexible in adjusting to the pandemic. You can check out there blog to see when the next giveaway day is https://www.pagliacci.com/blog/news read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

Yum! So much flavor and never disappoints. It's pricey but a pizza that is super fresh and seasoned is worth it. They have great customer service too. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Spicy chicken with vegan cheese and my own ranch - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

What kind of world do we live in where 4 slices of pizza costed me $25!? My goodness. Overpriced big time. Go to MOD- $25it will get you 2 full pizzas with unlimited toppings and a drink. read more

We ordered half chicken and half veggie. It was good and crispy. Actually I didn't know about this place. It is good to know. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Half chicken & basil,olive,mushroom,jalapeño - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

Good take out option during Covid-19. They follow guidelines strictly to be hygenic. They are efficient and fast at preparing the pizza. You can call, then head out and your order will be ready by the time you get there I specifically like their Pesto primo, but Verde primo and Parma primo are good too. Give it a try don't forget to take some chilli peppers! read more

This place has the BEST pizza in Bellevue, hands down. I moved to Bellevue a year ago and have tried pretty much all of the pizza's In the area and this place is amazing. Highly recommend! read more

A northwest classic. Always great pie here. The prices have gotten a little crazy but that's just the world we are living in. If you are in the area and want to some za this is a great place to land at. read more

My first time checking this place out. I had pepperoni, sausage, extra cheese. It was heavy with toppings, the way I like it. Very tasty. Thin crust, NY style. Sauce was very flavorful. 4 stars. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington

Really expensive but really good too. For a pizza place it takes awhile to get your order so order early

Oh man this pizza place is a little more expensive than your average pizza place but it's been a delicious treat during this pandemic. I'm trying to limit buying a pizza twice a month due to my expanding waistline but my favorite right is the seasonal butternut sage primo. Just writing about it makes me want to go online and order it right now. You also can't go wrong with the Brooklyn Bridge. Sorry there's no pictures with my review because we ate the pizza immediately! read more

Paglicacci Pizza has pretty good pizza. I got their: ~Amatriciana Pizza Slice, it had bacon and cheese. It was pretty good, score: 7.5/10. ~Cheese Pizza slice, it was delicious. The cheese and crust was nice and yummy. Score: 8.5/10. Nice staff and great service, would recommend. read more

Pagliacci Pizza - Cheese & Amatriciana Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellevue, Washington